Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics

Canonical force and electromagnetic geometrical phase in particle interference

S. A. R. Horsley, M. Babiker

Published May 18, 2007• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We provide arguments which demonstrate that the Berry phase effects involving particle interference in the presence of external electric and magnetic fields—namely the Aharonov–Bohm (AB), Aharonov–Casher (AC) and the Röntgen (R) effects—cannot be unambiguously explained (as has been controversially argued) through the use of any classical mechanical force. In fact, in the three scenarios which we consider, the only means to reclaim the standard quantum mechanical results is to use the expressions for the force that fail to satisfy the necessary conditions of gauge invariance. Our arguments explain the foundation of the controversy and confirm the standard idea that the Berry phase effects in question are non-local phenomena which only arise in the application of quantum theory. We lay special emphasis on the use of the concept of a canonical force, this being the quantity which ensures the agreement between the classical and quantum formulations. It is shown that if the Aharonov–Bohm effect is interpreted as being due to a force, through the use of the Bohmian formulation of quantum mechanics, then this force is equal in magnitude to the canonical force.

DOI
10.1088/0953-4075/40/11/005

Related papers

Röntgen Quantum Phase Shift: A Semiclassical Local Electrodynamical Effect?

S. A. R. Horsley, M. Babiker

The Röntgen quantum phase shift is exhibited by the interference of point particles endowed with an electric dipole moment due to their motion relative to a source of the magnetic field. Here we show, using arguments involving the classical concepts of force and its impulse, that the Röntgen phase shift arises within a largely classical (semiclassical) theoretical framework. All the subtleties normally associated with the nonlocality of magnetic (Aharonov-Bohm-type) quantum phase phenomena are uncontroversially absent in the classical treatment.

Physical Review Letters•Jun 29, 2005•19 citations

Unveiling the Role of Vector Potential in the Aharonov–Bohm Effect

M. Wakamatsu

The most popular interpretation of the Aharonov–Bohm (AB) effect is that the electromagnetic potential locally affects the complex phase of a charged particle’s wave function in the magnetic field free region. However, since the vector potential is a gauge-variant quantity, multiple researchers suspect that it is just a convenient tool for calculating the force field. This motivates them to explain the AB effect without using the vector potential, which inevitably leads to some sort of non-locality. This frustrating situation is shortly summarized by the statement by Aharonov et al. that the AB effect may be due to a local gauge potential or due to non-local gauge-invariant fields. In the present paper, we shall give several convincing arguments which support the viewpoint that the vector potential is not just a convenient mathematical tool with little physical entity. Despite its gauge arbitrariness, the vector potential certainly contains a gauge-invariant piece, which solely explains the observed AB phase shift. Importantly, this component has a property such that it is basically unique and cannot be eliminated by any regular gauge transformations. To complete the discussion, we also discuss the role of remaining gauge arbitrariness still contained in the entire vector potential.

arXiv:2506.07018•Symmetry•Jun 12, 2025•0 citations

The Aharonov-Bohm Effect and Its Applications to Magnetic Field Observation

Akira Tonomura

This article describes the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect of electron waves travelling in free space and its application to the observation of gauge fields (vector potentials). The AB effect is inconceivable in classical physics since an observable effect is produced on electrons passing through field-free spaces. Electrons can be affected only by Lorentz forces due to electromagnetic fields. The situation is different in quantum mechanics, where electrons show wave properties: the concept of force is no longer relevant, so electric field E and magnetic field B, defined as forces acting on a unit charge, take on secondary meanings. “Phase shifts” come into play, and the primary physical entities become neither E nor B but electrostatic potential V and vector potential A. These potentials interact with electron waves and shift their phases.

Asia Pacific Physics Newsletter•Jan 1, 2013•2 citations

Quantum Phases: 50 years of the Aharonov--Bohm effect and 25 years of the Berry phase

Mark R. Dennis, Sandu Popescu, Lev Vaidman A

This special issue celebrates the discovery of two of the most important aspects of quantum mechanics: the Aharonov–Bohm effect and the Berry phase. The issue includes work presented at two conferences, 50 Years of the Aharonov–Bohm Effect, 11–14 October 2009, Tel Aviv University, Israel, and the Aharonov–Bohm Effect and Berry Phase 50/25 Anniversary, 14–15 December 2009, Bristol University, UK. The Aharonov–Bohm (AB) effect and the Berry phase have many things in common, apart from the happy coincidence that they were discovered 25 years apart, making possible such a joint anniversary. First, they were both discovered in the same place, the H H Wills Physics Laboratory, University of Bristol, UK. Second, they both were there for everybody to see from day one, from the very beginning of quantum mechanics. They were, so to say, right on the surface; there was no need for sophisticated mathematics or involved constructions. Yet it took so long for somebody to see them. The explanation, we dare to speculate, is that they are so unusual, they challenge so much our everyday experience and ingrained intuitions about physics that it was difficult to recognise them. Third, both the AB effect and the Berry phase are quintessentially quantum; they both manifest themselves as topological/geometric quantum phases. The AB effect revolutionized our understanding of the role of potentials in physics. For the first time, it was shown that a particle moving in a field-free region could be affected by a field in a disjoint region. In doing so, it shattered one of the strongest held principles of physics. In the case of the Berry phase, the importance lies in its absolute generality—the topological/geometric phase named after Berry is acquired by all physical systems when the external parameters they depend upon undergo an adiabatic cyclic change. Remarkably this phase depends only on the geometry of the cyclic path in the abstract parameter space, a fact which deepens our appreciation of the underlying geometry of quantum mechanics. The AB effect and the Berry phase are ubiquitous in modern physics and have implications ranging from the most fundamental to the very applied. First and foremost, they give a deeper understanding of the nature of quantum mechanics itself. Furthermore, we find them in fields as varied as cosmology, particle physics, non-abelian gauge theories, condensed matter, chemical and molecular physics, and laser dynamics. Generalizations of the AB effect to non-abelian gauge theories, such as the Wilson and `t Hooft loops, are important tools for studying confinement and spontaneous symmetry breaking. They explain charge quantization, the quantum Hall effect and the Josephson junction and also play a crucial role in electron microscope holography. Without them an understanding of many effects in the new field of mesoscopic physics, where tiny electronic circuits exhibit quantum behaviour, would be impossible. Like good wine, the AB effect and the Berry phase become finer and more appreciated with time. Even though they appear in textbooks and encyclopaedias, the number of researchers thinking and publishing papers on these two effects is increasing annually. The AB effect and the Berry phase keep being observed in new systems and with every day that passes novel applications are routinely found. This special issue is just a small snapshot of the state of the art 50 and 25 years, respectively, from their discoveries.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Aug 12, 2010•4 citations

A Classical (Local) Account of The Aharonov-Bohm Effect

Vlatko Vedral

It is frequently stated that the electromagnetic vector potential acquires a fundamental role in quantum physics, whereas classically it only represents a convenient, but by no means necessary, way of representing the electromagnetic field. Here we argue that this is a historical accident due to the fact that the electromagnetic field was discovered before photons, while the electron itself was discovered first as a particle, before it became clear that it must also be treated as a wave and therefore as an excitation of the underlying electron field. We illustrate the fact that the vector potential ought to play a fundamental role classically using the Aharonov-Bohm effect. This effect is considered as the strongest argument for the role the vector potential plays in quantum physics, however, here we offer a fully classical account of it. This is a consequence of the fact that any account, be it classical or quantum, must involve the vector potential in order to preserve the local nature of the Aharonov-Bohm (as well as all the other) phases.

arXiv:2111.00476•Oct 31, 2021•2 citations

The Aharonov-Casher Phase: Considerations Regarding Force, Time-Dependence, and Berry Phase

Igor Kuzmenko, Y. B. Band, Y. Avishai

The relation of the Aharonov-Casher (AC) effect and the force on a particle having a magnetic moment is explored. The general form of the AC Hamiltonian is derived using the Foldy-Wouthuysen transformation to the Dirac equation. Geometries in which an analytic expression for the phase can be obtained are examined, as well as the relation of the AC phase to the Berry phase. The AC phase is determined for an arbitrary homogeneous electric field; it is quadratic (linear) in the field strength for small (large) electric field strengths.

arXiv:2506.11149•Jun 11, 2025•0 citations
We provide arguments which demonstrate that the Berry phase effects involving particle interference in the presence of external electric and magnetic fields—namely the Aharonov–Bohm (AB), Aharonov–Casher (AC) and the Röntgen (R) effects—cannot be unambiguously explained (as has been controversially argued) through the use of any classical mechanical force. In fact, in the three scenarios which we consider, the only means to reclaim the standard quantum mechanical results is to use the expressions for the force that fail to satisfy the necessary conditions of gauge invariance. Our arguments explain the foundation of the controversy and confirm the standard idea that the Berry phase effects in question are non-local phenomena which only arise in the application of quantum theory. We lay special emphasis on the use of the concept of a canonical force, this being the quantity which ensures the agreement between the classical and quantum formulations. It is shown that if the Aharonov–Bohm effect is interpreted as being due to a force, through the use of the Bohmian formulation of quantum mechanics, then this force is equal in magnitude to the canonical force.
The Röntgen quantum phase shift is exhibited by the interference of point particles endowed with an electric dipole moment due to their motion relative to a source of the magnetic field. Here we show, using arguments involving the classical concepts of force and its impulse, that the Röntgen phase shift arises within a largely classical (semiclassical) theoretical framework. All the subtleties normally associated with the nonlocality of magnetic (Aharonov-Bohm-type) quantum phase phenomena are uncontroversially absent in the classical treatment.
The most popular interpretation of the Aharonov–Bohm (AB) effect is that the electromagnetic potential locally affects the complex phase of a charged particle’s wave function in the magnetic field free region. However, since the vector potential is a gauge-variant quantity, multiple researchers suspect that it is just a convenient tool for calculating the force field. This motivates them to explain the AB effect without using the vector potential, which inevitably leads to some sort of non-locality. This frustrating situation is shortly summarized by the statement by Aharonov et al. that the AB effect may be due to a local gauge potential or due to non-local gauge-invariant fields. In the present paper, we shall give several convincing arguments which support the viewpoint that the vector potential is not just a convenient mathematical tool with little physical entity. Despite its gauge arbitrariness, the vector potential certainly contains a gauge-invariant piece, which solely explains the observed AB phase shift. Importantly, this component has a property such that it is basically unique and cannot be eliminated by any regular gauge transformations. To complete the discussion, we also discuss the role of remaining gauge arbitrariness still contained in the entire vector potential.
This article describes the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect of electron waves travelling in free space and its application to the observation of gauge fields (vector potentials). The AB effect is inconceivable in classical physics since an observable effect is produced on electrons passing through field-free spaces. Electrons can be affected only by Lorentz forces due to electromagnetic fields. The situation is different in quantum mechanics, where electrons show wave properties: the concept of force is no longer relevant, so electric field E and magnetic field B, defined as forces acting on a unit charge, take on secondary meanings. “Phase shifts” come into play, and the primary physical entities become neither E nor B but electrostatic potential V and vector potential A. These potentials interact with electron waves and shift their phases.
This special issue celebrates the discovery of two of the most important aspects of quantum mechanics: the Aharonov–Bohm effect and the Berry phase. The issue includes work presented at two conferences, 50 Years of the Aharonov–Bohm Effect, 11–14 October 2009, Tel Aviv University, Israel, and the Aharonov–Bohm Effect and Berry Phase 50/25 Anniversary, 14–15 December 2009, Bristol University, UK. The Aharonov–Bohm (AB) effect and the Berry phase have many things in common, apart from the happy coincidence that they were discovered 25 years apart, making possible such a joint anniversary. First, they were both discovered in the same place, the H H Wills Physics Laboratory, University of Bristol, UK. Second, they both were there for everybody to see from day one, from the very beginning of quantum mechanics. They were, so to say, right on the surface; there was no need for sophisticated mathematics or involved constructions. Yet it took so long for somebody to see them. The explanation, we dare to speculate, is that they are so unusual, they challenge so much our everyday experience and ingrained intuitions about physics that it was difficult to recognise them. Third, both the AB effect and the Berry phase are quintessentially quantum; they both manifest themselves as topological/geometric quantum phases. The AB effect revolutionized our understanding of the role of potentials in physics. For the first time, it was shown that a particle moving in a field-free region could be affected by a field in a disjoint region. In doing so, it shattered one of the strongest held principles of physics. In the case of the Berry phase, the importance lies in its absolute generality—the topological/geometric phase named after Berry is acquired by all physical systems when the external parameters they depend upon undergo an adiabatic cyclic change. Remarkably this phase depends only on the geometry of the cyclic path in the abstract parameter space, a fact which deepens our appreciation of the underlying geometry of quantum mechanics. The AB effect and the Berry phase are ubiquitous in modern physics and have implications ranging from the most fundamental to the very applied. First and foremost, they give a deeper understanding of the nature of quantum mechanics itself. Furthermore, we find them in fields as varied as cosmology, particle physics, non-abelian gauge theories, condensed matter, chemical and molecular physics, and laser dynamics. Generalizations of the AB effect to non-abelian gauge theories, such as the Wilson and `t Hooft loops, are important tools for studying confinement and spontaneous symmetry breaking. They explain charge quantization, the quantum Hall effect and the Josephson junction and also play a crucial role in electron microscope holography. Without them an understanding of many effects in the new field of mesoscopic physics, where tiny electronic circuits exhibit quantum behaviour, would be impossible. Like good wine, the AB effect and the Berry phase become finer and more appreciated with time. Even though they appear in textbooks and encyclopaedias, the number of researchers thinking and publishing papers on these two effects is increasing annually. The AB effect and the Berry phase keep being observed in new systems and with every day that passes novel applications are routinely found. This special issue is just a small snapshot of the state of the art 50 and 25 years, respectively, from their discoveries.
It is frequently stated that the electromagnetic vector potential acquires a fundamental role in quantum physics, whereas classically it only represents a convenient, but by no means necessary, way of representing the electromagnetic field. Here we argue that this is a historical accident due to the fact that the electromagnetic field was discovered before photons, while the electron itself was discovered first as a particle, before it became clear that it must also be treated as a wave and therefore as an excitation of the underlying electron field. We illustrate the fact that the vector potential ought to play a fundamental role classically using the Aharonov-Bohm effect. This effect is considered as the strongest argument for the role the vector potential plays in quantum physics, however, here we offer a fully classical account of it. This is a consequence of the fact that any account, be it classical or quantum, must involve the vector potential in order to preserve the local nature of the Aharonov-Bohm (as well as all the other) phases.
The relation of the Aharonov-Casher (AC) effect and the force on a particle having a magnetic moment is explored. The general form of the AC Hamiltonian is derived using the Foldy-Wouthuysen transformation to the Dirac equation. Geometries in which an analytic expression for the phase can be obtained are examined, as well as the relation of the AC phase to the Berry phase. The AC phase is determined for an arbitrary homogeneous electric field; it is quadratic (linear) in the field strength for small (large) electric field strengths.