Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Three-Level Systems as Amplifiers and Attenuators: A Thermodynamic Analysis

Erez Boukobza, David J. Tannor

Published Jun 13, 2007• 96 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Thermodynamics of a three-level maser was studied in the pioneering work of Scovil-Schulz-DuBois [Phys. Rev. Lett. 2, 262 (1959)10.1103/PhysRevLett.2.262]. In this Letter we consider the same three-level model, but we give a full thermodynamic analysis based on Hamiltonian and dissipative Lindblad superoperators. The first law of thermodynamics is obtained using a recently developed alternative [Phys. Rev. A 74, 063823 (2006)10.1103/PhysRevA.74.063823] to Alicki's definitions for heat flux and power [J. Phys. A 12, L103 (1979)10.1088/0305-4470/12/5/007]. Using a novel variation on Spohn's entropy production function [J. Math. Phys. (N.Y.) 19, 1227 (1978)10.1063/1.523789], we obtain Carnot's efficiency inequality and the Scovil-Schulz-DuBois maser efficiency formula when the three-level system is operated as a heat engine (amplifier). Finally, we show that the three-level system has two other modes of operation--a refrigerator mode and a squanderer mode--both of which attenuate the electric field.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.98.240601

Related papers

Thermodynamic analysis of quantum light amplification

Erez Boukobza, David J. Tannor

Thermodynamics of a three-level maser was studied in the pioneering work of Scovil and Schulz-DuBois [Phys. Rev. Lett. 2, 262 (1959)]. In this work we consider the same three-level model, but treat both the matter and the light quantum mechanically. Specifically, we analyze an extended (three-level) dissipative (ED) Jaynes-Cummings model (JCM) within the framework of a quantum heat engine, using formulas for heat flux and power in bipartite systems introduced in our previous work [E. Boukobza and D. J. Tannor Phys. Rev. A 74, 063823 (2006)] Amplification of the selected cavity mode occurs even in this simple model, as seen by a positive steady state power. However, initial field coherence is lost, as seen by the decaying off-diagonal field density matrix elements, and by the Husimi-Kano $Q$ function. We show that after an initial transient time the field's entropy rises linearly during the operation of the engine, which we attribute to the dissipative nature of the evolution and not to matter-field entanglement. We show that the second law of thermodynamics is satisfied in two formulations (Clausius, Carnot) and that the efficiency of the ED JCM heat engine agrees with that defined intuitively by Scovil and Schulz-DuBois. Finally, we compare the steady state heat flux and power of the fully quantum model with the semiclassical counterpart of the ED JCM, and derive the engine efficiency formula of Scovil and Schulz-DuBois analytically from fundamental thermodynamic fluxes.

arXiv:quant-ph/0611175•Physical Review A•Dec 21, 2006•41 citations

Positivity of entropy production for the three-level maser

Alex Arash Sand Kalaee, A. Wacker

Entropy production is a key concept of thermodynamics and allows one to analyze the operation of engines. For the Scovil-Schulz-DuBois heat engine, the archetypal three-level thermal maser coupled to thermal baths, it was argued that the common definition of heat flow may provide negative entropy production for certain parameters [Boukobza and Tannor, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 240601 (2007)]. Here, we show that this can be cured if corrections for detuning are properly applied to the energies used for the bath transitions. This method can be used more generally for the thermodynamical analysis of optical transitions where the modes of the light field are detuned from the transition energy.

arXiv:2010.08934•Physical Review A•Jan 7, 2021•15 citations

Concepts of work in autonomous quantum heat engines

Wolfgang Niedenzu, Marcus Huber, Erez Boukobza

One of the fundamental questions in quantum thermodynamics concerns the decomposition of energetic changes into heat and work. Contrary to classical engines, the entropy change of the piston cannot be neglected in the quantum domain. As a consequence, different concepts of work arise, depending on the desired task and the implied capabilities of the agent using the work generated by the engine. Each work quantifier---from ergotropy to non-equilibrium free energy---has well defined operational interpretations. We analyse these work quantifiers for a heat-pumped three-level maser and derive the respective engine efficiencies. In the classical limit of strong maser intensities the engine efficiency converges towards the Scovil--Schulz-DuBois maser efficiency, irrespective of the work quantifier.

arXiv:1907.01353•Quantum•Oct 14, 2019•84 citations

Efficiency at maximum power of a laser quantum heat engine enhanced by noise-induced coherence

Konstantin E. Dorfman, Dazhi Xu, Jianshu Cao

Quantum coherence has been demonstrated in various systems including organic solar cells and solid state devices. In this article, we report the lower and upper bounds for the performance of quantum heat engines determined by the efficiency at maximum power. Our prediction based on the canonical three-level Scovil and Schulz-Dubois maser model strongly depends on the ratio of system-bath couplings for the hot and cold baths and recovers the theoretical bounds established previously for the Carnot engine. Further, introducing a fourth level to the maser model can enhance the maximal power and its efficiency, thus demonstrating the importance of quantum coherence in the thermodynamics and operation of the heat engines beyond the classical limit.

arXiv:1803.11314•Physical review. E•Apr 13, 2018•87 citations

The quantum heat engine and heat pump: An irreversible thermodynamic analysis of the three-level amplifier

Eitan Geva, Ronnie Kosloff

The manifestations of the three laws of thermodynamics are explored in a model of an irreversible quantum heat engine. The engine is composed of a three-level system simultaneously coupled to hot and cold heat baths, and driven by an oscillating external field. General quantum heat baths are considered, which are weakly coupled to the three-level system. The work reservoir is modeled by a classical electro-magnetic field of arbitrary intensity, which is driving the three-level system. The first law of thermodynamics is related to the rate of change of energy obtained from the quantum master equation in the Heisenberg picture. The fluxes of the thermodynamic heat and work are then directly related to the expectation values of quantum observables. An analysis of the standard quantum master equation for the amplifier, first introduced by Lamb, is shown to be thermodynamically inconsistent when strong driving fields are used. A generalized master equation is rigorously derived, starting from the underlying quantum dynamics, which includes relaxation terms that explicitly depend upon the field. For weak fields the generalized master equation reduces to the standard equation. In very intense fields the amplifier splits into two heat engines. One engine accelerates as the field intensifies, while the other slows down and eventually switches direction to become a heat pump. The relative weight of the slower engine increases with the field intensity, leading to a maximum in power as a function of the field intensity. The amplifier is shown to go through four ‘‘phases’’ as the driving field is intensified, throughout all of which the second law of thermodynamics is generally satisfied. One phase corresponds to a ‘‘refrigeration window’’ which allows for the extraction of heat out of a cold bath of temperatures down to the absolute zero. This window disappears at absolute zero, which is conjectured to be a dynamical manifestation of the third law of thermodynamics.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•May 15, 1996•177 citations

Optimal operation of a three-level quantum heat engine and universal nature of efficiency

Varinder Singh

We present a detailed study of a three-level quantum heat engine operating at maximum efficient power function, a trade-off objective function defined by the product of the efficiency and power output of the engine.The efficient power function represents a trade-off between the power output and efficiency of a heat engine.Engines working in the maximum efficient power regime operate at finite power, with finite efficiency lying in between the regimes of maximum power and maximum efficiency (Carnot efficiency).First, for near-equilibrium conditions, we find a general expression for the efficiency and establish the universal nature of efficiency at maximum power and maximum efficient power.Then in the high-temperature limit, optimizing with respect to one parameter while constraining the other one, we obtain the lower and upper bounds on the efficiency for both strong as well as weak matter-field coupling conditions.Except for the weak matter-field coupling condition, the obtained bounds on the efficiency exactly match with the bounds already known for some models of classical heat engines.Further for weak matter-field coupling, we derive some new bounds on the efficiency of the engine which lie beyond the range covered by bounds obtained for strong matter-field coupling.We conclude by comparing the performance of our three-level quantum heat engine in maximum power and maximum efficient power regimes and show that the engine operating at maximum efficient power produces at least 88.89% of the maximum power output while considerably reducing the power loss due to entropy production.Finally, to complete our analysis, we review the experimental setup of a recently realized effective three-level quantum engine.

arXiv:2003.07608•Physical Review Research•Nov 5, 2020•47 citations
Thermodynamics of a three-level maser was studied in the pioneering work of Scovil-Schulz-DuBois [Phys. Rev. Lett. 2, 262 (1959)10.1103/PhysRevLett.2.262]. In this Letter we consider the same three-level model, but we give a full thermodynamic analysis based on Hamiltonian and dissipative Lindblad superoperators. The first law of thermodynamics is obtained using a recently developed alternative [Phys. Rev. A 74, 063823 (2006)10.1103/PhysRevA.74.063823] to Alicki's definitions for heat flux and power [J. Phys. A 12, L103 (1979)10.1088/0305-4470/12/5/007]. Using a novel variation on Spohn's entropy production function [J. Math. Phys. (N.Y.) 19, 1227 (1978)10.1063/1.523789], we obtain Carnot's efficiency inequality and the Scovil-Schulz-DuBois maser efficiency formula when the three-level system is operated as a heat engine (amplifier). Finally, we show that the three-level system has two other modes of operation--a refrigerator mode and a squanderer mode--both of which attenuate the electric field.
Thermodynamics of a three-level maser was studied in the pioneering work of Scovil and Schulz-DuBois [Phys. Rev. Lett. 2, 262 (1959)]. In this work we consider the same three-level model, but treat both the matter and the light quantum mechanically. Specifically, we analyze an extended (three-level) dissipative (ED) Jaynes-Cummings model (JCM) within the framework of a quantum heat engine, using formulas for heat flux and power in bipartite systems introduced in our previous work [E. Boukobza and D. J. Tannor Phys. Rev. A 74, 063823 (2006)] Amplification of the selected cavity mode occurs even in this simple model, as seen by a positive steady state power. However, initial field coherence is lost, as seen by the decaying off-diagonal field density matrix elements, and by the Husimi-Kano QQQ function. We show that after an initial transient time the field's entropy rises linearly during the operation of the engine, which we attribute to the dissipative nature of the evolution and not to matter-field entanglement. We show that the second law of thermodynamics is satisfied in two formulations (Clausius, Carnot) and that the efficiency of the ED JCM heat engine agrees with that defined intuitively by Scovil and Schulz-DuBois. Finally, we compare the steady state heat flux and power of the fully quantum model with the semiclassical counterpart of the ED JCM, and derive the engine efficiency formula of Scovil and Schulz-DuBois analytically from fundamental thermodynamic fluxes.
Entropy production is a key concept of thermodynamics and allows one to analyze the operation of engines. For the Scovil-Schulz-DuBois heat engine, the archetypal three-level thermal maser coupled to thermal baths, it was argued that the common definition of heat flow may provide negative entropy production for certain parameters [Boukobza and Tannor, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 240601 (2007)]. Here, we show that this can be cured if corrections for detuning are properly applied to the energies used for the bath transitions. This method can be used more generally for the thermodynamical analysis of optical transitions where the modes of the light field are detuned from the transition energy.
One of the fundamental questions in quantum thermodynamics concerns the decomposition of energetic changes into heat and work. Contrary to classical engines, the entropy change of the piston cannot be neglected in the quantum domain. As a consequence, different concepts of work arise, depending on the desired task and the implied capabilities of the agent using the work generated by the engine. Each work quantifier---from ergotropy to non-equilibrium free energy---has well defined operational interpretations. We analyse these work quantifiers for a heat-pumped three-level maser and derive the respective engine efficiencies. In the classical limit of strong maser intensities the engine efficiency converges towards the Scovil--Schulz-DuBois maser efficiency, irrespective of the work quantifier.
Quantum coherence has been demonstrated in various systems including organic solar cells and solid state devices. In this article, we report the lower and upper bounds for the performance of quantum heat engines determined by the efficiency at maximum power. Our prediction based on the canonical three-level Scovil and Schulz-Dubois maser model strongly depends on the ratio of system-bath couplings for the hot and cold baths and recovers the theoretical bounds established previously for the Carnot engine. Further, introducing a fourth level to the maser model can enhance the maximal power and its efficiency, thus demonstrating the importance of quantum coherence in the thermodynamics and operation of the heat engines beyond the classical limit.
The manifestations of the three laws of thermodynamics are explored in a model of an irreversible quantum heat engine. The engine is composed of a three-level system simultaneously coupled to hot and cold heat baths, and driven by an oscillating external field. General quantum heat baths are considered, which are weakly coupled to the three-level system. The work reservoir is modeled by a classical electro-magnetic field of arbitrary intensity, which is driving the three-level system. The first law of thermodynamics is related to the rate of change of energy obtained from the quantum master equation in the Heisenberg picture. The fluxes of the thermodynamic heat and work are then directly related to the expectation values of quantum observables. An analysis of the standard quantum master equation for the amplifier, first introduced by Lamb, is shown to be thermodynamically inconsistent when strong driving fields are used. A generalized master equation is rigorously derived, starting from the underlying quantum dynamics, which includes relaxation terms that explicitly depend upon the field. For weak fields the generalized master equation reduces to the standard equation. In very intense fields the amplifier splits into two heat engines. One engine accelerates as the field intensifies, while the other slows down and eventually switches direction to become a heat pump. The relative weight of the slower engine increases with the field intensity, leading to a maximum in power as a function of the field intensity. The amplifier is shown to go through four ‘‘phases’’ as the driving field is intensified, throughout all of which the second law of thermodynamics is generally satisfied. One phase corresponds to a ‘‘refrigeration window’’ which allows for the extraction of heat out of a cold bath of temperatures down to the absolute zero. This window disappears at absolute zero, which is conjectured to be a dynamical manifestation of the third law of thermodynamics.
We present a detailed study of a three-level quantum heat engine operating at maximum efficient power function, a trade-off objective function defined by the product of the efficiency and power output of the engine.The efficient power function represents a trade-off between the power output and efficiency of a heat engine.Engines working in the maximum efficient power regime operate at finite power, with finite efficiency lying in between the regimes of maximum power and maximum efficiency (Carnot efficiency).First, for near-equilibrium conditions, we find a general expression for the efficiency and establish the universal nature of efficiency at maximum power and maximum efficient power.Then in the high-temperature limit, optimizing with respect to one parameter while constraining the other one, we obtain the lower and upper bounds on the efficiency for both strong as well as weak matter-field coupling conditions.Except for the weak matter-field coupling condition, the obtained bounds on the efficiency exactly match with the bounds already known for some models of classical heat engines.Further for weak matter-field coupling, we derive some new bounds on the efficiency of the engine which lie beyond the range covered by bounds obtained for strong matter-field coupling.We conclude by comparing the performance of our three-level quantum heat engine in maximum power and maximum efficient power regimes and show that the engine operating at maximum efficient power produces at least 88.89% of the maximum power output while considerably reducing the power loss due to entropy production.Finally, to complete our analysis, we review the experimental setup of a recently realized effective three-level quantum engine.