Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

On total noncommutativity in quantum mechanics

PEKKA J. LAHTI, Kari Ylinen

Published Nov 1, 1987• 11 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is shown within the Hilbert space formulation of quantum mechanics that the total noncommutativity of any two physical quantities is necessary for their satisfying the uncertainty relation or for their being complementary. The importance of these results is illustrated with the canonically conjugate position and momentum of a free particle and of a particle closed in a box.

DOI
10.1063/1.527754

Related papers

A Note on Quantum Theory, Complementarity, and Uncertainty

Paul Busch, PEKKA J. LAHTI

Uncertainty relations and complementarity of canonically conjugate position and momentum observables in quantum theory are discussed with respect to some general coupling properties of a function and its Fourier transform. The question of joint localization of a particle on bounded position and momentum value sets and the relevance of this question to the interpretation of position-momentum uncertainty relations is surveyed. In particular, it is argued that the Heisenberg interpretation of the uncertainty relations can consistently be carried through in a natural extension of the usual Hilbert space frame of the quantum theory.

Philosophy of Science•Mar 1, 1985•23 citations

Nontraditional role of interparticle forces in quantum mechanics

A.I. Steshenko

A quantum-mechanical model for systems of interacting bodies that takes into account noncommutativity of the operators of coordinates and momenta of different particles and correlations of the uncertainties of these quantities is considered. Here, the noncommutativity of these operators is due to the effect of interparticle forces and arises as a natural generalization of the usual commutation relation between the coordinate and momentum operators for a single particle. The efficiency of the model is proven by specific calculations for systems known in atomic and nuclear physics.

Physics of Atomic Nuclei•Aug 1, 2006•0 citations

The interparticle interaction and noncommutativity of conjugate operators in quantum mechanics. $H$-like atoms

A.I. Steshenko

A quantum mechanical model for the systems consisting of interacting bodies is considered. The model takes into account the noncommutativity of the space and impulse operators and the correlation equations for the indeterminacy of these quantities. The noncommutativity of the operators is here a result of the action of the interparticle forces and represents a natural generalization of the conventional commutation relation for the space and impulse operators for a single particle. The efficiency of the model is demonstrated by specific calculations concerning several well-known atomic systems.

arXiv:nucl-th/0410018•Oct 5, 2004•0 citations

Uncertainty and Wigner negativity in Hilbert-space classical mechanics

Mustafa Amin

Classical mechanics, in the Koopman-von Neumann formulation, is described in Hilbert space. It is shown here that classical canonical transformations are generated by Hermitian operators that are in general noncommutative. This naturally brings about uncertainty relations inherent in classical mechanics, for example between position and the generator of space translations, between momentum and the generator of momentum translations, and between dynamical time and the Liouvillian, to name a few. Further, it is shown that the Wigner representation produces a quasi-probability distribution that can take on negative values. Thus, two of the hallmark features of quantum mechanics are reproduced, and become apparent, in a Hilbert-space formulation of classical mechanics.

quant-pharXiv:2602.10341•Feb 12, 2026•0 citations

News and views

AAPPS

The article gives an introductory summary of our recent results from the perspective of the new conceptual notion of noncommutative values of quantum observables, where basic quantum mechanics is seen a theory of particle dynamics that is intrinsically noncommutative.Real numbers as an algebra is really an abstract mathematical model for the description of values of physical quantities.Quantum mechanics illustrates the limitation of that perspective.The noncommutative values preserve the algebraic relations among the observables in their values.Such a value contains the complete information the theory presents for an observable on a given state.All physical quantities, including coordinates of the physical space for describing the location of a particle take definite noncommutative values.

AAPPS bulletin•Feb 8, 2022•0 citations

On non-commutativity in quantum theory (I): from classical to quantum probability

Luca Curcuraci

A central feature of quantum mechanics is the non-commutativity of operators used to describe physical observables. In this article, we present a critical analysis on the role of non-commutativity in quantum theory, focusing on its consequences in the probabilistic description. Typically, a random phenomenon is described using the measure-theoretic formulation of probability theory. Such a description can also be done using algebraic methods, which are capable to deal with non-commutative random variables (like in quantum mechanics). Here we propose a method to construct a non-commutative probability theory starting from an ordinary measure-theoretic description of probability. This will be done using the entropic uncertainty relations between random variables, in order to evaluate the presence of non-commutativity in their algebraic description.

arXiv:1803.04913•Mar 13, 2018•0 citations
It is shown within the Hilbert space formulation of quantum mechanics that the total noncommutativity of any two physical quantities is necessary for their satisfying the uncertainty relation or for their being complementary. The importance of these results is illustrated with the canonically conjugate position and momentum of a free particle and of a particle closed in a box.
Uncertainty relations and complementarity of canonically conjugate position and momentum observables in quantum theory are discussed with respect to some general coupling properties of a function and its Fourier transform. The question of joint localization of a particle on bounded position and momentum value sets and the relevance of this question to the interpretation of position-momentum uncertainty relations is surveyed. In particular, it is argued that the Heisenberg interpretation of the uncertainty relations can consistently be carried through in a natural extension of the usual Hilbert space frame of the quantum theory.
A quantum-mechanical model for systems of interacting bodies that takes into account noncommutativity of the operators of coordinates and momenta of different particles and correlations of the uncertainties of these quantities is considered. Here, the noncommutativity of these operators is due to the effect of interparticle forces and arises as a natural generalization of the usual commutation relation between the coordinate and momentum operators for a single particle. The efficiency of the model is proven by specific calculations for systems known in atomic and nuclear physics.
The interparticle interaction and noncommutativity of conjugate operators in quantum mechanics. HHH-like atoms
A quantum mechanical model for the systems consisting of interacting bodies is considered. The model takes into account the noncommutativity of the space and impulse operators and the correlation equations for the indeterminacy of these quantities. The noncommutativity of the operators is here a result of the action of the interparticle forces and represents a natural generalization of the conventional commutation relation for the space and impulse operators for a single particle. The efficiency of the model is demonstrated by specific calculations concerning several well-known atomic systems.
Classical mechanics, in the Koopman-von Neumann formulation, is described in Hilbert space. It is shown here that classical canonical transformations are generated by Hermitian operators that are in general noncommutative. This naturally brings about uncertainty relations inherent in classical mechanics, for example between position and the generator of space translations, between momentum and the generator of momentum translations, and between dynamical time and the Liouvillian, to name a few. Further, it is shown that the Wigner representation produces a quasi-probability distribution that can take on negative values. Thus, two of the hallmark features of quantum mechanics are reproduced, and become apparent, in a Hilbert-space formulation of classical mechanics.
The article gives an introductory summary of our recent results from the perspective of the new conceptual notion of noncommutative values of quantum observables, where basic quantum mechanics is seen a theory of particle dynamics that is intrinsically noncommutative.Real numbers as an algebra is really an abstract mathematical model for the description of values of physical quantities.Quantum mechanics illustrates the limitation of that perspective.The noncommutative values preserve the algebraic relations among the observables in their values.Such a value contains the complete information the theory presents for an observable on a given state.All physical quantities, including coordinates of the physical space for describing the location of a particle take definite noncommutative values.
A central feature of quantum mechanics is the non-commutativity of operators used to describe physical observables. In this article, we present a critical analysis on the role of non-commutativity in quantum theory, focusing on its consequences in the probabilistic description. Typically, a random phenomenon is described using the measure-theoretic formulation of probability theory. Such a description can also be done using algebraic methods, which are capable to deal with non-commutative random variables (like in quantum mechanics). Here we propose a method to construct a non-commutative probability theory starting from an ordinary measure-theoretic description of probability. This will be done using the entropic uncertainty relations between random variables, in order to evaluate the presence of non-commutativity in their algebraic description.