Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

New Journal of Physics

Comment on ‘Wigner function for a particle in an infinite lattice’

João P. S. Bizarro

Published Jun 13, 2013• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is pointed out that in a recent paper (2012 New J. Phys. 14 103009) in which a Wigner function for a particle in an infinite lattice (a system described by an unbounded discrete coordinate and its conjugate angle-like momentum) has been introduced, no reference is made to previous, pioneering work on discrete Wigner distributions (more precisely, on the rotational Wigner function for a system described by a rotation angle and its unbounded discrete-conjugate angular momentum). Not only has the problem addressed in essence been solved for a long time (the discrete coordinate and angle-like conjugate momentum are the perfect dual of the rotation angle and discrete-conjugate angular momentum), but the solution advanced only in some distorted manner obeys two of the fundamental properties of a Wigner distribution (that, when integrated over one period of the momentum variable, it should yield the correct marginal distribution on the discrete position variable, and that it should be invariant with respect to translation).

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/15/6/068001

Related papers

Comment on “Full quantum reconstruction of vortex states”

João P. S. Bizarro

It is pointed out that the bona fide Wigner distribution recently introduced [Phys. Rev. A 78, 060101(R) (2008)] is in fact the rotational Wigner function earlier derived and thoroughly studied [Phys. Rev. A 49, 3255 (1994); 71, 069901(E) (2005)], so the latter remains indeed the natural phase-space representation for the rotation-angle and angular-momentum pair.

Physical Review A•Jan 13, 2010•2 citations

Wigner distribution for angle coordinates in quantum mechanics

Narasimhaiengar Mukunda

The method of Wigner distribution functions, and the Weyl correspondence between quantum and classical variables, are extended from the usual kind of canonically conjugate position and momentum operators to the case of an angle and angular momentum operator pair. The sense in which one has a description of quantum mechanics using classical phase-space language is much clarified by this extension.

American Journal of Physics•Feb 1, 1979•74 citations

Wigner formalism for a particle on an infinite lattice: dynamics and spin

Hinarejos, M., Bañuls, M., Perez, A.

The recently proposed Wigner function for a particle in an infinite lattice (Hinarejos M, Bañuls M C and Pérez A 2012 New J. Phys. 14 103009) is extended here to include an internal degree of freedom as spin. This extension is made by introducing a Wigner matrix. The formalism is developed to account for dynamical processes, with or without decoherence. We show explicit solutions for the case of Hamiltonian evolution under a position-dependent potential, and for evolution governed by a master equation under some simple models of decoherence, for which the Wigner matrix formalism is well suited. Discrete processes are also discussed. Finally, we discuss the possibility of introducing a negativity concept for the Wigner function in the case where the spin degree of freedom is included.

•Jan 20, 2015•2 citations

Weyl-Wigner formalism for rotation-angle and angular-momentum variables in quantum mechanics

João P. S. Bizarro

A comprehensive study is presented on the Weyl-Wigner formalism for rotation-angle and angular-momentum variables: the elements of kinematics are extended, the elements of dynamics are established, and the implications of rotational perodicity and angular-momentum quantization are investigated. Particular attention is paid to discreteness, and two of its consequences are emphasized: the importance of evenness and oddness, and the need to use two difference operators in a discrete domain, whereas one differential operator suffices in a continuous domain. These consequences are shown to strongly distinguish the Weyl-Wigner formalism for rotation-angle and angular-momentum variables from the well-known Weyl-Wigner formalism for Cartesian-position and linear-momentum variables. The point is made clear that the first of these formalisms cannot be regarded as a trivial and straightforward extension of the second. The rotational Wigner function is derived as the only bilinear form of the state vector that is real, has the natural invariances for rotational motion, and yields the correct distributions for the rotation-angle and angular-momentum variables as well as the appropriate expression for the transition probability between states. The conditions for its uniqueness are thus established. Its properties are described in detail and, in particular, its uniform boundedness is demonstrated. The rotational Wigner function and the associated correspondence between quantum operators and classical-like functions, as well as the relations they obey, are explored and are written so as to clearly exhibit the distinct contributions of evenness and oddness in the discrete domain of the angular-momentum eigenvalues, thus providing a most natural way to account for periodicity.Using the derivative, which acts on the continuous rotation-angle variable, and the forward and backward differences, which act on the discrete angular-momentum variable, the equation of motion for the rotational Wigner function is established. This equation is detailed for the following Hamiltonian forms: those that depend only on the angular-momentum variable, including, in particular, the free rotator, and those that are in the cosine of the rotation-angle variable. It is verified that the Weyl-Wigner formalism for rotation-angle and angular-momentum variables has the correct nonperiodic limit and that it properly reduces to the Weyl-Wigner formalism for Cartesian-position and linear-momentum variables. In order to illustrate the formalism, a careful analysis is carried out for the rotational Wigner function representing the energy eigenstates of a hindered rotator whose Hamiltonian is the sum of a term in the absolute value of the angular-momentum variable with a term in the cosine of the rotation-angle variable. For this hindered rotator, and within the approximation of a large absolute value of the angular-momentum variable, the equation of motion for the rotational Wigner function is solved for its stationary solutions, and the time-independent Schr\"odinger equation is also solved.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1994•70 citations

Wigner formalism for a particle on an infinite lattice: dynamics and spin

M Hinarejos, Mari Carmen Bañuls, A Pérez

The recently proposed Wigner function for a particle in an infinite lattice (Hinarejos M, Bañuls M C and Pérez A 2012 New J. Phys.14 103009) is extended here to include an internal degree of freedom as spin.This extension is made by introducing a Wigner matrix.The formalism is developed to account for dynamical processes, with or without decoherence.We show explicit solutions for the case of Hamiltonian evolution under a position-dependent potential, and for evolution governed by a master equation under some simple models of decoherence, for which the Wigner matrix formalism is well suited.Discrete processes are also discussed.Finally, we discuss the possibility of introducing a negativity concept for the Wigner function in the case where the spin degree of freedom is included.

arXiv:1405.2944•New Journal of Physics•Jan 20, 2015•3 citations

Wigner functions for the pair angle and orbital angular momentum

H.A. Kastrup

The problem of constructing physically and mathematically well-defined Wigner functions for the canonical pair angle $\ensuremath{\theta}$ and angular momentum $p$ is solved. While a key element for the construction of Wigner functions for the planar phase space ${(q,p)\ensuremath{\in}{\mathbb{R}}^{2}}$ is the Heisenberg-Weyl group, the corresponding group for the cylindrical phase space ${(\ensuremath{\theta},p)\ensuremath{\in}{S}^{1}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathbb{R}}$ is the Euclidean group $E(2)$ of the plane and its unitary representations. Here the angle $\ensuremath{\theta}$ is replaced by the pair $(cos\ensuremath{\theta},sin\ensuremath{\theta})$, which corresponds uniquely to the points on the unit circle. The main structural properties of the Wigner functions for the planar and the cylindrical phase spaces are strikingly similar. A crucial role is played by the $sinc$ function, which provides the interpolation for the discontinuous quantized angular momenta in terms of the continuous classical ones, in accordance with the famous Whittaker cardinal function well known from interpolation and sampling theories. The quantum mechanical marginal distributions for the angle (continuous) and angular momentum (discontinuous) are, as usual, uniquely obtained by appropriate integrations of the $(\ensuremath{\theta},p)$ Wigner function. Among the examples discussed is an elementary system of simple cat states.

arXiv:1601.02520•Physical Review A•Dec 15, 2016•29 citations
It is pointed out that in a recent paper (2012 New J. Phys. 14 103009) in which a Wigner function for a particle in an infinite lattice (a system described by an unbounded discrete coordinate and its conjugate angle-like momentum) has been introduced, no reference is made to previous, pioneering work on discrete Wigner distributions (more precisely, on the rotational Wigner function for a system described by a rotation angle and its unbounded discrete-conjugate angular momentum). Not only has the problem addressed in essence been solved for a long time (the discrete coordinate and angle-like conjugate momentum are the perfect dual of the rotation angle and discrete-conjugate angular momentum), but the solution advanced only in some distorted manner obeys two of the fundamental properties of a Wigner distribution (that, when integrated over one period of the momentum variable, it should yield the correct marginal distribution on the discrete position variable, and that it should be invariant with respect to translation).
The recently proposed Wigner function for a particle in an infinite lattice (Hinarejos M, Bañuls M C and Pérez A 2012 New J. Phys. 14 103009) is extended here to include an internal degree of freedom as spin. This extension is made by introducing a Wigner matrix. The formalism is developed to account for dynamical processes, with or without decoherence. We show explicit solutions for the case of Hamiltonian evolution under a position-dependent potential, and for evolution governed by a master equation under some simple models of decoherence, for which the Wigner matrix formalism is well suited. Discrete processes are also discussed. Finally, we discuss the possibility of introducing a negativity concept for the Wigner function in the case where the spin degree of freedom is included.
A comprehensive study is presented on the Weyl-Wigner formalism for rotation-angle and angular-momentum variables: the elements of kinematics are extended, the elements of dynamics are established, and the implications of rotational perodicity and angular-momentum quantization are investigated. Particular attention is paid to discreteness, and two of its consequences are emphasized: the importance of evenness and oddness, and the need to use two difference operators in a discrete domain, whereas one differential operator suffices in a continuous domain. These consequences are shown to strongly distinguish the Weyl-Wigner formalism for rotation-angle and angular-momentum variables from the well-known Weyl-Wigner formalism for Cartesian-position and linear-momentum variables. The point is made clear that the first of these formalisms cannot be regarded as a trivial and straightforward extension of the second. The rotational Wigner function is derived as the only bilinear form of the state vector that is real, has the natural invariances for rotational motion, and yields the correct distributions for the rotation-angle and angular-momentum variables as well as the appropriate expression for the transition probability between states. The conditions for its uniqueness are thus established. Its properties are described in detail and, in particular, its uniform boundedness is demonstrated. The rotational Wigner function and the associated correspondence between quantum operators and classical-like functions, as well as the relations they obey, are explored and are written so as to clearly exhibit the distinct contributions of evenness and oddness in the discrete domain of the angular-momentum eigenvalues, thus providing a most natural way to account for periodicity.Using the derivative, which acts on the continuous rotation-angle variable, and the forward and backward differences, which act on the discrete angular-momentum variable, the equation of motion for the rotational Wigner function is established. This equation is detailed for the following Hamiltonian forms: those that depend only on the angular-momentum variable, including, in particular, the free rotator, and those that are in the cosine of the rotation-angle variable. It is verified that the Weyl-Wigner formalism for rotation-angle and angular-momentum variables has the correct nonperiodic limit and that it properly reduces to the Weyl-Wigner formalism for Cartesian-position and linear-momentum variables. In order to illustrate the formalism, a careful analysis is carried out for the rotational Wigner function representing the energy eigenstates of a hindered rotator whose Hamiltonian is the sum of a term in the absolute value of the angular-momentum variable with a term in the cosine of the rotation-angle variable. For this hindered rotator, and within the approximation of a large absolute value of the angular-momentum variable, the equation of motion for the rotational Wigner function is solved for its stationary solutions, and the time-independent Schr\"odinger equation is also solved.
The recently proposed Wigner function for a particle in an infinite lattice (Hinarejos M, Bañuls M C and Pérez A 2012 New J. Phys.14 103009) is extended here to include an internal degree of freedom as spin.This extension is made by introducing a Wigner matrix.The formalism is developed to account for dynamical processes, with or without decoherence.We show explicit solutions for the case of Hamiltonian evolution under a position-dependent potential, and for evolution governed by a master equation under some simple models of decoherence, for which the Wigner matrix formalism is well suited.Discrete processes are also discussed.Finally, we discuss the possibility of introducing a negativity concept for the Wigner function in the case where the spin degree of freedom is included.
The problem of constructing physically and mathematically well-defined Wigner functions for the canonical pair angle $\ensuremath{\theta}$ and angular momentum ppp is solved. While a key element for the construction of Wigner functions for the planar phase space ${(q,p)\ensuremath{\in}{\mathbb{R}}^{2}}$ is the Heisenberg-Weyl group, the corresponding group for the cylindrical phase space ${(\ensuremath{\theta},p)\ensuremath{\in}{S}^{1}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathbb{R}}$ is the Euclidean group E(2)E(2)E(2) of the plane and its unitary representations. Here the angle $\ensuremath{\theta}$ is replaced by the pair $(cos\ensuremath{\theta},sin\ensuremath{\theta})$, which corresponds uniquely to the points on the unit circle. The main structural properties of the Wigner functions for the planar and the cylindrical phase spaces are strikingly similar. A crucial role is played by the sincsincsinc function, which provides the interpolation for the discontinuous quantized angular momenta in terms of the continuous classical ones, in accordance with the famous Whittaker cardinal function well known from interpolation and sampling theories. The quantum mechanical marginal distributions for the angle (continuous) and angular momentum (discontinuous) are, as usual, uniquely obtained by appropriate integrations of the $(\ensuremath{\theta},p)$ Wigner function. Among the examples discussed is an elementary system of simple cat states.