Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics

The random-field puzzle. I. Solution by equivalent annealing

Moshe Schwartz

Published Jan 10, 1985• 51 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Random-field ferromagnetism systems are discussed, using an equivalent annealed system. It is shown how the critical exponents of the random system are related to the exponents of the pure system. The critical exponent eta is expressed in terms of a dimensionality reduction d'=d-2+ eta (d'). The lower critical dimension for the Ising model is two and for the continuous models it is four. Very strong arguments are given for a hyperscaling relation 2- alpha =d'v and for all the exponents to be given by a dimensionality reduction.

DOI
10.1088/0022-3719/18/1/019

Related papers

Critical exponents of the random-field O(N) model

Dima E. Feldman

The critical behavior of the random-field Ising model has been a puzzle for a long time. Different theoretical methods predict that the critical exponents of the random-field ferromagnet in D dimensions are the same as in the pure (D-2)-dimensional ferromagnet with the same number of the magnetization components. This result contradicts the experiments and simulations. We calculate the critical exponents of the random-field O(N) model with the (4+ε)-expansion and obtain values different from the critical exponents of the pure ferromagnet in 2+εdimensions. In contrast to the previous approaches we take into account an infinite set of relevant operators emerging in the problem. We demonstrate how these previously missed relevant operators lead to the breakdown of the (6-ε)-expansion for the random-field Ising model.

arXiv:cond-mat/0010012•Oct 1, 2000•3 citations

Critical exponents of the pure and random-field Ising models

Th. Jolicœur, Jean-Claude Le Guillou

We show that current estimates of the critical exponents of the three-dimensional random-field Ising model are in agreement with the exponents of the pure Ising system in dimension $3\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\theta}$ where \ensuremath{\theta} is the exponent that governs the hyperscaling violation in the random case.

arXiv:cond-mat/9706254•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Nov 1, 1997•5 citations

Critical Exponents of the Random-Field O(N) Model

Dima E. Feldman

The critical behavior of the random-field Ising model has long been a puzzle. Different methods predict that its critical exponents in D dimensions are the same as in the pure (D-2)-dimensional ferromagnet with the same number of the magnetization components contrary to the experiments and simulations. We calculate the exponents of the random-field O(N) model with the (4+epsilon)-expansion and obtain values different from the exponents of the pure ferromagnet in 2+epsilon dimensions. An infinite set of relevant operators missed in previous studies leads to a breakdown of the (6-epsilon)-expansion.

Physical Review Letters•Apr 15, 2002•62 citations

Scaling theory of the random-field Ising model

Alan J. Bray, M A Moore

The scaling laws derived by Grinstein (1976) for the random-field Ising model (RFIM) are rederived on the assumption that the transition is second order and that the critical behaviour is controlled by a zero-temperature fixed point. The scaling laws involve three independent exponents nu , eta and gamma , the last appearing in a modified hyperscaling relation, 2- alpha =(d-y) nu . It is argued that such hyperscaling modifications are a general feature of phase transitions controlled by zero-temperature fixed points. Explicit evaluation of the RFIM exponents in d=2+ epsilon dimensions, yields, to order epsilon , 1/ nu = epsilon , eta =1- epsilon /2 and y=1+ epsilon /2. The exponent nu is different from that of the pure model in (d-y) dimensions implying that no exact 'dimensional reduction' is possible near two dimensions.

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics•Oct 10, 1985•206 citations

Restoration of dimensional reduction in the random-field Ising model at five dimensions

Nikolaos G. Fytas, Víctor Martín-Mayor, Marco Picco +1 more

The random-field Ising model is one of the few disordered systems where the perturbative renormalization group can be carried out to all orders of perturbation theory. This analysis predicts dimensional reduction, i.e., that the critical properties of the random-field Ising model in D dimensions are identical to those of the pure Ising ferromagnet in D-2 dimensions. It is well known that dimensional reduction is not true in three dimensions, thus invalidating the perturbative renormalization group prediction. Here, we report high-precision numerical simulations of the 5D random-field Ising model at zero temperature. We illustrate universality by comparing different probability distributions for the random fields. We compute all the relevant critical exponents (including the critical slowing down exponent for the ground-state finding algorithm), as well as several other renormalization-group invariants. The estimated values of the critical exponents of the 5D random-field Ising model are statistically compatible to those of the pure 3D Ising ferromagnet. These results support the restoration of dimensional reduction at D=5. We thus conclude that the failure of the perturbative renormalization group is a low-dimensional phenomenon. We close our contribution by comparing universal quantities for the random-field problem at dimensions 3≤D<6 to their values in the pure Ising model at D-2 dimensions, and we provide a clear verification of the Rushbrooke equality at all studied dimensions.

arXiv:1612.06156•Physical review. E•Apr 10, 2017•49 citations

Lowering of Dimensionality in Phase Transitions with Random Fields

Amnon Aharony A, Y. Imry, Shang-keng Ma

We prove that to all orders in perturbation expansion, the critical exponents of a phase transition in a $d$-dimensional ($4<d<6$) system with short-range exchange and a random quenched field are the same as those of a ($d\ensuremath{-}2$)-dimensional pure system. Heuristic arguments are given to discuss both this result and the random-field Ising model for $2<d<6$.

Physical Review Letters•Nov 15, 1976•424 citations
Random-field ferromagnetism systems are discussed, using an equivalent annealed system. It is shown how the critical exponents of the random system are related to the exponents of the pure system. The critical exponent eta is expressed in terms of a dimensionality reduction d'=d-2+ eta (d'). The lower critical dimension for the Ising model is two and for the continuous models it is four. Very strong arguments are given for a hyperscaling relation 2- alpha =d'v and for all the exponents to be given by a dimensionality reduction.
The critical behavior of the random-field Ising model has been a puzzle for a long time. Different theoretical methods predict that the critical exponents of the random-field ferromagnet in D dimensions are the same as in the pure (D-2)-dimensional ferromagnet with the same number of the magnetization components. This result contradicts the experiments and simulations. We calculate the critical exponents of the random-field O(N) model with the (4+ε)-expansion and obtain values different from the critical exponents of the pure ferromagnet in 2+εdimensions. In contrast to the previous approaches we take into account an infinite set of relevant operators emerging in the problem. We demonstrate how these previously missed relevant operators lead to the breakdown of the (6-ε)-expansion for the random-field Ising model.
The critical behavior of the random-field Ising model has long been a puzzle. Different methods predict that its critical exponents in D dimensions are the same as in the pure (D-2)-dimensional ferromagnet with the same number of the magnetization components contrary to the experiments and simulations. We calculate the exponents of the random-field O(N) model with the (4+epsilon)-expansion and obtain values different from the exponents of the pure ferromagnet in 2+epsilon dimensions. An infinite set of relevant operators missed in previous studies leads to a breakdown of the (6-epsilon)-expansion.
The scaling laws derived by Grinstein (1976) for the random-field Ising model (RFIM) are rederived on the assumption that the transition is second order and that the critical behaviour is controlled by a zero-temperature fixed point. The scaling laws involve three independent exponents nu , eta and gamma , the last appearing in a modified hyperscaling relation, 2- alpha =(d-y) nu . It is argued that such hyperscaling modifications are a general feature of phase transitions controlled by zero-temperature fixed points. Explicit evaluation of the RFIM exponents in d=2+ epsilon dimensions, yields, to order epsilon , 1/ nu = epsilon , eta =1- epsilon /2 and y=1+ epsilon /2. The exponent nu is different from that of the pure model in (d-y) dimensions implying that no exact 'dimensional reduction' is possible near two dimensions.
The random-field Ising model is one of the few disordered systems where the perturbative renormalization group can be carried out to all orders of perturbation theory. This analysis predicts dimensional reduction, i.e., that the critical properties of the random-field Ising model in D dimensions are identical to those of the pure Ising ferromagnet in D-2 dimensions. It is well known that dimensional reduction is not true in three dimensions, thus invalidating the perturbative renormalization group prediction. Here, we report high-precision numerical simulations of the 5D random-field Ising model at zero temperature. We illustrate universality by comparing different probability distributions for the random fields. We compute all the relevant critical exponents (including the critical slowing down exponent for the ground-state finding algorithm), as well as several other renormalization-group invariants. The estimated values of the critical exponents of the 5D random-field Ising model are statistically compatible to those of the pure 3D Ising ferromagnet. These results support the restoration of dimensional reduction at D=5. We thus conclude that the failure of the perturbative renormalization group is a low-dimensional phenomenon. We close our contribution by comparing universal quantities for the random-field problem at dimensions 3≤D<6 to their values in the pure Ising model at D-2 dimensions, and we provide a clear verification of the Rushbrooke equality at all studied dimensions.
We prove that to all orders in perturbation expansion, the critical exponents of a phase transition in a ddd-dimensional (4<d<64<d<64<d<6) system with short-range exchange and a random quenched field are the same as those of a ($d\ensuremath{-}2$)-dimensional pure system. Heuristic arguments are given to discuss both this result and the random-field Ising model for 2<d<62<d<62<d<6.