© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

Terms Privacy Legal Notice

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry

Generalized Hellmann–Feynman and curvature theorems in classical and quantum mechanics

Jeremiah N. Silverman

Published May 1, 1984• 12 citations

Abstract

Abstract The generalized Hellmann–Feynman and curvature theorems are derived for the generalized Sturm–Liouville‐type eigenvalue equation which is widely encountered in many branches of physics. In classical mechanics, the Sturm–Liouville eigenvalue equation primarily arises from applying the theory of small oscillations to vibration problems while, in quantum mechanics, the most important example is the time‐independent Schrödinger equation. The generalized theorems, respectively, provide simple useful expressions for the first and second λ derivatives of the eigenvalue where λ is an arbitrary real parameter appearing in the eigenvalue equation. These results, which apply to both classical and quantal systems, include as special cases the well‐known quantum mechanical Hellmann–Feynman and curvature theorems for the time‐independent Schrödinger equation, thus unifying the formalism. This connection between classical and quantum mechanics is of interest per se, and also because classical eigenvalue equations find application in the treatment of some quantum chemical problems. Two derivations of both generalizations are presented, the first proof applying to exact and Rayleigh–Ritz (linear variational) solutions of the eigenvalue problem, and the second, more general one, to arbitrary optimal variational as well as exact solutions. Necessary and sufficient conditions for the validity of the results are discussed. To demonstrate the insight they afford, several applications of the theorems in conjunction with perturbation theory are described.

DOI: 10.1002/qua.560250512

Related papers

Extensions of the Feynman–Hellman theorem and applications

Sukhbinder Singh, Chetan Singh

Epstein’s [Am. J. Phys. 22, 613 (1954)] off-diagonal and higher-order extensions of the Feynman–Hellmann theorem, obtained by using the basic technique of parameter differentiation under the integral sign, are further pursued. Epstein’s rederivation of the Rayleigh–Schrödinger perturbation expansion is also extended to include the degenerate case. The same approach is also used to obtain the Lennard-Jones–Brillouin–Wigner perturbation theory. The quantum virial theorem and its off-diagonal generalization is deduced and its application is illustrated by taking the example of the linear harmonic oscillator. The semiclassical expression for the kinetic energy is obtained directly from the quantization condition.

American Journal of Physics•Oct 1, 1989•22 citations

- Time-independent Perturbation Theory and the Variational Principle

Alastair I. M. Rae, Jim Napolitano

Throughout our discussion of the general principles of quantum mechanics we have emphasized the importance of the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of the operators representing physical quantities. However, we have seen that solving the basic eigenvalue equations determining these is often not straightforward. In the early chapters discussing the energy eigenvalue equation (or time-independent Schro¨dinger equation) for example, we found that this could often not be solved exactly and that, even when a solution was possible, it frequently required considerable mathematical analysis. Because of this, methods have been developed to obtain approximate solutions to eigenvalue equations. One of the most important of such techniques is known as time-independent perturbation theory and will be the first method to be discussed in the present chapter. Another, known as the variational principle, will be discussed later. We shall confine our discussion to the timeindependent Schro¨dinger equation, but generalization to other eigenvalue equations is quite straightforward. We shall mainly use the wave function representation, but we shall restate some of the important results in Dirac notation so that they can be readily transformed to a matrix representation if desired.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 16, 2015•0 citations

Hellmann-Feynman Theorems in Classical and Quantum Mechanics

William A. McKinley

Theorems giving exact expressions for the derivative of the energy with respect to a parameter in the Hamiltonian for cyclic classical mechanical problems in both the relativistic and nonrelativistic cases are derived. Comparison is made with similar well-known theorems in the quantum mechanical case. Applications of both classical and quantum derivative relations are made to deduction of parametric dependence of the energy in simple cases, deduction of a meaning to the expectation value of the Dirac operator β, and construction of a test of consistency for a well posed problem in the theory of a Dirac particle in a bound state.

American Journal of Physics•Aug 1, 1971•22 citations

Deduction of Quantum Physics, Its Applications to the Eigenvalue Problems and Solving Two Puzzles of the Origins of Wave-Particle Duality and the First Quantization

Changyu Huang, Yong-Chang Huang, Jia-Min Song

This chapter demonstrates the deduction of quantum physics and, in particular, presents its new applications to eigenvalue problems. Specifically, it derives three of the five axiom presumptions of quantum mechanics (QM), for example, deducing the Schrödinger equation in two general ways. It transforms these three axiom presumptions into three theorems of QM, not only resolving the difficulty in understanding them but also yielding new theories and discoveries. For instance, this paper addresses the puzzle of the origin of wave-particle duality, derives operators, eigenvalues, and eigenstates, deduces commutation relations for coordinate and momentum as well as for time and energy, and reveals that QM is essentially a generalized (mechanics) theory of the complex square root of the (real density function of) classical statistical mechanics. The realization that QM is a generalized theory of the complex square root of classical statistical mechanics represents both a groundbreaking discovery and a revolutionary advancement in physics. This insight profoundly influences philosophical perspectives on the development of modern physics, resolves numerous puzzles in QM and quantum information, and provides QM with a scientifically solid foundation. This foundation eliminates the need for basic axiom presumptions and dispels the so-called “strange incomprehensible properties” of QM, as both classical statistical mechanics and its complex square root that have been scientifically validated. Additionally, this chapter uncovers the reason for not taking the time derivative of spatial coordinates in the Schrödinger equation. Consequently, it offers a solution to the puzzle of the origin of first quantization and primarily deduces quantum physics without the strange and incomprehensible properties currently associated with it.

IntechOpen eBooks•Aug 17, 2026•0 citations

Classical Hamiltonian structures in wave packet dynamics

Stephen K. Gray, John M. Verosky

The general, N state matrix representation of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation is equivalent to an N degree of freedom classical Hamiltonian system. We describe how classical mechanical methods and ideas can be applied towards understanding and modeling exact quantum dynamics. Two applications are presented. First, we illustrate how qualitative insights may be gained by treating the two state problem with a time-dependent coupling. In the case of periodic coupling, Poincaré surfaces of section are used to view the quantum dynamics, and features such as the Floquet modes take on interesting interpretations. The second application illustrates computational implications by showing how Liouville’s theorem, or more generally the symplectic nature of classical Hamiltonian dynamics, provides a new perspective for carrying out numerical wave packet propagation. We show how certain simple and explicit symplectic integrators can be used to numerically propagate wave packets. The approach is illustrated with an application to the problem of a diatomic molecule interacting with a laser, although it and related approaches may be useful for describing a variety of problems.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Apr 1, 1994•78 citations

Approximate energy levels of bound quantum systems

Francisco Marcelo Fernández, Eduardo Alberto Castro

A simple approximate method based on variational principles is used to obtain energy eigenvalues for bound quantum systems. It is shown that the approximate eigenvalues satisfy both virial and Hellmann–Feynman theorems. Results obtained by this method are compared with the exact solutions of the Schrödinger equation.

American Journal of Physics•May 1, 1984•5 citations

Abstract The generalized Hellmann–Feynman and curvature theorems are derived for the generalized Sturm–Liouville‐type eigenvalue equation which is widely encountered in many branches of physics. In classical mechanics, the Sturm–Liouville eigenvalue equation primarily arises from applying the theory of small oscillations to vibration problems while, in quantum mechanics, the most important example is the time‐independent Schrödinger equation. The generalized theorems, respectively, provide simple useful expressions for the first and second λ derivatives of the eigenvalue where λ is an arbitrary real parameter appearing in the eigenvalue equation. These results, which apply to both classical and quantal systems, include as special cases the well‐known quantum mechanical Hellmann–Feynman and curvature theorems for the time‐independent Schrödinger equation, thus unifying the formalism. This connection between classical and quantum mechanics is of interest per se, and also because classical eigenvalue equations find application in the treatment of some quantum chemical problems. Two derivations of both generalizations are presented, the first proof applying to exact and Rayleigh–Ritz (linear variational) solutions of the eigenvalue problem, and the second, more general one, to arbitrary optimal variational as well as exact solutions. Necessary and sufficient conditions for the validity of the results are discussed. To demonstrate the insight they afford, several applications of the theorems in conjunction with perturbation theory are described.

Epstein’s [Am. J. Phys. 22, 613 (1954)] off-diagonal and higher-order extensions of the Feynman–Hellmann theorem, obtained by using the basic technique of parameter differentiation under the integral sign, are further pursued. Epstein’s rederivation of the Rayleigh–Schrödinger perturbation expansion is also extended to include the degenerate case. The same approach is also used to obtain the Lennard-Jones–Brillouin–Wigner perturbation theory. The quantum virial theorem and its off-diagonal generalization is deduced and its application is illustrated by taking the example of the linear harmonic oscillator. The semiclassical expression for the kinetic energy is obtained directly from the quantization condition.

Throughout our discussion of the general principles of quantum mechanics we have emphasized the importance of the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of the operators representing physical quantities. However, we have seen that solving the basic eigenvalue equations determining these is often not straightforward. In the early chapters discussing the energy eigenvalue equation (or time-independent Schro¨dinger equation) for example, we found that this could often not be solved exactly and that, even when a solution was possible, it frequently required considerable mathematical analysis. Because of this, methods have been developed to obtain approximate solutions to eigenvalue equations. One of the most important of such techniques is known as time-independent perturbation theory and will be the first method to be discussed in the present chapter. Another, known as the variational principle, will be discussed later. We shall confine our discussion to the timeindependent Schro¨dinger equation, but generalization to other eigenvalue equations is quite straightforward. We shall mainly use the wave function representation, but we shall restate some of the important results in Dirac notation so that they can be readily transformed to a matrix representation if desired.

Theorems giving exact expressions for the derivative of the energy with respect to a parameter in the Hamiltonian for cyclic classical mechanical problems in both the relativistic and nonrelativistic cases are derived. Comparison is made with similar well-known theorems in the quantum mechanical case. Applications of both classical and quantum derivative relations are made to deduction of parametric dependence of the energy in simple cases, deduction of a meaning to the expectation value of the Dirac operator β, and construction of a test of consistency for a well posed problem in the theory of a Dirac particle in a bound state.

This chapter demonstrates the deduction of quantum physics and, in particular, presents its new applications to eigenvalue problems. Specifically, it derives three of the five axiom presumptions of quantum mechanics (QM), for example, deducing the Schrödinger equation in two general ways. It transforms these three axiom presumptions into three theorems of QM, not only resolving the difficulty in understanding them but also yielding new theories and discoveries. For instance, this paper addresses the puzzle of the origin of wave-particle duality, derives operators, eigenvalues, and eigenstates, deduces commutation relations for coordinate and momentum as well as for time and energy, and reveals that QM is essentially a generalized (mechanics) theory of the complex square root of the (real density function of) classical statistical mechanics. The realization that QM is a generalized theory of the complex square root of classical statistical mechanics represents both a groundbreaking discovery and a revolutionary advancement in physics. This insight profoundly influences philosophical perspectives on the development of modern physics, resolves numerous puzzles in QM and quantum information, and provides QM with a scientifically solid foundation. This foundation eliminates the need for basic axiom presumptions and dispels the so-called “strange incomprehensible properties” of QM, as both classical statistical mechanics and its complex square root that have been scientifically validated. Additionally, this chapter uncovers the reason for not taking the time derivative of spatial coordinates in the Schrödinger equation. Consequently, it offers a solution to the puzzle of the origin of first quantization and primarily deduces quantum physics without the strange and incomprehensible properties currently associated with it.

The general, N state matrix representation of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation is equivalent to an N degree of freedom classical Hamiltonian system. We describe how classical mechanical methods and ideas can be applied towards understanding and modeling exact quantum dynamics. Two applications are presented. First, we illustrate how qualitative insights may be gained by treating the two state problem with a time-dependent coupling. In the case of periodic coupling, Poincaré surfaces of section are used to view the quantum dynamics, and features such as the Floquet modes take on interesting interpretations. The second application illustrates computational implications by showing how Liouville’s theorem, or more generally the symplectic nature of classical Hamiltonian dynamics, provides a new perspective for carrying out numerical wave packet propagation. We show how certain simple and explicit symplectic integrators can be used to numerically propagate wave packets. The approach is illustrated with an application to the problem of a diatomic molecule interacting with a laser, although it and related approaches may be useful for describing a variety of problems.