Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Complementarity and certainty relations for two-dimensional systems

Alfredo Luis

Published Jun 6, 2001• 34 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Very simple duality relations assessing complementarity for two-dimensional systems are obtained by introducing a measure of fluctuations derived from dispersion. These relations fully explain the enforcement of complementarity in situations in which the standard position-momentum uncertainty relation plays no role.
DOI
10.1103/physreva.64.012103

Related papers

Complementarity and duality relations for finite-dimensional systems

Alfredo Luis

We generalize to systems with arbitrary finite dimension a measure of quantum fluctuations (the certainty) previously introduced for two-dimensional systems. Using this measure, we study the duality relations satisfied by complementary observables looking for states with minimum joint fluctuations (maximum certainty states). We extend the duality relations to encompass several complementary observables simultaneously.

Physical Review A•Mar 19, 2003•28 citations

The Complementary Information Principle of Quantum Mechanics

Yunlong Xiao, Kun Fang, Gilad Gour

The uncertainty principle bounds the uncertainties about incompatible measurements, clearly setting quantum theory apart from the classical world. Its mathematical formulation via uncertainty relations, plays an irreplaceable role in quantum technologies. However, neither the uncertainty principle nor uncertainty relations can fully describe the complementarity between quantum measurements. As an attempt to advance the efforts of complementarity in quantum theories, we formally propose a complementary information principle, significantly extending the one introduced by Heisenberg. First, we build a framework of black box testing consisting of pre- and post-testing with two incompatible measurements, introducing a rigorous mathematical expression of complementarity with definite information causality. Second, we provide majorization lower and upper bounds for the complementary information by utilizing the tool of semidefinite programming. In particular, we prove that our bounds are optimal under majorization due to the completeness of the majorization lattice. Finally, as applications to our framework, we present a general method to outer-approximating all uncertainty regions and also establish fundamental limits for all qualified joint uncertainties.

arXiv:1908.07694•Aug 21, 2019•5 citations

More certainty about the uncertainty principle

Jan Hilgevoord, Jos Uffink

The uncertainty principle of position and momentum is a mathematically more involved relation than is usually realised. The well-known Heisenberg uncertainty relation between standard deviations is much too weak to express the uncertainty principle. By employing other notions of width, relations are given which do express the uncertainty principle.

European Journal of Physics•Jul 1, 1985•21 citations

Uncertainty is complementary to Complementarity

Ole Steuernagel

For any ideal two-path interferometer it is shown that the wave-particle duality of quantum mechanics implies Heisenberg's uncertainty relation and vice versa. It is conjectured that complementarity and uncertainty are two aspects of the same general principle.

arXiv:quant-ph/9908011•Aug 3, 1999•2 citations

Complementarity for Generalized Observables

Alfredo Luis

We examine basic properties of complementarity by using the most general description of quantum observables as positive-operator measures. We show that, in general, two observables can be complementary or not depending on the measure of fluctuations adopted and that complementarity is not a symmetric relation. This occurs because the states that determine the measured statistics do not necessarily coincide with the minimum uncertainty states for the same observable. We also show that there are observables without a complementary observable and that complementarity is not preserved by the Neumark extensions.

Physical Review Letters•May 22, 2002•16 citations

Position-momentum entropic uncertainty relation and complementarity in single-slit and double-slit experiments

Jorge Sánchez-Ruiz

The exact analytical values of the position and momentum information entropies are calculated for the single-slit and double-slit diffraction experiments. In both cases, the product of the exponentials of the entropies is strictly greater than the lower bound $\ensuremath{\pi}e\ensuremath{\Elzxh}$ given by the optimal entropic uncertainty relation for position and momentum, which implies that the single-slit and double-slit configurations are not minimum-uncertainty states. The results obtained show that the position-momentum entropic uncertainty relation provides a rigorous quantitative expression for the uncertainty principle in these experiments, unlike the Heisenberg inequality for standard deviations. However, it is also shown that, in the double-slit experiment, wave-particle duality cannot be derived from the entropic uncertainty relation.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1998•18 citations
The uncertainty principle bounds the uncertainties about incompatible measurements, clearly setting quantum theory apart from the classical world. Its mathematical formulation via uncertainty relations, plays an irreplaceable role in quantum technologies. However, neither the uncertainty principle nor uncertainty relations can fully describe the complementarity between quantum measurements. As an attempt to advance the efforts of complementarity in quantum theories, we formally propose a complementary information principle, significantly extending the one introduced by Heisenberg. First, we build a framework of black box testing consisting of pre- and post-testing with two incompatible measurements, introducing a rigorous mathematical expression of complementarity with definite information causality. Second, we provide majorization lower and upper bounds for the complementary information by utilizing the tool of semidefinite programming. In particular, we prove that our bounds are optimal under majorization due to the completeness of the majorization lattice. Finally, as applications to our framework, we present a general method to outer-approximating all uncertainty regions and also establish fundamental limits for all qualified joint uncertainties.
We examine basic properties of complementarity by using the most general description of quantum observables as positive-operator measures. We show that, in general, two observables can be complementary or not depending on the measure of fluctuations adopted and that complementarity is not a symmetric relation. This occurs because the states that determine the measured statistics do not necessarily coincide with the minimum uncertainty states for the same observable. We also show that there are observables without a complementary observable and that complementarity is not preserved by the Neumark extensions.
The exact analytical values of the position and momentum information entropies are calculated for the single-slit and double-slit diffraction experiments. In both cases, the product of the exponentials of the entropies is strictly greater than the lower bound $\ensuremath{\pi}e\ensuremath{\Elzxh}$ given by the optimal entropic uncertainty relation for position and momentum, which implies that the single-slit and double-slit configurations are not minimum-uncertainty states. The results obtained show that the position-momentum entropic uncertainty relation provides a rigorous quantitative expression for the uncertainty principle in these experiments, unlike the Heisenberg inequality for standard deviations. However, it is also shown that, in the double-slit experiment, wave-particle duality cannot be derived from the entropic uncertainty relation.