Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Scaling in Spin-Glasses

Daniel S. Fisher, Haim Sompolinsky

Published Mar 11, 1985• 82 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Many results of the mean-field theory of spin-glasses violate simple scaling laws, including the magnetic field dependence of the transition lines, crossover effects of random anisotropy, and critical behavior in the ordered phase. These violations arise from two dangerously irrelevant variables. Below eight dimensions some mean-field exponents change and at $d=6$ scaling is restored. Below $d=6$ all scaling laws should be valid implying that the critical properties of real spin-glasses should be simpler than in mean-field theory. Experimental consequences are discussed.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.54.1063

Related papers

Spin-glass transition in a magnetic field: A renormalization group study

Iveta R. Pimentel, T. Temesvári, C. De Dominicis

We study the transition of short-range Ising spin glasses in a magnetic field, within a general replica symmetric field theory, which contains three masses and eight cubic couplings, that is defined in terms of the fields representing the replicon, anomalous, and longitudinal modes. We discuss the symmetry of the theory in the limit of replica number $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{n}0,$ and consider the regular case where the longitudinal and anomalous masses remain degenerate. The spin-glass transitions in zero and nonzero fields are analyzed in a common framework. The mean-field treatment shows the usual results, that is a transition in zero field, where all the modes become critical, and a transition in nonzero field, at the de Almeida--Thouless (AT) line, with only the replicon mode critical. Renormalization group methods are used to study the critical behavior, to order $\ensuremath{\varepsilon}=6\ensuremath{-}d.$ In the general theory we find a stable fixed point associated with a spin-glass transition in a zero field. This fixed point becomes unstable in the presence of a small magnetic field, and we calculate crossover exponents, which we relate to zero-field critical exponents. In a finite magnetic field, we find no physical stable fixed point to describe the AT transition, in agreement with previous results of other authors.

arXiv:cond-mat/0204615•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jun 6, 2002•50 citations

Finite-size critical scaling in Ising spin glasses in the mean-field regime

Timo Aspelmeier, Helmut G. Katzgraber, Derek Larson +3 more

We study in Ising spin glasses the finite-size effects near the spin-glass transition in zero field and at the de Almeida-Thouless transition in a field by Monte Carlo methods and by analytical approximations. In zero field, the finite-size scaling function associated with the spin-glass susceptibility of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick mean-field spin-glass model is of the same form as that of one-dimensional spin-glass models with power-law long-range interactions in the regime where they can be a proxy for the Edwards-Anderson short-range spin-glass model above the upper critical dimension. We also calculate a simple analytical approximation for the spin-glass susceptibility crossover function. The behavior of the spin-glass susceptibility near the de Almeida-Thouless transition line has also been studied, but here we have only been able to obtain analytically its behavior in the asymptotic limit above and below the transition. We have also simulated the one-dimensional system in a field in the non-mean-field regime to illustrate that when the Imry-Ma droplet length scale exceeds the system size one can then be erroneously lead to conclude that there is a de Almeida-Thouless transition even though it is absent.

arXiv:1509.05372•Physical review. E•Mar 14, 2016•21 citations

Critical point scaling of Ising spin glasses in a magnetic field

Joonhyun Yeo, M A Moore

Critical point scaling in a field $H$ applies for the limits $t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ (where $t=T/{T}_{c}\ensuremath{-}1)$ and $H\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ but with the ratio $R=t/{H}^{2/\ensuremath{\Delta}}$ finite. $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ is a critical exponent of the zero-field transition. We study the replicon correlation length $\ensuremath{\xi}$ and from it the crossover scaling function $f(R)$ defined via $1/(\ensuremath{\xi}{H}^{4/(d+2\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\eta})})\ensuremath{\sim}f(R)$. We have calculated analytically $f(R)$ for the mean-field limit of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model. In dimension $d=3$, we have determined the exponents and the critical scaling function $f(R)$ within two versions of the Migdal-Kadanoff (MK) renormalization group procedure. One of the MK versions gives results for $f(R)$ in $d=3$ in reasonable agreement with those of the Monte Carlo simulations at the values of $R$ for which they can be compared. If there were a de Almeida-Thouless (AT) line for $d\ensuremath{\le}6$, it would appear as a zero of the function $f(R)$ at some negative value of $R$, but there is no evidence for such behavior. This is consistent with the arguments that there should be no AT line for $d\ensuremath{\le}6$, which we review.

arXiv:1412.2448•Physical Review B•Mar 30, 2015•11 citations

Static chaos and scaling behavior in the spin-glass phase

Félix Ritort

We discuss the problem of static chaos in spin glasses. In the case of magnetic-field perturbations, we propose a scaling theory for the spin-glass phase. Using the mean-field approach we argue that some pure states are suppressed by the magnetic field and their free-energy cost is determined by the finite-temperature fixed-point exponents. In this framework, numerical results suggest that mean-field chaos exponents are probably exact in finite dimensions. If we use the droplet approach, numerical results suggest that the zero-temperature fixed-point exponent \ensuremath{\theta} is very close to (d-3)/2. In both approaches d=3 is the lower critical dimension in agreement with recent numerical simulations.

arXiv:cond-mat/9404020•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Sep 1, 1994•53 citations

Short-range interactions: low-temperature properties

K. H. Fischer, John Hertz

The mean field theory discussed in the preceding chapters revealed a surprisingly rich structure and in particular a very complex ordered phase with many ‘pure’ states. However, we know from periodic systems that the mean field theory does not always give the right answer. In this and the next two chapters, we will discuss alternative approaches to the study of spin glasses with short-range interactions. The most important one will be the renormalization group which led to a deep understanding of phase transitions (and in particular critical behaviour) of nonrandom systems and which has also turned out to be extremely useful for the study of spin glasses. Together with Monte Carlo simulations and experimental data, this will give us a fairly complete picture, at least of static spin glass properties below T f . Critical behaviour near T f and scaling arguments for T < T f have also been considered for the spin glass dynamics but here the situation seems to be less clear. Depending on the system, the remanent magnetization decays with quite different decay laws (see Chapter 1), which indicates that not all dynamic processes are universal. However, all spin glasses have a huge range of characteristic relaxation times, ranging from 10 −13 s (the Korringa relaxation in a metallic spin glass) to 10 −6 – 10 −8 s. This long-time limit is not inherent to the system but is simply determined by the patience of an experimentalist (or the average time of a student's thesis).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 2, 1991•0 citations

Low-temperature phase boundary of dilute-lattice spin glasses

Stefan Boettcher, Emiliano Marchetti

The thermal-to-percolative crossover exponent $\ensuremath{\phi}$, well known for ferromagnetic systems, is studied extensively for Edwards--Anderson spin glasses. The scaling of defect energies are determined at the bond percolation threshold ${p}_{c}$ using an improved reduction algorithm. Simulations extend to system sizes above $N={10}^{8}$ in dimensions $d=2,\dots{},7$. The results can be related to the behavior of the transition temperature ${T}_{g}\ensuremath{\sim}{(p\ensuremath{-}{p}_{c})}^{\ensuremath{\phi}}$ between the paramagnetic and the glassy regime for $p\ensuremath{\searrow}{p}_{c}$. In three dimensions, where our simulations predict $\ensuremath{\phi}=1.127(5)$, this scaling form for ${T}_{g}$ provides a rare experimental test of predictions arising from the equilibrium theory of low-temperature spin glasses. For dimensions near and above the upper critical dimension, the results provide a challenge to reconcile mean-field theory with finite-dimensional properties.

Physical Review B•Mar 27, 2008•3 citations
Many results of the mean-field theory of spin-glasses violate simple scaling laws, including the magnetic field dependence of the transition lines, crossover effects of random anisotropy, and critical behavior in the ordered phase. These violations arise from two dangerously irrelevant variables. Below eight dimensions some mean-field exponents change and at d=6d=6d=6 scaling is restored. Below d=6d=6d=6 all scaling laws should be valid implying that the critical properties of real spin-glasses should be simpler than in mean-field theory. Experimental consequences are discussed.
We study the transition of short-range Ising spin glasses in a magnetic field, within a general replica symmetric field theory, which contains three masses and eight cubic couplings, that is defined in terms of the fields representing the replicon, anomalous, and longitudinal modes. We discuss the symmetry of the theory in the limit of replica number $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{n}0,$ and consider the regular case where the longitudinal and anomalous masses remain degenerate. The spin-glass transitions in zero and nonzero fields are analyzed in a common framework. The mean-field treatment shows the usual results, that is a transition in zero field, where all the modes become critical, and a transition in nonzero field, at the de Almeida--Thouless (AT) line, with only the replicon mode critical. Renormalization group methods are used to study the critical behavior, to order $\ensuremath{\varepsilon}=6\ensuremath{-}d.$ In the general theory we find a stable fixed point associated with a spin-glass transition in a zero field. This fixed point becomes unstable in the presence of a small magnetic field, and we calculate crossover exponents, which we relate to zero-field critical exponents. In a finite magnetic field, we find no physical stable fixed point to describe the AT transition, in agreement with previous results of other authors.
We study in Ising spin glasses the finite-size effects near the spin-glass transition in zero field and at the de Almeida-Thouless transition in a field by Monte Carlo methods and by analytical approximations. In zero field, the finite-size scaling function associated with the spin-glass susceptibility of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick mean-field spin-glass model is of the same form as that of one-dimensional spin-glass models with power-law long-range interactions in the regime where they can be a proxy for the Edwards-Anderson short-range spin-glass model above the upper critical dimension. We also calculate a simple analytical approximation for the spin-glass susceptibility crossover function. The behavior of the spin-glass susceptibility near the de Almeida-Thouless transition line has also been studied, but here we have only been able to obtain analytically its behavior in the asymptotic limit above and below the transition. We have also simulated the one-dimensional system in a field in the non-mean-field regime to illustrate that when the Imry-Ma droplet length scale exceeds the system size one can then be erroneously lead to conclude that there is a de Almeida-Thouless transition even though it is absent.
Critical point scaling in a field HHH applies for the limits $t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ (where $t=T/{T}_{c}\ensuremath{-}1)$ and $H\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$ but with the ratio $R=t/{H}^{2/\ensuremath{\Delta}}$ finite. $\ensuremath{\Delta}$ is a critical exponent of the zero-field transition. We study the replicon correlation length $\ensuremath{\xi}$ and from it the crossover scaling function f(R)f(R)f(R) defined via $1/(\ensuremath{\xi}{H}^{4/(d+2\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\eta})})\ensuremath{\sim}f(R)$. We have calculated analytically f(R)f(R)f(R) for the mean-field limit of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick model. In dimension d=3d=3d=3, we have determined the exponents and the critical scaling function f(R)f(R)f(R) within two versions of the Migdal-Kadanoff (MK) renormalization group procedure. One of the MK versions gives results for f(R)f(R)f(R) in d=3d=3d=3 in reasonable agreement with those of the Monte Carlo simulations at the values of RRR for which they can be compared. If there were a de Almeida-Thouless (AT) line for $d\ensuremath{\le}6$, it would appear as a zero of the function f(R)f(R)f(R) at some negative value of RRR, but there is no evidence for such behavior. This is consistent with the arguments that there should be no AT line for $d\ensuremath{\le}6$, which we review.
We discuss the problem of static chaos in spin glasses. In the case of magnetic-field perturbations, we propose a scaling theory for the spin-glass phase. Using the mean-field approach we argue that some pure states are suppressed by the magnetic field and their free-energy cost is determined by the finite-temperature fixed-point exponents. In this framework, numerical results suggest that mean-field chaos exponents are probably exact in finite dimensions. If we use the droplet approach, numerical results suggest that the zero-temperature fixed-point exponent \ensuremath{\theta} is very close to (d-3)/2. In both approaches d=3 is the lower critical dimension in agreement with recent numerical simulations.
The mean field theory discussed in the preceding chapters revealed a surprisingly rich structure and in particular a very complex ordered phase with many ‘pure’ states. However, we know from periodic systems that the mean field theory does not always give the right answer. In this and the next two chapters, we will discuss alternative approaches to the study of spin glasses with short-range interactions. The most important one will be the renormalization group which led to a deep understanding of phase transitions (and in particular critical behaviour) of nonrandom systems and which has also turned out to be extremely useful for the study of spin glasses. Together with Monte Carlo simulations and experimental data, this will give us a fairly complete picture, at least of static spin glass properties below T f . Critical behaviour near T f and scaling arguments for T < T f have also been considered for the spin glass dynamics but here the situation seems to be less clear. Depending on the system, the remanent magnetization decays with quite different decay laws (see Chapter 1), which indicates that not all dynamic processes are universal. However, all spin glasses have a huge range of characteristic relaxation times, ranging from 10 −13 s (the Korringa relaxation in a metallic spin glass) to 10 −6 – 10 −8 s. This long-time limit is not inherent to the system but is simply determined by the patience of an experimentalist (or the average time of a student's thesis).
The thermal-to-percolative crossover exponent $\ensuremath{\phi}$, well known for ferromagnetic systems, is studied extensively for Edwards--Anderson spin glasses. The scaling of defect energies are determined at the bond percolation threshold pc{p}_{c}pc​ using an improved reduction algorithm. Simulations extend to system sizes above N=108N={10}^{8}N=108 in dimensions d=2,…,7d=2,\dots{},7d=2,…,7. The results can be related to the behavior of the transition temperature ${T}_{g}\ensuremath{\sim}{(p\ensuremath{-}{p}_{c})}^{\ensuremath{\phi}}$ between the paramagnetic and the glassy regime for $p\ensuremath{\searrow}{p}_{c}$. In three dimensions, where our simulations predict $\ensuremath{\phi}=1.127(5)$, this scaling form for Tg{T}_{g}Tg​ provides a rare experimental test of predictions arising from the equilibrium theory of low-temperature spin glasses. For dimensions near and above the upper critical dimension, the results provide a challenge to reconcile mean-field theory with finite-dimensional properties.