Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Contradictions between different measures of quantum uncertainty

Paloma Matía-Hernando, Alfredo Luis

Published Nov 9, 2012• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We show that variance and Shannon entropy provide contradictory conclusions for the uncertainty associated with the number operator for some families of states of harmonic oscillator systems with fixed mean number, and for the uncertainty of a spin component for states with and without fixed mean. We analyze this behavior in terms of the properties of these uncertainty measures. We explore their impact on quantum metrology, examining the limits to resolution caused by number fluctuations in diverse scenarios of phase-shift detection.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.86.052106

Related papers

Alternative measures of uncertainty in quantum metrology: Contradictions and limits

Alfredo Luis, Alfonso Rodil

We examine a family of intrinsic performance measures in terms of probability distributions that generalize Hellinger distance and Fisher information. They are applied to quantum metrology to assess the uncertainty in the detection of minute changes of physical quantities. We show that different measures lead to contradictory conclusions, including the possibility of arbitrarily small uncertainty for fixed resources. These intrinsic performances are compared with the averaged error in the corresponding estimation problem after single-shot measurements.

arXiv:1201.3072•Physical Review A•Mar 7, 2013•18 citations

Quantum uncertainties of the confined Harmonic Oscillator in position, momentum and phase‐space

Humberto G. Laguna, Robin P. Sagar

Quantum uncertainties in position, momentum and phase‐space are studied in the confined Harmonic Oscillator. Standard deviations and Shannon entropies are used to quantify these uncertainties and their behaviors are compared and contrasted. We observe a minimum in the momentum space Shannon entropy as the box length is increased, a feature that is not present in the momentum space standard deviation. The behaviors of the standard deviation product and the Shannon entropy sum, which form the basis of uncertainty relationships, are also analyzed. Maxima are observed in the product as the box length increases in sharp contrast to the entropy sum. The relationship between these behaviors and that of the Shannon entropy of the phase‐space Wigner function is analyzed and discussed. An analysis of the energetic components is also performed. The results reinforce the idea that the confined Harmonic Oscillator can be considered as an intermediate model which interpolates between the Particle in a Box Model and the Harmonic Oscillator and thus contains characteristics of both models. image

Annalen der Physik•Oct 21, 2014•24 citations

Information-theoretic measure of uncertainty due to quantum and thermal fluctuations

Arlen Anderson, J. J. Halliwell

We study an information-theoretic measure of uncertainty for quantum systems. It is the Shannon information I of the phase-space probability distribution 〈z\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\rho}\ensuremath{\Vert}z〉, where \ensuremath{\Vert}z〉 are coherent states and \ensuremath{\rho} is the density matrix. As shown by Lieb I\ensuremath{\ge}1, and this bound represents a strengthened version of the uncertainty principle. For a harmonic oscillator in a thermal state, I coincides with von Neumann entropy, -Tr(\ensuremath{\rho}ln\ensuremath{\rho}), in the high-temperature regime, but unlike entropy, it is nonzero (and equal to the Lieb bound) at zero temperature. It therefore supplies a nontrivial measure of uncertainty due to both quantum and thermal fluctuations. We study I as a function of time for a class of nonequilibrium quantum systems consisting of a distinguished system coupled to a heat bath. We derive an evolution equation for I. For the harmonic oscillator, in the Fokker-Planck regime, we show that I increases monotonically, if the width of the coherent states is chosen to be the same as the width of the harmonic oscillator ground state. For other choices of the width, and for more general Hamiltonians, I settles down to a monotonic increase in the long run, but may suffer an initial decrease for certain initial states that undergo ``reassembly'' (the opposite of quantum spreading). Our main result is to prove, for linear systems, that I at each moment of time has a lower bound ${\mathit{I}}_{\mathit{t}}^{\mathrm{min}}$, over all possible initial states.This bound is a generalization of the uncertainty principle to include thermal fluctuations in nonequilibrium systems, and represents the least amount of uncertainty the system must suffer after evolution in the presence of an environment for time t. ${\mathit{I}}_{\mathit{t}}^{\mathrm{min}}$ is an envelope, equal for each time t, to the time evolution of I for a certain initial state, which we calculate to be a nonminimal Gaussian. ${\mathit{I}}_{\mathit{t}}^{\mathrm{min}}$ coincides with the Lieb bound in the absence of an environment, and is related to von Neumann entropy in the long-time limit. The form of ${\mathit{I}}_{\mathit{t}}^{\mathrm{min}}$ indicates that the thermal fluctuations become comparable with the quantum fluctuations on a time scale equal to the decoherence time scale, in agreement with earlier work of Hu and Zhang. Our results are also related to those of Zurek, Habib, and Paz, who looked for the set of initial states generating the least amount of von Neumann entropy after a fixed period of nonunitary evolution.

arXiv:gr-qc/9304025•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Sep 15, 1993•130 citations

Entropic uncertainty relations for a quantum oscillator

Vladimír Majerník, Tomáš Opatrný

We calculated the Shannon entropy of position and momentum for the stationary quantum states of the harmonic oscillator as a function of its energy and determined the corresponding entropic uncertainty relations for them. We found an approximate phenomenological function for the dependence of position and momentum entropies on the large quantum numbers and the corresponding asymptotic entropy - energy relation for the stationary harmonic oscillator. We also studied the time evolution of the position and momentum entropies of the non-stationary harmonic oscillator for the coherent states, squeezed vacuum and Schrödinger cat states.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•May 7, 1996•110 citations

Two Kinds of Uncertainty? Variances and Resolution in Quantum Bound States

Francesco R. Ruggeri

In (1), which deals with entropic uncertainty relationships, it is pointed out that x-variances of quantum bound states may possibly behave in a counterintuitive manner. In particular an example is given of two small boxes attached to the ends of a long pipe centered at zero so the average x is 0. If a particle has a probability of .5 to be in one box or the other a certain variance is found. If the particle can also be anywhere along the pipe or in the boxes the authors of (1) argue there is more uncertainty yet the variance decreases. Mathematically this occurs because there is now probability associated with small x values. We argue this is only counterintuitive if one considers probability distributions which decrease monotonically such as a Gaussian. In such a case, the variance increases if the particle is spread over a larger range. Such, however, does not seem to be the case if one has increased resolution which seems to be the case for quantum bound states such as a particle in a box with infinite potential walls or a quantum oscillator. Increased resolution occurs with increasing energy, but by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle the variance of p and x (or at least their product) increases. Increased resolution which seems to be linked to more order (less uncertainty) as argued in (1) can lead to an increased variance if probability only exists at distances far from the origin (i.e. high x) as in the closed two boxes example. As a result, the idea of uncertainty in the expression Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle seems to be based on the idea of how far the particle may be from the average value. As noted in (1) this means a large variance, but could represent high resolution i.e. a lack of uncertainty in finding the particle. We suggest there are two different kinds of uncertainty, Heisenberg’s uncertainty linked to the average and a resolution uncertainty. We examine the cases of a particle in a box and and the quantum oscillator.

•May 14, 2022•0 citations

Complexity measures and uncertainty relations of the high-dimensional harmonic and hydrogenic systems

Nahual Sobrino, David Puertas‐Centeno, I. V. Toranzo +1 more

Abstract In this work we find that not only the Heisenberg-like uncertainty products and the Rényi-entropy-based uncertainty sum have the same first-order values for all the quantum states of the D -dimensional hydrogenic and oscillator-like systems, respectively, in the pseudoclassical ( D → ∞ ) limit but a similar phenomenon also happens for both the Fisher-information-based uncertainty product and the Shannon-entropy-based uncertainty sum, as well as for the Crámer–Rao and Fisher–Shannon complexities. Moreover, we show that the López–Ruiz–Mancini–Calvet (LMC) and LMC-Rényi complexity measures capture the hydrogenic-harmonic difference in the high dimensional limit already at first order.

arXiv:1708.07299•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Aug 1, 2017•24 citations
We show that variance and Shannon entropy provide contradictory conclusions for the uncertainty associated with the number operator for some families of states of harmonic oscillator systems with fixed mean number, and for the uncertainty of a spin component for states with and without fixed mean. We analyze this behavior in terms of the properties of these uncertainty measures. We explore their impact on quantum metrology, examining the limits to resolution caused by number fluctuations in diverse scenarios of phase-shift detection.
We examine a family of intrinsic performance measures in terms of probability distributions that generalize Hellinger distance and Fisher information. They are applied to quantum metrology to assess the uncertainty in the detection of minute changes of physical quantities. We show that different measures lead to contradictory conclusions, including the possibility of arbitrarily small uncertainty for fixed resources. These intrinsic performances are compared with the averaged error in the corresponding estimation problem after single-shot measurements.
Quantum uncertainties in position, momentum and phase‐space are studied in the confined Harmonic Oscillator. Standard deviations and Shannon entropies are used to quantify these uncertainties and their behaviors are compared and contrasted. We observe a minimum in the momentum space Shannon entropy as the box length is increased, a feature that is not present in the momentum space standard deviation. The behaviors of the standard deviation product and the Shannon entropy sum, which form the basis of uncertainty relationships, are also analyzed. Maxima are observed in the product as the box length increases in sharp contrast to the entropy sum. The relationship between these behaviors and that of the Shannon entropy of the phase‐space Wigner function is analyzed and discussed. An analysis of the energetic components is also performed. The results reinforce the idea that the confined Harmonic Oscillator can be considered as an intermediate model which interpolates between the Particle in a Box Model and the Harmonic Oscillator and thus contains characteristics of both models. image
We study an information-theoretic measure of uncertainty for quantum systems. It is the Shannon information I of the phase-space probability distribution 〈z\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\rho}\ensuremath{\Vert}z〉, where \ensuremath{\Vert}z〉 are coherent states and \ensuremath{\rho} is the density matrix. As shown by Lieb I\ensuremath{\ge}1, and this bound represents a strengthened version of the uncertainty principle. For a harmonic oscillator in a thermal state, I coincides with von Neumann entropy, -Tr(\ensuremath{\rho}ln\ensuremath{\rho}), in the high-temperature regime, but unlike entropy, it is nonzero (and equal to the Lieb bound) at zero temperature. It therefore supplies a nontrivial measure of uncertainty due to both quantum and thermal fluctuations. We study I as a function of time for a class of nonequilibrium quantum systems consisting of a distinguished system coupled to a heat bath. We derive an evolution equation for I. For the harmonic oscillator, in the Fokker-Planck regime, we show that I increases monotonically, if the width of the coherent states is chosen to be the same as the width of the harmonic oscillator ground state. For other choices of the width, and for more general Hamiltonians, I settles down to a monotonic increase in the long run, but may suffer an initial decrease for certain initial states that undergo ``reassembly'' (the opposite of quantum spreading). Our main result is to prove, for linear systems, that I at each moment of time has a lower bound Itmin{\mathit{I}}_{\mathit{t}}^{\mathrm{min}}Itmin​, over all possible initial states.This bound is a generalization of the uncertainty principle to include thermal fluctuations in nonequilibrium systems, and represents the least amount of uncertainty the system must suffer after evolution in the presence of an environment for time t. Itmin{\mathit{I}}_{\mathit{t}}^{\mathrm{min}}Itmin​ is an envelope, equal for each time t, to the time evolution of I for a certain initial state, which we calculate to be a nonminimal Gaussian. Itmin{\mathit{I}}_{\mathit{t}}^{\mathrm{min}}Itmin​ coincides with the Lieb bound in the absence of an environment, and is related to von Neumann entropy in the long-time limit. The form of Itmin{\mathit{I}}_{\mathit{t}}^{\mathrm{min}}Itmin​ indicates that the thermal fluctuations become comparable with the quantum fluctuations on a time scale equal to the decoherence time scale, in agreement with earlier work of Hu and Zhang. Our results are also related to those of Zurek, Habib, and Paz, who looked for the set of initial states generating the least amount of von Neumann entropy after a fixed period of nonunitary evolution.
We calculated the Shannon entropy of position and momentum for the stationary quantum states of the harmonic oscillator as a function of its energy and determined the corresponding entropic uncertainty relations for them. We found an approximate phenomenological function for the dependence of position and momentum entropies on the large quantum numbers and the corresponding asymptotic entropy - energy relation for the stationary harmonic oscillator. We also studied the time evolution of the position and momentum entropies of the non-stationary harmonic oscillator for the coherent states, squeezed vacuum and Schrödinger cat states.
In (1), which deals with entropic uncertainty relationships, it is pointed out that x-variances of quantum bound states may possibly behave in a counterintuitive manner. In particular an example is given of two small boxes attached to the ends of a long pipe centered at zero so the average x is 0. If a particle has a probability of .5 to be in one box or the other a certain variance is found. If the particle can also be anywhere along the pipe or in the boxes the authors of (1) argue there is more uncertainty yet the variance decreases. Mathematically this occurs because there is now probability associated with small x values. We argue this is only counterintuitive if one considers probability distributions which decrease monotonically such as a Gaussian. In such a case, the variance increases if the particle is spread over a larger range. Such, however, does not seem to be the case if one has increased resolution which seems to be the case for quantum bound states such as a particle in a box with infinite potential walls or a quantum oscillator. Increased resolution occurs with increasing energy, but by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle the variance of p and x (or at least their product) increases. Increased resolution which seems to be linked to more order (less uncertainty) as argued in (1) can lead to an increased variance if probability only exists at distances far from the origin (i.e. high x) as in the closed two boxes example. As a result, the idea of uncertainty in the expression Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle seems to be based on the idea of how far the particle may be from the average value. As noted in (1) this means a large variance, but could represent high resolution i.e. a lack of uncertainty in finding the particle. We suggest there are two different kinds of uncertainty, Heisenberg’s uncertainty linked to the average and a resolution uncertainty. We examine the cases of a particle in a box and and the quantum oscillator.
Abstract In this work we find that not only the Heisenberg-like uncertainty products and the Rényi-entropy-based uncertainty sum have the same first-order values for all the quantum states of the D -dimensional hydrogenic and oscillator-like systems, respectively, in the pseudoclassical ( D → ∞ ) limit but a similar phenomenon also happens for both the Fisher-information-based uncertainty product and the Shannon-entropy-based uncertainty sum, as well as for the Crámer–Rao and Fisher–Shannon complexities. Moreover, we show that the López–Ruiz–Mancini–Calvet (LMC) and LMC-Rényi complexity measures capture the hydrogenic-harmonic difference in the high dimensional limit already at first order.