Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Operator formalism for double quantum NMR

Shimon Vega, Alexander Pines

Published Jun 15, 1977• 379 citations
Publisher

Abstract

An operator formalism is presented which conveniently treats the interaction of a spin-1 nucleus with a weak radio frequency field. The Hamiltonian in the rotating frame is ℋ=−Δω Iz−ω1Ix+(1/3) ωQ[3 I2z−I (I+1)], where Δω is the resonance offset (Δω=ω0−ω), ω1 is the intensity of the rf field, and ωQ is the quadrupolar splitting. Nine fictitious spin−1/2 operators, Ip,i where p=x,y,z and i=1,2,3, are defined where p refers to the transition between two of the levels and i the Cartesian component. The operators, which are the generators of the group SU (3), satisfy spin-1/2 commutation relations [Ip,j, Ip,k]=i Ip,l, where j,k,l=1,2,3 or cyclic permutation. Thus each p defines a three-dimensional space termed p space. For irradiation near one of the quadrupolar satellites, for example, Δω=ωQ+δω with δω, ω1≪ωQ, it is shown that the effective Hamiltonian can be written ℋ?−δωIx,3−√2 ω1Ix,1, i.e., a fictitious spin-1/2 Hamiltonian in x space with effective magnetogyric ratio γ along the 3 (resonance offset) axis and √2 γ along the 1 (rf field) axis. For irradiation near the center we can effect double quantum transitions between m=±1. The formalism allows us to write the effective operators for these transitions. For example, if we take Δω=δω again with δω, ω1≪ωQ we find the effective double quantum (DQ) Hamiltonian H?−2 δω Iz,1−(ω21/ωQ) Iz,3. Thus the z space is referred to as the double quantum frame with effective magnetogyric ratio 2γ along the 1 (resonance offset) axis and (ω1/ωQ) γ along the 3 (rf field) axis. The limiting expressions are compared with exact calculations for arbitrary ω1 done by high speed computer. The theory is applied to various cases of irradiation including our previously reported technique of Fourier transform double quantum NMR. Various pulse sequences for preparing, storing, and maintaining the evolution of double quantum coherence are analyzed for single crystal and polycrystalline samples. Finally, the effects of rf phase on the double quantum phase are presented briefly, and the possibility of double quantum spin locking is analyzed.

DOI
10.1063/1.433884

Related papers

Fictitious spin 1/2 operator formalism for multiple quantum NMR

Shimon Vega

A formalism is presented that describes the time behavior of the spin density matrix of a nuclear spin system with arbitrary spin in terms of fictitious spin −(1/2) operators. This formalism is an extension of that used earlier for nuclei with spin I=1. For a spin system with n eigenstates we define for every pair of eigenstates ‖i〉 and ‖j〉 three operators Ii−jp, with p=x, y, and z, according to the three 2×2 Pauli matrices σx, σy, and σz. These operators together constitute a complete set of n2−1 independent Hermitian operators, and we can write the n×n density matrix and the spin Hamiltonian of the system in terms of the Ii−jp operators. The commutation relations among the operators make it possible in many cases to solve the equation of motion of the density matrix analytically. Three examples of the use of the Ii−jp operators are presented. Firstly a system of noninteracting spins with I=1 is considered. The Ii−jp operators for this case are compared with the Iq,k operator defined earlier. The cw signal intensities of the single and double quantum transitions for the I=1 spin system are derived. Secondly a spin system with I=3/2 is described as a simple extension of the use of the Ii−jp operators. The excitation and the detection of the triple quantum coherence are discussed for noninteracting nuclei in solids. Finally the double quantum effects in a system of two interacting spins with I=1/2 are discussed.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jun 15, 1978•393 citations

The effective Hamiltonian of the Pound-Overhauser controlled-NOT gate

David G. Cory, A. E. Dunlop, Timothy F. Havel +2 more

In NMR-based quantum computing, it is known that the controlled-NOT gate can be implemented by applying a low-power, monochromatic radio-frequency field to one peak of a doublet in a weakly-coupled two-spin system. This is known in NMR spectroscopy as Pound-Overhauser double resonance. The ``transition'' Hamiltonian that has been associated with this procedure is however only an approximation, which ignores off-resonance effects and does not correctly predict the associated phase factors. In this paper, the exact effective Hamiltonian for evolution of the spins' state in a rotating frame is derived, both under irradiation of a single peak (on-transition) as well as between the peaks of the doublet (on-resonance). The accuracy of these effective Hamiltonians is validated by comparing the observable product operator components of the density matrix obtained by simulation to those obtained by fitting the corresponding experiments. It is further shown how both the on-transition and on-resonance fields can be used to implement the controlled-NOT gate exactly up to conditional phases, and analytic expressions for these phases are derived. In Appendices, the on-resonance Hamiltonian is analytically diagonalized, and proofs are given that, in the weak-coupling approximation, off-resonance effects can be neglected whenever the radio-frequency field power is small compared to the difference in resonance frequencies of the two spins.

arXiv:quant-ph/9809045•Sep 16, 1998•8 citations

Four-field excitation of multiphoton NMR resonances in spin I=(1/2)

Eric M. Krauss, Shimon Vega

The use of four pulsed rf fields for the excitation of multiphoton resonances in a two-level system is investigated. A general theoretical description of the experiment is provided based on the Floquet formalism and application of basic conservation laws to the overall transition process. The predictions of the theory are compared with computer simulations of the time evolution of the magnetization according to the exact time-dependent Hamiltonian. It is shown that N-photon resonances occur when the fields are applied at frequencies \ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}k\ensuremath{\omega} and \ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}l\ensuremath{\omega} from the Larmor frequency, where k and l are positive integers having no common factors and where 0\ensuremath{\le}k<l, k+l=N. For any resonance k photons are taken from the outer field pair and l are taken from the inner field pair. A total of 2[(l+k)!]/(k!l!) mutually interfering transition pathways exist for the overall process and the resultant magnitude of the effective N-photon field is very sensitive to the relative initial phases of the rf fields. The spiral motion observed for multiphoton resonances induced by double-frequency irradiation is absent here when the field intensities are symmetrical. In addition, the fraction of total applied rf intensity available for multiphoton pumping is considerably greater than for two fields. Phase cycling to enhance detection of multiphoton effects and multiphoton spin locking are considered.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1986•27 citations

Response to Double Irradiation of a Nuclear Spin System: General Treatment and New Multiple Quantum Transitions

Pietro Bucci, Massimo Martinelli, S. Santucci

A general theory has been developed to calculate the response, in NMR conditions, of a spin system irradiated by two nearly resonant waves having different frequencies and intense enough to produce an appreciable saturation. The absorption signal has been calculated employing the statistical operator technique, treating the electromagnetic field by the second quantization formalism. Two kinds of transitions are expected: The first one arises from processes in which n photons of one wave are emitted and n photons of the other wave are absorbed, the second one arises from processes involving the emission of n photons of one wave and the absorption of n ± 1 photons of the other. In the first case all the transitions coalesce in a single dispersionlike signal, which occurs when the frequencies of the two waves are nearly the same; in the second case a many-line spectrum occurs in which emission and absorption lines are present. The experimental results here reported strictly agree with theoretical previsions.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 15, 1970•49 citations

Magnetic Resonance of Coupled Spins

W. Franzen, Mahbub'-UL Alam

The solution of the time-dependent wave equation describing the interaction of two coupled spins with a rotating magnetic field in the presence of a steady field, as in the usual magnetic resonance situation, has been reexamined. By extending the method previously developed by Salwen, an exact expression is derived for all components of the wave function describing a three-state system under magnetic-resonance conditions. This solution describes in analytical form all the single and multiple resonances of which the system is capable for fields of any intensity. It is shown that when $z$ is the axis of quantization, the projection of the wave function on an eigenstate of ${F}_{x}$ oscillates at twice the resonance frequency at exact double quantum resonance. An approximate form is derived for the transition probability near double quantum resonance, showing that our solution is consistent with Salwen's in the limit of well-separated single and double quantum resonances. The theory is applied to the uppermost three substates of the upper hyperfine multiplet of an alkali metal of arbitrary nuclear spin, a case of interest to the analysis of magnetic resonance in optically pumped vapors.

Physical Review•Jan 20, 1964•11 citations

³¹P NMR: A Spin-½, 100% Abundant Two-Level Quantum System — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

FINDING: ³¹P is a spin-½ NMR-active nucleus (I = ½, 100% natural abundance), making it a clean two-level quantum system for magnetic resonance. MATH: - Nuclear spin quantum number: I = ½ → multiplicity 2I+1 = 2 (two Zeeman eigenstates m_I = ±½) - Composition: Z = 15 protons, N = 16 neutrons, A = 31 (odd A → half-integer spin) - Larmor frequency: ω₀ = γB₀, with ³¹P gyromagnetic ratio γ ≈ 1.08 × 10⁸ rad·s⁻¹·T⁻¹ (17.235 MHz/T) - Zeeman splitting: ΔE = γℏB₀ - NMR transition (single-quantum): Δm_I = ±1 - Double-quantum coherence: Δm_I = ±2 (referenced in findings for spin pairs / quadrupolar nuclei) - Schrödinger eigenvalue problem: Ĥψ = Eψ governs the spin state evolution - Magnetization precession: dM/dt = γM × B (Bloch equation) CONNECTION: - Spin-½ is the fundamental representation of SU(2); the two-level system maps to the Bloch sphere — a geometric object with the golden-ratio-free but maximally symmetric structure of CP¹. - SU(2) ≅ unit quaternions; double cover of SO(3). The 2:1 c Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•Nov 1, 2026•0 citations
An operator formalism is presented which conveniently treats the interaction of a spin-1 nucleus with a weak radio frequency field. The Hamiltonian in the rotating frame is ℋ=−Δω Iz−ω1Ix+(1/3) ωQ[3 I2z−I (I+1)], where Δω is the resonance offset (Δω=ω0−ω), ω1 is the intensity of the rf field, and ωQ is the quadrupolar splitting. Nine fictitious spin−1/2 operators, Ip,i where p=x,y,z and i=1,2,3, are defined where p refers to the transition between two of the levels and i the Cartesian component. The operators, which are the generators of the group SU (3), satisfy spin-1/2 commutation relations [Ip,j, Ip,k]=i Ip,l, where j,k,l=1,2,3 or cyclic permutation. Thus each p defines a three-dimensional space termed p space. For irradiation near one of the quadrupolar satellites, for example, Δω=ωQ+δω with δω, ω1≪ωQ, it is shown that the effective Hamiltonian can be written ℋ?−δωIx,3−√2 ω1Ix,1, i.e., a fictitious spin-1/2 Hamiltonian in x space with effective magnetogyric ratio γ along the 3 (resonance offset) axis and √2 γ along the 1 (rf field) axis. For irradiation near the center we can effect double quantum transitions between m=±1. The formalism allows us to write the effective operators for these transitions. For example, if we take Δω=δω again with δω, ω1≪ωQ we find the effective double quantum (DQ) Hamiltonian H?−2 δω Iz,1−(ω21/ωQ) Iz,3. Thus the z space is referred to as the double quantum frame with effective magnetogyric ratio 2γ along the 1 (resonance offset) axis and (ω1/ωQ) γ along the 3 (rf field) axis. The limiting expressions are compared with exact calculations for arbitrary ω1 done by high speed computer. The theory is applied to various cases of irradiation including our previously reported technique of Fourier transform double quantum NMR. Various pulse sequences for preparing, storing, and maintaining the evolution of double quantum coherence are analyzed for single crystal and polycrystalline samples. Finally, the effects of rf phase on the double quantum phase are presented briefly, and the possibility of double quantum spin locking is analyzed.
A formalism is presented that describes the time behavior of the spin density matrix of a nuclear spin system with arbitrary spin in terms of fictitious spin −(1/2) operators. This formalism is an extension of that used earlier for nuclei with spin I=1. For a spin system with n eigenstates we define for every pair of eigenstates ‖i〉 and ‖j〉 three operators Ii−jp, with p=x, y, and z, according to the three 2×2 Pauli matrices σx, σy, and σz. These operators together constitute a complete set of n2−1 independent Hermitian operators, and we can write the n×n density matrix and the spin Hamiltonian of the system in terms of the Ii−jp operators. The commutation relations among the operators make it possible in many cases to solve the equation of motion of the density matrix analytically. Three examples of the use of the Ii−jp operators are presented. Firstly a system of noninteracting spins with I=1 is considered. The Ii−jp operators for this case are compared with the Iq,k operator defined earlier. The cw signal intensities of the single and double quantum transitions for the I=1 spin system are derived. Secondly a spin system with I=3/2 is described as a simple extension of the use of the Ii−jp operators. The excitation and the detection of the triple quantum coherence are discussed for noninteracting nuclei in solids. Finally the double quantum effects in a system of two interacting spins with I=1/2 are discussed.
In NMR-based quantum computing, it is known that the controlled-NOT gate can be implemented by applying a low-power, monochromatic radio-frequency field to one peak of a doublet in a weakly-coupled two-spin system. This is known in NMR spectroscopy as Pound-Overhauser double resonance. The ``transition'' Hamiltonian that has been associated with this procedure is however only an approximation, which ignores off-resonance effects and does not correctly predict the associated phase factors. In this paper, the exact effective Hamiltonian for evolution of the spins' state in a rotating frame is derived, both under irradiation of a single peak (on-transition) as well as between the peaks of the doublet (on-resonance). The accuracy of these effective Hamiltonians is validated by comparing the observable product operator components of the density matrix obtained by simulation to those obtained by fitting the corresponding experiments. It is further shown how both the on-transition and on-resonance fields can be used to implement the controlled-NOT gate exactly up to conditional phases, and analytic expressions for these phases are derived. In Appendices, the on-resonance Hamiltonian is analytically diagonalized, and proofs are given that, in the weak-coupling approximation, off-resonance effects can be neglected whenever the radio-frequency field power is small compared to the difference in resonance frequencies of the two spins.
The use of four pulsed rf fields for the excitation of multiphoton resonances in a two-level system is investigated. A general theoretical description of the experiment is provided based on the Floquet formalism and application of basic conservation laws to the overall transition process. The predictions of the theory are compared with computer simulations of the time evolution of the magnetization according to the exact time-dependent Hamiltonian. It is shown that N-photon resonances occur when the fields are applied at frequencies \ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}k\ensuremath{\omega} and \ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}l\ensuremath{\omega} from the Larmor frequency, where k and l are positive integers having no common factors and where 0\ensuremath{\le}k<l, k+l=N. For any resonance k photons are taken from the outer field pair and l are taken from the inner field pair. A total of 2[(l+k)!]/(k!l!) mutually interfering transition pathways exist for the overall process and the resultant magnitude of the effective N-photon field is very sensitive to the relative initial phases of the rf fields. The spiral motion observed for multiphoton resonances induced by double-frequency irradiation is absent here when the field intensities are symmetrical. In addition, the fraction of total applied rf intensity available for multiphoton pumping is considerably greater than for two fields. Phase cycling to enhance detection of multiphoton effects and multiphoton spin locking are considered.
A general theory has been developed to calculate the response, in NMR conditions, of a spin system irradiated by two nearly resonant waves having different frequencies and intense enough to produce an appreciable saturation. The absorption signal has been calculated employing the statistical operator technique, treating the electromagnetic field by the second quantization formalism. Two kinds of transitions are expected: The first one arises from processes in which n photons of one wave are emitted and n photons of the other wave are absorbed, the second one arises from processes involving the emission of n photons of one wave and the absorption of n ± 1 photons of the other. In the first case all the transitions coalesce in a single dispersionlike signal, which occurs when the frequencies of the two waves are nearly the same; in the second case a many-line spectrum occurs in which emission and absorption lines are present. The experimental results here reported strictly agree with theoretical previsions.
The solution of the time-dependent wave equation describing the interaction of two coupled spins with a rotating magnetic field in the presence of a steady field, as in the usual magnetic resonance situation, has been reexamined. By extending the method previously developed by Salwen, an exact expression is derived for all components of the wave function describing a three-state system under magnetic-resonance conditions. This solution describes in analytical form all the single and multiple resonances of which the system is capable for fields of any intensity. It is shown that when zzz is the axis of quantization, the projection of the wave function on an eigenstate of Fx{F}_{x}Fx​ oscillates at twice the resonance frequency at exact double quantum resonance. An approximate form is derived for the transition probability near double quantum resonance, showing that our solution is consistent with Salwen's in the limit of well-separated single and double quantum resonances. The theory is applied to the uppermost three substates of the upper hyperfine multiplet of an alkali metal of arbitrary nuclear spin, a case of interest to the analysis of magnetic resonance in optically pumped vapors.
FINDING: ³¹P is a spin-½ NMR-active nucleus (I = ½, 100% natural abundance), making it a clean two-level quantum system for magnetic resonance. MATH: - Nuclear spin quantum number: I = ½ → multiplicity 2I+1 = 2 (two Zeeman eigenstates m_I = ±½) - Composition: Z = 15 protons, N = 16 neutrons, A = 31 (odd A → half-integer spin) - Larmor frequency: ω₀ = γB₀, with ³¹P gyromagnetic ratio γ ≈ 1.08 × 10⁸ rad·s⁻¹·T⁻¹ (17.235 MHz/T) - Zeeman splitting: ΔE = γℏB₀ - NMR transition (single-quantum): Δm_I = ±1 - Double-quantum coherence: Δm_I = ±2 (referenced in findings for spin pairs / quadrupolar nuclei) - Schrödinger eigenvalue problem: Ĥψ = Eψ governs the spin state evolution - Magnetization precession: dM/dt = γM × B (Bloch equation) CONNECTION: - Spin-½ is the fundamental representation of SU(2); the two-level system maps to the Bloch sphere — a geometric object with the golden-ratio-free but maximally symmetric structure of CP¹. - SU(2) ≅ unit quaternions; double cover of SO(3). The 2:1 c Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com