The quantum Zeno effect is the inhibition of the free evolution of a system when that system is subject to a measurement process. The authors of one recent experiment study, W. M. Itano et al., [Phys. Rev. A 41, 2295 (1990)] claimed a demonstration of the quantum Zeno effect. This was done by performing discontinuous atomic-level measurements on a coherently evolving two-level atomic stystem. The measurement was implemented using a pulsed laser strong enough to saturate the two-level atomic system. In this paper, we examine the simpler case where the measurement laser is continuously on and does not saturate the two-level atomic system. In contrast to previous treatments, we show certain parameter regimes wherein an effective state reduction does occur. We ascertain the experimental parameter regimes under which a measurement can be said to have been performed. We show that, in some regimes, fully efficient photon detection does not give good information about the atomic-level populations and hence no measurement has been performed. Throughout, we emphasize that the design of an atomic level-measurement device requires more than the analysis of a mechanism for photon detection or of coherence loss. We gain insight into the operation of a particular measurement process by following the selective evolution of various systems using the quantum-trajectories approach.
The quantum Zeno effect is the inhibition of the free evolution of a system when that system is subject to a measurement process. The authors of one recent experiment study, W. M. Itano et al., [Phys. Rev. A 41, 2295 (1990)] claimed a demonstration of the quantum Zeno effect. This was done by performing discontinuous atomic-level measurements on a coherently evolving two-level atomic stystem. The measurement was implemented using a pulsed laser strong enough to saturate the two-level atomic system. In this paper, we examine the simpler case where the measurement laser is continuously on and does not saturate the two-level atomic system. In contrast to previous treatments, we show certain parameter regimes wherein an effective state reduction does occur. We ascertain the experimental parameter regimes under which a measurement can be said to have been performed. We show that, in some regimes, fully efficient photon detection does not give good information about the atomic-level populations and hence no measurement has been performed. Throughout, we emphasize that the design of an atomic level-measurement device requires more than the analysis of a mechanism for photon detection or of coherence loss. We gain insight into the operation of a particular measurement process by following the selective evolution of various systems using the quantum-trajectories approach.
Itano and co-workers [Wayne M. Itano, D. J. Heinzen, J. J. Bollinger, and D. J. Wineland, Phys. Rev. A 41, 2295 (1990)] have recently reported the experimental verification of the quantum Zeno effect, which is the inhibition of a quantum transition by frequent measurements. In this article, we offer an alternative interpretation of the quantum Zeno effect. We show that an analysis of the dynamics of the full three-level system gives the same result. There is no need to assume explicitly that the wave function has collapsed, nor even to assume that an ideal measurement has been made. In addition, we differentiate between what has been referred to as the quantum Zeno effect and what has been termed the quantum Zeno paradox. The former is the inhibition of induced transitions, and the latter is the, as yet experimentally unobserved, inhibition of spontaneous decay. Our interpretation, which emphasizes the ``measurement''-induced interruption of atomic-state coherences as the cause of inhibited quantum transitions, suggests a resolution to the quantum Zeno paradox. The theoretical limit of continuous observation is discussed.
We propose an experiment to observe the quantum Zeno effect in atomic Bragg scattering. The quantum Zeno effect is the inhibition of the free evolution of a system when that system is subject to a decohering measurement process. This effect is usually studied theoretically in an idealized two-level system, though this system has been difficult to realize in practice. The coherent population exchange between the forward and Bragg beams provides an ideal two-level system, though as there is no practical scheme for continuously monitoring the motion of an atom we include decoherence by adding noise to the laser. Using the method of stochastic Hamiltonians we show that the noise suppresses tunneling in the two-state system and, in the large noise limit, the system can freeze in its initial state.
This is a theoretical thesis in the area of quantum measurement theory. Due to the extensive breadth of this field we choose to narrow our focus to examine a particular problem - the quantum Zeno effect (defined below). Quantum measurement theory is introduced in Chap. 1, using the terminology of effects and operations. This approach allows an operational definition of such terms as a state vector, an ensemble, and a measurement device (for instance), and a consideration of interactions between quantum systems and inaccurate measurement devices. We further introduce the quantum trajectories approach to consider the evolution of an individual quantum system subject to measurement. The quantum Zeno effect is introduced in Chap. 2. Any quantum treatment of a measurement interaction must consider the measurement backaction onto the measured system and this backaction will disrupt the free evolution of the system. The quantum Zeno effect occurs in the strong measurement limit where the measurement backaction totally freezes the evolution of the system, thus rendering the measurement useless. The effect is introduced via projective measurements of two level systems subject to measurement of level populations. At this stage we are able to discuss the main questions addressed by this thesis, and present its structure in Chap. 2. We then develop a new measurement model for the interaction between a system and a measurement device in Chap. 3. Our motivation in doing this is to better model the usual laboratory meter, and in our approach the meter dynamics are such that it relaxes towards an appropriate readout of the system parameter of interest. The irreducible quantum noise of the meter introduces fluctuations that drive the stochastic dynamical collapse of the system wavefunction. In our model, the measured system dynamics (if treated selectively) are described by a stochastic, nonlinear Schroedinger equation. A double well system subject to position measurement provides a natural first application for this model. This is done in Chap. 4 where we monitor the coherent tunnelling of a particle from one well to the other. The advantage afforded by considering this system is that it displays differing regimes where the measurement observable (position) is approximated as possessing either, respectively, a continuous or a discrete eigenvalue structure. Thus, we use this one model to explore the quantum Zeno effect in both measurement regimes. The above treatment is of a theoretical measurement model. In Chap. 5 we turn to consider a recent experimental test of the quantum Zeno effect which examined the dynamics of a two level atom subject to pulsed measurements of atomic level populations. We treat a slightly modified experiment in a fully continuous measurement regime. By first unravelling the optical Bloch equations, and second, using the quantum trajectories approach we demonstrate the existence of certain measurement regimes where there is a quantum Zeno effect, and other regimes where no measurement of the atomic populations is being effected at all. Through these results we demonstrate the importance of making a full analysis of the system-detector interaction before any conclusions can be made. In the remainder of the thesis we propose further possible tests of the quantum Zeno effect. In Chap. 6 the evolution of a Rydberg atom exchanging one photon with a single cavity mode subject to measurement is examined. The measurement is made by monitoring the photon number occupancy of the cavity mode using a beam of Rydberg atoms configured so as to perform phase sensitive detection. In the limit of frequent monitoring we show that the free oscillation of the atomic inversion is disrupted, and the atom is trapped close to its initial state. This is the quantum Zeno effect. In Chap. 7 we realize the Zeno effect on two possible systems. We consider first, a two level Jaynes-Cumming atom interacting with a cavity mode, and second, two electromagnetic modes configured as a multi-level parametric frequency converter. These systems interact with another cavity mode via a quadratic coupling system based on four wave mixing, and constructed to be a quantum nondemolition measurement of the photon number. This mode is damped to the environment thus effecting a measurement of the system populations. Again we show that this interaction, can manifest the quantum Zeno effect. Our explicit modelling of the system-detector interaction enables us to show how the effect depends on the resolution time of the detector. Finally, we consider a proposed measurement of the square of the quadrature phase of an electromagnetic mode in Chap. 8. Here, a three mode interaction mediated by a second order nonlinear susceptibility is considered. One mode, the pump, is prepared in a feedback generated photon number state to give insight into the role of pump noise. The other two modes are treated as an angular momentum system, and we show that photon counting on the two mode rotation system effects the above mentioned measurement. In addition, this measurement provides a direct measure of the second order squeezing of the signal. With that we finish our investigation of the quantum Zeno effect using the techniques of quantum measurement theory. However, in the epilogue [Chap. 9] we note that no thesis in quantum measurement theory would be complete without some consideration of the ``meaning attributed to the theory. In the epilogue we take a novel historical approach and examine the method by which metaphysical theories are formed to draw conclusions regarding quantum metaphysics.
The quantum Zeno effect is not a general characteristic of continuous measurements. In a recently reported experiment [Itano et al., Phys. Rev. A 41, 2295 (1990)], the inhibition of atomic excitation and deexcitation is not due to any ``collapse of the wave function,'' but instead is caused by a very strong perturbation due to the optical pulses and the coupling to the radiation field. The experiment should not be cited as providing empirical evidence in favor of the notion of ``wave-function collapse.''
Reiterated or continuous measurement on a quantum system impedes the quantum object's evolution. This "quantum Zeno" effect (QZE), contemplated for decades, has been conventionally attributed to the reaction of the measuring device on the quantum object being measured, in the sense of the Heisenberg microscope. However, even reactionless "quantum non-demolition" measurements seem to qualify for that inhibition to take place and may constitute a "quantum Zeno paradox" (QZP). An experimental proof of QZE had been attempted in the past on clouds of ions confined in a Paul trap. In the meantime it has been shown, however, that the anticipated impediment of the quantum evolution by a sheer gain of information, i.e. by reactionless measurement cannot be, in principle, proven with an ensemble. Recently, experiments have been performed with the use of a single quantum system: an 172Yb+ ion, laser-driven on its E2 line S1/2 - D5/2, or an 171Yb+ ion, microwave-driven on its ground-state hyperfine resonance. The results of these experiments demonstrate that mere gain of information on the quantum system, while lacking dynamic action, modifies the system's evolution as it is predicted by quantum mechanics, based on the system's preparation. This seems plausible if we attribute reality to the results of the measurements. If, in contrast, reality is claimed for the prediction, two-fold discontinuity must be admitted: loss of coherence with potential measurements, and renormalization from the results of actual measurements.