Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Limitations of STIRAP-like population transfer in extended systems: The three-level system embedded in a web of background states

Werner Jakubetz

Published Dec 13, 2012• 16 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This paper presents a systematic numerical investigation of background state participation in STIRAP (stimulated Raman-adiabatic passage) population transfer among vibrational states, focusing on the consequences for the robustness of the method. The simulations, which are performed over extended grids in the parameter space of the Stokes- and pump pulses (frequencies, field strengths, and pulse lengths), involve hierarchies of (3 + N)-level systems of increasing complexity, ranging from the standard three-level STIRAP setup, (N = 0) in Λ-configuration, up to N = 446. A strongly coupled three-level core system is selected from the full Hamiltonian of the double-well HCN∕HNC system, and the couplings connecting this core system to the remaining states are (re-) parameterized in different ways, from very weak to very strong. The systems so obtained represent a three-level system embedded in various ways in webs of cross-linked vibrational background states and incorporate typical molecular properties. We first summarize essential properties of population transfer in the standard three-level system and quantify the robustness of the method and its dependence on the pulse parameters. Against these reference results, we present results obtained for four (3 + 446)-level systems and several subsystems. For pulse lengths of at most few picoseconds the intrinsic robustness of STIRAP with respect to variations in the field strength disappears as soon as the largest core-background couplings exceed about one tenth of the STIRAP couplings. In such cases robustness with respect to variations in the field strength is entirely lost, since at higher field strengths, except for irregularly spaced narrow frequency ranges, transfer probabilities are strongly reduced. STIRAP-like population transfer is maintained, with some restrictions, at low field strengths near the onset of adiabatic transfer. The suppression of STIRAP is traced back to different mechanisms based on a plentitude of single- and multiphoton transitions to background states, which at the high field strengths characteristic for STIRAP proceed readily even along weakly coupled pathways.

DOI
10.1063/1.4770053

Related papers

Selective Vibrational Population Transfer using Combined Stimulated Raman Adiabatic Passage and Counter-Diabatic Fields

Shumpei Masuda, Stuart A. Rice

We report studies of state-to-state vibrational energy transfer in an isolated polyatomic molecule driven by combined stimulated Raman adiabatic passage (STIRAP) and counter-diabatic fields (CDFs). The goal of these studies is development of a method for improving the efficiency of level-to-level population transfer under conditions that degrade the efficiency of conventional STIRAP-generated population transfer. The vehicles for our studies are selective population of one of a pair of near-degenerate states in nonrotating SCCl 2 and enhancing the yield of nonrotating HNC in the HCN → HNC isomerization reaction. The efficiency of the population transfer within a subset of states embedded in a manifold of states is examined for the cases in which the transition dipole moments between the initial and target states are much smaller than and comparable to the transition dipole moments between background states and for the case in which the subset states have large transition dipole moments with the background states. We show that, in a subset of states that is coupled to background states, a combination of STIRAP fields and CDFs that do not individually generate processes that are competitive with the desired population transfer can generate population transfer efficiency greater than can ordinary STIRAP with field strength and/or pulse duration similarly restricted and that the exact CDF for an isolated three-level system is a useful approximation to the exact CDF for three- and five-state systems embedded in background states. We report a study of the stability of the STIRAP and approximate CDF control protocol to variation of the CDF intensity, the relative phase between the STIRAP and CDFs, and the pulse duration.

The Journal of Physical Chemistry C•Oct 27, 2014•24 citations

Selective Vibrational Population Transfer using Combined STIRAP and Counter-Diabatic Fields

Shumpei Masuda, Stuart A. Rice

We report studies of state-to-state vibrational energy transfer in an isolated polyatomic molecule driven by combined stimulated Raman adiabatic passage (STIRAP) and counter-diabatic fields (CDF), using as vehicles selective population of one of a pair of near degenerate states in SCCl$_2$ and enhancing the yield of HNC in the HCN/HNC isomerization reaction. The efficiency of the population transfer within a subset of states embedded in a dense manifold of states is examined for the cases that the transition dipole moments between the initial and target states are much smaller than and comparable to the transition dipole moments between background states, and for the case that the subset states have large transition dipole moments with the background states. We show that, in a subset of states that is coupled to background states, a combination of STIRAP fields and CDFs that do not individually generate processes that are competitive with the desired population transfer can generate greater population transfer efficiency than can ordinary STIRAP with field strength and/or pulse duration similarly restricted. We also show that the exact CDF for an isolated three level system is a useful approximation to the exact CDF for three and five state systems embedded in background states, and we report a study of the stability of the STIRAP + approximate CDF control protocol to variation of the CDF.

arXiv:1409.0784•Sep 2, 2014•2 citations

Population transfer by stimulated Raman scattering with delayed pulses: Analytical results for multilevel systems

George W. Coulston, Klaas Bergmann

Stimulated Raman scattering involving adiabatic passage (STIRAP) is a proven technique for population transfer in three-level systems with strong oscillator strengths. We show that the STIRAP process should also yield high transfer efficiencies when the densities of states near the intermediate and final levels are high, provided certain criteria for the experimentally controllable parameters are met. We also show that high transfer efficiencies may even be possible when the pump and Stokes lasers can access levels outside of the three-level system. The criteria are derived with an approach that emphasizes the adiabatic nature of the transfer process in an eigenvector of the interaction Hamiltonian that resembles a trapped state. The results are compared to density matrix calculations.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 1, 1992•126 citations

Stimulated Raman adiabatic passage with trains of weak pulses*

Ignacio R. Solá, Bo Y. Chang, Svetlana Malinovskaya +2 more

Abstract We consider coherent population transfer in multilevel quantum systems driven by time-delayed pulse trains. We show how to choose the parameters of the trains so that the population dynamics tracks the behavior of a Λ-type three-level system under stimulated Raman adiabatic passage (STIRAP). Efficient population transfer can be achieved regardless of the order and with or without overlap of the pump and the Stokes sub-pulses of the trains. Generalized STIRAP schemes of population transfer in N -level system with sequential couplings are also examined. The mechanism of the population transfer and the robustness of the proposed schemes are discussed.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Oct 13, 2022•6 citations

Simple and robust extension of the stimulated Raman adiabatic passage technique to N -level systems

Vladimir S. Malinovsky, David J. Tannor

STIRAP (stimulated Raman adiabatic passage) has proven to be an efficient and robust technique for transferring population in a three-level system without populating the intermediate state. Here we show that the counterintuitive pulse sequence in STIRAP, in which the Stokes pulse precedes the pump, emerges automatically from a variant of optimal control theory we have previously called ``local'' optimization. Since local optimization is a well-defined, automated computational procedure, this opens the door to automated computation of generalized STIRAP schemes in arbitrarily complicated $N$-level coupling situations. If the coupling is sequential, a simple qualitative extension of STIRAP emerges: the Stokes pulse precedes the pump as in the three-level system. But, in addition, spanning both the Stokes and pump pulses are pulses corresponding to the transitions between the $N\ensuremath{-}2$ intermediate states with intensities about an order of magnitude greater than those of the Stokes and pump pulses. This scheme is amazingly robust, leading to almost 100% population transfer with significantly less population transfer to the $N\ensuremath{-}2$ intermediate states than in previously proposed extensions of STIRAP.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1997•165 citations

Fast-Forward Assisted STIRAP

Shumpei Masuda, Stuart A. Rice

We consider combined stimulated Raman adiabatic passage (STIRAP) and fast-forward field (FFF) control of selective vibrational population transfer in a polyatomic molecule. The motivation for using this combination control scheme is 2-fold: (i) to overcome transfer inefficiency that occurs when the STIRAP fields and pulse durations must be restricted to avoid excitation of population transfers that compete with the targeted transfer and (ii) to overcome transfer inefficiency resulting from embedding of the actively driven subset of states in a large manifold of states. We show that, in a subset of states that is coupled to background states, a combination of STIRAP and FFFs that do not individually generate processes that are competitive with the desired population transfer can generate greater population transfer efficiency than can ordinary STIRAP with similar field strength and/or pulse duration.

arXiv:1410.1883•The Journal of Physical Chemistry A•Mar 16, 2015•69 citations
This paper presents a systematic numerical investigation of background state participation in STIRAP (stimulated Raman-adiabatic passage) population transfer among vibrational states, focusing on the consequences for the robustness of the method. The simulations, which are performed over extended grids in the parameter space of the Stokes- and pump pulses (frequencies, field strengths, and pulse lengths), involve hierarchies of (3 + N)-level systems of increasing complexity, ranging from the standard three-level STIRAP setup, (N = 0) in Λ-configuration, up to N = 446. A strongly coupled three-level core system is selected from the full Hamiltonian of the double-well HCN∕HNC system, and the couplings connecting this core system to the remaining states are (re-) parameterized in different ways, from very weak to very strong. The systems so obtained represent a three-level system embedded in various ways in webs of cross-linked vibrational background states and incorporate typical molecular properties. We first summarize essential properties of population transfer in the standard three-level system and quantify the robustness of the method and its dependence on the pulse parameters. Against these reference results, we present results obtained for four (3 + 446)-level systems and several subsystems. For pulse lengths of at most few picoseconds the intrinsic robustness of STIRAP with respect to variations in the field strength disappears as soon as the largest core-background couplings exceed about one tenth of the STIRAP couplings. In such cases robustness with respect to variations in the field strength is entirely lost, since at higher field strengths, except for irregularly spaced narrow frequency ranges, transfer probabilities are strongly reduced. STIRAP-like population transfer is maintained, with some restrictions, at low field strengths near the onset of adiabatic transfer. The suppression of STIRAP is traced back to different mechanisms based on a plentitude of single- and multiphoton transitions to background states, which at the high field strengths characteristic for STIRAP proceed readily even along weakly coupled pathways.
We report studies of state-to-state vibrational energy transfer in an isolated polyatomic molecule driven by combined stimulated Raman adiabatic passage (STIRAP) and counter-diabatic fields (CDFs). The goal of these studies is development of a method for improving the efficiency of level-to-level population transfer under conditions that degrade the efficiency of conventional STIRAP-generated population transfer. The vehicles for our studies are selective population of one of a pair of near-degenerate states in nonrotating SCCl 2 and enhancing the yield of nonrotating HNC in the HCN → HNC isomerization reaction. The efficiency of the population transfer within a subset of states embedded in a manifold of states is examined for the cases in which the transition dipole moments between the initial and target states are much smaller than and comparable to the transition dipole moments between background states and for the case in which the subset states have large transition dipole moments with the background states. We show that, in a subset of states that is coupled to background states, a combination of STIRAP fields and CDFs that do not individually generate processes that are competitive with the desired population transfer can generate population transfer efficiency greater than can ordinary STIRAP with field strength and/or pulse duration similarly restricted and that the exact CDF for an isolated three-level system is a useful approximation to the exact CDF for three- and five-state systems embedded in background states. We report a study of the stability of the STIRAP and approximate CDF control protocol to variation of the CDF intensity, the relative phase between the STIRAP and CDFs, and the pulse duration.
We report studies of state-to-state vibrational energy transfer in an isolated polyatomic molecule driven by combined stimulated Raman adiabatic passage (STIRAP) and counter-diabatic fields (CDF), using as vehicles selective population of one of a pair of near degenerate states in SCCl2_22​ and enhancing the yield of HNC in the HCN/HNC isomerization reaction. The efficiency of the population transfer within a subset of states embedded in a dense manifold of states is examined for the cases that the transition dipole moments between the initial and target states are much smaller than and comparable to the transition dipole moments between background states, and for the case that the subset states have large transition dipole moments with the background states. We show that, in a subset of states that is coupled to background states, a combination of STIRAP fields and CDFs that do not individually generate processes that are competitive with the desired population transfer can generate greater population transfer efficiency than can ordinary STIRAP with field strength and/or pulse duration similarly restricted. We also show that the exact CDF for an isolated three level system is a useful approximation to the exact CDF for three and five state systems embedded in background states, and we report a study of the stability of the STIRAP + approximate CDF control protocol to variation of the CDF.
Stimulated Raman scattering involving adiabatic passage (STIRAP) is a proven technique for population transfer in three-level systems with strong oscillator strengths. We show that the STIRAP process should also yield high transfer efficiencies when the densities of states near the intermediate and final levels are high, provided certain criteria for the experimentally controllable parameters are met. We also show that high transfer efficiencies may even be possible when the pump and Stokes lasers can access levels outside of the three-level system. The criteria are derived with an approach that emphasizes the adiabatic nature of the transfer process in an eigenvector of the interaction Hamiltonian that resembles a trapped state. The results are compared to density matrix calculations.
Abstract We consider coherent population transfer in multilevel quantum systems driven by time-delayed pulse trains. We show how to choose the parameters of the trains so that the population dynamics tracks the behavior of a Λ-type three-level system under stimulated Raman adiabatic passage (STIRAP). Efficient population transfer can be achieved regardless of the order and with or without overlap of the pump and the Stokes sub-pulses of the trains. Generalized STIRAP schemes of population transfer in N -level system with sequential couplings are also examined. The mechanism of the population transfer and the robustness of the proposed schemes are discussed.
STIRAP (stimulated Raman adiabatic passage) has proven to be an efficient and robust technique for transferring population in a three-level system without populating the intermediate state. Here we show that the counterintuitive pulse sequence in STIRAP, in which the Stokes pulse precedes the pump, emerges automatically from a variant of optimal control theory we have previously called ``local'' optimization. Since local optimization is a well-defined, automated computational procedure, this opens the door to automated computation of generalized STIRAP schemes in arbitrarily complicated NNN-level coupling situations. If the coupling is sequential, a simple qualitative extension of STIRAP emerges: the Stokes pulse precedes the pump as in the three-level system. But, in addition, spanning both the Stokes and pump pulses are pulses corresponding to the transitions between the $N\ensuremath{-}2$ intermediate states with intensities about an order of magnitude greater than those of the Stokes and pump pulses. This scheme is amazingly robust, leading to almost 100% population transfer with significantly less population transfer to the $N\ensuremath{-}2$ intermediate states than in previously proposed extensions of STIRAP.
We consider combined stimulated Raman adiabatic passage (STIRAP) and fast-forward field (FFF) control of selective vibrational population transfer in a polyatomic molecule. The motivation for using this combination control scheme is 2-fold: (i) to overcome transfer inefficiency that occurs when the STIRAP fields and pulse durations must be restricted to avoid excitation of population transfers that compete with the targeted transfer and (ii) to overcome transfer inefficiency resulting from embedding of the actively driven subset of states in a large manifold of states. We show that, in a subset of states that is coupled to background states, a combination of STIRAP and FFFs that do not individually generate processes that are competitive with the desired population transfer can generate greater population transfer efficiency than can ordinary STIRAP with similar field strength and/or pulse duration.