TRANSACTIONS OF THE JAPAN SOCIETY FOR AERONAUTICAL AND SPACE SCIENCES SPACE TECHNOLOGY JAPAN

Comparison of Free-Space and Fiber-Based Transmission Systems in Quantum Cryptography

Morio Toyoshima, Yozo Shoji, Christian SCHAEFER, Yoshihisa Takayama, Hiroo Kunimori, Masahiro Takeoka, Mikio Fujiwara, Masahide Sasaki

Published Jan 1, 2009• 3 citations

Publisher

Abstract

The distance for quantum key distribution using optical fibers is limited to around 100 km by the transmission loss, background level in the optical fibers, and birefringence in the fibers. Free space is an ideal medium for transmitting photon-based quantum information; this is considered to be the key advantage of quantum cryptography. In fiber-based systems, there is an optical loss in the fiber of about 0.2 dB/km for a telecom wavelength of 1.5 µm. That is, after a propagation of 150 km, the transmission loss in the fiber becomes 30 dB. On the other hand, free-space transmission obeys the diffraction theory of laser light; therefore, the free-space transmission loss is inversely proportional to the square of the distance, and this transmission has an advantage at longer distances over fiber-based transmission. The final key rates for free-space and fiber-based transmission systems are compared with respect to the parameters for the dark count rate, the imperfection of the optical system, and so on. In this paper, the trade-off of free-space and fiber-based systems is presented.

DOI: 10.2322/tstj.7.pj_7

Related papers

Long-distance quantum cryptography with entangled photons

Anton Zeilinger

Entanglement-based quantum cryptography has the appealing advantage of intuitively more evident security. While originally, weak laser pulse schemes were implemented earlier as technologically simpler, it is now possible to build entanglement-based quantum key distribution systems on a technically equally advanced level. The existing polarization-based systems as developed in Vienna now cover distances of the order of 100 km in fiber and of 144 km in free space. In a recent fiber experiment, an asymmetric source is used such that one photon at the 1.550 nm telecom wavelength is transmitted to Bob, while the other photon at 810 nm is locally measured by Alice. It turns out that polarization entanglement is rather robust, certainly over distances of 100 km in fibers. In a recent long-distance free-space experiment, one photon was sent over 144 km from the Canary Island of La Palma to the island of Tenerife, while again the other photon was measured locally. The receiving station uses the OGS telescope operated by the European Space Agency ESA. This experiment opens up the possibility for future quantum key distribution using satellites.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIESep 9, 200711 citations

Discrete Variable Quantum Key Distribution over a Free-Space Optical Channel

John Gariano

When light is propagated through a channel that is not a waveguide, such as a fiber, it is known as a free-space optical channel. When used in communication systems, free-space optical channels provide the advantages of high communication rates, lower power, and minimal infrastructure installation. When the free-space optical channel has a random medium in it, such as the atmosphere, the distortions will be applied to the phase. The phase distortions can lead to intensity fluctuations and additional beam spreading. To compensate for the distortions adaptive optics can be used, allowing for the stability of the system to be improved. Additionally, post processing techniques on transmitted data can also be used to improve the stability of the channel. By significantly decreasing the number of photons transmitted, a classical communication channel can be considered as a quantum channel. Encoding information into the quantum states of the transmitted photons, quantum communication can be performed. When transmitting on the order of 1 photon per pulse, classical post processing techniques cannot be used to improve the stability of the channel. To stabilize the free-space optical channel, adaptive optics can be used at the transmitter or receiver. As no measurement of the quantum state is performed by the adaptive optics system, no information in the photon is lost. In this work, quantum key distribution will be implemented over the quantum channel. The focus of this work is on the design and study of how the channel degradations can be overcome, as well as the establishment of a free-space optical channel with adaptive optics in a quantum networking testbed. Quantum key distribution systems were simulated over a 30 km maritime channel as well as over a underwater channel. For the 30 km channel, the use of multiple parallel spatial modes results in the highest increases of the secure key rate at the cost of transmitting a lower average number of photons. When adaptive optics is applied, the secure key rates have a small increase, however as the strength of the turbulence increases from weak to moderate, the relative improvement is higher. For the underwater channel, operation at lower depths is optimal as fewer background photons reach the receiver and the channel attenuation is lower. In the experimental setup, it was found that the single photon detectors that are being used are the limiting the channel loss to be at most 6 dB. The free space optical link established between the Electrical and Computer Engineering building and College of Optical Sciences uses a corner cube retro-reflector to yield a distance of 1.45 km. The channel has been characterized at various times of day to determine the strength of the atmospheric turbulence, which ranges from a scintillation index of 0.07 to 2.21. A classical communication experiment was performed, resulting in error-free transmission while the input power to the EDFA before the photodetector was consistently above -25 dBm.

Jan 1, 20190 citations

Development of the polarization tracking scheme for free-space quantum cryptography

Morio Toyoshima, Yoshihisa Takayama, Hiroo Kunimori +3 more

Quantum cryptography is a new technique for transmitting quantum information. The information is securely transmitted due to the laws of physics. In such systems, the vehicle that transfers quantum information is a single photon. The problem with using photons is that the transmission distance is limited by the absorption of the photons by the optical fiber along which they pass. The maximum demonstrated range so far is approximately 100 km. Using free-space quantum cryptography between a ground station and a satellite is a possible way of sending quantum information farther than is possible with optical fibers. This is because there is no birefringence effect in the atmosphere. However, there is a complication in that the directions of the polarization basis between the transmitter and the receiver must coincide with each other. This polarization changes because the mobile terminals for free-space transmission continuously change their attitudes. If the transmission protocol is based on polarization, it is necessary to compensate for the change in attitude between the mobile terminals. We are developing a scheme to track the polarization basis between the transceivers. The preliminary result is presented.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIEApr 3, 20084 citations

Effects of loss and dispersion on fiber-based quantum key distribution system

Shu Yang, Wei Liu, Yu‐Hong Han +1 more

Studied are the effects of fiber dispersion and loss and single-photon detector dark counts on key transmission rate and bit error rate of quantum key distribution system through theoretical analysis and computation. Research demonstrates that fiber loss is the main factor that influences quantum key transmission rate, while quantum bit error rate is related to fiber loss, dispersion, pulse width, dark counts and Rayleigh backscattering. Theoretical calculation indicates that in the current single-mode fiber-based plug & play quantum key distribution system with a dark counts of 10 -5/ns, the utilization of short pulse with 1550 nm wavelength and a 50 ps width can achieve the maximum transmission distance of 131 km. If we reduce dark counts or use G.653 dispersion-shifted fiber with short pulse, we can further improve key transmission rate and reduce the quantum bit error rate, thus effectively enhance the transmission distance of quantum key distribution system.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIEOct 17, 20083 citations

Conceptual designs of onboard transceivers for ground-to-satellite quantum cryptography

Morio Toyoshima, Yozo Shoji, Yoshihisa Takayama +4 more

A free-space quantum key distribution system is being developed by the National Institute of Information and Communications Technology (NICT) in Koganei, Japan. Quantum cryptography is a new technique for transmitting information where the security is guaranteed by the laws of physics. In such systems, a single photon is used for the quantum information. However, since the transmission distance in optical fibers is limited by the absorption of photons by the fiber, the maximum demonstrated range has been limited to about 100 km. Free-space quantum cryptography between an optical ground station and a satellite is a possible solution to extend the distance for a quantum network beyond the limits of optical fibers. At NICT, a laser communication demonstration between the NICT optical ground station and a low earth orbit satellite was successfully conducted in 2006. The use of free-space quantum key distribution for such space communication links is considered an important future application. This paper presents conceptual designs for the onboard transceivers for satellite quantum cryptography

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIEMay 1, 20091 citation

Secure Communications Using Quantum Cryptography

Richard Hughes, Buttler, William T., Kwiat, Paul G. +5 more

The secure distribution of the secret random bit sequences known as {open_quotes}key{close_quotes} material, is an essential precursor to their use for the encryption and decryption of confidential communications. Quantum cryptography is an emerging technology for secure key distribution with single-photon transmissions, nor evade detection (eavesdropping raises the key error rate above a threshold value). We have developed experimental quantum cryptography systems based on the transmission of non-orthogonal single-photon states to generate shared key material over multi-kilometer optical fiber paths and over line-of-sight links. In both cases, key material is built up using the transmission of a single-photon per bit of an initial secret random sequence. A quantum-mechanically random subset of this sequence is identified, becoming the key material after a data reconciliation stage with the sender. In our optical fiber experiment we have performed quantum key distribution over 24-km of underground optical fiber using single-photon interference states, demonstrating that secure, real-time key generation over {open_quotes}open{close_quotes} multi-km node-to-node optical fiber communications links is possible. We have also constructed a quantum key distribution system for free-space, line-of-sight transmission using single-photon polarization states, which is currently undergoing laboratory testing. 7 figs.

Jan 1, 19972 citations