Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics

Some results for the two-dimensional Ising model with competing interactions

Eytan Domany

Published Feb 14, 1979• 43 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The applicability of the n-replica method to an Ising system with positive and negative bonds of equal strength is investigated. It is shown that this method does reproduce the correct low-temperature and low-(negative bond) concentration series for the ground-state energy. It is essential, however, to take the low-temperature limit after the n to 0 limit. For a square lattice, the slope of the critical line near the pure-system transition point is found to be 2 square root 2/ln( square root 2+1). The onset of spin-glass order is conjectured to be associated with a negative bond concentration at which unfrustrated plaquettes no longer percolate the lattice. The estimated value of 16% is in agreement with Monte Carlo results.

DOI
10.1088/0022-3719/12/3/007

Related papers

The critical temperature of the two-dimensional JIsing spin glass

R Sungthong, J. Poulter

We have studied the two-dimensional ± J Ising model on the square lattice with a view to determine whether a spin glass can exist at small finite temperatures. By mapping the Ising model onto an ensemble of non-interacting lattice fermions, we have shown that the critical temperature for the spin glass phase transition appears to vanish. This result applies for all concentrations of negative bonds where the ground state is a spin glass.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jun 5, 2003•7 citations

Low-concentration series expansions for dilute spin glasses at zero temperature

Amnon Aharony A, Kurt Binder

An Ising (spin- 1 / 2 ) model with random positive, negative and zero nearest-neighbour exchange coefficients is considered at zero temperature. The authors define two 'spin glass' susceptibilities, through average sums over ((s i s j ) 2 ) av and ( mod (s i s j ) mod ) av , where ( ) means averaging over degenerate ground states and ( ) av means averaging over the random bond distribution. These susceptibilities are expanded in powers of the concentrations of the non-zero bonds, for the triangular (seven terms), square (nine terms) and d-dimensional hypercubic (eight terms) lattices. All the series show a singularity, which is associated with the paramagnetic to spin-glass phase transition. The phase boundary between these phases, and the corresponding critical exponents, are estimated.

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics•Jul 30, 1980•20 citations

Critical behavior of the bond-dilute two-dimensional Ising model

D. Zobin

We have performed Monte Carlo calculations of the thermodynamic properties of the bond-dilute Ising model on the square lattice. The results are obtained for the magnetization, internal energy, specific heat, and susceptibility for several concentrations of missing bonds. The dependence of the Curie temperature on dilution is in good agreement with the results obtained by other methods. The phase transition is found to remain sharp with the same value of the susceptibility exponent as for the pure Ising model.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Sep 1, 1978•23 citations

A new approach to the quenched bond-diluted Ising model

Eduardo Lage

The techniques developed by Edwards and Anderson (1975) for the spin-glass problem are here applied to the bond-diluted quenched Ising model (S= 1 / 2 ). The n to 0 trick is used to express exactly the free energy in terms of a generalized Hamiltonian representing n different but coupled replicas. The only approximation of the theory consists of decoupling these replicas in a way that reduces the free energy of the diluted system to that of a pure system with renormalized, concentration-dependent parameters. To first order in the concentration of missing bonds the author obtains all the results previously derived by Harris (1974) using a cumulant expansion and which are exact in this limit. More generally, the theory allows a discussion of the concentration dependence of the critical temperature; in particular, the values deduced for the critical concentration agree rather well with those obtained exactly or through series expansions. The behaviour of the system near the transition is also studied and the critical exponents are found to be Fisher-renormalized.

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics•Mar 14, 1977•12 citations

Magnetic correlations in two-dimensional spin-glasses

I. Morgenstern, Kurt Binder

By a recursive method numerically exact free energies are calculated for square $L\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}L$ Ising lattices, with $6<~L<~18$, for several kinds of frozen-in bond disorder: (i) bonds $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ with various concentrations of negative bonds; (ii) bonds distributed according to a Gaussian distribution. Ground states of these systems are identified, the response to "ordering fields" is studied, and the correlation function ${〈{S}_{0}{S}_{R}〉}_{T}^{2}$ is calculated as a function of temperature for various distances $R$ in the lattice. This correlation is found to decay strongly (presumably exponentially) with increasing $R$ even at temperatures distinctly below the apparent freezing temperature ${T}_{f}$ of previous Monte Carlo simulations; this "freezing transition" is hence unambiguously identified as a nonequilibrium effect. However, the correlation length is found to become long ranged at low temperatures, and it is suggested that a phase transition still occurs at $T=0$; while in the Gaussian model the spin-glass order parameter $q(T=0)=1$, it is found that $q\ensuremath{\equiv}0$ in the $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ model where rather a power-law decay of correlations ${〈{S}_{0}{S}_{R}〉}_{T=0}^{2}$ occurs. Performing Monte Carlo simulations for precisely the same systems, the cooling times necessary to reach the true ground states of the system are identified, as well as the simulation times necessary to reach thermal equilibrium for the correlation functions. These times are found to increase so strongly with $L$ that for systems of macroscopic size the correct thermal equilibrium is probably irrelevant for experimental purposes. Rather a statistical mechanics based on the many long-lived metastable states would be required.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jul 1, 1980•304 citations

Monte Carlo studies of the Ising square lattice with competing interactions

Ansgar Kalz, A. Honecker, Sebastian Fuchs +1 more

We use improved Monte-Carlo algorithms to study the antiferromagnetic 2D-Ising model with competing interactions J 1 on nearest neighbour and J 2 on next-nearest neighbour bonds. The finite-temperature phase diagram is divided by a critical point at J 2 = J 1 /2 where the groundstate is highly degenerate. To analyse the phase boundaries we look at the speciflc heat and the energy distribution for various ratios of J 2 / 1 . We find a first order transition for small J 2 > J 1 /2 and the transition temperature suppressed to T C = 0 at the critical point.

arXiv:0809.2503•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jan 1, 2009•22 citations
The applicability of the n-replica method to an Ising system with positive and negative bonds of equal strength is investigated. It is shown that this method does reproduce the correct low-temperature and low-(negative bond) concentration series for the ground-state energy. It is essential, however, to take the low-temperature limit after the n to 0 limit. For a square lattice, the slope of the critical line near the pure-system transition point is found to be 2 square root 2/ln( square root 2+1). The onset of spin-glass order is conjectured to be associated with a negative bond concentration at which unfrustrated plaquettes no longer percolate the lattice. The estimated value of 16% is in agreement with Monte Carlo results.
An Ising (spin- 1 / 2 ) model with random positive, negative and zero nearest-neighbour exchange coefficients is considered at zero temperature. The authors define two 'spin glass' susceptibilities, through average sums over ((s i s j ) 2 ) av and ( mod (s i s j ) mod ) av , where ( ) means averaging over degenerate ground states and ( ) av means averaging over the random bond distribution. These susceptibilities are expanded in powers of the concentrations of the non-zero bonds, for the triangular (seven terms), square (nine terms) and d-dimensional hypercubic (eight terms) lattices. All the series show a singularity, which is associated with the paramagnetic to spin-glass phase transition. The phase boundary between these phases, and the corresponding critical exponents, are estimated.
We have performed Monte Carlo calculations of the thermodynamic properties of the bond-dilute Ising model on the square lattice. The results are obtained for the magnetization, internal energy, specific heat, and susceptibility for several concentrations of missing bonds. The dependence of the Curie temperature on dilution is in good agreement with the results obtained by other methods. The phase transition is found to remain sharp with the same value of the susceptibility exponent as for the pure Ising model.
The techniques developed by Edwards and Anderson (1975) for the spin-glass problem are here applied to the bond-diluted quenched Ising model (S= 1 / 2 ). The n to 0 trick is used to express exactly the free energy in terms of a generalized Hamiltonian representing n different but coupled replicas. The only approximation of the theory consists of decoupling these replicas in a way that reduces the free energy of the diluted system to that of a pure system with renormalized, concentration-dependent parameters. To first order in the concentration of missing bonds the author obtains all the results previously derived by Harris (1974) using a cumulant expansion and which are exact in this limit. More generally, the theory allows a discussion of the concentration dependence of the critical temperature; in particular, the values deduced for the critical concentration agree rather well with those obtained exactly or through series expansions. The behaviour of the system near the transition is also studied and the critical exponents are found to be Fisher-renormalized.
By a recursive method numerically exact free energies are calculated for square $L\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}L$ Ising lattices, with 6< L< 186<~L<~186< L< 18, for several kinds of frozen-in bond disorder: (i) bonds $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ with various concentrations of negative bonds; (ii) bonds distributed according to a Gaussian distribution. Ground states of these systems are identified, the response to "ordering fields" is studied, and the correlation function 〈S0SR〉T2{〈{S}_{0}{S}_{R}〉}_{T}^{2}〈S0​SR​〉T2​ is calculated as a function of temperature for various distances RRR in the lattice. This correlation is found to decay strongly (presumably exponentially) with increasing RRR even at temperatures distinctly below the apparent freezing temperature Tf{T}_{f}Tf​ of previous Monte Carlo simulations; this "freezing transition" is hence unambiguously identified as a nonequilibrium effect. However, the correlation length is found to become long ranged at low temperatures, and it is suggested that a phase transition still occurs at T=0T=0T=0; while in the Gaussian model the spin-glass order parameter q(T=0)=1q(T=0)=1q(T=0)=1, it is found that $q\ensuremath{\equiv}0$ in the $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ model where rather a power-law decay of correlations 〈S0SR〉T=02{〈{S}_{0}{S}_{R}〉}_{T=0}^{2}〈S0​SR​〉T=02​ occurs. Performing Monte Carlo simulations for precisely the same systems, the cooling times necessary to reach the true ground states of the system are identified, as well as the simulation times necessary to reach thermal equilibrium for the correlation functions. These times are found to increase so strongly with LLL that for systems of macroscopic size the correct thermal equilibrium is probably irrelevant for experimental purposes. Rather a statistical mechanics based on the many long-lived metastable states would be required.
We use improved Monte-Carlo algorithms to study the antiferromagnetic 2D-Ising model with competing interactions J 1 on nearest neighbour and J 2 on next-nearest neighbour bonds. The finite-temperature phase diagram is divided by a critical point at J 2 = J 1 /2 where the groundstate is highly degenerate. To analyse the phase boundaries we look at the speciflc heat and the energy distribution for various ratios of J 2 / 1 . We find a first order transition for small J 2 > J 1 /2 and the transition temperature suppressed to T C = 0 at the critical point.