Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A

Comments on a Proposed Quantization of Interacting Fields

Udo Schröder

Published Dec 1, 1971• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The meaning of a recently proposed formalism for quantization of interacting fields is discussed by studying the consequences of the time-dependent unitary transformation which is essential for this approach. It turns out that non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics in dipole approximation may serve as a useful, although rather singular, example for this method. In the relativistic case a different point of view is suggested in order to avoid inconsistent interpretation. It is further possible to give arguments for a reasonable choice of the unitary transformation concerned

DOI
10.1515/zna-1971-1201

Related papers

Quantum Field Theory in the Weyl–Wigner Representation

Emilio Santos

The Wigner representation for quantum mechanics of particles is generalized to Bose fields. The standard Hilbert space quantization becomes, via the Weyl transform, a quantization method that consists of adding a Gaussian zeropoint field distribution to the vacuum. I comment on the possible advantages of the method in order to study quantum fields in curved spaces. I study a unified formulation of non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics in the Weyl–Wigner formalism, in terms of (classical-like) c-numbers.

arXiv:2606.17085•Universe•Dec 9, 2025•1 citation

Notes on the second quantization in quantum electrodynamics

В. А. Головко

It is demonstrated that the second quantization which is the basis of quantum electrodynamics is introduced without sufficient grounds and even logically inconsistently although it yields extremely accurate predictions that are in excellent agreement with experiment. The physical essence hidden behind the second quantization is discussed as well.

arXiv:1706.02585•Jun 6, 2017•0 citations

Comment on "Electric dipole interaction in quantum optics"

W P Healy

It is shown that Mandel's argument that the electric dipole interaction in quantum electrodynamics is inconsistent with Maxwell's equations relies on the use of the wrong canonical momenta in the multipolar form of the Hamiltonian; the field conjugate to the vector potential in the Coulomb gauge is proportional to the transverse displacement vector and not, as in the minimal-coupling form of the Hamiltonian, to the transverse electric field, and similarly the canonical momenta of the charged particles differ in the two cases. Some consequences of this for time-dependent perturbation theory are discussed.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1980•29 citations

The time-dependent canonical formalism: Generalized harmonic oscillator and the infinite square well with a moving boundary

José M. Cerveró, Juan D Lejarreta

In this paper a systematic formalism for dealing with non-relativistic time-dependent quantum Hamiltonians is presented. The starting point is the well-known Lewis and Riesenfeld idea which involves the construction of an invariant operator I ( x , t ) which defines both the dynamics of the physical system and the canonical formalism that has to be used in order to obtain a consistent theoretical framework. In order to exhibit the full power of the formalism we discuss two examples: the generalized harmonic oscillator and the infinite square well with a moving boundary. As the first example has already been analyzed by the present authors from other different points of view, we are able to compare the results of the canonical formalism with these other approaches and, as it was expected, we obtain identical descriptions of this physical system. After this, we turn to the case of the square well with a moving boundary. The main surprise is that in order to obtain consistency with the formalism an effective interaction appears which seems to be due to the time dependence of the boundary. Also consistency with the principle of minimal coupling and gauge invariance is obtained just by using this canonical operator formalism. Finally some interesting physical applications are suggested and discussed.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Jan 1, 1999•25 citations

Time-dependent theory and linear response

ROBERT K. NESBET

In the quantum theory of interacting electrons, a physically correct theory of time dependence should in principle be formulated as a relativistic quantum field theory. The physical model is that of electrons, each characterized by a probability distribution over space-time events x i , t i , that interact indirectly through the quantized electromagnetic field. This theory is simplified for particular applications by neglecting true radiative effects of quantum electrodynamics, and by passing to the limit of large c , the velocity of light in vacuo .

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 14, 2002•0 citations

Quantum optics without second quantization

Tomáš Tyc, Časlav Brukner, Anton Zeilinger +1 more

A possibility of formulation of quantum optics without the second quantization formalism is considered.

•Jan 1, 2000•0 citations
The meaning of a recently proposed formalism for quantization of interacting fields is discussed by studying the consequences of the time-dependent unitary transformation which is essential for this approach. It turns out that non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics in dipole approximation may serve as a useful, although rather singular, example for this method. In the relativistic case a different point of view is suggested in order to avoid inconsistent interpretation. It is further possible to give arguments for a reasonable choice of the unitary transformation concerned
The Wigner representation for quantum mechanics of particles is generalized to Bose fields. The standard Hilbert space quantization becomes, via the Weyl transform, a quantization method that consists of adding a Gaussian zeropoint field distribution to the vacuum. I comment on the possible advantages of the method in order to study quantum fields in curved spaces. I study a unified formulation of non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics in the Weyl–Wigner formalism, in terms of (classical-like) c-numbers.
It is shown that Mandel's argument that the electric dipole interaction in quantum electrodynamics is inconsistent with Maxwell's equations relies on the use of the wrong canonical momenta in the multipolar form of the Hamiltonian; the field conjugate to the vector potential in the Coulomb gauge is proportional to the transverse displacement vector and not, as in the minimal-coupling form of the Hamiltonian, to the transverse electric field, and similarly the canonical momenta of the charged particles differ in the two cases. Some consequences of this for time-dependent perturbation theory are discussed.
In this paper a systematic formalism for dealing with non-relativistic time-dependent quantum Hamiltonians is presented. The starting point is the well-known Lewis and Riesenfeld idea which involves the construction of an invariant operator I ( x , t ) which defines both the dynamics of the physical system and the canonical formalism that has to be used in order to obtain a consistent theoretical framework. In order to exhibit the full power of the formalism we discuss two examples: the generalized harmonic oscillator and the infinite square well with a moving boundary. As the first example has already been analyzed by the present authors from other different points of view, we are able to compare the results of the canonical formalism with these other approaches and, as it was expected, we obtain identical descriptions of this physical system. After this, we turn to the case of the square well with a moving boundary. The main surprise is that in order to obtain consistency with the formalism an effective interaction appears which seems to be due to the time dependence of the boundary. Also consistency with the principle of minimal coupling and gauge invariance is obtained just by using this canonical operator formalism. Finally some interesting physical applications are suggested and discussed.
In the quantum theory of interacting electrons, a physically correct theory of time dependence should in principle be formulated as a relativistic quantum field theory. The physical model is that of electrons, each characterized by a probability distribution over space-time events x i , t i , that interact indirectly through the quantized electromagnetic field. This theory is simplified for particular applications by neglecting true radiative effects of quantum electrodynamics, and by passing to the limit of large c , the velocity of light in vacuo .