Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

Phase-transition-like behaviour of quantum games

Jiangfeng Du, Hui Li, Xiaodong Xu, Xianyi Zhou, Rongdian Han

Published May 28, 2003• 78 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The discontinuous dependence of the properties of a quantum game on its entanglement has been shown to be very much like phase transitions viewed in the entanglement-payoff diagram (J Du et al 2002 Phys. Rev. Lett. 88 137902). In this paper we investigate such phase-transition-like behaviour of quantum games, by suggesting a method which would help to illuminate the origin of such a kind of behaviour. For the particular case of the generalized Prisoners' Dilemma, we find that, for different settings of the numerical values in the payoff table, even though the classical game behaves the same, the quantum game exhibits different and interesting phase-transition-like behaviour.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/36/23/318

Related papers

Phase-transition-like Behavior of Quantum Games

Jiangfeng Du, Hui Li, Xiaodong Xu +2 more

The discontinuous dependence of the properties of a quantum game on its entanglement has been shown up to be very much like phase transitions viewed in the entanglement-payoff diagram [J. Du et al., Phys. Rev. Lett, 88, 137902 (2002)]. In this paper we investigate such phase-transition-like behavior of quantum games, by suggesting a method which would help to illuminate the origin of such kind of behavior. For the particular case of the generalized Prisoners' Dilemma, we find that, for different settings of the numerical values in the payoff table, even though the classical game behaves the same, the quantum game exhibits different and interesting phase-transition-like behavior.

arXiv:quant-ph/0111138•Nov 26, 2001•3 citations

Phase Transitions in Quantum Games

Jiangfeng Du, Hui Li, Xiaodong Xu +2 more

The discontinuous dependence of the properties of a quantum game on its entanglement has been shown up as phase transitions [Phys. Rev. Lett, 88, 137902]. In this paper we explore this kind of phase transitions in quantum games and reveal the underlying physical foundations, using a method which is appropriate for the task here. For the generalized version of Prisoners' Dilemma, we find that, with different settings of the numerical values in the payoff table, even though the classical game behaves the same, the quantum game behaves greatly differently and exhibits novel features in view of phase transitions.

•Nov 26, 2001•0 citations

Entanglement Correlated Phase Changes in Quantum Games

Jiangfeng Du, Hui Li, Xiaodong Xu +3 more

In one of our previous works we investigated the correlation between a quantum game and its entanglement. For the particular case of the Prisoners' Dilemma, the result shows that the game's property depends discontinuously on the amount of the entanglement. This discontinuity can be considered as phase changes with respect to the varying of the game's entanglement. In this paper, we reveal the correlation between the phase changes and the numerical values in the payoff matrix of the game. We find that if these numerical values satisfy some certain condition, the phase in which the game has two asymmetric Nash equilibria will disappear. Furthermore, the phase changes exhibits interesting variation with respect to the numerical values in the payoff matrix.

•Nov 26, 2001•5 citations

Quantum-like modelling in game theory: Quo Vadis? A brief review

Sudip Patra, Partha Ghose

Purpose The current paper is a brief review of the emerging field of quantum-like modelling in game theory. This paper aims to explore several quantum games, which are superior compared to their classical counterparts, which means either they give rise to superior Nash equilibria or they make the game fairer. For example, quantum Prisoners Dilemma generates Pareto superior outcomes as compared to defection outcome in the famous classical case. Again, a quantum-like version of cards game can make the game fairer, increasing the chance of winning of players who are disadvantaged in the classical case. This paper explores all the virtues of simple quantum games, also highlighting some findings of the authors as regards Prisoners Dilemma game. Design/methodology/approach As this is a general review paper, the authors have not demonstrated any specific mathematical method, rather explored the well-known quantum probability framework, used for designing quantum games. They have a short appendix which explores basic structure of Hilbert space representation of human decision-making. Findings Along with the review of the extant literature, the authors have also highlighted some new findings for quantum Prisoners Dilemma game. Specifically, they have shown in the earlier studies (which are referred to here) that a pure quantum entanglement set up is not needed for designing better games, even a weaker condition, which is classical entanglement is sufficient for producing Pareto improved outcomes. Research limitations/implications Theoretical research, with findings and implications for future game designs, it has been argued that it is not always needed to have true quantum entanglement for superior Nash Equilibria. Originality/value The main purpose here is to raise awareness mainly in the social science community about the possible applications of quantum-like game theory paradigm. The findings related to Prisoners Dilemma game are, however, original.

Asian Journal of Economics and Banking•Dec 3, 2020•4 citations

The Strategic Form of Quantum Prisoners' Dilemma

Ahmad Nawaz

In a normal form, prisoners' dilemma (PD) is represented by a payoff matrix showing players' strategies and payoffs. To obtain the distinguishing trait and strategic form of PD, certain constraints are imposed on the elements of its payoff matrix. We quantize PD by a generalized quantization scheme to analyze its strategic behavior in the quantum domain. The game starts with a general entangled state of the form and the measurement for payoffs is performed in entangled and product bases. We show that for both measurements, there exist respective cutoff values of entanglement of the initial quantum state up to which the strategic form of the game remains intact. Beyond these cutoffs the quantized PD behaves like the chicken game (CG) up to another cutoff value. For the measurement in the entangled basis the dilemma is resolved for sinξ > 1/7 with Q ⊗ Q as a Nash Equilibrium (NE). However, the quantized game behaves like PD when sinξ > 1/3; whereas in the range 1/7 < sinξ < 1/3 it behaves like CG with Q ⊗ Q as an NE. For the measurement in the product basis the quantized PD behaves like classical PD for with D ⊗ D as an NE. In region , the quantized PD behaves like classical CG with C ⊗ D and D ⊗ C as NEs.

Chinese Physics Letters•May 1, 2013•14 citations

The strategic form of quantum prisoners' dilemma

Ahmad Nawaz

In its normal form prisoners' dilemma (PD) is represented by a payoff matrix showing players strategies and payoffs. To obtain distinguishing trait and strategic form of PD certain constraints are imposed on the elements of its payoff matrix. We quantize PD by generalized quantization scheme to analyze its strategic behavior in quantum domain. The game starts with general entangled state of the form $\left}ψ\right\rangle =\cos\fracξ% {2}\left|00\right\rangle +i\sin\fracξ{2}\left|11\right\rangle $ and the measurement for payoffs is performed in entangled and product bases. We show that for both measurements there exist respective cutoff values of entanglement of initial quantum state up to which strategic form of game remains intact. Beyond these cutoffs the quantized PD behaves like chicken game up to another cutoff value. For the measurement in entangled basis the dilemma is resolved for\ $\sinξ>\frac{1}{7}$ with $Q\otimes Q$ as a NE but the quantized game behaves like PD when $\sinξ>\frac{1}{3}$; whereas in the range $\frac{1}{7}

arXiv:1307.6541•Jul 21, 2013•0 citations
The discontinuous dependence of the properties of a quantum game on its entanglement has been shown to be very much like phase transitions viewed in the entanglement-payoff diagram (J Du et al 2002 Phys. Rev. Lett. 88 137902). In this paper we investigate such phase-transition-like behaviour of quantum games, by suggesting a method which would help to illuminate the origin of such a kind of behaviour. For the particular case of the generalized Prisoners' Dilemma, we find that, for different settings of the numerical values in the payoff table, even though the classical game behaves the same, the quantum game exhibits different and interesting phase-transition-like behaviour.
The discontinuous dependence of the properties of a quantum game on its entanglement has been shown up to be very much like phase transitions viewed in the entanglement-payoff diagram [J. Du et al., Phys. Rev. Lett, 88, 137902 (2002)]. In this paper we investigate such phase-transition-like behavior of quantum games, by suggesting a method which would help to illuminate the origin of such kind of behavior. For the particular case of the generalized Prisoners' Dilemma, we find that, for different settings of the numerical values in the payoff table, even though the classical game behaves the same, the quantum game exhibits different and interesting phase-transition-like behavior.
The discontinuous dependence of the properties of a quantum game on its entanglement has been shown up as phase transitions [Phys. Rev. Lett, 88, 137902]. In this paper we explore this kind of phase transitions in quantum games and reveal the underlying physical foundations, using a method which is appropriate for the task here. For the generalized version of Prisoners' Dilemma, we find that, with different settings of the numerical values in the payoff table, even though the classical game behaves the same, the quantum game behaves greatly differently and exhibits novel features in view of phase transitions.
In one of our previous works we investigated the correlation between a quantum game and its entanglement. For the particular case of the Prisoners' Dilemma, the result shows that the game's property depends discontinuously on the amount of the entanglement. This discontinuity can be considered as phase changes with respect to the varying of the game's entanglement. In this paper, we reveal the correlation between the phase changes and the numerical values in the payoff matrix of the game. We find that if these numerical values satisfy some certain condition, the phase in which the game has two asymmetric Nash equilibria will disappear. Furthermore, the phase changes exhibits interesting variation with respect to the numerical values in the payoff matrix.
Purpose The current paper is a brief review of the emerging field of quantum-like modelling in game theory. This paper aims to explore several quantum games, which are superior compared to their classical counterparts, which means either they give rise to superior Nash equilibria or they make the game fairer. For example, quantum Prisoners Dilemma generates Pareto superior outcomes as compared to defection outcome in the famous classical case. Again, a quantum-like version of cards game can make the game fairer, increasing the chance of winning of players who are disadvantaged in the classical case. This paper explores all the virtues of simple quantum games, also highlighting some findings of the authors as regards Prisoners Dilemma game. Design/methodology/approach As this is a general review paper, the authors have not demonstrated any specific mathematical method, rather explored the well-known quantum probability framework, used for designing quantum games. They have a short appendix which explores basic structure of Hilbert space representation of human decision-making. Findings Along with the review of the extant literature, the authors have also highlighted some new findings for quantum Prisoners Dilemma game. Specifically, they have shown in the earlier studies (which are referred to here) that a pure quantum entanglement set up is not needed for designing better games, even a weaker condition, which is classical entanglement is sufficient for producing Pareto improved outcomes. Research limitations/implications Theoretical research, with findings and implications for future game designs, it has been argued that it is not always needed to have true quantum entanglement for superior Nash Equilibria. Originality/value The main purpose here is to raise awareness mainly in the social science community about the possible applications of quantum-like game theory paradigm. The findings related to Prisoners Dilemma game are, however, original.
In a normal form, prisoners' dilemma (PD) is represented by a payoff matrix showing players' strategies and payoffs. To obtain the distinguishing trait and strategic form of PD, certain constraints are imposed on the elements of its payoff matrix. We quantize PD by a generalized quantization scheme to analyze its strategic behavior in the quantum domain. The game starts with a general entangled state of the form and the measurement for payoffs is performed in entangled and product bases. We show that for both measurements, there exist respective cutoff values of entanglement of the initial quantum state up to which the strategic form of the game remains intact. Beyond these cutoffs the quantized PD behaves like the chicken game (CG) up to another cutoff value. For the measurement in the entangled basis the dilemma is resolved for sinξ > 1/7 with Q ⊗ Q as a Nash Equilibrium (NE). However, the quantized game behaves like PD when sinξ > 1/3; whereas in the range 1/7 < sinξ < 1/3 it behaves like CG with Q ⊗ Q as an NE. For the measurement in the product basis the quantized PD behaves like classical PD for with D ⊗ D as an NE. In region , the quantized PD behaves like classical CG with C ⊗ D and D ⊗ C as NEs.
In its normal form prisoners' dilemma (PD) is represented by a payoff matrix showing players strategies and payoffs. To obtain distinguishing trait and strategic form of PD certain constraints are imposed on the elements of its payoff matrix. We quantize PD by generalized quantization scheme to analyze its strategic behavior in quantum domain. The game starts with general entangled state of the form $\left}ψ\right\rangle =\cos\fracξ% {2}\left|00\right\rangle +i\sin\fracξ{2}\left|11\right\rangle $ and the measurement for payoffs is performed in entangled and product bases. We show that for both measurements there exist respective cutoff values of entanglement of initial quantum state up to which strategic form of game remains intact. Beyond these cutoffs the quantized PD behaves like chicken game up to another cutoff value. For the measurement in entangled basis the dilemma is resolved for\ sin⁡ξ>17\sinξ>\frac{1}{7}sinξ>71​ with Q⊗QQ\otimes QQ⊗Q as a NE but the quantized game behaves like PD when sin⁡ξ>13\sinξ>\frac{1}{3}sinξ>31​; whereas in the range $\frac{1}{7}