Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Nature of Quantum States

James L Park

Published Mar 1, 1968• 72 citations
Publisher

Abstract

This paper carefully explores the relations among the statistical ensembles, systems, and states (pure and mixed) of quantum theory. By systematically contrasting the classical and quantal realizations of a general paradigm for a probabilistic physics, important distinctions are exposed both in statics and dynamics. Included are observations concerning the intrinsic ambiguity of the quantum-state concept and the peculiarly quantum property of dynamic indivisibility. It is concluded that the conceptual gulf between classical states and quantum “states” is wider than commonly assumed.

DOI
10.1119/1.1974484

Related papers

Quantum Theoretical Concepts of Measurement: Part I

James L Park

The overall purpose of this paper is to clarify the physical meaning and epistemological status of the term ‘measurement’ as used in quantum theory. After a review of the essential logical structure of quantum physics. Part I presents interpretive discussions contrasting the quantal concepts observable and ensemble with their classical ancestors along the lines of Margenau's latency theory. Against this background various popular ideas concerning the nature of quantum measurement are critically surveyed. The analysis reveals that, in addition to internal mathematical difficulties, all the so-called quantum theories of measurement are grounded in unjustifiable, classical presuppositions.

Philosophy of Science•Sep 1, 1968•36 citations

Quantum particles from classical statistics

C. Wetterich

Abstract Quantum particles and classical particles are described in a common setting of classical statistical physics. The property of a particle being “classical” or “quantum” ceases to be a basic conceptual difference. The dynamics differs, however, between quantum and classical particles. We describe position, motion and correlations of a quantum particle in terms of observables in a classical statistical ensemble. On the other side, we also construct explicitly the quantum formalism with wave function and Hamiltonian for classical particles. For a suitable time evolution of the classical probabilities and a suitable choice of observables all features of a quantum particle in a potential can be derived from classical statistics, including interference and tunneling. Besides conceptual advances, the treatment of classical and quantum particles in a common formalism could lead to interesting cross‐fertilization between classical statistics and quantum physics.

arXiv:0904.3048•Annalen der Physik•Oct 5, 2010•26 citations

Emergence of equilibrium thermodynamic properties in quantum pure states. I. Theory

Barbara Fresch, Giorgio J. Moro

Investigation on foundational aspects of quantum statistical mechanics recently entered a renaissance period due to novel intuitions from quantum information theory and to increasing attention on the dynamical aspects of single quantum systems. In the present contribution a simple but effective theoretical framework is introduced to clarify the connections between a purely mechanical description and the thermodynamic characterization of the equilibrium state of an isolated quantum system. A salient feature of our approach is the very transparent distinction between the statistical aspects and the dynamical aspects in the description of isolated quantum systems. Like in the classical statistical mechanics, the equilibrium distribution of any property is identified on the basis of the time evolution of the considered system. As a consequence equilibrium properties of quantum system appear to depend on the details of the initial state due to the abundance of constants of the motion in the Schrodinger dynamics. On the other hand the study of the probability distributions of some functions, such as the entropy or the equilibrium state of a subsystem, in statistical ensembles of pure states reveals the crucial role of typicality as the bridge between macroscopic thermodynamics and microscopic quantum dynamics. We shall consider two particular ensembles: the random pure state ensemble and the fixed expectation energy ensemble. The relation between the introduced ensembles, the properties of a given isolated system, and the standard quantum statistical description are discussed throughout the presentation. Finally we point out the conditions which should be satisfied by an ensemble in order to get meaningful thermodynamical characterization of an isolated quantum system.

arXiv:0910.1553•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 20, 2010•17 citations

Quantum Theory

Jochen Rau

From the outset statistical mechanics will be framed in the language of quantum theory. The typical macroscopic system is composed of multiple constituents, and hence described in some many-particle Hilbert space. In general, not much is known about such a system, certainly not the precise preparation of all its microscopic details. Thus, its description requires a more general notion of a quantum state, a so-called mixed state. This chapter begins with a brief review of the basic axioms of quantum theory regarding observables, pure states, measurements, and time evolution. Particular attention is paid to the use of projection operators and to the most elementary quantum system, a two-level system. The chapter then motivates the introduction of mixed states and examines in detail their mathematical representation and properties. It also dwells on the description of composite systems, introducing, in particular, the notions of statistical independence and correlations.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Nov 22, 2017•1 citation

Conceptual Separation between Decoherence and Quantum Probabilities within the Intrinsic Observability Framework

Atsushi Okamoto

We investigate the conceptual relationship between decoherence and the origin of probabilistic outcomes in quantum mechanics. While decoherence theory successfully explains the suppression of interference and the emergence of classical behavior through interactions with environmental degrees of freedom, its role in providing a complete account of the probabilistic nature of quantum measurement remains limited. In this work, we argue that the suppression of interference and the origin of probabilistic outcomes constitute distinct problems that should be conceptually distinguished. By “probabilistic outcomes,” we refer to the appearance of statistical distributions in measurement results as described by the Born rule. To clarify this distinction, we analyze limiting scenarios, including isolated quantum systems and the universe treated as a closed system, where the standard decoherence mechanism becomes ineffective or inapplicable, yet probabilistic outcomes persist. These considerations are not intended as a formal proof, but rather as a means to isolate conceptual dependencies. We then revisit the Intrinsic Observability Framework (IOF), in which the Hilbert space is intrinsically decomposed into observable and hidden degrees of freedom. Within this framework, probabilistic descriptions arise from restricted access to the full quantum state, rather than from environmental interactions or dynamical processes. By contrasting decoherence with the IOF perspective, we argue that decoherence provides an account of the emergence of classicality, but does not directly address the origin of quantum probabilities. The IOF, on the other hand, offers a structural perspective at the level of pure states. This suggests that a complete understanding of quantum measurement requires recognizing the distinct roles played by these two elements.

•Apr 30, 2026•0 citations

Individuals, Ensembles, States

Bernard d’Espagnat

Most of the predictions of quantum mechanics are of a statistical nature and therefore make sense only for ensembles. The axiomatics based on the quantum calculus of propositions might open the way toward a general definition of the quantum state of an individual system. It was soon recognized that this leads to separability and thereby to violation of some of the quantum-mechanical predictions. In contemporary literature, the concept of state is not wholly unambiguous. Some authors associate it with the notion of an individual system and say, for instance that a given system is in a given state. Others associate it exclusively with ensembles. The situation is complicated by the fact that for some theorists the concept of state refers only to ensembles that can be described by some state vector. For other authors it refers just as well to ensembles that cannot be associated with any state vector and for which only a density matrix description is therefore acceptable.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2018•0 citations
This paper carefully explores the relations among the statistical ensembles, systems, and states (pure and mixed) of quantum theory. By systematically contrasting the classical and quantal realizations of a general paradigm for a probabilistic physics, important distinctions are exposed both in statics and dynamics. Included are observations concerning the intrinsic ambiguity of the quantum-state concept and the peculiarly quantum property of dynamic indivisibility. It is concluded that the conceptual gulf between classical states and quantum “states” is wider than commonly assumed.
The overall purpose of this paper is to clarify the physical meaning and epistemological status of the term ‘measurement’ as used in quantum theory. After a review of the essential logical structure of quantum physics. Part I presents interpretive discussions contrasting the quantal concepts observable and ensemble with their classical ancestors along the lines of Margenau's latency theory. Against this background various popular ideas concerning the nature of quantum measurement are critically surveyed. The analysis reveals that, in addition to internal mathematical difficulties, all the so-called quantum theories of measurement are grounded in unjustifiable, classical presuppositions.
Abstract Quantum particles and classical particles are described in a common setting of classical statistical physics. The property of a particle being “classical” or “quantum” ceases to be a basic conceptual difference. The dynamics differs, however, between quantum and classical particles. We describe position, motion and correlations of a quantum particle in terms of observables in a classical statistical ensemble. On the other side, we also construct explicitly the quantum formalism with wave function and Hamiltonian for classical particles. For a suitable time evolution of the classical probabilities and a suitable choice of observables all features of a quantum particle in a potential can be derived from classical statistics, including interference and tunneling. Besides conceptual advances, the treatment of classical and quantum particles in a common formalism could lead to interesting cross‐fertilization between classical statistics and quantum physics.
Investigation on foundational aspects of quantum statistical mechanics recently entered a renaissance period due to novel intuitions from quantum information theory and to increasing attention on the dynamical aspects of single quantum systems. In the present contribution a simple but effective theoretical framework is introduced to clarify the connections between a purely mechanical description and the thermodynamic characterization of the equilibrium state of an isolated quantum system. A salient feature of our approach is the very transparent distinction between the statistical aspects and the dynamical aspects in the description of isolated quantum systems. Like in the classical statistical mechanics, the equilibrium distribution of any property is identified on the basis of the time evolution of the considered system. As a consequence equilibrium properties of quantum system appear to depend on the details of the initial state due to the abundance of constants of the motion in the Schrodinger dynamics. On the other hand the study of the probability distributions of some functions, such as the entropy or the equilibrium state of a subsystem, in statistical ensembles of pure states reveals the crucial role of typicality as the bridge between macroscopic thermodynamics and microscopic quantum dynamics. We shall consider two particular ensembles: the random pure state ensemble and the fixed expectation energy ensemble. The relation between the introduced ensembles, the properties of a given isolated system, and the standard quantum statistical description are discussed throughout the presentation. Finally we point out the conditions which should be satisfied by an ensemble in order to get meaningful thermodynamical characterization of an isolated quantum system.
From the outset statistical mechanics will be framed in the language of quantum theory. The typical macroscopic system is composed of multiple constituents, and hence described in some many-particle Hilbert space. In general, not much is known about such a system, certainly not the precise preparation of all its microscopic details. Thus, its description requires a more general notion of a quantum state, a so-called mixed state. This chapter begins with a brief review of the basic axioms of quantum theory regarding observables, pure states, measurements, and time evolution. Particular attention is paid to the use of projection operators and to the most elementary quantum system, a two-level system. The chapter then motivates the introduction of mixed states and examines in detail their mathematical representation and properties. It also dwells on the description of composite systems, introducing, in particular, the notions of statistical independence and correlations.
We investigate the conceptual relationship between decoherence and the origin of probabilistic outcomes in quantum mechanics. While decoherence theory successfully explains the suppression of interference and the emergence of classical behavior through interactions with environmental degrees of freedom, its role in providing a complete account of the probabilistic nature of quantum measurement remains limited. In this work, we argue that the suppression of interference and the origin of probabilistic outcomes constitute distinct problems that should be conceptually distinguished. By “probabilistic outcomes,” we refer to the appearance of statistical distributions in measurement results as described by the Born rule. To clarify this distinction, we analyze limiting scenarios, including isolated quantum systems and the universe treated as a closed system, where the standard decoherence mechanism becomes ineffective or inapplicable, yet probabilistic outcomes persist. These considerations are not intended as a formal proof, but rather as a means to isolate conceptual dependencies. We then revisit the Intrinsic Observability Framework (IOF), in which the Hilbert space is intrinsically decomposed into observable and hidden degrees of freedom. Within this framework, probabilistic descriptions arise from restricted access to the full quantum state, rather than from environmental interactions or dynamical processes. By contrasting decoherence with the IOF perspective, we argue that decoherence provides an account of the emergence of classicality, but does not directly address the origin of quantum probabilities. The IOF, on the other hand, offers a structural perspective at the level of pure states. This suggests that a complete understanding of quantum measurement requires recognizing the distinct roles played by these two elements.
Most of the predictions of quantum mechanics are of a statistical nature and therefore make sense only for ensembles. The axiomatics based on the quantum calculus of propositions might open the way toward a general definition of the quantum state of an individual system. It was soon recognized that this leads to separability and thereby to violation of some of the quantum-mechanical predictions. In contemporary literature, the concept of state is not wholly unambiguous. Some authors associate it with the notion of an individual system and say, for instance that a given system is in a given state. Others associate it exclusively with ensembles. The situation is complicated by the fact that for some theorists the concept of state refers only to ensembles that can be described by some state vector. For other authors it refers just as well to ensembles that cannot be associated with any state vector and for which only a density matrix description is therefore acceptable.