Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Reduced Dynamics Need Not Be Completely Positive

Philip Pechukas

Published Aug 22, 1994• 460 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The reduced dynamics of a quantum system in contact with a reservoir is generally thought to be "completely positive"; this is certainly true if product initial conditions are used to define the dynamics. We show that with correlated initial conditions it need not be so. In this case the dynamics can properly be defined only on a subset of initial system states; extension, by linearity, to all possible initial states is trivially possible, but the extension may not be physically realizable and may not even be positive, let alone completely positive.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.73.1060

Related papers

Deviation from linear reduced dynamics always occurs for each non-factorisable system-environment unitary evolution

Iman Sargolzahi

In the simplest approximation, the reduced dynamics of a quantum system $S$ interacting with its environment $E$ is considered to be given by a completely positive map. But, in general, this is not the case. In fact, the reduced dynamics of the system in not even linear, in general. Whether the reduced dynamics is linear or not is determined by two factors: the set of possible initial states of the system-environment $\mathcal{S}=\left\lbrace ρ_{SE} \right\rbrace $, and the joint system-environment unitary evolution $U$. When $U$ is factorisable as $U=U_S\otimes U_E$, then we can choose $\mathcal{S}=\mathcal{D}$, where $\mathcal{D}$ is the set of all system-environment density operators. In other words, when $U$ is factorisable, the reduced dynamics of the system $S$ is linear (in fact unitary) for arbitrary initial state of the system-environment $ρ_{SE}$. We show that this result cannot be generalized to any non-factorisable $U$: For any non-factorisable unitary evolution of the whole system-environment $U$, the set $\mathcal{S}$ must be chosen as a proper subset of $\mathcal{D}$ to achieve linear reduced dynamics. As a byproduct, considering a convex set of possible initial states of the system-environment $\mathcal{S}$ such that $\mathrm{Tr}_{E} \ \mathcal{S}=\mathrm{Tr}_{E} \ \mathcal{D}$, we show that when the reduced dynamics of the system, for one system-environment unitary evolution $U_1$, is positive, but not completely positive, this implies that reduced dynamics is not linear for another $U_2$.

quant-pharXiv:2608.18977•Aug 20, 2026•0 citations

Linearity conditions leading to complete positivity

Iman Sargolzahi

The reduced dynamics of an open quantum system $S$, interacting with its environment $E$, is not completely positive, in general. In this paper, we demonstrate that if the two following conditions are satisfied, simultaneously, then the reduced dynamics is completely positive: (1) the reduced dynamics of the system is linear, for arbitrary system-environment unitary evolution $U$; and (2) the reduced dynamics of the system is linear, for arbitrary initial state of the system ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{S}$.

arXiv:2108.06200•Physical Review A•Sep 6, 2022•3 citations

Initial Correlations and Complete Positivity of Dynamical Maps

Vinayak Jagadish, R. Srikanth, Francesco Petruccione

It is now increasingly realized in the study of open system dynamics that initial correlations do not pose a conceptual difficulty as traditionally believed. A similar methodology as used to describe initial product states can be adopted, with the only difference being that the reduced dynamics is possibly not completely positive, entailing that only a restricted set of initial reduced states lead to a physically valid dynamics. Here we study the interplay between the initial correlations, especially in the form of highly entangled states, and the system–environment unitary. In particular, for almost any initial entangled state, one can furnish infinitely many joint unitaries that generate CP dynamics on the system. Restricting to the case of initial, pure entangled states, we obtain the scaling of the dimension of the set of these unitaries and show that it is of zero measure in the set of all possible interaction unitaries.

Open Systems & Information Dynamics•Sep 1, 2023•2 citations

On non-Markovian Time Evolution in Open Quantum Systems

Andrzej Kossakowski, Rolando Rebolledo

Non-Markovian reduced dynamics of an open system is investigated. In the case when the initial state of the reservoir is the vacuum state, an approximation is introduced which makes it possible to construct a reduced dynamics which is completely positive.

Open Systems & Information Dynamics•Sep 1, 2007•37 citations

Completely positive reduced dynamics with non-Markovian initial states

Nazifkar, Samira, Sargolzahi, Iman

Consider an open quantum system S, interacting with its environment E, and also an ancillary Hilbert space R. The reduced dynamics of the system S is given by a completely positive map, if the set S={ρSE} , of possible initial states of the system-environment, can be written as a steered set from a tripartite Markov state ƮRSE. In this paper, we call such steered states as Markovian states ρSE, and study a physical case, in which the reduced dynamics of the system can be completely positive, even when the initial states of the system-environment ρSE are non-Markovian.

Iranian Journal of Physics Research•Mar 1, 2023•0 citations

Reduced dynamics for entangled initial state of the full density operator

A. J. van Wonderen, K. Lendi

Starting from the Schrödinger equation for a system and a reservoir, we construct a quantum dynamical map that describes reduced dynamics. We work with an arbitrary initial state for the system and reservoir, and thus refrain from performing any factorizations. The map is found to be nonlinear, not completely positive, and not unique. To investigate the physical implications, the Bloch equations are constructed. If the freedom the new map offers us is fully exploited, then the classic inequality γ ⊥ ⩾γ ∥ /2 for the damping coefficients must be replaced by a weaker condition.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 10, 2000•11 citations
The reduced dynamics of a quantum system in contact with a reservoir is generally thought to be "completely positive"; this is certainly true if product initial conditions are used to define the dynamics. We show that with correlated initial conditions it need not be so. In this case the dynamics can properly be defined only on a subset of initial system states; extension, by linearity, to all possible initial states is trivially possible, but the extension may not be physically realizable and may not even be positive, let alone completely positive.
In the simplest approximation, the reduced dynamics of a quantum system SSS interacting with its environment EEE is considered to be given by a completely positive map. But, in general, this is not the case. In fact, the reduced dynamics of the system in not even linear, in general. Whether the reduced dynamics is linear or not is determined by two factors: the set of possible initial states of the system-environment $\mathcal{S}=\left\lbrace ρ_{SE} \right\rbrace $, and the joint system-environment unitary evolution UUU. When UUU is factorisable as U=US⊗UEU=U_S\otimes U_EU=US​⊗UE​, then we can choose S=D\mathcal{S}=\mathcal{D}S=D, where D\mathcal{D}D is the set of all system-environment density operators. In other words, when UUU is factorisable, the reduced dynamics of the system SSS is linear (in fact unitary) for arbitrary initial state of the system-environment ρSEρ_{SE}ρSE​. We show that this result cannot be generalized to any non-factorisable UUU: For any non-factorisable unitary evolution of the whole system-environment UUU, the set S\mathcal{S}S must be chosen as a proper subset of D\mathcal{D}D to achieve linear reduced dynamics. As a byproduct, considering a convex set of possible initial states of the system-environment S\mathcal{S}S such that TrE S=TrE D\mathrm{Tr}_{E} \ \mathcal{S}=\mathrm{Tr}_{E} \ \mathcal{D}TrE​ S=TrE​ D, we show that when the reduced dynamics of the system, for one system-environment unitary evolution U1U_1U1​, is positive, but not completely positive, this implies that reduced dynamics is not linear for another U2U_2U2​.
The reduced dynamics of an open quantum system SSS, interacting with its environment EEE, is not completely positive, in general. In this paper, we demonstrate that if the two following conditions are satisfied, simultaneously, then the reduced dynamics is completely positive: (1) the reduced dynamics of the system is linear, for arbitrary system-environment unitary evolution UUU; and (2) the reduced dynamics of the system is linear, for arbitrary initial state of the system ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{S}$.
It is now increasingly realized in the study of open system dynamics that initial correlations do not pose a conceptual difficulty as traditionally believed. A similar methodology as used to describe initial product states can be adopted, with the only difference being that the reduced dynamics is possibly not completely positive, entailing that only a restricted set of initial reduced states lead to a physically valid dynamics. Here we study the interplay between the initial correlations, especially in the form of highly entangled states, and the system–environment unitary. In particular, for almost any initial entangled state, one can furnish infinitely many joint unitaries that generate CP dynamics on the system. Restricting to the case of initial, pure entangled states, we obtain the scaling of the dimension of the set of these unitaries and show that it is of zero measure in the set of all possible interaction unitaries.
Consider an open quantum system S, interacting with its environment E, and also an ancillary Hilbert space R. The reduced dynamics of the system S is given by a completely positive map, if the set S={ρSE} , of possible initial states of the system-environment, can be written as a steered set from a tripartite Markov state ƮRSE. In this paper, we call such steered states as Markovian states ρSE, and study a physical case, in which the reduced dynamics of the system can be completely positive, even when the initial states of the system-environment ρSE are non-Markovian.
Starting from the Schrödinger equation for a system and a reservoir, we construct a quantum dynamical map that describes reduced dynamics. We work with an arbitrary initial state for the system and reservoir, and thus refrain from performing any factorizations. The map is found to be nonlinear, not completely positive, and not unique. To investigate the physical implications, the Bloch equations are constructed. If the freedom the new map offers us is fully exploited, then the classic inequality γ ⊥ ⩾γ ∥ /2 for the damping coefficients must be replaced by a weaker condition.