Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Polarization Correlation Analysis of the Radiation from a Two-Photon Deuterium Source Using Three Polarizers: A Test of Quantum Mechanics versus Local Realism

T. Haji-Hassan, Alan J. Duncan, Walter Perrie, Hans Kleinpoppen, Eugen Merzbacher

Published Jan 16, 1989• 19 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Measurements have been made of the polarization properties of the two photons emitted in the decay of metastable atomic deuterium in an experiment in which three linear polarizers, instead of the normal two, are used. The quantum-mechanical predictions for these imperfect polarizers have been calculated and shown to be in good agreement with the experimental results. The results have also been used to test local realistic models which are capable of explaining all existing two-polarizer-type experiments, and have provided conclusive evidence against these theories.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.62.237

Related papers

Tests of quantum mechanics versus local realism using an atomic deuterium source

T. Haji-Hassan

Measurements of the polarization correlation of the two-photons emitted simultaneously by metastable atomic deuterium in a true second order radiative process, are described. Two experiments, one involving the use of a half-wave plate and two linear polarizers, and the other three linear polarizers. have been carried out to investigate the validity of quantum mechanics in hitherto unexplored situations and to test local realistic theories of the type recently proposed by Garucclo and Selleri. The result, of the experiment. provide clear evidence against local realistic theories in which the probability of detection is postulated to be dependent on the angle between a polarization vector I. and a detection vector λ- The quantum mechanical predictions for such experiments, in which non-ideal analysers, were employed, have also been established and have been shown to be in agreement with the experimental results. In addition. the results of circular polarization \nmeasurements confirm the conservation of angular momentum along the common axis of detection and give further verification of the correctness of the form of the state vector describing the state of polarization of the two-photons. In another experiment, the effect of an electric field on the polarization properties of the two-photons has been measured for the first time. The Stoke's parameters characterizing the two-photon beam have been determined and the results suggest that the two-photon radiation is partially polarized at 22.5o with respect to the electric field vector. It is suggested that the affect is due to the removal of the degeneracy of the virtual Intermediate P states of the deuterium atom.

•Jan 1, 1987•0 citations

Polarisation correlation in the two-photon decay of metastable atomic deuterium and a test of Bell's inequality

Walter Perrie

A 1-keV metastable atomic deuterium [D(2S)] beam of density about 104 atoms cm-3 has been produced by charge-exchange, in caesium vapour, of deuterons extracted from a radio-frequency ion source. The linear and circular polarisation correlation of the two photons emitted spontaneously by metastable atomic deuterium in a true second order radiative process have been measured for the first time. While the circular polarisation results confirm the conservation of angular momentum along the common axis of detection, the correlation in linear polarisation has been applied in a test of Bell’s Inequality which allows a quantitative distinction to be made between the predictions of Quantum Mechanics and local realistic ("hidden variable") theories. The results are in agreement with Quantum Mechanics and violate Bell’s Inequality by almost two standard deviations.

•Jan 1, 1985•0 citations

Polarization Correlation of the Two Photons Emitted by Metastable Atomic Deuterium: A Test of Bell's Inequality

Walter Perrie, Alan J. Duncan, H. J. Beyer +1 more

The polarization correlation of the two photons emitted simultaneously by metastable atomic deuterium in a true second-order decay process has been measured for the first time. The results are in agreement with quantum mechanics and violate Bell's inequality by nearly 2 standard deviations in an experiment where the process of absorption and reemission is not important.

Physical Review Letters•Apr 22, 1985•152 citations

Circular polarization correlation of the two photons emitted in the decay of metastable atomic deuterium

HT Haji-Hassan, Alan J. Duncan, Walter Perrie +2 more

The circular polarization correlation of the two photons emitted simultaneously in the decay of metastable atomic deuterium has been measured for the first time. Taking full account of the imperfections of the achromatic quarter-wave plates and linear polarizers used in the experiments, it is concluded that the results are most probably consistent with the predictions of the quantum mechanical formalism but do not provide a test of Bell's inequality.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Dec 14, 1991•6 citations

Polarization and Coherence Analysis of the Optical Two-Photon Radiation from the metastable22 S 1/2 State of Atomic Hydrogen

Alan J. Duncan, H. Kleinpoppen, Z. A. Sheikh

The Paper first summarizes fundamental aspects and results of the quantum electrodynamical theory of the two-photon radiationfromthe decay of the metastable 2 2 S 1/2 atomic hydrogen state. After a brief description of the second improved Stirling two-photon coincidence experiment polarization correlations of the two-photon decay are described in which both two or three linear polarizers are applied in order to test predictions of such correlations based upon quantum mechanics and local realistic theories (i.e., Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen type experiments). It is particularly noticeable that the three-polarizer coincidence measurement provided the largest difference (about 40%) between the Bell limits of local realistic theories and quantum mechanics so far. Apart from confirming in addition the correlations of right-right and left-left circularly polarized two-photon correlations a new type of coherence analysis of the two-photon radiation has been carried out experimentally and theoretically. A result of it is the measured coherence time of τ coh = 1.2 · 10 −15 s and coherence length of l coh = c · τ coh = 350 nm of the two-photon emission. By applying a theoretical model of the two-photon radiation linked to cascade transitions the coherence length can be estimated to l coh ≈ 100 nm in agreement by order of magnitude with the experimental data.

Kluwer Academic Publishers eBooks•Dec 15, 2005•0 citations

Quantum mechanics v. local realism

Alastair I. M. Rae

The latest experiment to test the predictions of quantum mechanics about the properties of photons has been carried out by an international group of scientists based at the University of Stirling (Haji-Hassan et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 62 237). By observing a source which emits pairs of photons 'back to back' using a battery of three linear polarisers (rather than the two which have been conventionally employed in previous experiments of this kind) the experimenters have been able to test a class of 'local realistic' theories which have been suggested as alternatives to quantum mechanics. The results of their measurements are in excellent agreement with the quantum predictions and render even more difficult the task of constructing a more realistic theory.

Physics World•Apr 1, 1989•0 citations
Measurements have been made of the polarization properties of the two photons emitted in the decay of metastable atomic deuterium in an experiment in which three linear polarizers, instead of the normal two, are used. The quantum-mechanical predictions for these imperfect polarizers have been calculated and shown to be in good agreement with the experimental results. The results have also been used to test local realistic models which are capable of explaining all existing two-polarizer-type experiments, and have provided conclusive evidence against these theories.
Measurements of the polarization correlation of the two-photons emitted simultaneously by metastable atomic deuterium in a true second order radiative process, are described. Two experiments, one involving the use of a half-wave plate and two linear polarizers, and the other three linear polarizers. have been carried out to investigate the validity of quantum mechanics in hitherto unexplored situations and to test local realistic theories of the type recently proposed by Garucclo and Selleri. The result, of the experiment. provide clear evidence against local realistic theories in which the probability of detection is postulated to be dependent on the angle between a polarization vector I. and a detection vector λ- The quantum mechanical predictions for such experiments, in which non-ideal analysers, were employed, have also been established and have been shown to be in agreement with the experimental results. In addition. the results of circular polarization \nmeasurements confirm the conservation of angular momentum along the common axis of detection and give further verification of the correctness of the form of the state vector describing the state of polarization of the two-photons. In another experiment, the effect of an electric field on the polarization properties of the two-photons has been measured for the first time. The Stoke's parameters characterizing the two-photon beam have been determined and the results suggest that the two-photon radiation is partially polarized at 22.5o with respect to the electric field vector. It is suggested that the affect is due to the removal of the degeneracy of the virtual Intermediate P states of the deuterium atom.
A 1-keV metastable atomic deuterium [D(2S)] beam of density about 104 atoms cm-3 has been produced by charge-exchange, in caesium vapour, of deuterons extracted from a radio-frequency ion source. The linear and circular polarisation correlation of the two photons emitted spontaneously by metastable atomic deuterium in a true second order radiative process have been measured for the first time. While the circular polarisation results confirm the conservation of angular momentum along the common axis of detection, the correlation in linear polarisation has been applied in a test of Bell’s Inequality which allows a quantitative distinction to be made between the predictions of Quantum Mechanics and local realistic ("hidden variable") theories. The results are in agreement with Quantum Mechanics and violate Bell’s Inequality by almost two standard deviations.
The Paper first summarizes fundamental aspects and results of the quantum electrodynamical theory of the two-photon radiationfromthe decay of the metastable 2 2 S 1/2 atomic hydrogen state. After a brief description of the second improved Stirling two-photon coincidence experiment polarization correlations of the two-photon decay are described in which both two or three linear polarizers are applied in order to test predictions of such correlations based upon quantum mechanics and local realistic theories (i.e., Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen type experiments). It is particularly noticeable that the three-polarizer coincidence measurement provided the largest difference (about 40%) between the Bell limits of local realistic theories and quantum mechanics so far. Apart from confirming in addition the correlations of right-right and left-left circularly polarized two-photon correlations a new type of coherence analysis of the two-photon radiation has been carried out experimentally and theoretically. A result of it is the measured coherence time of τ coh = 1.2 · 10 −15 s and coherence length of l coh = c · τ coh = 350 nm of the two-photon emission. By applying a theoretical model of the two-photon radiation linked to cascade transitions the coherence length can be estimated to l coh ≈ 100 nm in agreement by order of magnitude with the experimental data.
The latest experiment to test the predictions of quantum mechanics about the properties of photons has been carried out by an international group of scientists based at the University of Stirling (Haji-Hassan et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 62 237). By observing a source which emits pairs of photons 'back to back' using a battery of three linear polarisers (rather than the two which have been conventionally employed in previous experiments of this kind) the experimenters have been able to test a class of 'local realistic' theories which have been suggested as alternatives to quantum mechanics. The results of their measurements are in excellent agreement with the quantum predictions and render even more difficult the task of constructing a more realistic theory.