Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Quantum-classical correspondence and quantum chaos in the periodically kicked pendulum

Boon Leong Lan, Ronald F. Fox

Published Jan 1, 1991• 23 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The behavior of the periodically kicked pendulum is determined classically and quantum mechanically. Our earlier analytic study [Phys. Rev. A 41, 2952 (1990)] is confirmed and extended by the numerical results presented here. We are able to construct minimum uncertainty, Gaussian wave packets that maintain their form, and shadow the corresponding classical motion for long times when the classical motion is nonchaotic or only weakly chaotic. However, when the classical motion is robustly chaotic, the quantum-mechanical probability distribution grows macroscopically broad exponentially fast and the quantum-classical correspondence breaks down.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.43.646

Related papers

Chaos and the correspondence limit in the periodically kicked pendulum

Ronald F. Fox, Boon Leong Lan

The correspondence limit is illustrated for the periodically kicked pendulum. The classical dynamics of this system can be represented by a discrete map. A corresponding quantum map is derived and then rendered in the Ehrenfest formulation for expectation values. The Ehrenfest representation is studied for a minimum uncertainty Gaussian wave packet. It is shown that as \ensuremath{\Elzxh} gets very small, followed by a decrease in the variance of the wave packet, the quantum map shadows the classical map with an error approaching zero for a length of time approaching infinity. The Gaussian form of the wave packet is preserved by the time evolution provided ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{0}$T\ensuremath{\ll}1. This constraint implies that the classical map is predominantly not chaotic with very small regions of very weak chaos. As ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{0}$T approaches 1, where the classical map becomes strongly chaotic, the propagation in time of the Gaussian wave packet completely breaks down. The possible significance of this breakdown is discussed.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1990•21 citations

Wave-packet initial motion, spreading, and energy in the periodically kicked pendulum

Boon Leong Lan

The initial quantum dynamics of an initially well-localized, minimum-uncertainty Gaussian wave packet is studied analytically for the periodically kicked pendulum. The general results presented here include our earlier analytic result [Phys. Rev. A 41, 2952 (1990)] as a special case. We find that as long as the packet remains localized, it remains approximately Gaussian, while its center and widths evolve in time approximately according to, respectively, the classical map and a variance map which utilize the instantaneous values of the classical Jacobi matrix. When the classical map is very strongly chaotic, we predict that the average kinetic energy of the well-localized wave packet does not initially grow diffusively (linearly with time). We show that, instead, in the presence of chaos, the deviations initially grow, on the average, exponentially at a rate equal to the corresponding classical Liapunov exponent under the appropriate conditions. The time scale (Ehrenfest time) on which the Ehrenfest-Hamilton correspondence holds in the presence of chaos is estimated and is slightly different from a previous estimate made by Chirikov, Israilev, and Shepelyansky [Sov. Sci. Rev. C 2, 209 (1981)]. Numerical evidence in support of these analytical results is presented.

Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Aug 1, 1994•11 citations

Chaos and a quantum-classical correspondence in the kicked top

Ronald F. Fox, Timothy C. Elston

The problem ``what is the quantum signature of a classically chaotic system'' is studied for the periodically kicked top. We find that the quantum variances initially grow exponentially if the corresponding classical description is chaotic. The rate of growth is connected to the corresponding classical Jacobi matrix and, thereby, to the local, classical, transient expansion rate. These connections were recently established in an analysis of the kicked pendulum for the correspondence between quantum Husimi-O'Connell-Wigner distributions and classical Gaussian ensembles. Here, we present closely related results for the kicked top by using generalized coherent states. An explanation is given for why this quantum signature of classical chaos was missed in earlier studies of the kicked top.

Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Oct 1, 1994•41 citations

Quantum-classical correspondence in two simple systems

Bradley Clarke Hughes

In this thesis, a comparison between quantum and classical mechanics was made for two systems whose classical behaviour can be chaotic.The general correspondence between classical mechanics and quantum mechanics in the classical regime has always been assumed but never proved.Recent research in the field of quantum chaos has brought this assumption into question.For some systems, such as the kicked rotor in the classically chaotic regime, quantum mechanics does not display the classical behaviour of unbounded momentum.It has been suggested that quantum mechanics will fail to produce classical chaos for a broad range of simple systems.A comparison of quantum and classical mechanics was made using numerical simulations, without recourse to taking limits such as 7i going to zero.The two systems studied were a driven pendulum and a pair of pendula joined by a spring.The quantum and classical expectation values for a number of observables were computed, as were the probability distributions in phase space.For periodic motion of the driven pendulum it was found that the theories agreed well for times up to 150 driving periods.Similar agreement was found for initial conditions whose classical behaviour was chaotic, but only for times up to a few tens of driving periods.For longer times, it was found that the quantum system displayed a boundedness in position and/or momentum that was absent in the classical system.A possible explanation was given in terms of the quasienergy expansion.In the coupled-pendula system no such disagreements between the theories were found.I would like to thank Dr. Ballentine for his continued support during this project and his help in editing and revising this thesis.I would like to thank the members of my committee, Drs.Bechhoefer, Boa1 and Loss for their many suggestions.For many helpful discussions, I would like to thank Dominic Mimnagh and Jim Zibin.

•Jan 1, 1995•0 citations

Violation of the correspondence principle: Breakdown of the Bohm-Newton trajectory correspondence in a macroscopic system

Boon Leong Lan

The trajectory predicted by Bohm's quantum equation of motion, using an initially angle-localized minimum-uncertainty Gaussian wave packet, is compared with the trajectory predicted by Newton's classical equation of motion for a macroscopic periodically kicked pendulum system. We find that, in violation of the strong form of the correspondence principle, the Bohmian trajectory does not, in general, agree or correspond with the Newtonian trajectory for all times. The Bohm-Newton trajectory correspondence holds as long as the wave packet remains localized in angle. Delocalization of the wave packet in angle triggers the breakdown of the correspondence. The breakdown occurs exponentially quickly if either the Newtonian trajectory that initially coincides with the Bohmian trajectory or one of its classical neighbors is chaotic. In contrast, the breakdown occurs much slower if neither the Newtonian trajectory nor its neighbors are chaotic. These behaviors of the Bohm-Newton trajectory correspondence are generic, or universal, for the class of macroscopic Hamiltonian dynamical systems with bound coordinate space since the kick pendulum is a prototypical member. We predict that neither Bohm's equation of motion nor Newton's correctly predicts the experimentally observed and measured trajectory of a macroscopic system after the breakdown of the correspondence, implying that the all-times agreement required by the strong form of the correspondence principle is unnecessary.

Physical Review A•Feb 11, 2000•7 citations

Classical and quantum chaos for a kicked top

Giulio Casati, Boris V. Chirikov

We discuss a top undergoing constant precession around a magnetic field and suffering a periodic sequence of impulsive nonlinear kicks. The squared angular momentum being a constant of the motion the quantum dynamics takes place in a finite dimensional Hilbert space. We find a distinction between regular and irregular behavior for times exceeding the quantum mechanical quasiperiod at which classical behavior, whether chaotic or regular, has died out in quantum means. The degree of level repulsion depends on whether or not the top is endowed with a generalized time reversal invariance. Introduction The quantum treatment of systems capable of chaotic motion in the classical limit is interesting for several reasons. First, there is the desire to see how the classical distinguishability between regular and chaotic motion gradually arises as the system is turned more and more classical by changing a suitable parameter. By a controlled increase of quantum mechanical time scales such as wave packet spreading times or inverse level spacings, for instance, one would like to study the growth of the life time of effectively chaotic evolution of suitable observables. Perhaps an even greater incentive for quantum mechanical investigations lies in the question whether quantum chaos can be more than a mere transient mimicry of classical chaos. If so, we need intrinsically quantum mechanical criteria to distinguish regular an irregular behavior; the relation of such quantum criteria to the traditional ones for classical chaos would have to be clarified.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 27, 1995•1 citation
The behavior of the periodically kicked pendulum is determined classically and quantum mechanically. Our earlier analytic study [Phys. Rev. A 41, 2952 (1990)] is confirmed and extended by the numerical results presented here. We are able to construct minimum uncertainty, Gaussian wave packets that maintain their form, and shadow the corresponding classical motion for long times when the classical motion is nonchaotic or only weakly chaotic. However, when the classical motion is robustly chaotic, the quantum-mechanical probability distribution grows macroscopically broad exponentially fast and the quantum-classical correspondence breaks down.
The correspondence limit is illustrated for the periodically kicked pendulum. The classical dynamics of this system can be represented by a discrete map. A corresponding quantum map is derived and then rendered in the Ehrenfest formulation for expectation values. The Ehrenfest representation is studied for a minimum uncertainty Gaussian wave packet. It is shown that as \ensuremath{\Elzxh} gets very small, followed by a decrease in the variance of the wave packet, the quantum map shadows the classical map with an error approaching zero for a length of time approaching infinity. The Gaussian form of the wave packet is preserved by the time evolution provided ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{0}$T\ensuremath{\ll}1. This constraint implies that the classical map is predominantly not chaotic with very small regions of very weak chaos. As ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{0}$T approaches 1, where the classical map becomes strongly chaotic, the propagation in time of the Gaussian wave packet completely breaks down. The possible significance of this breakdown is discussed.
The initial quantum dynamics of an initially well-localized, minimum-uncertainty Gaussian wave packet is studied analytically for the periodically kicked pendulum. The general results presented here include our earlier analytic result [Phys. Rev. A 41, 2952 (1990)] as a special case. We find that as long as the packet remains localized, it remains approximately Gaussian, while its center and widths evolve in time approximately according to, respectively, the classical map and a variance map which utilize the instantaneous values of the classical Jacobi matrix. When the classical map is very strongly chaotic, we predict that the average kinetic energy of the well-localized wave packet does not initially grow diffusively (linearly with time). We show that, instead, in the presence of chaos, the deviations initially grow, on the average, exponentially at a rate equal to the corresponding classical Liapunov exponent under the appropriate conditions. The time scale (Ehrenfest time) on which the Ehrenfest-Hamilton correspondence holds in the presence of chaos is estimated and is slightly different from a previous estimate made by Chirikov, Israilev, and Shepelyansky [Sov. Sci. Rev. C 2, 209 (1981)]. Numerical evidence in support of these analytical results is presented.
The problem ``what is the quantum signature of a classically chaotic system'' is studied for the periodically kicked top. We find that the quantum variances initially grow exponentially if the corresponding classical description is chaotic. The rate of growth is connected to the corresponding classical Jacobi matrix and, thereby, to the local, classical, transient expansion rate. These connections were recently established in an analysis of the kicked pendulum for the correspondence between quantum Husimi-O'Connell-Wigner distributions and classical Gaussian ensembles. Here, we present closely related results for the kicked top by using generalized coherent states. An explanation is given for why this quantum signature of classical chaos was missed in earlier studies of the kicked top.
In this thesis, a comparison between quantum and classical mechanics was made for two systems whose classical behaviour can be chaotic.The general correspondence between classical mechanics and quantum mechanics in the classical regime has always been assumed but never proved.Recent research in the field of quantum chaos has brought this assumption into question.For some systems, such as the kicked rotor in the classically chaotic regime, quantum mechanics does not display the classical behaviour of unbounded momentum.It has been suggested that quantum mechanics will fail to produce classical chaos for a broad range of simple systems.A comparison of quantum and classical mechanics was made using numerical simulations, without recourse to taking limits such as 7i going to zero.The two systems studied were a driven pendulum and a pair of pendula joined by a spring.The quantum and classical expectation values for a number of observables were computed, as were the probability distributions in phase space.For periodic motion of the driven pendulum it was found that the theories agreed well for times up to 150 driving periods.Similar agreement was found for initial conditions whose classical behaviour was chaotic, but only for times up to a few tens of driving periods.For longer times, it was found that the quantum system displayed a boundedness in position and/or momentum that was absent in the classical system.A possible explanation was given in terms of the quasienergy expansion.In the coupled-pendula system no such disagreements between the theories were found.I would like to thank Dr. Ballentine for his continued support during this project and his help in editing and revising this thesis.I would like to thank the members of my committee, Drs.Bechhoefer, Boa1 and Loss for their many suggestions.For many helpful discussions, I would like to thank Dominic Mimnagh and Jim Zibin.
The trajectory predicted by Bohm's quantum equation of motion, using an initially angle-localized minimum-uncertainty Gaussian wave packet, is compared with the trajectory predicted by Newton's classical equation of motion for a macroscopic periodically kicked pendulum system. We find that, in violation of the strong form of the correspondence principle, the Bohmian trajectory does not, in general, agree or correspond with the Newtonian trajectory for all times. The Bohm-Newton trajectory correspondence holds as long as the wave packet remains localized in angle. Delocalization of the wave packet in angle triggers the breakdown of the correspondence. The breakdown occurs exponentially quickly if either the Newtonian trajectory that initially coincides with the Bohmian trajectory or one of its classical neighbors is chaotic. In contrast, the breakdown occurs much slower if neither the Newtonian trajectory nor its neighbors are chaotic. These behaviors of the Bohm-Newton trajectory correspondence are generic, or universal, for the class of macroscopic Hamiltonian dynamical systems with bound coordinate space since the kick pendulum is a prototypical member. We predict that neither Bohm's equation of motion nor Newton's correctly predicts the experimentally observed and measured trajectory of a macroscopic system after the breakdown of the correspondence, implying that the all-times agreement required by the strong form of the correspondence principle is unnecessary.
We discuss a top undergoing constant precession around a magnetic field and suffering a periodic sequence of impulsive nonlinear kicks. The squared angular momentum being a constant of the motion the quantum dynamics takes place in a finite dimensional Hilbert space. We find a distinction between regular and irregular behavior for times exceeding the quantum mechanical quasiperiod at which classical behavior, whether chaotic or regular, has died out in quantum means. The degree of level repulsion depends on whether or not the top is endowed with a generalized time reversal invariance. Introduction The quantum treatment of systems capable of chaotic motion in the classical limit is interesting for several reasons. First, there is the desire to see how the classical distinguishability between regular and chaotic motion gradually arises as the system is turned more and more classical by changing a suitable parameter. By a controlled increase of quantum mechanical time scales such as wave packet spreading times or inverse level spacings, for instance, one would like to study the growth of the life time of effectively chaotic evolution of suitable observables. Perhaps an even greater incentive for quantum mechanical investigations lies in the question whether quantum chaos can be more than a mere transient mimicry of classical chaos. If so, we need intrinsically quantum mechanical criteria to distinguish regular an irregular behavior; the relation of such quantum criteria to the traditional ones for classical chaos would have to be clarified.