Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Necessary and sufficient detector-efficiency conditions for the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger paradox

Jan-Åke Larsson

Published May 1, 1998• 32 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this paper detector efficiency conditions are derived for the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) paradox. The conditions will be necessary and sufficient, i.e., the GHZ paradox is explicable in terms of a local-variable model if the efficiency is below the bounds, and the GHZ prerequisites are inconsistent at higher efficiencies. The derivation does not make use of any of the symmetry assumptions usually made in the literature, most notably the assumption of independent errors. The errors in local-hidden-variable models are governed by the ``hidden variable'' and, therefore, one cannot in general assume that the errors are independent. It will be shown that this assumption is not necessary. Moreover, bounds are presented that do not need the emission rate of particle triples to be known. An example of such a bound is the ratio of the triple coincidence rate and the double coincidence rate at two detectors, which needs to be higher than 75% to yield a contradiction.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.57.r3145

Related papers

Detector efficiency in the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger paradox: Independent errors

Jan-Åke Larsson

The Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) paradox is subject to the detector-efficiency ``loophole'' in a similar manner as the Bell inequality. In a paper by J.-\AA{}. Larsson [Phys. Rev. A 57, R3145 (1998)], the issue is investigated for very general assumptions. Here, the assumptions of constant efficiency and independent errors will be imposed, and it will be shown that the necessary and sufficient efficiency bound is not lowered, but remains at $75%$. An explicit local-variable model is constructed in this paper to show the necessity of this bound. In other words, it is not possible to use the independence of experimental nondetection errors to rule out local realism in the GHZ paradox below $75%$ efficiency.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1999•13 citations

Solving the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger paradox: an explicit model of local hidden variables for the GHZ quantum state

David H. Oaknin

The Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox is widely regarded as a conclusive logical argument that rules out the possibility of describing quantum phenomena within the framework of any model of local hidden variables in which the observers are free to choose their own experimental settings. In this paper, we show, however, that the GHZ argument implicitly relies on a subtle, though crucial, assumption that is not required by fundamental physical principles, and which had gone unnoticed. Namely, we note that the argument implicitly assumes the existence of an absolute angular frame of reference with respect to which the polarization properties of the hypothetical hidden configurations of the entangled particles, as well as the orientations of the measurement devices that test them, can be defined. We further note that such an absolute frame of reference may not exist if the hidden configurations of the entangled particles spontaneously break the gauge rotational symmetry. Indeed, by skipping the disputed requirement we are able to build a model of local hidden variables for the GHZ state, which complies with the 'free-will' hypothesis and reproduces the quantum mechanical predictions. Our model, thus, completes-in the EPR sense-the quantum description of the GHZ state.

•Apr 22, 2022•0 citations

Solving the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger paradox: an explicitly local and realistic model of hidden variables for the GHZ quantum state

David H. Oaknin

The Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger~(GHZ) version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen~(EPR) paradox is widely regarded as a conclusive logical argument that rules out the possibility of describing quantum phenomena within the framework of a local and realistic model of hidden variables in which the observers are free to choose their own experimental settings. In this paper we show, however, that the GHZ argument implicitly relies on an additional crucial assumption, which is not required by fundamental physical principles and had gone unnoticed. Namely, we note that the argument implicitly assumes the existence of an absolute angular frame of reference with respect to which the polarization properties of the hypothetical hidden configurations of the entangled particles as well as the orientation of the measurement apparatus that test the system can be defined. We further note that such an absolute frame of reference would not exist if the hidden configurations of the entangled particles spontaneously break the gauge rotational symmetry. Indeed, by skipping this unnecessary additional assumption we are able to build an explicitly local and realistic model of hidden variables for the GHZ state, which complies with the 'free-will' hypothesis and reproduces the quantum mechanical predictions, and thus completes the description of the system in the EPR sense.

arXiv:1709.00167•Sep 1, 2017•1 citation

A local hidden-variable model for experimental tests of the GHZ puzzle

Brian R. La Cour

The Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) puzzle has been used to study quantum nonlocality and provide an all-or-nothing, no-go theorem for local hidden-variable models. Recent experiments using coincident-detected entangled photons prepared in a three-particle GHZ state have been used to test quantum nonlocality, but fail to rule out local realism due to a reliance on the fair-sampling hypothesis and insufficient detection efficiency. This paper describes a physically motivated local hidden-variable model based on amplitude-threshold detection that is capable of producing similar results. Detection efficiencies for the model are within the bounds permitted for local realism and, interestingly, exhibit statistical correlations between detectors, even when the detection events are spacelike separated. Increasing the detection threshold improves agreement with the ideal quantum predictions at the cost of decreased detection efficiency. A curious emergent feature of the model is that detection efficiencies may depend upon which observables are chosen for measurement.

arXiv:2104.14503•Quantum Studies Mathematics and Foundations•May 2, 2016•2 citations

Inequalities for Dealing with Detector Inefficiencies in Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger–Type Experiments

J. Acácio de Barros, Patrick Suppes

In this article we show that the three-particle Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger theorem can be reformulated in terms of inequalities, allowing imperfect correlations due to detector inefficiencies. We show quantitatively that taking into account these inefficiencies, the published results of the Innsbruck experiment support the nonexistence of local hidden variables that explain the experimental results.

arXiv:quant-ph/0001034•Physical Review Letters•Jan 31, 2000•65 citations

Stronger Nonlocality in GHZ States: A Step Beyond the Conventional GHZ Paradox

Ananya Chakraborty, Agarwal, Kunika, Sahil Gopalkrishna Naik +1 more

The Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) paradox, involving quantum systems with three or more subsystems, offers an 'all-vs-nothing' test of quantum nonlocality. Unlike Bell tests for bipartite systems, which reveal statistical contradictions, the GHZ paradox demonstrates a definitive (i.e. 100%) conflict between local hidden variable theories and quantum mechanics. Given this, how can the claim made in the title be justified? The key lies in recognising that GHZ games are typically played under a predefined promise condition for input distribution. By altering this promise, different GHZ games can be constructed. Here, we introduce a randomized variant of GHZ game, where the promise condition is randomly selected from multiple possibilities and revealed to only one of the parties chosen randomly. We demonstrate that this randomized GHZ paradox can also be perfectly resolved using a GHZ state, revealing a potentially stronger form of nonlocality than the original paradox. The claim of enhanced nonlocality is supported by its operational implications: correlations yielding perfect success in the randomized game offer a greater communication advantage than traditional GHZ correlations in a distributed multi-party communication complexity task.

arXiv:2409.14711•Sep 23, 2024•0 citations
In this paper detector efficiency conditions are derived for the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) paradox. The conditions will be necessary and sufficient, i.e., the GHZ paradox is explicable in terms of a local-variable model if the efficiency is below the bounds, and the GHZ prerequisites are inconsistent at higher efficiencies. The derivation does not make use of any of the symmetry assumptions usually made in the literature, most notably the assumption of independent errors. The errors in local-hidden-variable models are governed by the ``hidden variable'' and, therefore, one cannot in general assume that the errors are independent. It will be shown that this assumption is not necessary. Moreover, bounds are presented that do not need the emission rate of particle triples to be known. An example of such a bound is the ratio of the triple coincidence rate and the double coincidence rate at two detectors, which needs to be higher than 75% to yield a contradiction.
The Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) paradox is subject to the detector-efficiency ``loophole'' in a similar manner as the Bell inequality. In a paper by J.-\AA{}. Larsson [Phys. Rev. A 57, R3145 (1998)], the issue is investigated for very general assumptions. Here, the assumptions of constant efficiency and independent errors will be imposed, and it will be shown that the necessary and sufficient efficiency bound is not lowered, but remains at 7575%75. An explicit local-variable model is constructed in this paper to show the necessity of this bound. In other words, it is not possible to use the independence of experimental nondetection errors to rule out local realism in the GHZ paradox below 7575%75 efficiency.
The Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) paradox is widely regarded as a conclusive logical argument that rules out the possibility of describing quantum phenomena within the framework of any model of local hidden variables in which the observers are free to choose their own experimental settings. In this paper, we show, however, that the GHZ argument implicitly relies on a subtle, though crucial, assumption that is not required by fundamental physical principles, and which had gone unnoticed. Namely, we note that the argument implicitly assumes the existence of an absolute angular frame of reference with respect to which the polarization properties of the hypothetical hidden configurations of the entangled particles, as well as the orientations of the measurement devices that test them, can be defined. We further note that such an absolute frame of reference may not exist if the hidden configurations of the entangled particles spontaneously break the gauge rotational symmetry. Indeed, by skipping the disputed requirement we are able to build a model of local hidden variables for the GHZ state, which complies with the 'free-will' hypothesis and reproduces the quantum mechanical predictions. Our model, thus, completes-in the EPR sense-the quantum description of the GHZ state.
The Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger~(GHZ) version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen~(EPR) paradox is widely regarded as a conclusive logical argument that rules out the possibility of describing quantum phenomena within the framework of a local and realistic model of hidden variables in which the observers are free to choose their own experimental settings. In this paper we show, however, that the GHZ argument implicitly relies on an additional crucial assumption, which is not required by fundamental physical principles and had gone unnoticed. Namely, we note that the argument implicitly assumes the existence of an absolute angular frame of reference with respect to which the polarization properties of the hypothetical hidden configurations of the entangled particles as well as the orientation of the measurement apparatus that test the system can be defined. We further note that such an absolute frame of reference would not exist if the hidden configurations of the entangled particles spontaneously break the gauge rotational symmetry. Indeed, by skipping this unnecessary additional assumption we are able to build an explicitly local and realistic model of hidden variables for the GHZ state, which complies with the 'free-will' hypothesis and reproduces the quantum mechanical predictions, and thus completes the description of the system in the EPR sense.
The Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger (GHZ) puzzle has been used to study quantum nonlocality and provide an all-or-nothing, no-go theorem for local hidden-variable models. Recent experiments using coincident-detected entangled photons prepared in a three-particle GHZ state have been used to test quantum nonlocality, but fail to rule out local realism due to a reliance on the fair-sampling hypothesis and insufficient detection efficiency. This paper describes a physically motivated local hidden-variable model based on amplitude-threshold detection that is capable of producing similar results. Detection efficiencies for the model are within the bounds permitted for local realism and, interestingly, exhibit statistical correlations between detectors, even when the detection events are spacelike separated. Increasing the detection threshold improves agreement with the ideal quantum predictions at the cost of decreased detection efficiency. A curious emergent feature of the model is that detection efficiencies may depend upon which observables are chosen for measurement.
The Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) paradox, involving quantum systems with three or more subsystems, offers an 'all-vs-nothing' test of quantum nonlocality. Unlike Bell tests for bipartite systems, which reveal statistical contradictions, the GHZ paradox demonstrates a definitive (i.e. 100%) conflict between local hidden variable theories and quantum mechanics. Given this, how can the claim made in the title be justified? The key lies in recognising that GHZ games are typically played under a predefined promise condition for input distribution. By altering this promise, different GHZ games can be constructed. Here, we introduce a randomized variant of GHZ game, where the promise condition is randomly selected from multiple possibilities and revealed to only one of the parties chosen randomly. We demonstrate that this randomized GHZ paradox can also be perfectly resolved using a GHZ state, revealing a potentially stronger form of nonlocality than the original paradox. The claim of enhanced nonlocality is supported by its operational implications: correlations yielding perfect success in the randomized game offer a greater communication advantage than traditional GHZ correlations in a distributed multi-party communication complexity task.