Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Nature

Co-ordinate Operators in Quantum Mechanics

H. T. Flint

Published Jan 1, 1949• 3 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1038/163131a0

Related papers

The Operators of Quantum Mechanics

Philip Franklin

Studies in Applied Mathematics•Apr 1, 1929•1 citation

The quantum mechanics of the electron

H. T. Flint, E. Marjorie Williamson

Abstract This paper is concerned chiefly with the introduction of a co-ordinate operator in the quantum mechanics of the electron. It differs from other work on the same subject in the derivation, of the form of the operator by an analogy with the quantum expression for the angular momentum of the electron. Expressions for velocity and momentum operators are derived, and the relation between them is formally that of the classical theory in the absence of a field of force. By the introduction of reciprocal relations for the co-ordinate and momentum operators a condition is obtained which is applicable when the finite extension of the particle cannot be ignored. This is similar to the condition introduced by Yukawa in the theory of non-local fields. In the course of the development of the work, an explanation is offered of the significance of the fifth co-ordinate introduced in Kaluza’s theory of the gravitational and electromagnetic field and in Klein’s adaptation of it. Further, a new aspect of the question of the quantization of space and time is revealed by the use of co-ordinate operators (Xk), for it appears that the interest lies, not in a property of space-time, but in the quantization of localization of a particle. It should, however, be emphasized that the co-ordinates (xk) are retained with their usual meaning, but it is suggested that they are insufficient as a basis of a mechanical description of the electron. It is by operations upon (Xk) and not upon (xk) that mechanical quantities are obtained. The momentum (uk), like (xk), keeps its usual meaning, but it also is part of an operator (Mk) of wider significance. This is analogous to the case of the angular momentum of the electron where Dirac’s introduction of ‘spin’ shows that the orbital angular momentum is a part of a complete angular momentum operator. The application has been limited to the electron, because the derivation of the form of the operator (Xk) rests upon this analogy. The intention has not been to develop a calculus in which ordinary geometrical co-ordinates are replaced by operators. Finally, in proceeding to a force operator an additional term arises proportional to the derivative of the acceleration with respect to time. This term, which is usually ascribed to the reaction of the field of the electron, occurs here without reference to the self field, and suggests that, in addition to charge and current, a non-Maxwellian quantity must be considered as interacting with the external field.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences•Jul 6, 1951•2 citations

Operator approach to quantum mechanics

Graduate studies in mathematics•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

The density operator and applications

Brian P. Cowan

It is often inconvenient, for one reason or another, to keep track of all the variables of a complex system. For example, in a many-body system it would be impracticable to consider the co-ordinates of each particle. Furthermore, such information is actually not of much interest. Thus in a spin system the behaviour of the individual magnetic moments is unimportant; the components of the total magnetisation are the variables of primary interest. Very generally, for a system with ∼ 1023 co-ordinates, one is unlikely to need more than, say, ten variables to describe its observable properties. However, it is quite clear that this reduced amount of information is no longer sufficient to write down a wavefunction and, therefore, it is no longer possible to calculate the evolution of such a system using the usual methods of quantum mechanics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 17, 1997•0 citations

The quantum mechanics of non-holonomic systems

Richard J. Eden

Abstract Interactions of a non-holonomic type are fundamentally different from interactions which can be treated as part of the Hamiltonian of a system. They usually lead to constraints which do not commute with the Hamiltonian, and cause important alterations in the development of a state vector. This paper deals with the Heisenberg equations of motion by analogy with classical dynamics using the Poisson bracket formalism of a previous paper (Eden 1951). The Schrödinger equation is investigated in co-ordinate representation, and it is shown that the wave function will have a non-integrabie phase factor or quasi phase. The quasi phase leads to an indefiniteness in the wave function, but does not violate the fundamental laws of quantum mechanics nor lead to any ambiguity in the physical interpretation of the theory. The relation between the Schrödinger and the Heisenberg equations shows that the Schrödinger treatment is also consistent with the classical analogue. If there is a given initial probability that the non-holonomic system has co-ordinates q(0)r, then there will be the same probability that the wave function in the subsequent motion will be zero except in a certain region of co-ordinate space. This region is the part of co-ordinate space which is accessible in the classical theory from the point q(0)r.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences•Mar 7, 1951•29 citations

On Quantum Mechanical Operators in Generalized Coordinates

Gary R. Gruber

American Journal of Physics•Oct 1, 1972•6 citations
Abstract This paper is concerned chiefly with the introduction of a co-ordinate operator in the quantum mechanics of the electron. It differs from other work on the same subject in the derivation, of the form of the operator by an analogy with the quantum expression for the angular momentum of the electron. Expressions for velocity and momentum operators are derived, and the relation between them is formally that of the classical theory in the absence of a field of force. By the introduction of reciprocal relations for the co-ordinate and momentum operators a condition is obtained which is applicable when the finite extension of the particle cannot be ignored. This is similar to the condition introduced by Yukawa in the theory of non-local fields. In the course of the development of the work, an explanation is offered of the significance of the fifth co-ordinate introduced in Kaluza’s theory of the gravitational and electromagnetic field and in Klein’s adaptation of it. Further, a new aspect of the question of the quantization of space and time is revealed by the use of co-ordinate operators (Xk), for it appears that the interest lies, not in a property of space-time, but in the quantization of localization of a particle. It should, however, be emphasized that the co-ordinates (xk) are retained with their usual meaning, but it is suggested that they are insufficient as a basis of a mechanical description of the electron. It is by operations upon (Xk) and not upon (xk) that mechanical quantities are obtained. The momentum (uk), like (xk), keeps its usual meaning, but it also is part of an operator (Mk) of wider significance. This is analogous to the case of the angular momentum of the electron where Dirac’s introduction of ‘spin’ shows that the orbital angular momentum is a part of a complete angular momentum operator. The application has been limited to the electron, because the derivation of the form of the operator (Xk) rests upon this analogy. The intention has not been to develop a calculus in which ordinary geometrical co-ordinates are replaced by operators. Finally, in proceeding to a force operator an additional term arises proportional to the derivative of the acceleration with respect to time. This term, which is usually ascribed to the reaction of the field of the electron, occurs here without reference to the self field, and suggests that, in addition to charge and current, a non-Maxwellian quantity must be considered as interacting with the external field.
It is often inconvenient, for one reason or another, to keep track of all the variables of a complex system. For example, in a many-body system it would be impracticable to consider the co-ordinates of each particle. Furthermore, such information is actually not of much interest. Thus in a spin system the behaviour of the individual magnetic moments is unimportant; the components of the total magnetisation are the variables of primary interest. Very generally, for a system with ∼ 1023 co-ordinates, one is unlikely to need more than, say, ten variables to describe its observable properties. However, it is quite clear that this reduced amount of information is no longer sufficient to write down a wavefunction and, therefore, it is no longer possible to calculate the evolution of such a system using the usual methods of quantum mechanics.
Abstract Interactions of a non-holonomic type are fundamentally different from interactions which can be treated as part of the Hamiltonian of a system. They usually lead to constraints which do not commute with the Hamiltonian, and cause important alterations in the development of a state vector. This paper deals with the Heisenberg equations of motion by analogy with classical dynamics using the Poisson bracket formalism of a previous paper (Eden 1951). The Schrödinger equation is investigated in co-ordinate representation, and it is shown that the wave function will have a non-integrabie phase factor or quasi phase. The quasi phase leads to an indefiniteness in the wave function, but does not violate the fundamental laws of quantum mechanics nor lead to any ambiguity in the physical interpretation of the theory. The relation between the Schrödinger and the Heisenberg equations shows that the Schrödinger treatment is also consistent with the classical analogue. If there is a given initial probability that the non-holonomic system has co-ordinates q(0)r, then there will be the same probability that the wave function in the subsequent motion will be zero except in a certain region of co-ordinate space. This region is the part of co-ordinate space which is accessible in the classical theory from the point q(0)r.