Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Photon interference and correlation effects produced by independent quantum sources

L. Mandeļ

Published Aug 1, 1983• 183 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Interference effects produced by independent quantum sources are investigated, when the state of the field is not describable as a simple mixture of coherent states. The results of classical and quantum-mechanical calculations are compared. Whereas correlation effects are predicted both classically and quantum mechanically when the sources have random phases, there are important differences when the number of atoms is small. In particular, when each source consists of just one atom, the joint probability of detecting two photons at two different points in the receiving plane is found to vanish when the distance between them is an odd number of half fringes. Finally it is shown that when the number of atoms of each source is subject to Poisson fluctuations, one recovers the solution given by classical optics for thermal light, no matter how weak the sources may be on the average.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.28.929

Related papers

Interference and quantum effects in third-order spatial intensity correlations

Th. Richter

The joint probability of detecting simultaneously three photons at three different points in the superposition field of two independent plane waves with random phases is calculated and compared with the results of a classical wave theory. There are important differences when the number of photons is small. In particular, if there is one photon in one beam and two photons in the other one, three photodetectors can be placed at positions such that all three never respond at once, even though one beam intensity is two times stronger than the other.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1990•15 citations

Multi-Photon Interferences of Independent Light Sources

Steffen Oppel

In this thesis we discuss an extension of the historical Hanbury Brown and Twiss experiment and investigate spatial intensity correlations of higher-orders in the radiation field of statistically independent light sources. The light sources can be non-classical like single-photon emitters or classical, obeying thermal or coherent statistics. Although the light sources are assumed to emit the photons in an incoherent manner, we find spatial photon correlations in the far field which can be explained by the quantum mechanical concept of multi-photon interferences. We demonstrate that spatial correlation measurements between indistinguishable photons based on linear optical detection techniques can be used to overcome the resolution limit of classical optics (Abbe/Rayleigh limit) and also to manipulate the spatial radiation characteristic of the light sources. Both remarkable properties of higher-order intensity correlations have been experimentally verified using statistically independent pseudothermal light sources. Due to the fact that the reported correlation measurements require neither special quantum tailoring of light nor N-photon absorbing media, they are of particular interest for the field of quantum imaging and quantum information processing. The thesis is divided into three main parts: In the first part (Chapter 2 and 3) we introduce a quantum path formalism which allows to describe multi-photon interferences arising in both classical and nonclassical light fields. This quantum path approach explains the origin of the underlying interference mechanism of the higher-order spatial intensity correlation functions in a transparent and simple manner. Moreover, it enables us to compare the multi-photon interferences obtained by nonclassical single-photon emitters with those generated by classical light sources. In the course of this discussion it appears that Dirac's famous statement “Each photon interferes only with itself. Interference between two different photons never occurs.” should better read “A multi-photon state of independent photons only interferes with itself. Interference between different multi-photon states never occurs.” This general statement summarizes the physics behind all multi-photon interference phenomena investigated in this thesis. In the second part of the thesis (Chapter 4) we investigate particular multi-photon interference measurements of independent light sources in the context of quantum imaging. We demonstrate that the Nth-order spatial intensity correlation functions display at specific ‘magic’ detector positions the ability to filter sub-wavelength information out of the light fields arising from N incoherently radiating light sources. These multi-photon interference patterns achieve a higher resolution for N>2 than the classical Abbe/Rayleigh limit for imaging the light source. In case of N single-photon emitters we theoretically show that the super-resolving interference patterns obtained for the ‘magic’ detector positions are identical to the ones generated by NOON states with N-1 photons. Quite unexpected, the same is true for N thermal light sources, except for a reduced visibility. Experimental results with up to eight independent thermal light sources confirm this approach to improve the spatial resolution in imaging. In the last part of this thesis (Chapter 5) we finally demonstrate that multi-photon detections can lead to a strong angular focussing of incoherent photons emitted again by either uncorrelated single-photon sources or statistically independent classical light sources. For this effect the sources can be far away from each other and do not interact. The mth-order intensity correlation measurement causes source correlations which produce a heralded peaked emission pattern for the initially uncorrelated light sources. In particular, we show that if m-1 photons have been detected in a particular direction, the conditional probability to detect the mth photon in the same direction can be as high as 100 %. Owing to the great flexibility of detector positions for the correlation measurement, a wide variety of additional detection schemes exists which produces similar directional photon emission patterns. This theoretically predicted measurement-induced focussing was experimentally confirmed with up to eight pseudothermal light sources for three particular detection schemes.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Quantum Theory of Interference Effects Produced by Independent Light Beams

L. Mandeļ

The conditions are examined under which interference effects should be observable in the superposition of two light beams derived from independent sources. The quantum-mechanical description of these effects differs from the classical description principally in that it is necessarily based on expectation values of the light intensity at one or more space-time points. It is shown that pure states of the radiation field which are not energy states give rise to interference effects, but in that case the two beams cannot meaningfully be described as statistically independent. For a realistic description mixed states have to be introduced, when the expectation value of the intensity gives no indication of interference effects. On the other hand, the intensity correlation at two space-time points is a periodic function of the separation of the points and indicates the presence of transient interference effects. The effects become readily observable only when the average photon occupation number of each cell of phase space is appreciably greater than 1, and this explains why laser beams were needed for the experimental observations. It is pointed out that, even in these experiments, each photon may be regarded as interfering only with itself.

Physical Review•Apr 6, 1964•54 citations

Interference between independent photons

Henryk Paul

A comprehensive review is given of investigations, both theoretical and experimental, that demonstrate interference to take place even when the fields involved are produced by independent sources. The physical situation is rather different for coherent and incoherent fields. In the first case, where the sources are lasers, a conventional interference pattern can be observed which is adequately described by the classical theory. In the present paper, special attention is paid to the question of whether this interference persists when the two laser beams become strongly attenuated. In the second case, the sources are individual atoms excited by a pumping mechanism, that emit spontaneously and, hence, independently from each other. In those circumstances, no interference pattern can show up. However, it becomes evident from both the classical and the quantum-mechanical theory that interference effects can still be established by observing intensity correlations rather than the intensity itself. This point is discussed in greater detail. The pioneering experiments of Forrester, Gudmundson and Johnson, and Brown and Twiss are reviewed in this context. Especially interesting from the theoretical point of view is the case of two emitting atoms, since then the classical and the quantum-mechanical description differ significantly, the quantum theory predicting the intensity correlations to be distinctly stronger than those following from classical considerations. This specific quantum-mechanical feature is shown to be intimately connected with the corpuscular aspect of light.

Reviews of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 1986•147 citations

Interference an non-classical spatial intensity correlations

Tim Richter

The joint probability of simultaneously detecting four photons at at least two different points in the superposition field of two independent plane waves with random phases is calculated and compared with the results of a classical wave theory. There are important differences when the number of photons is small. In particular, if there is one photon in one beam and three photons in the other one, two two-photon detectors can be placed at positions such that they never both respond at the same time, even though the intensity of one beam is three times stronger than that of the other. This conclusion has no classical analogue.

Quantum Optics Journal of the European Optical Society Part B•Apr 1, 1991•7 citations

Experimental interference of uncorrelated photons

Heonoh Kim, Osung Kwon, Han Seb Moon

The distinguishing of the multiphoton quantum interference effect from the classical one forms one of the most important issues in modern quantum mechanics and experimental quantum optics. For a long time, the two-photon interference (TPI) of correlated photons has been recognized as a pure quantum effect that cannot be simulated with classical lights. In the meantime, experiments have been carried out to investigate the classical analogues of the TPI. In this study, we conduct TPI experiments with uncorrelated photons with different center frequencies from a luminescent light source, and we compare our results with the previous ones of correlated photons. The observed TPI fringe can be expressed in the form of three phase terms related to the individual single-photon and two-photon states, and the fringe pattern is strongly affected by the two single-photon-interference fringes and also by their visibilities. With the exception of essential differences such as valid and accidental coincidence events within a given resolving time and the two-photon spectral bandwidth, the interference phenomenon itself exhibits the same features for both correlated and uncorrelated photons in the single-photon counting regime.

arXiv:1911.05298•Scientific Reports•Dec 5, 2019•20 citations
Interference effects produced by independent quantum sources are investigated, when the state of the field is not describable as a simple mixture of coherent states. The results of classical and quantum-mechanical calculations are compared. Whereas correlation effects are predicted both classically and quantum mechanically when the sources have random phases, there are important differences when the number of atoms is small. In particular, when each source consists of just one atom, the joint probability of detecting two photons at two different points in the receiving plane is found to vanish when the distance between them is an odd number of half fringes. Finally it is shown that when the number of atoms of each source is subject to Poisson fluctuations, one recovers the solution given by classical optics for thermal light, no matter how weak the sources may be on the average.
The joint probability of detecting simultaneously three photons at three different points in the superposition field of two independent plane waves with random phases is calculated and compared with the results of a classical wave theory. There are important differences when the number of photons is small. In particular, if there is one photon in one beam and two photons in the other one, three photodetectors can be placed at positions such that all three never respond at once, even though one beam intensity is two times stronger than the other.
In this thesis we discuss an extension of the historical Hanbury Brown and Twiss experiment and investigate spatial intensity correlations of higher-orders in the radiation field of statistically independent light sources. The light sources can be non-classical like single-photon emitters or classical, obeying thermal or coherent statistics. Although the light sources are assumed to emit the photons in an incoherent manner, we find spatial photon correlations in the far field which can be explained by the quantum mechanical concept of multi-photon interferences. We demonstrate that spatial correlation measurements between indistinguishable photons based on linear optical detection techniques can be used to overcome the resolution limit of classical optics (Abbe/Rayleigh limit) and also to manipulate the spatial radiation characteristic of the light sources. Both remarkable properties of higher-order intensity correlations have been experimentally verified using statistically independent pseudothermal light sources. Due to the fact that the reported correlation measurements require neither special quantum tailoring of light nor N-photon absorbing media, they are of particular interest for the field of quantum imaging and quantum information processing. The thesis is divided into three main parts: In the first part (Chapter 2 and 3) we introduce a quantum path formalism which allows to describe multi-photon interferences arising in both classical and nonclassical light fields. This quantum path approach explains the origin of the underlying interference mechanism of the higher-order spatial intensity correlation functions in a transparent and simple manner. Moreover, it enables us to compare the multi-photon interferences obtained by nonclassical single-photon emitters with those generated by classical light sources. In the course of this discussion it appears that Dirac's famous statement “Each photon interferes only with itself. Interference between two different photons never occurs.” should better read “A multi-photon state of independent photons only interferes with itself. Interference between different multi-photon states never occurs.” This general statement summarizes the physics behind all multi-photon interference phenomena investigated in this thesis. In the second part of the thesis (Chapter 4) we investigate particular multi-photon interference measurements of independent light sources in the context of quantum imaging. We demonstrate that the Nth-order spatial intensity correlation functions display at specific ‘magic’ detector positions the ability to filter sub-wavelength information out of the light fields arising from N incoherently radiating light sources. These multi-photon interference patterns achieve a higher resolution for N>2 than the classical Abbe/Rayleigh limit for imaging the light source. In case of N single-photon emitters we theoretically show that the super-resolving interference patterns obtained for the ‘magic’ detector positions are identical to the ones generated by NOON states with N-1 photons. Quite unexpected, the same is true for N thermal light sources, except for a reduced visibility. Experimental results with up to eight independent thermal light sources confirm this approach to improve the spatial resolution in imaging. In the last part of this thesis (Chapter 5) we finally demonstrate that multi-photon detections can lead to a strong angular focussing of incoherent photons emitted again by either uncorrelated single-photon sources or statistically independent classical light sources. For this effect the sources can be far away from each other and do not interact. The mth-order intensity correlation measurement causes source correlations which produce a heralded peaked emission pattern for the initially uncorrelated light sources. In particular, we show that if m-1 photons have been detected in a particular direction, the conditional probability to detect the mth photon in the same direction can be as high as 100 %. Owing to the great flexibility of detector positions for the correlation measurement, a wide variety of additional detection schemes exists which produces similar directional photon emission patterns. This theoretically predicted measurement-induced focussing was experimentally confirmed with up to eight pseudothermal light sources for three particular detection schemes.
The conditions are examined under which interference effects should be observable in the superposition of two light beams derived from independent sources. The quantum-mechanical description of these effects differs from the classical description principally in that it is necessarily based on expectation values of the light intensity at one or more space-time points. It is shown that pure states of the radiation field which are not energy states give rise to interference effects, but in that case the two beams cannot meaningfully be described as statistically independent. For a realistic description mixed states have to be introduced, when the expectation value of the intensity gives no indication of interference effects. On the other hand, the intensity correlation at two space-time points is a periodic function of the separation of the points and indicates the presence of transient interference effects. The effects become readily observable only when the average photon occupation number of each cell of phase space is appreciably greater than 1, and this explains why laser beams were needed for the experimental observations. It is pointed out that, even in these experiments, each photon may be regarded as interfering only with itself.
A comprehensive review is given of investigations, both theoretical and experimental, that demonstrate interference to take place even when the fields involved are produced by independent sources. The physical situation is rather different for coherent and incoherent fields. In the first case, where the sources are lasers, a conventional interference pattern can be observed which is adequately described by the classical theory. In the present paper, special attention is paid to the question of whether this interference persists when the two laser beams become strongly attenuated. In the second case, the sources are individual atoms excited by a pumping mechanism, that emit spontaneously and, hence, independently from each other. In those circumstances, no interference pattern can show up. However, it becomes evident from both the classical and the quantum-mechanical theory that interference effects can still be established by observing intensity correlations rather than the intensity itself. This point is discussed in greater detail. The pioneering experiments of Forrester, Gudmundson and Johnson, and Brown and Twiss are reviewed in this context. Especially interesting from the theoretical point of view is the case of two emitting atoms, since then the classical and the quantum-mechanical description differ significantly, the quantum theory predicting the intensity correlations to be distinctly stronger than those following from classical considerations. This specific quantum-mechanical feature is shown to be intimately connected with the corpuscular aspect of light.
The joint probability of simultaneously detecting four photons at at least two different points in the superposition field of two independent plane waves with random phases is calculated and compared with the results of a classical wave theory. There are important differences when the number of photons is small. In particular, if there is one photon in one beam and three photons in the other one, two two-photon detectors can be placed at positions such that they never both respond at the same time, even though the intensity of one beam is three times stronger than that of the other. This conclusion has no classical analogue.
The distinguishing of the multiphoton quantum interference effect from the classical one forms one of the most important issues in modern quantum mechanics and experimental quantum optics. For a long time, the two-photon interference (TPI) of correlated photons has been recognized as a pure quantum effect that cannot be simulated with classical lights. In the meantime, experiments have been carried out to investigate the classical analogues of the TPI. In this study, we conduct TPI experiments with uncorrelated photons with different center frequencies from a luminescent light source, and we compare our results with the previous ones of correlated photons. The observed TPI fringe can be expressed in the form of three phase terms related to the individual single-photon and two-photon states, and the fringe pattern is strongly affected by the two single-photon-interference fringes and also by their visibilities. With the exception of essential differences such as valid and accidental coincidence events within a given resolving time and the two-photon spectral bandwidth, the interference phenomenon itself exhibits the same features for both correlated and uncorrelated photons in the single-photon counting regime.