Philosophy of Science

Chaos in a Model of an Open Quantum System

Frederick M. Kronz

Published Jan 1, 2000• 0 citations

Abstract

In a previous essay I argued that quantum chaos cannot be exhibited in models of quantum systems within von Neumann's mathematical framework for quantum mechanics, and that it can be exhibited in models within Dirac's formal framework. In this essay, the negative thesis concerning von Neumann's framework is elaborated further by extending it to the case of Hamiltonian operators having a continuous spectrum. The positive thesis concerning Dirac's formal framework is also elaborated further by constructing a chaotic model of an open quantum system in which an entropy measure is shown to approach its maximum value as time goes to infinity. Having such an entropy measure is a characteristic that is closely connected to chaotic behavior in phase space models of classical systems.

DOI: 10.1086/392837

Related papers

Nonseparability and Quantum Chaos

Frederick M. Kronz

Conventional wisdom currently has it that chaotic behavior is either strongly suppressed or absent in quantum models. Indeed, some researchers have concluded that these considerations serve to undermine the correspondence principle, thereby raising serious doubts about the adequacy of quantum mechanics as a fundamental physical theory. Thus, the quantum chaos question is a prime subject for philosophical analysis. The most significant reasons given for the absence or suppression of chaotic behavior in quantum models are the linearity of Schrödinger's equation and the unitarity of the time-evolution described by that equation. Both are shown in this essay to be irrelevant by demonstrating that the crucial feature for chaos is the nonseparability of the Hamiltonian. That demonstration indicates that quantum chaos is likely to be exhibited in models of open quantum systems. A measure for probing such models for chaotic behavior is developed, and then used to show that quantum mechanics has chaotic models for systems having a continuous energy spectrum. The prospects of this result for vindicating the essence of the correspondence principle are then briefly examined.

Philosophy of ScienceMar 1, 199814 citations

Quantum Chaos and Quantum Information: Interactions and Implications

Arul Lakshminarayan, Karol Życzkowski

The notion of Shannon entropy is crucial for the theory of classical information. In quantum information theory, an analogous key role is played by the von Neumann entropy: quantum information processing is closely related to entropy dynamics. This reveals a direct link with the theory of quantum chaotic systems, which can be characterized by a positive entropy production. Furthermore, noise, which inevitably affects any quantum system, can be modeled by a random quantum operation or by coupling to an environment in a generic chaotic state. In this contribution, we emphasize the universality of quantum chaotic dynamics and discuss its implications for quantum information processing.

quant-pharXiv:2604.12267Apr 15, 20260 citations

Quantum chaos: a decoherent definition

Zurek, W H, Paz, J P

We show that the rate of increase of von Neumann entropy computed from the reduced density matrix of an open quantum system is an excellent indicator of the dynamical behavior of its classical hamiltonian counterpart. In decohering quantum analogs of systems which exhibit classical hamiltonian chaos entropy production rate quickly tends to a constant which is given by the sum of the positive Lyapunov exponents, and falls off only as the system approaches equilibrium. By contrast, integrable systems tend to have entropy production rate which decreases as t^{-1} well before equilibrium is attained. Thus, behavior of quantum systems in contact with the environment can be used as a test to determine the nature of their hamiltonian evolution.

Jan 1, 199594 citations

Quantum Chaos and Quantum Randomness—Paradigms of Entropy Production on the Smallest Scales

Thomas Dittrich

Quantum chaos is presented as a paradigm of information processing by dynamical systems at the bottom of the range of phase-space scales. Starting with a brief review of classical chaos as entropy flow from micro- to macro-scales, I argue that quantum chaos came as an indispensable rectification, removing inconsistencies related to entropy in classical chaos: bottom-up information currents require an inexhaustible entropy production and a diverging information density in phase-space, reminiscent of Gibbs' paradox in statistical mechanics. It is shown how a mere discretization of the state space of classical models already entails phenomena similar to hallmarks of quantum chaos and how the unitary time evolution in a closed system directly implies the "quantum death" of classical chaos. As complementary evidence, I discuss quantum chaos under continuous measurement. Here, the two-way exchange of information with a macroscopic apparatus opens an inexhaustible source of entropy and lifts the limitations implied by unitary quantum dynamics in closed systems. The infiltration of fresh entropy restores permanent chaotic dynamics in observed quantum systems. Could other instances of stochasticity in quantum mechanics be interpreted in a similar guise? Where observed quantum systems generate randomness, could it result from an exchange of entropy with the macroscopic meter? This possibility is explored, presenting a model for spin measurement in a unitary setting and some preliminary analytical results based on it.

arXiv:1901.09845EntropyMar 15, 20196 citations

The emergence of chaos in continuously monitored open quantum systems

Jessica K. Eastman

This thesis makes a unique contribution to the field of quantum chaos by theoretically demonstrating the effect that measurement has on the emergence of chaos from the quantum world and demonstrating a means to control the onset of chaos in the quantum system using adaptive measurements. Here we investigate how the choice of the continuous measurement strategy for an open quantum system affects the emergence of chaos in the transition from the quantum limit to the classical limit when the system is dissipative. We consider two models in our research. The Duffing oscillator is classically chaotic and also dissipative( ie. an open quantum system), whereas the driven top is classically a closed system; adding dissipation via continuous measurement therefore changes the behaviour in from the classical limit. The first half of this thesis presents the investigation of a dissipative system whose classical limit is chaotic. We explore the emergence of chaos from the open quantum system that is continuously monitored and investigate the dependence on the choice of monitoring by changing a single parameter in a homodyne measurement scheme, effectively changing the information gained by the measurement. We show that the emergence of chaos in the regime where quantum effects are still present can be determined solely by changing the measurement parameter. This is a result of the interplay between the quantum interference effects induced by the nonlinear dynamics and the localisation and decoherence that occurs due to the measurement. We also investigate the case where the classical limit is regular for the Duffing oscillator, and demonstrate the semiclassical effect of chaos induced by the measurement back-action. A certain choice of measurement leads to a noise which drives the system to large spread in the dimensionless position enabling a non-classical transition mechanism that is classically forbidden, inducing chaos in the system. These results are verified by the numerical calculation of the maximal Lyapunov exponent in the quantum regime. The second part of this thesis investigates the possibility of controlling the degree of chaos with quantum control. We design an effective control scheme to control the degree of chaos using the measurement dependency of the state. We propose an adaptive measurement scheme which changes the homodyne measurement angle in real time depending on the direction of the state's interference fringes in phase space. This is done using the knowledge gained by the measurement signal. We show that this control scheme can enhance or suppress chaos. By enhancing the degree of chaos we are also able to push the onset of chaos further into the quantum regime than was possible before. By suppressing chaos we generate highly non-classical states and regular motion. The feasibility of experimentally realising this control technique is discussed in detail. The final section of this thesis considers a chaotic system that is not dissipative in the classical limit: the driven top. We investigate the effect that opening the quantum system to decoherence has on the degree of chaos when we continuously measure the system. We demonstrate that the presence of decoherence suppresses the chaos and alters the dynamics of the quantum system. This is seen to worsen as the strength of the measurement is increased unless a particular measurement is chosen that perfectly cancels out the decoherence resulting in the Hamiltonian evolution in addition to noise from the measurement. These results are verified by the separation time between classical and quantum dynamics.

Jan 1, 20200 citations

Quantum Entanglement Modeling in Chaos Dynamics

Jincheng Zhang

Quantum entanglement, a bizarre phenomenon in quantum mechanics, offers a unique perspective for modeling complex systems, particularly those exhibiting chaotic behavior. This paper explores the potential of utilizing quantum entanglement to represent and simulate the dynamics of chaotic systems, proposing a novel framework for investigating the fundamental mechanisms underlying chaos and stability. We delve into the implications of entanglement, focusing on its capacity to represent correlations beyond classical limits and provide a means for probing the underlying structure of chaotic systems. The work outlines the theoretical foundation of this approach, detailing the key mathematical concepts involved and illustrating its potential for advancing our understanding of chaos.

Aug 31, 20260 citations