Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Methodology, Theory and the Advance of Science

Brian D. Josephson

Published Jan 1, 2005• 0 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

A science (or a paradigm within a science) is a product of a particular way of approaching the problems of nature. This paper is concerned with the science behind the existence of paradigms: why do they exist, and what are the mechanics of change? Of particular interest is Bohr's question: does quantum mechanics encompass life or not, the answer being that it depends on how one wishes to interpret the question. An argument of Conrad et al. shows a way in which quantum mechanics might be inadequate, the argument being equally relevant in certain other contexts that are discussed.

Related papers

- Some Views of Science

David K. Ferry

In some sense, the concepts of Mach and Bohr discussed in the previous chapter are separated from the real world interactions in which we live our day to day lives. But then, are those considerations limited to an esoteric corner of science related merely to the philosophical interpretations of quantum mechanics? We will see that this question arises in a much more general discussion of a wide range of sciences, so it is certainly not limited to such an esoteric corner. In this chapter, I will explore these points a little further to illuminate how the question arises elsewhere. While this is certainly of interest, at least to me, some other observations which have appeared to me during the last half-century also will be discussed in this chapter. In some sense, these discussions may more likely be termed rants by me, but they have probably also occurred to others during this period.

•May 27, 2015•0 citations

Uncertain for a century: quantum mechanics and the dilemma of interpretation

Adam Frank

Quantum mechanics, the physical theory describing the microworld, is one of science's greatest triumphs. Remarkably, however, after more than 100 years it is still unclear what quantum mechanics means in terms of basic philosophical questions about the nature of reality. While there are many interpretations of the mathematical machinery of quantum physics, there remain no experimental means to distinguish between most of them. In this contribution, I wish to consider the ways in which the enduring lack of an agreed-upon interpretation of quantum physics influences a number of critical philosophical debates about physics and reality. I briefly review two problems affected by quantum interpretations: the meaning of the term universe and the nature of consciousness.

arXiv:1604.06488•Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences•Dec 1, 2015•6 citations

The Quantum Paradigm and Challenging the Objectivity Assumption

George Weissmann, Cynthia Sue Larson

Most interpretations of quantum theory fail to provide a fundamental, complete, self-consistent account of nature describing physical reality itself, as opposed to merely yielding predictions about results of experiments and observations. A paradigm providing a self-consistent foundation for quantum theory and a description of the reality it refers to, generalized to a worldview, is a Quantum Paradigm, where ‘paradigm' is defined as structure of experiential reality. We assert that the fundamental obstruction in the quest for a quantum paradigm is the assumption of objectivity. The subject-object distinction, drawn within experience, has within the natural sciences degenerated into a dichotomy-an absolute split into separate realms-with scientists adopting the classical paradigm where the object pole of experience ("objective reality") can be studied independently from the subject pole ("the experiencer"), with a presupposition that this procedure yields a fundamental description of nature. In fact, the subjective is often eliminated altogether as a fundamental category, and reduced to an epiphenomenon of objective processes. We claim this objectivity assumption precludes a full comprehension and a paradox-free formulation of quantum theory. By challenging this presupposition, i.e. leaving the question open, a coherent understanding of quantum nature falls naturally into place, providing appropriate foundation for quantum theory and an associated world-view. The resulting Quantum Paradigm is "realist" in the sense that it provides a description of what is actually happening: namely the arena of all happening is Mind or Consciousness-from which mind and matter, subject and object, individual and collective, and time and space co-dependently arise. The subject matter of quantum theory then becomes the fundamental mind-function of distinction ("measurement"), resulting in information and its statistical correlations. The message of quantum mechanics is surprising: the basic components of objects-the particles, electrons, quarks, etc.-cannot be thought of as ‘self-existent'. The reality that they, and hence all objects, are components of is ‘empirical reality', of experience."The universe begins to look more like a great thought than a great machine."-James Jeans Anomalous phenomena such as ESP and psychokinesis, collective consciousness, and synchronicity that are considered impossible in the context of the classical paradigm, fit naturally in, and can in turn provide evidence for the Quantum Paradigm. Spirituality and science are shown to be complementary approaches referring to the same reality, Mind, while each discipline retains its integrity. The Quantum Paradigm can be intellectually comprehended, as well as embodied: one can live in quantum reality. A good metaphor for this is "life as a dream": with no "real" objects as distinguished from experienced objects. Experience is "empty" of self-nature in the Buddhist sense, with everything interconnected and co-dependently arising. Experiencing the world by "embodying the Quantum Paradigm" is transformative, healing, and an antidote to alienation resulting from embodying the classical paradigm. Embodying the Quantum Paradigm and living in the Oneness of all creation can help humanity-increasingly lost in the materialism and individualism reinforced by our embodiment of the classical paradigm-and restore intimate connection and harmony with Spirit, Nature and fellow humans; we need such a transformation to survive and thrive in our technological society.

Cosmos and history•Mar 25, 2017•2 citations

Making better sense of quantum mechanics

N. David Mermin

We still lack any consensus about what one is actually talking about as one uses quantum mechanics. There is a gap between the abstract terms in which the theory is couched and the phenomena the theory enables each of us to account for so well. Because it has no practical consequences for how we each use quantum mechanics to deal with physical problems, this cognitive dissonance has managed to coexist with the quantum theory from the very beginning. The absence of conceptual clarity for almost a century suggests that the problem might lie in some implicit misconceptions about the nature of scientific explanation that are deeply held by virtually all physicists, but are rarely explicitly acknowledged. I describe here such unvoiced but widely shared assumptions. Rejecting them clarifies and unifies a range of obscure remarks about quantum mechanics made almost from the beginning by some of the giants of physics, many of whom are held to be in deep disagreement. This new view of physics requires physicists to think about science in an unfamiliar way. My primary purpose is to explain the new perspective and urge that it be taken seriously. My secondary aims are to explain why this perspective differs significantly from what Bohr, Heisenberg, and Pauli had been saying from the very beginning, and why it is not solipsism, as some have maintained. To emphasize that this is a general view of science, and not just of quantum mechanics, I apply it to a long-standing puzzle in classical physics: the apparent inability of physics to give any meaning to 'Now'-the present moment.

arXiv:1809.01639•Reports on Progress in Physics•Sep 20, 2018•71 citations

The Projection Postulate and Bohr's Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Paul Teller

Why does Bohr nowhere discuss the projection postulate? He has the courtesy to cast at least a few disparaging words at some other notions for which he has no use, such as quantum logic. But he will not even admit the projection postulate as a subject for discussion. Another way to raise the puzzle is to point out that, although Bohr has a lot to say about measurement, he won't even recognize the existence of what has come to be called the “problem of measurement”. I have exaggerated slightly. We have one relevant comment, in the report of the discussion after Bohr's talk at the 1938 Warsaw conference: Professor Bohr wished to say, relative to the question propounded by the president, that the duality he noticed in the interpretation of the formalism of quantum mechanics was, in his opinion, a question of choosing the most adequate description of the experiment.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1980•15 citations

A New Theory of Time and an Interpretations for Quantum Mecahnics

Mahmood Khotaba

It’s time to figure out time! We wish in this paper to answer what is time and how it works, as Einstein changed our whole idea about time, however, not even he answered this one question, which might seem of no importance, in answering it will change all of physics. This paper is bringing a whole new set of ideas, while one might think it is just about time, and that is the start and the original purpose of this paper, one will be shown that this paper will extend to much more beyond that, yielding some very excited and highly unexpected results, the paper will be based on a thought experiment, then going on to arguing and redefining what is time, by asking questions some are previously asked and others are not, then showing for starters how for instance the time dilation effect comes out naturally from this new definition of time both physically and mathematically, the paper then starts using its new ideas and applying it to some of the unsolved problems, however the biggest, unexpected, and most important result that will come out from this paper, The Detection Property, it will be shown how this property will lead not only to the interpretation of quantum mechanics, but a much more powerful effect will be produced, in that the detection property will even require the weird quantum behavior, it will be shown how one can start with simple classical world, and just by considering this new argument of time will be forced to introduce to it – in addition to special relativity - all the weird quantum behavior what will be most exciting about it, is that it will do so by the fact that all the phenomena of quantum mechanics like the measurement problem and Entanglement, and to go even further it will not only explain the phenomena of the Superposition and the wave function collapse, but it will even require its existence, this new definition of time along with the detection property will require that quantum mechanics behave in the way it does.

International Journal of Theoretical and Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations
A science (or a paradigm within a science) is a product of a particular way of approaching the problems of nature. This paper is concerned with the science behind the existence of paradigms: why do they exist, and what are the mechanics of change? Of particular interest is Bohr's question: does quantum mechanics encompass life or not, the answer being that it depends on how one wishes to interpret the question. An argument of Conrad et al. shows a way in which quantum mechanics might be inadequate, the argument being equally relevant in certain other contexts that are discussed.
In some sense, the concepts of Mach and Bohr discussed in the previous chapter are separated from the real world interactions in which we live our day to day lives. But then, are those considerations limited to an esoteric corner of science related merely to the philosophical interpretations of quantum mechanics? We will see that this question arises in a much more general discussion of a wide range of sciences, so it is certainly not limited to such an esoteric corner. In this chapter, I will explore these points a little further to illuminate how the question arises elsewhere. While this is certainly of interest, at least to me, some other observations which have appeared to me during the last half-century also will be discussed in this chapter. In some sense, these discussions may more likely be termed rants by me, but they have probably also occurred to others during this period.
Quantum mechanics, the physical theory describing the microworld, is one of science's greatest triumphs. Remarkably, however, after more than 100 years it is still unclear what quantum mechanics means in terms of basic philosophical questions about the nature of reality. While there are many interpretations of the mathematical machinery of quantum physics, there remain no experimental means to distinguish between most of them. In this contribution, I wish to consider the ways in which the enduring lack of an agreed-upon interpretation of quantum physics influences a number of critical philosophical debates about physics and reality. I briefly review two problems affected by quantum interpretations: the meaning of the term universe and the nature of consciousness.
Most interpretations of quantum theory fail to provide a fundamental, complete, self-consistent account of nature describing physical reality itself, as opposed to merely yielding predictions about results of experiments and observations. A paradigm providing a self-consistent foundation for quantum theory and a description of the reality it refers to, generalized to a worldview, is a Quantum Paradigm, where ‘paradigm' is defined as structure of experiential reality. We assert that the fundamental obstruction in the quest for a quantum paradigm is the assumption of objectivity. The subject-object distinction, drawn within experience, has within the natural sciences degenerated into a dichotomy-an absolute split into separate realms-with scientists adopting the classical paradigm where the object pole of experience ("objective reality") can be studied independently from the subject pole ("the experiencer"), with a presupposition that this procedure yields a fundamental description of nature. In fact, the subjective is often eliminated altogether as a fundamental category, and reduced to an epiphenomenon of objective processes. We claim this objectivity assumption precludes a full comprehension and a paradox-free formulation of quantum theory. By challenging this presupposition, i.e. leaving the question open, a coherent understanding of quantum nature falls naturally into place, providing appropriate foundation for quantum theory and an associated world-view. The resulting Quantum Paradigm is "realist" in the sense that it provides a description of what is actually happening: namely the arena of all happening is Mind or Consciousness-from which mind and matter, subject and object, individual and collective, and time and space co-dependently arise. The subject matter of quantum theory then becomes the fundamental mind-function of distinction ("measurement"), resulting in information and its statistical correlations. The message of quantum mechanics is surprising: the basic components of objects-the particles, electrons, quarks, etc.-cannot be thought of as ‘self-existent'. The reality that they, and hence all objects, are components of is ‘empirical reality', of experience."The universe begins to look more like a great thought than a great machine."-James Jeans Anomalous phenomena such as ESP and psychokinesis, collective consciousness, and synchronicity that are considered impossible in the context of the classical paradigm, fit naturally in, and can in turn provide evidence for the Quantum Paradigm. Spirituality and science are shown to be complementary approaches referring to the same reality, Mind, while each discipline retains its integrity. The Quantum Paradigm can be intellectually comprehended, as well as embodied: one can live in quantum reality. A good metaphor for this is "life as a dream": with no "real" objects as distinguished from experienced objects. Experience is "empty" of self-nature in the Buddhist sense, with everything interconnected and co-dependently arising. Experiencing the world by "embodying the Quantum Paradigm" is transformative, healing, and an antidote to alienation resulting from embodying the classical paradigm. Embodying the Quantum Paradigm and living in the Oneness of all creation can help humanity-increasingly lost in the materialism and individualism reinforced by our embodiment of the classical paradigm-and restore intimate connection and harmony with Spirit, Nature and fellow humans; we need such a transformation to survive and thrive in our technological society.
We still lack any consensus about what one is actually talking about as one uses quantum mechanics. There is a gap between the abstract terms in which the theory is couched and the phenomena the theory enables each of us to account for so well. Because it has no practical consequences for how we each use quantum mechanics to deal with physical problems, this cognitive dissonance has managed to coexist with the quantum theory from the very beginning. The absence of conceptual clarity for almost a century suggests that the problem might lie in some implicit misconceptions about the nature of scientific explanation that are deeply held by virtually all physicists, but are rarely explicitly acknowledged. I describe here such unvoiced but widely shared assumptions. Rejecting them clarifies and unifies a range of obscure remarks about quantum mechanics made almost from the beginning by some of the giants of physics, many of whom are held to be in deep disagreement. This new view of physics requires physicists to think about science in an unfamiliar way. My primary purpose is to explain the new perspective and urge that it be taken seriously. My secondary aims are to explain why this perspective differs significantly from what Bohr, Heisenberg, and Pauli had been saying from the very beginning, and why it is not solipsism, as some have maintained. To emphasize that this is a general view of science, and not just of quantum mechanics, I apply it to a long-standing puzzle in classical physics: the apparent inability of physics to give any meaning to 'Now'-the present moment.
Why does Bohr nowhere discuss the projection postulate? He has the courtesy to cast at least a few disparaging words at some other notions for which he has no use, such as quantum logic. But he will not even admit the projection postulate as a subject for discussion. Another way to raise the puzzle is to point out that, although Bohr has a lot to say about measurement, he won't even recognize the existence of what has come to be called the “problem of measurement”. I have exaggerated slightly. We have one relevant comment, in the report of the discussion after Bohr's talk at the 1938 Warsaw conference: Professor Bohr wished to say, relative to the question propounded by the president, that the duality he noticed in the interpretation of the formalism of quantum mechanics was, in his opinion, a question of choosing the most adequate description of the experiment.
It’s time to figure out time! We wish in this paper to answer what is time and how it works, as Einstein changed our whole idea about time, however, not even he answered this one question, which might seem of no importance, in answering it will change all of physics. This paper is bringing a whole new set of ideas, while one might think it is just about time, and that is the start and the original purpose of this paper, one will be shown that this paper will extend to much more beyond that, yielding some very excited and highly unexpected results, the paper will be based on a thought experiment, then going on to arguing and redefining what is time, by asking questions some are previously asked and others are not, then showing for starters how for instance the time dilation effect comes out naturally from this new definition of time both physically and mathematically, the paper then starts using its new ideas and applying it to some of the unsolved problems, however the biggest, unexpected, and most important result that will come out from this paper, The Detection Property, it will be shown how this property will lead not only to the interpretation of quantum mechanics, but a much more powerful effect will be produced, in that the detection property will even require the weird quantum behavior, it will be shown how one can start with simple classical world, and just by considering this new argument of time will be forced to introduce to it – in addition to special relativity - all the weird quantum behavior what will be most exciting about it, is that it will do so by the fact that all the phenomena of quantum mechanics like the measurement problem and Entanglement, and to go even further it will not only explain the phenomena of the Superposition and the wave function collapse, but it will even require its existence, this new definition of time along with the detection property will require that quantum mechanics behave in the way it does.