ACM Transactions on Sensor Networks

Efficient High-Rate Secret Key Extraction in Wireless Sensor Networks Using Collaboration

Sriram N. Premnath, Jessica Croft, Neal Patwari, Sneha Kumar Kasera

Published Jul 28, 2014• 23 citations

Abstract

Secret key establishment is a fundamental requirement for private communication between two entities. In this article, we propose and evaluate a new approach for secret key extraction where multiple sensors collaborate in exchanging probe packets and collecting channel measurements. Essentially, measurements from multiple channels have a substantially higher differential entropy compared to the measurements from a single channel, thereby resulting in more randomness in the information source for key extraction, and this in turn produces stronger secret keys. We also explore the fundamental trade-off between the quadratic increase in the number of measurements of the channels due to multiple nodes per group versus a linear reduction in the sampling rate and a linear increase in the time gap between bidirectional measurements. To experimentally evaluate collaborative secret key extraction in wireless sensor networks, we first build a simple yet flexible testbed with multiple TelosB sensor nodes. Next, we perform large-scale experiments with different configurations of collaboration. Our experiments show that in comparison to the 1 × 1 configuration, collaboration among sensor nodes significantly increases the secret bit extraction per second, per probe, as well as per millijoule of transmission energy. In addition, we show that the collaborating nodes can improve the performance further when they exploit both space and frequency diversities.

DOI: 10.1145/2541289

Related papers

Secret Key Extraction from Wireless Signal Strength in Real Environments

Sriram N. Premnath, Suman Jana, Jessica Croft +5 more

We evaluate the effectiveness of secret key extraction, for private communication between two wireless devices, from the received signal strength (RSS) variations on the wireless channel between the two devices. We use real world measurements of RSS in a variety of environments and settings. The results from our experiments with 802.11-based laptops show that in certain environments, due to lack of variations in the wireless channel, the extracted bits have very low entropy making these bits unsuitable for a secret key, an adversary can cause predictable key generation in these static environments, and in dynamic scenarios where the two devices are mobile, and/or where there is a significant movement in the environment, high entropy bits are obtained fairly quickly. Building on the strengths of existing secret key extraction approaches, we develop an environment adaptive secret key generation scheme that uses an adaptive lossy quantizer in conjunction with Cascade-based information reconciliation and privacy amplification. Our measurements show that our scheme, in comparison to the existing ones that we evaluate, performs the best in terms of generating high entropy bits at a high bit rate. The secret key bit streams generated by our scheme also pass the randomness tests of the NIST test suite that we conduct. We also build and evaluate the performance of secret key extraction using small, low-power, hand-held devices-Google Nexus One phones-that are equipped 802.11 wireless network cards. Last, we evaluate secret key extraction in a multiple input multiple output (MIMO)-like sensor network testbed that we create using multiple TelosB sensor nodes. We find that our MIMO-like sensor environment produces prohibitively high bit mismatch, which we address using an iterative distillation stage that we add to the key extraction process. Ultimately, we show that the secret key generation rate is increased when multiple sensors are involved in the key extraction process.

IEEE Transactions on Mobile ComputingMar 19, 2012297 citations

Secret key extraction in MIMO-like sensor networks using wireless signal strength

Sriram N. Premnath, Sneha Kumar Kasera, Neal Patwari

In this work, we evaluate the use of multiple sensors for secret key extraction. We find that the key generation rate increases linearly with the number of nodes. We show that the use of multiple nodes causes a significant mismatch in the extracted bits. We address the high bit mismatch problem by adding an iterative distillation stage to the key extraction process.

ACM SIGMOBILE Mobile Computing and Communications ReviewJul 22, 20103 citations

Enhancement of Physical Layer Security by Exploiting Channel Phase Randomness in Wireless Networks

Varshinee Krishnamurthy, Ranjiny Natarajan Kumar, Sivasankar Sundaram

A less expensive and more flexible solution to the problem of sharing secret keys between wireless nodes is to use the inherent randomness in the wireless channel between them as the source for extracting bits of the secret key between these nodes. We propose a new secret key distribution approach that utilizes the uniformly distributed phase information of channel responses to extract shared cryptographic keys under narrowband multipath fading models. Compared to existing approaches which only support pair wise key distribution, our scheme is highly scalable and can support efficient group key distribution. Various key distribution schemes are appraised to determine the level of security and connectivity. Simulated results show that key distribution exploiting channel phase has improved resilience against node capture. them as the source for extracting bits of the secret key between these nodes. Shared secret key distribution from channel measurements is an application which benefits from the randomnessof the multipath channel. It would not, for example, work in a truly free-space environment (such as deep space radio links). Secret sharing benefits from: • Reciprocity of the wireless radio channel: The multipath properties of the radio channel (gains, phase shifts, and delays) at any point in time and on any given frequency channel are identical on both directions of the link. • Temporal variations in the radio channel: Over time, the multipath channel changes due to movement of either end of the link, and any motion of people and objects in the environment near the link. An application may specifically request a user to move or shake the wireless device in order to generate more temporal variation. • Spatial variations: The properties of the radio channel are unique to the locations of the two endpoints of the link. An eavesdropper at a third location more than a few wavelengths from either endpoint will measure a different, uncorrelated radio channel. The proposed scheme is more flexible and can be applied in both static and mobile environments. Our scheme introduces phase randomness to bit distribution and removes the reliance on node mobility to obtain high entropy bits. We evaluate the proposed schemes through both analytical and simulation studies. The parameters of the scheme can be selected such that a desired level of key distribution accuracy and reliability is achieved with high efficiency.

International Journal of Future Computer and CommunicationJan 1, 20120 citations

Secret keys from entangled sensor motes

Matthias Wilhelm, Ivan Martinović, Jens Burkhard Schmitt

Key management in wireless sensor networks does not only face typical, but also several new challenges. The scale, resource limitations, and new threats such as node capture and compromise necessitate the use of an on-line key generation, where secret keys are generated by the nodes themselves. However, the cost of such schemes is high since their secrecy is based on computational complexity. Recently, several research contributions justified that the wireless channel itself can be used to generate information-theoretic secure keys between two parties. By exchanging sampling messages during movement, a bit string can be derived that is only known to the involved entities. Yet, movement is not the only possibility to generate randomness. The channel response is also strongly dependent on the frequency of the transmitted signal. In our work, we introduce a protocol for key generation based on the frequency-selectivity of channel fading. The great practical advantage of this approach is that we do not rely on node movement as the source of randomness. Thus, the frequent case of a sensor network with static motes is supported. Furthermore, the error correction property of the proposed protocol mitigates the effects of measurement errors and other temporal effects, giving rise to a key agreement rate of over 97%. We show the applicability of our protocol by implementing it on MICAz motes, and evaluate its robustness and secrecy through experiments and analysis.

Wireless Network SecurityMar 22, 201045 citations

Scalable Secret Key Generation for Wireless Sensor Networks

Ufuk Altun, Semiha Tedik Başaran, Güneş Karabulut Kurt +1 more

Future sensor networks require energy and bandwidth efficient designs to support the growing number of nodes. The security aspect is often neglected due to the extra computational burden imposed on the sensor nodes. In this article, we propose a secret key generation method for wireless sensor networks by using the physical layer features. This key generation method is based on the superposition property of wireless channels. The proposed method exploits the multiple access property of the wireless channel with simultaneous transmissions as in theanalog function computationtechnique to solve the latency and scarce bandwidth problems of highly populated dense networks. All nodes use the same time and frequency block to provide scalability that islinearly proportionalto the number of nodes. The proposed method also benefits from the network density to provide security against eavesdroppers that aim to sniff the secret key from the channel. The security of the proposed method against eavesdroppers is analytically studied. Moreover, their application in multiple layers is investigated. The presented results have shown that there is a tradeoff between the total power consumption and total used bandwidth for secret key generation. Lastly, the error probability of the generated keys due to thermal noise and channel estimation error is investigated with computer simulations and compared with broadcasting-based benchmark model.

IEEE Systems JournalAug 24, 202214 citations

Fast and scalable secret key generation exploiting channel phase randomness in wireless networks

Qian Wang, Hai Su, Kui Ren +1 more

Recently, there has been great interest in physical layer security techniques that exploit the randomness of wireless channels for securely extracting cryptographic keys. Several interesting approaches have been developed and demonstrated for their feasibility. The state-of-the-art, however, still has much room for improving their practicality. This is because i) the key bit generation rate supported by most existing approaches is very low which significantly limits their practical usage given the intermittent connectivity in mobile environments; ii) existing approaches suffer from the scalability and flexibility issues, i.e., they cannot be directly extended to support efficient group key generation and do not suit for static environments. With these observations in mind, we present a new secret key generation approach that utilizes the uniformly distributed phase information of channel responses to extract shared cryptographic keys under narrowband multipath fading models. The proposed approach enjoys a high key bit generation rate due to its efficient introduction of multiple randomized phase information within a single coherence time interval as the keying sources. The proposed approach also provides scalability and flexibility because it relies only on the transmission of periodical extensions of unmodulated sinusoidal beacons, which allows effective accumulation of channel phases across multiple nodes. The proposed scheme is thoroughly evaluated through both analytical and simulation studies. Compared to existing work that focus on pairwise key generation, our approach is highly scalable and can improve the analytical key bit generation rate by a couple of orders of magnitude.

IEEE Conference on Computer Communications (INFOCOM)Apr 1, 2011255 citations