Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences

Interferometry of the intensity fluctuations in light. II. An experimental test of the theory for partially coherent light

Robert Hanbury Brown, R. Q. Twiss

Published Jan 14, 1958• 263 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract A theoretical analysis is given of the correlation to be expected between the fluctuations in the outputs of two photoelectric detectors when these detectors are illuminated with partially coherent light. It is shown how this correlation depends upon the parameters of the equipment and upon the geometry of the experiment. The correlation may be detected either by linear multiplication of the fluctuations in the two outputs or by a coincidence counter which counts the simultaneous arrival of photons at the detectors. The theory is given for both these techniques and it is shown that they are closely equivalent. A laboratory test is described in which two photomultipliers were illuminated with partially coherent light and the correlation between the fluctuations in their outputs measured as a function of the degree of coherence. The results of this experiment are compared with the theory and it is shown that they agree within the limits of accuracy of the test; it is concluded that if there is any systematic error in the theory it is unlikely to exceed a few parts per cent.

DOI
10.1098/rspa.1958.0001

Related papers

Interferometry of the intensity fluctuations in light - I. Basic theory: the correlation between photons in coherent beams of radiation

Robert Hanbury Brown, R. Q. Twiss, givenName surName

Abstract It is shown by a quantum-mechanical treatment that the emission times of photoelectrons at different points illuminated by a plane wave of light are partially correlated, and identical results are obtained by a classical theory in which the photocathode is regarded as a square-law detector of suitable conversion efficiency. It is argued that the phenomenon exemplifies the wave rather than the particle aspect of light and that it may most easily be interpreted as a correlation between the intensity fluctuations at different points on a wavefront which arise because of interference between different frequency components of the light. From the point of view of the corpuscular picture the interpretation is much less straight­forward but it is shown that the correlation is directly related to the so-called bunching of photons which arises because light quanta are mutually indistinguishable and obey Bose-Einstein statistics. However, it is stressed that the use of the photon concept before the light energy is actually detected is highly misleading since, in an interference experiment, the electromagnetic field behaves in a manner which cannot be explained in terms of classical particles. The quantitative predictions of the theory have been confirmed by laboratory experi­ments and the phenomenon has been used, in an interferometer, to measure the apparent angular diameter of Sirius: these results, together with further applications to astronomy, will be discussed in detail in later papers. It is shown that the classical and quantum treatments give identical results when applied to find the fluctuations in the photoemission current produced by a single light beam, and the connexion between these fluctuations and the correlation between photons in coherent beams is pointed out. The results given here are in full agreement with those obtained by Kahn from an analysis based on quantum statistics: however, they differ from those derived on thermodynamical grounds by Fellgett and by Clark Jones and the reasons for this discrepancy are discussed.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences•Nov 5, 1957•429 citations

Fluctuations of Photon Beams and their Correlations

L. Mandeļ

The distribution of counts from a photoelectric detector illuminated by light of bandwidth Δν 0 is analysed by associating the photons with Gaussian random waves. This is shown to lead to a full statistical description of the counts. It is shown that the number n T in a time interval T << 1/Δν 0 obeys pure Bose-Einstein statistics, and that the fluctuations in longer intervals T >> 1/Δν 0 are simply the density fluctuations of a boson assembly in a phase space of ~ Δν 0 T cells. The correlation coefficient ρ of the fluctuations of counts from two detectors illuminated by partially coherent beams is found to be proportional to the local time average of the square of the coherence function ⟨γ 12 2 ⟩. The correlation is shown to depend on the degeneracy of the beams in such a way that ρ → 2⟨γ 12 2 ⟩ for highly degenerate beams. The results are all consistent with those obtained by Hanbury Brown and Twiss in 1957.

Proceedings of the Physical Society•Dec 1, 1958•390 citations

The Detection of Time-correlated Photons by a Coincidence Counter

R. Q. Twiss, A. G. Little

The existence of a correlation between the arrival times of photons has been confirmed by measurements with a coincidence counter having a resolving time of 3·5 X 10-9 sec in three different experiments. In the first experiment it was found that the number of coincidence counts recorded from two photomultipliers, the apertures of which were optically superimposed, was significantly greater than when the light beams were incoherent. Furthermore, the number of these correlated counts was in satisfactory agreement with that predicted by theory. In the second experiment the change in the number of excess coincidences was measured as the degree of coherence of the light was altered by increasing the apparent separation of the photocathodes, and in this case also there was reasonable agreement between theory and experiment. In the final experiment it was shown that there was a significant difference between the number of coincidences observed when the light beams were in identical as opposed to orthogonal polarizations, and this last result especially makes it extremely improbable that the correlation could be caused by some spurious effect, such as plasma oscillations in the source, since the light source itself was found to be completely unpolarized.

Australian Journal of Physics•Mar 1, 1959•37 citations

Some Recent Research on Coherence and Fluctuations of Light

A review is presented of various investigations on coherence and fluctuations of light which have been carried out within the last few years. In particular some of the research carried out at the University of Rochester and related investigations undertaken elsewhere are described. This research is mainly concerned with the following topics: classical and quantum description of higher order coherence effects, photon correlation and coincidence experiments, stellar correlation interferometry, photon bunching, and the determination of the statistical properties of light from photoelectric counting experiments.

Optica Acta International Journal of Optics•Oct 1, 1966•9 citations

Phenomenological Theory of Laser Beam Fluctuations and Beam Mixing

L. Mandeļ

The paper contains a quantum theoretical analysis of laser beam fluctuations and of the light beat experiments with two lasers. With the help of experimental results on photon counting fluctuations in a single-mode laser field, some correlation properties of the field are derived. It is shown that the correlation equations are satisfied by states of the field which are much more general than "coherent" states. The equations lead directly to the spectral density of the intensity operator in the light beat experiments, which can be obtained from photoelectric measurements. The resulting expression is practically identical to that found by Forrester for light having thermal statistical properties. The reasons for this are discussed by a comparison of the corresponding probability distributions of photon counts and of the classical wave amplitude.

Physical Review•May 10, 1965•32 citations

Fluctuations of Photon Beams: The Distribution of the Photo-Electrons

L. Mandeļ

The probability distribution p ( n , T ) of the number of counts n from a photoelectric detector illuminated by coherent light for a time T is studied, by associating photons stochastically with Gaussian random waves. The cumulants of the distribution are derived and it is shown to be of the expected form for a boson assembly in a limited volume of phase space. The distribution depends strongly on the degeneracy of the light beam. It approaches the Poisson form for classical particles at low degeneracies and the distribution characteristic of classical waves at high degeneracies. The analysis leads, incidentally, to an expression for the extent of the unit cell of phase space in the direction of the beam. It is argued that this should be adopted as the measure of coherence length.

Proceedings of the Physical Society•Sep 1, 1959•476 citations
Abstract A theoretical analysis is given of the correlation to be expected between the fluctuations in the outputs of two photoelectric detectors when these detectors are illuminated with partially coherent light. It is shown how this correlation depends upon the parameters of the equipment and upon the geometry of the experiment. The correlation may be detected either by linear multiplication of the fluctuations in the two outputs or by a coincidence counter which counts the simultaneous arrival of photons at the detectors. The theory is given for both these techniques and it is shown that they are closely equivalent. A laboratory test is described in which two photomultipliers were illuminated with partially coherent light and the correlation between the fluctuations in their outputs measured as a function of the degree of coherence. The results of this experiment are compared with the theory and it is shown that they agree within the limits of accuracy of the test; it is concluded that if there is any systematic error in the theory it is unlikely to exceed a few parts per cent.
Abstract It is shown by a quantum-mechanical treatment that the emission times of photoelectrons at different points illuminated by a plane wave of light are partially correlated, and identical results are obtained by a classical theory in which the photocathode is regarded as a square-law detector of suitable conversion efficiency. It is argued that the phenomenon exemplifies the wave rather than the particle aspect of light and that it may most easily be interpreted as a correlation between the intensity fluctuations at different points on a wavefront which arise because of interference between different frequency components of the light. From the point of view of the corpuscular picture the interpretation is much less straight­forward but it is shown that the correlation is directly related to the so-called bunching of photons which arises because light quanta are mutually indistinguishable and obey Bose-Einstein statistics. However, it is stressed that the use of the photon concept before the light energy is actually detected is highly misleading since, in an interference experiment, the electromagnetic field behaves in a manner which cannot be explained in terms of classical particles. The quantitative predictions of the theory have been confirmed by laboratory experi­ments and the phenomenon has been used, in an interferometer, to measure the apparent angular diameter of Sirius: these results, together with further applications to astronomy, will be discussed in detail in later papers. It is shown that the classical and quantum treatments give identical results when applied to find the fluctuations in the photoemission current produced by a single light beam, and the connexion between these fluctuations and the correlation between photons in coherent beams is pointed out. The results given here are in full agreement with those obtained by Kahn from an analysis based on quantum statistics: however, they differ from those derived on thermodynamical grounds by Fellgett and by Clark Jones and the reasons for this discrepancy are discussed.
The distribution of counts from a photoelectric detector illuminated by light of bandwidth Δν 0 is analysed by associating the photons with Gaussian random waves. This is shown to lead to a full statistical description of the counts. It is shown that the number n T in a time interval T << 1/Δν 0 obeys pure Bose-Einstein statistics, and that the fluctuations in longer intervals T >> 1/Δν 0 are simply the density fluctuations of a boson assembly in a phase space of ~ Δν 0 T cells. The correlation coefficient ρ of the fluctuations of counts from two detectors illuminated by partially coherent beams is found to be proportional to the local time average of the square of the coherence function ⟨γ 12 2 ⟩. The correlation is shown to depend on the degeneracy of the beams in such a way that ρ → 2⟨γ 12 2 ⟩ for highly degenerate beams. The results are all consistent with those obtained by Hanbury Brown and Twiss in 1957.
The existence of a correlation between the arrival times of photons has been confirmed by measurements with a coincidence counter having a resolving time of 3·5 X 10-9 sec in three different experiments. In the first experiment it was found that the number of coincidence counts recorded from two photomultipliers, the apertures of which were optically superimposed, was significantly greater than when the light beams were incoherent. Furthermore, the number of these correlated counts was in satisfactory agreement with that predicted by theory. In the second experiment the change in the number of excess coincidences was measured as the degree of coherence of the light was altered by increasing the apparent separation of the photocathodes, and in this case also there was reasonable agreement between theory and experiment. In the final experiment it was shown that there was a significant difference between the number of coincidences observed when the light beams were in identical as opposed to orthogonal polarizations, and this last result especially makes it extremely improbable that the correlation could be caused by some spurious effect, such as plasma oscillations in the source, since the light source itself was found to be completely unpolarized.
A review is presented of various investigations on coherence and fluctuations of light which have been carried out within the last few years. In particular some of the research carried out at the University of Rochester and related investigations undertaken elsewhere are described. This research is mainly concerned with the following topics: classical and quantum description of higher order coherence effects, photon correlation and coincidence experiments, stellar correlation interferometry, photon bunching, and the determination of the statistical properties of light from photoelectric counting experiments.
The paper contains a quantum theoretical analysis of laser beam fluctuations and of the light beat experiments with two lasers. With the help of experimental results on photon counting fluctuations in a single-mode laser field, some correlation properties of the field are derived. It is shown that the correlation equations are satisfied by states of the field which are much more general than "coherent" states. The equations lead directly to the spectral density of the intensity operator in the light beat experiments, which can be obtained from photoelectric measurements. The resulting expression is practically identical to that found by Forrester for light having thermal statistical properties. The reasons for this are discussed by a comparison of the corresponding probability distributions of photon counts and of the classical wave amplitude.
The probability distribution p ( n , T ) of the number of counts n from a photoelectric detector illuminated by coherent light for a time T is studied, by associating photons stochastically with Gaussian random waves. The cumulants of the distribution are derived and it is shown to be of the expected form for a boson assembly in a limited volume of phase space. The distribution depends strongly on the degeneracy of the light beam. It approaches the Poisson form for classical particles at low degeneracies and the distribution characteristic of classical waves at high degeneracies. The analysis leads, incidentally, to an expression for the extent of the unit cell of phase space in the direction of the beam. It is argued that this should be adopted as the measure of coherence length.