Physical review. B, Solid state

Chronospectroscopy of Exchange-Coupled Cr3+ -Ion Pairs in Ruby

Herbert L. Engstrom, L. F. Mollenauer

Published Feb 15, 1973• 22 citations

Abstract

A rather simple method of determining the lifetimes of the excited states of exchange-coupled ion pairs in ruby is described. The technique utilizes a chopped pump light and phasesensitive detection. It has permitted a great increase in the resolution of optical transitions, and in particular, it allows for a virtual elimination of the vibronic sidebands of the $R$ lines, in order that the true pair spectrum may stand out clearly. Furthermore, transitions originating from different excited levels may be definitely distinguished, thus aiding in the identification of particular transitions with a given pair type. The chronospectroscopic method is of potential value in the studies of energy-transfer mechanisms between single ions and pairs. It has also provided evidence for a fourth-neighbor absorption band at 6050 \AA{}.

DOI: 10.1103/physrevb.7.1616

Related papers

Cr3+ Ion Pair Spectrum in Ruby

Masayoshi Naitō

Journal of the Physical Society of JapanJun 1, 197333 citations

Absorption Spectrum of Optically Pumped Al2 O3 : Cr3+

Huang Jin, Henry W. Moos

Physical ReviewSep 10, 196822 citations

Fluorescence Studies of Energy Transfer between Single and Pair Cr3+ Systems in Al2 O3

Richard C. Powell, Baldassare Di Bartolo, Behzad Birang +1 more

Physical ReviewMar 10, 196764 citations

Absorption Spectrum of Optically Pumped Ruby I. Experimental Studies of Spectrum in Excited States

Takashi Kushida

Journal of the Physical Society of JapanJul 1, 196652 citations

On the effect of exchange interaction on the impurity ion optical spectrum

Anatoliy E. Nikiforov, V. I. Cherepanov

Abstract The method of effective Hamiltonian (EFH) is applied to the excited state (2E4A2) fine structure of Cr3+–Cr3+ fourth order pairs in ruby. Comparison with experimental data illustrates the importance of both the anisotropic and antisymmetric exchange interactions, and that part of isotropic exchange interaction, which is nondiagonal in the orbital variables. Various microscopical mechanisms responsible for terms in the effective Hamiltonian are discussed.

physica status solidi (b)Mar 1, 197110 citations

Fluorescence-line-narrowing and energy-transfer studies in ruby

Peter M. Selzer, David L. Huber, B. B. Barnett +1 more

Physical review. B, Condensed matterJun 15, 197891 citations

Physical review. B, Solid state

Chronospectroscopy of Exchange-Coupled Cr3+ -Ion Pairs in Ruby

Herbert L. Engstrom, L. F. Mollenauer

Published Feb 15, 1973• 22 citations

Publisher

Abstract

R

lines, in order that the true pair spectrum may stand out clearly. Furthermore, transitions originating from different excited levels may be definitely distinguished, thus aiding in the identification of particular transitions with a given pair type. The chronospectroscopic method is of potential value in the studies of energy-transfer mechanisms between single ions and pairs. It has also provided evidence for a fourth-neighbor absorption band at 6050 \AA{}.

DOI: 10.1103/physrevb.7.1616

Related papers

Cr3+ Ion Pair Spectrum in Ruby

Masayoshi Naitō

The optical spectrum due to the exchange coupled Cr 3+ ions in ruby has been studied theoretically. The effect of the lowering of the Cr 3+ site symmetry due to the formation of a pair was taken into account. For the 2nd neighbor pair, a good fitting of the excited state energies between theory and experiment was obtained. The effect of the higher order exchange is found to be very important for this pair. It is also found that the deviation of the Cr 3+ site symmetry from C 3 is rather large for this pair. For the 4th neighbor pair, the level diagram of the excited state was obtained and the absorption intensities were calculated. Most of the observed lines in this pair are explained by this theory. The lines so called N 1 and N 2 are found to be the transitions due to the exchange induced electric dipole.The optical spectrum due to the exchange coupled Cr 3+ ions in ruby has been studied theoretically. The effect of the lowering of the Cr 3+ site symmetry due to the formation of a pair was taken into account. For the 2nd neighbor pair, a good fitting of the excited state energies between theory and experiment was obtained. The effect of the higher order exchange is found to be very important for this pair. It is also found that the deviation of the Cr 3+ site symmetry from C 3 is rather large for this pair. For the 4th neighbor pair, the level diagram of the excited state was obtained and the absorption intensities were calculated. Most of the observed lines in this pair are explained by this theory. The lines so called N 1 and N 2 are found to be the transitions due to the exchange induced electric dipole.

Journal of the Physical Society of JapanJun 1, 197333 citations

Absorption Spectrum of Optically Pumped Al2 O3 : Cr3+

Huang Jin, Henry W. Moos

The absorption cross sections of the ${\mathrm{Cr}}^{3+}$ ion in the metastable states $^{2}E (\overline{E} \mathrm{and} 2\overline{A})$ of lightly doped ruby (\ensuremath{\sim}0.01%) have been measured as a function of polarization at temperatures of 30, 105, and 296\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{}K in the region from 2300 to 7000 \AA{}. The lifetime of these states was measured by observing the decay rate of the excited-state absorption, and agreed with the value of the measured fluorescence decay rate at various temperatures. The population of the excited states was measured by the change of the area under the first two vibronic sidebands at low temperatures. At room temperature the population was measured by the change of transmitted intensity of a ruby laser.The absorption cross sections of the ${\mathrm{Cr}}^{3+}$ ion in the metastable states $^{2}E (\overline{E} \mathrm{and} 2\overline{A})$ of lightly doped ruby (\ensuremath{\sim}0.01%) have been measured as a function of polarization at temperatures of 30, 105, and 296\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{}K in the region from 2300 to 7000 \AA{}. The lifetime of these states was measured by observing the decay rate of the excited-state absorption, and agreed with the value of the measured fluorescence decay rate at various temperatures. The population of the excited states was measured by the change of the area under the first two vibronic sidebands at low temperatures. At room temperature the population was measured by the change of transmitted intensity of a ruby laser.

Physical ReviewSep 10, 196822 citations

Fluorescence Studies of Energy Transfer between Single and Pair Cr3+ Systems in Al2 O3

Richard C. Powell, Baldassare Di Bartolo, Behzad Birang +1 more

The fluorescence intensities and lifetimes of various no-phonon lines in ruby samples with 2.1 and 0.94% ${\mathrm{Cr}}^{3+}$ were studied from 13 to 700\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{}K. The temperature dependences of the intensities of numerous lines were used to determine the energy levels of two pair systems. The relative intensities of the single-ion ( $R$ ) lines and the pair ( $N$ ) lines are proportional to Boltzmann factors ${e}^{\frac{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\Delta}E}{\mathrm{kT}}}$, where $\ensuremath{\Delta}E$ is the difference in energy of the metastable states, at high temperatures but not at low temperatures. The deviation from this law is greater and occurs at higher temperatures in the less concentrated sample. The fluorescence decays of the $R$ and $N$ lines are pure exponentials in the temperature region where the $N$ lines follow a Boltzmann law; at low temperatures the $N$ lines have an initial rise in fluorescence and then a decay. These results are interpreted in terms of coupled fluorescence systems consisting of single ions and pairs. A phonon-assisted cross-relaxation coupling process is suggested which allows for thermalization of the systems at high temperatures and direct pumping of the pair systems by the single-ion system at low temperatures. Energy transfer from single-ion to multi-ion systems was also observed.The fluorescence intensities and lifetimes of various no-phonon lines in ruby samples with 2.1 and 0.94% ${\mathrm{Cr}}^{3+}$ were studied from 13 to 700\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{}K. The temperature dependences of the intensities of numerous lines were used to determine the energy levels of two pair systems. The relative intensities of the single-ion ($R$) lines and the pair ($N$) lines are proportional to Boltzmann factors ${e}^{\frac{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\Delta}E}{\mathrm{kT}}}$, where $\ensuremath{\Delta}E$ is the difference in energy of the metastable states, at high temperatures but not at low temperatures. The deviation from this law is greater and occurs at higher temperatures in the less concentrated sample. The fluorescence decays of the $R$ and $N$ lines are pure exponentials in the temperature region where the $N$ lines follow a Boltzmann law; at low temperatures the $N$ lines have an initial rise in fluorescence and then a decay. These results are interpreted in terms of coupled fluorescence systems consisting of single ions and pairs. A phonon-assisted cross-relaxation coupling process is suggested which allows for thermalization of the systems at high temperatures and direct pumping of the pair systems by the single-ion system at low temperatures. Energy transfer from single-ion to multi-ion systems was also observed.

Physical ReviewMar 10, 196764 citations

Absorption Spectrum of Optically Pumped Ruby I. Experimental Studies of Spectrum in Excited States

Takashi Kushida

Absorption transitions between two excited optical states in ruby have been studied by comparing the absorption coefficients measured under optically pumped and unpumped conditions. The spectrum has been determined in the π-and σ-polarizations in the photon energy range from 5,500 to 45,000 cm -1 . Several absorption bands have been found which arise from the transitions from the excited states t 2g 3 2 E g and t 2g 3 2 T 1g of the Cr 3+ ion. From the locations and intensities of these bands, the terminal states of the observed transitions are assigned to the charge transfer state, the t 2g 3 2 T 2g state, and the doublet states belonging to the electron configuration t 2g 3 e g . Calculated energies between these states and the metastable states, t 2g 3 2 E g and t 2g 3 2 T 1g , are in good agreement with the peak energies of the observed absorption bands. The present experiment gives new information inaccessible by the ordinary ground state absorption measurement, such as the locations of several doublet states with the configuration t 2g 2 e g and the intensities of doublet-doublet transitions in ruby.Absorption transitions between two excited optical states in ruby have been studied by comparing the absorption coefficients measured under optically pumped and unpumped conditions. The spectrum has been determined in the π-and σ-polarizations in the photon energy range from 5,500 to 45,000 cm -1 . Several absorption bands have been found which arise from the transitions from the excited states t 2g 3 2 E g and t 2g 3 2 T 1g of the Cr 3+ ion. From the locations and intensities of these bands, the terminal states of the observed transitions are assigned to the charge transfer state, the t 2g 3 2 T 2g state, and the doublet states belonging to the electron configuration t 2g 3 e g . Calculated energies between these states and the metastable states, t 2g 3 2 E g and t 2g 3 2 T 1g , are in good agreement with the peak energies of the observed absorption bands. The present experiment gives new information inaccessible by the ordinary ground state absorption measurement, such as the locations of several doublet states with the configuration t 2g 2 e g and the intensities of doublet-doublet transitions in ruby.

Journal of the Physical Society of JapanJul 1, 196652 citations

On the effect of exchange interaction on the impurity ion optical spectrum

Anatoliy E. Nikiforov, V. I. Cherepanov

physica status solidi (b)Mar 1, 197110 citations

Fluorescence-line-narrowing and energy-transfer studies in ruby

Peter M. Selzer, David L. Huber, B. B. Barnett +1 more

Fluorescence-line-narrowing and time-resolved studies have been conducted in ruby crystals and powders, in concentrations varying from 0.025 to 0.9 at.%. The resonance fluorescence component of the ${R}_{1}$ line at low temperatures is observed to increase dramatically as the laser is tuned from line center toward the low-energy wing of the inhomogeneously broadened absorption. This is presumed to indicate the presence of weakly coupled pairs in the wings of the line. Intraline and interline (${R}_{1}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{N}_{1,2}$) energy transfer have also been studied, and an elaboration of earlier work is given. Time-resolved selective-excitation scans have revealed numerous channels in the vicinity of the $R$ lines by which the different pairs can be directly excited. These are assumed to be Cr ions near enough to a pair to be in a highly perturbed environment. Various experimental results are shown to be consistent with a model of rapid transfer between resonant Cr ions which feeds the pairs via a weak, nonresonant coupling to these perturbed ions. Macroscopic strain broadening is also shown to be favored over microscopic broadening, and the implications for Anderson localization in ruby are discussed.Fluorescence-line-narrowing and time-resolved studies have been conducted in ruby crystals and powders, in concentrations varying from 0.025 to 0.9 at.%. The resonance fluorescence component of the ${R}_{1}$ line at low temperatures is observed to increase dramatically as the laser is tuned from line center toward the low-energy wing of the inhomogeneously broadened absorption. This is presumed to indicate the presence of weakly coupled pairs in the wings of the line. Intraline and interline (${R}_{1}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{N}_{1,2}$) energy transfer have also been studied, and an elaboration of earlier work is given. Time-resolved selective-excitation scans have revealed numerous channels in the vicinity of the $R$ lines by which the different pairs can be directly excited. These are assumed to be Cr ions near enough to a pair to be in a highly perturbed environment. Various experimental results are shown to be consistent with a model of rapid transfer between resonant Cr ions which feeds the pairs via a weak, nonresonant coupling to these perturbed ions. Macroscopic strain broadening is also shown to be favored over microscopic broadening, and the implications for Anderson localization in ruby are discussed.

Physical review. B, Condensed matterJun 15, 197891 citations

R

The absorption cross sections of the

{\mathrm{Cr}}^{3+}

ion in the metastable states

^{2}E (\overline{E} \mathrm{and} 2\overline{A})

of lightly doped ruby (\ensuremath{\sim}0.01%) have been measured as a function of polarization at temperatures of 30, 105, and 296\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{}K in the region from 2300 to 7000 \AA{}. The lifetime of these states was measured by observing the decay rate of the excited-state absorption, and agreed with the value of the measured fluorescence decay rate at various temperatures. The population of the excited states was measured by the change of the area under the first two vibronic sidebands at low temperatures. At room temperature the population was measured by the change of transmitted intensity of a ruby laser.

The fluorescence intensities and lifetimes of various no-phonon lines in ruby samples with 2.1 and 0.94%

{\mathrm{Cr}}^{3+}

were studied from 13 to 700\ifmmode^\circ\else\textdegree\fi{}K. The temperature dependences of the intensities of numerous lines were used to determine the energy levels of two pair systems. The relative intensities of the single-ion (

R

) lines and the pair (

N

) lines are proportional to Boltzmann factors ${e}^{\frac{\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\Delta}E}{\mathrm{kT}}}$, where $\ensuremath{\Delta}E$ is the difference in energy of the metastable states, at high temperatures but not at low temperatures. The deviation from this law is greater and occurs at higher temperatures in the less concentrated sample. The fluorescence decays of the

R

and

N

lines are pure exponentials in the temperature region where the

N

lines follow a Boltzmann law; at low temperatures the

N

lines have an initial rise in fluorescence and then a decay. These results are interpreted in terms of coupled fluorescence systems consisting of single ions and pairs. A phonon-assisted cross-relaxation coupling process is suggested which allows for thermalization of the systems at high temperatures and direct pumping of the pair systems by the single-ion system at low temperatures. Energy transfer from single-ion to multi-ion systems was also observed.

Fluorescence-line-narrowing and time-resolved studies have been conducted in ruby crystals and powders, in concentrations varying from 0.025 to 0.9 at.%. The resonance fluorescence component of the

{R}_{1}

line at low temperatures is observed to increase dramatically as the laser is tuned from line center toward the low-energy wing of the inhomogeneously broadened absorption. This is presumed to indicate the presence of weakly coupled pairs in the wings of the line. Intraline and interline (${R}_{1}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}{N}_{1,2}$) energy transfer have also been studied, and an elaboration of earlier work is given. Time-resolved selective-excitation scans have revealed numerous channels in the vicinity of the

R

lines by which the different pairs can be directly excited. These are assumed to be Cr ions near enough to a pair to be in a highly perturbed environment. Various experimental results are shown to be consistent with a model of rapid transfer between resonant Cr ions which feeds the pairs via a weak, nonresonant coupling to these perturbed ions. Macroscopic strain broadening is also shown to be favored over microscopic broadening, and the implications for Anderson localization in ruby are discussed.