Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Nature

Science and the Unobservable

Herbert Dingle

Published May 1, 1938• 5 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1038/141878c0

Related papers

Experiment, time and theory : on the scientific exploration of the unobservable

J.A.M. Potters

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Popper’s Propensity Interpretation of Quantum Physics as a form of Modal Metaphysics

Basilis Dzelajei

With the emergence of quantum physics in the 1920s, the major philosophical question was, do the unobservables in quantum system have ontological status or are mere instruments for scientific prediction? The Copenhagen interpretation developed an instrumentalist thesis, contending that the unobservables are tools for making predictions concerning the observables. Thus, we cannot have knowledge of the quantum particles. However, Popper attempts a realist and an objective interpretation. As such, he criticizes the Copenhagen interpretation, developing the propensity view, which accords ontological status to subatomic particles. The main thrust of our argument in this paper is that by replacing probability possibilities with propensities, Popper positions himself as a proponent of the metaphysics of modality. It is then our objective to establish the parallelism between Popper’s Propensity Interpretation and Modal Metaphysics. To establish this contention we proceeded analytically: firstly by situating the seismic shift from macro to quantum physics, secondly by examining Popper’s critique of the Copenhagen Interpretation and thirdly by attempting a demonstration of the correlation between Popper’s propensity interpretation and modal metaphysics. The merit of this paper resides in its elucidation of the importance of metaphysics in science. It is a double challenge at the same time for antimetaphysical philosophy of science and for antiscientific metaphysics, to rethink the relationship between Metaphysics and science and invest in finding how both disciplines nurture each other. Finally, it is hoped that policy makers in Philosphy and science uses our findings to revamp the conceptualisation and practice of interdisciplinarity.

European Journal of Physical Sciences•Jul 10, 2023•0 citations

Reality and Other Sciences

Philip R. Wallace

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1996•0 citations

The hole argument and the nature of space-time: A critical review from a constructivist perspective

C. S. Unnikrishnan

This chapter examines the nature of physical reality in the context of unavoidable unobservables in physics. One of the features of science, especially physical science, is a powerful urge to construct theories of phenomena, instead of just cataloging and classifying phenomena and their spatio-temporal patterns. The concept of fields' of various kinds dominates physical theory and modern physics, and fields are essential to both classical and quantum theories. The concept of physical reality in the context of the Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR) assertion of the incompleteness of quantum mechanics is perhaps appropriate. Quantum theory of physical systems consisting of large number of particles led to the concept of a quantum field associated with the particles, a generalisation of the wave function itself. Space and time are supreme and primary unobservables in physics, without any reality independent of matter, notwithstanding their modern status as the dynamical arena of gravitational effects as described in Einstein's general theory of relativity.

Routledge eBooks•Jun 23, 2016•0 citations

Science and Philosophy

Bernard d’Espagnat

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1983•2 citations

Science, Common Sense and Decency

William P. D. Wightman

Nature•May 22, 1943•0 citations
With the emergence of quantum physics in the 1920s, the major philosophical question was, do the unobservables in quantum system have ontological status or are mere instruments for scientific prediction? The Copenhagen interpretation developed an instrumentalist thesis, contending that the unobservables are tools for making predictions concerning the observables. Thus, we cannot have knowledge of the quantum particles. However, Popper attempts a realist and an objective interpretation. As such, he criticizes the Copenhagen interpretation, developing the propensity view, which accords ontological status to subatomic particles. The main thrust of our argument in this paper is that by replacing probability possibilities with propensities, Popper positions himself as a proponent of the metaphysics of modality. It is then our objective to establish the parallelism between Popper’s Propensity Interpretation and Modal Metaphysics. To establish this contention we proceeded analytically: firstly by situating the seismic shift from macro to quantum physics, secondly by examining Popper’s critique of the Copenhagen Interpretation and thirdly by attempting a demonstration of the correlation between Popper’s propensity interpretation and modal metaphysics. The merit of this paper resides in its elucidation of the importance of metaphysics in science. It is a double challenge at the same time for antimetaphysical philosophy of science and for antiscientific metaphysics, to rethink the relationship between Metaphysics and science and invest in finding how both disciplines nurture each other. Finally, it is hoped that policy makers in Philosphy and science uses our findings to revamp the conceptualisation and practice of interdisciplinarity.
This chapter examines the nature of physical reality in the context of unavoidable unobservables in physics. One of the features of science, especially physical science, is a powerful urge to construct theories of phenomena, instead of just cataloging and classifying phenomena and their spatio-temporal patterns. The concept of fields' of various kinds dominates physical theory and modern physics, and fields are essential to both classical and quantum theories. The concept of physical reality in the context of the Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR) assertion of the incompleteness of quantum mechanics is perhaps appropriate. Quantum theory of physical systems consisting of large number of particles led to the concept of a quantum field associated with the particles, a generalisation of the wave function itself. Space and time are supreme and primary unobservables in physics, without any reality independent of matter, notwithstanding their modern status as the dynamical arena of gravitational effects as described in Einstein's general theory of relativity.