Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry

Symmetry adaptation and the relation between the spin‐free and space‐spin formulations of electronic structure

Daniel Klein, Antonio A. Cantú

Published Mar 1, 1974• 11 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract An information‐theoretic degree of symmetry adaptation of a ket with respect to a given group is introduced. Then the general equivalence between spin‐free electronic kets and antisymmetrized space‐spin kets is obtained so long as our attention is restricted to spin‐independent observables. It is noted that there are spin‐free kets for which there exists no single antisymmetrized space‐spin ket giving all the same expectation values; the converse is also noted.

DOI
10.1002/qua.560080209

Related papers

Spin‐free quantum electronic structure: Its second quantization and para‐Fermionics

Douglas J. Klein

Abstract First, the spin‐free formulation of electronic structure is reviewed within the standard first‐quantized framework, with special attention to its manner of correspondence to the standard antisymmetrized space‐spin (ASspin) formulation. Second, within this first‐quantized framework, note is made of some “discrepancies” in the correspondence, for example, regarding mismatches of symmetry‐related degeneracies. Third, a novel second‐quantized spin‐free formulation is introduced to overcome these “discrepancies,” and so achieve a one‐to‐one correspondence between ASspin wave functions and second‐quantized spin‐free wave functions. Yet further, this second‐quantized spin‐free description enables the identification of electrons as “para‐Fermions,” at least in the nonrelativistic limit of spin‐free interactions. From the point of view of elementary particle physics, a rather complete picture of the behavior of para‐Fermions emerges with electrons as a proxy, and so suggests that in fact para‐Fermions would be difficult to distinguish from ordinary Fermions, at least in this nonrelativistic limit or with but few such particles. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2011

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Dec 15, 2009•4 citations

Spin‐Free quantum chemistry. XVIII. The unitary group formulation of the many‐electron problem

F. A. Matsen

Abstract The representation of an N‐electron Schrödinger Hamiltonian on an orthonormal, spin‐free (freon) orbital product space is exactly modeled by a second‐degree polynomial in the infinitesimal generators of the unitary group. Symmetry adaptation of the orbital product space with respect to the symmetric group yields Gel'fand states which provide base for irreducible represntations of the unitary group. These exist in closed form as, in consequence, does the representation of the model Hamiltonian in this same basis. We retain as physical only those states characterized by tableaux with no more than two columns for which the spin labelling is one‐half the difference in the lengths of the two columns. The unitary group formulation is equivalent to standard, number‐conserving, second‐quantized, many‐body theory.

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•May 1, 1976•34 citations

Permutation-Algebraic Formulation of Spin-Free Transition Density Matrices

R. D. Poshusta, F. A. Matsen

Spin-free transition density matrices are derived from spin-free kets which are symmetry-adapted to the symmetric group and its algebra. The Dirac identity establishes that these spin-free density matrices are identical to those obtained by integrating the spin from the full-spin density martices. Derivations are first given for arbitrary primitive kets which may be geminals of higher polymals, after which we consider products of orbitals, either orthonormal or nonorthonormal. Correlation in the spin-free space is discussed and we show the influence of permutational symmetry on the probability of coincidence of pairs. A special case of this correlation is the well-known Fermi hole.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Apr 1, 1966•18 citations

Spin‐free quantum chemistry: What one can gain from fock's cyclic symmetry

Anatoliy V. Luzanov

Abstract The spin‐free wave function due to Fock (Zh Eksp Teor Fiz, 1940, 10, 961) is re‐examined with a stress on the reduced density matrix (RDM) theory. The key notion of the Fock approach is the cyclic symmetry of wave functions. It is a specific algebraic identity involving transpositions of numbers taken from two different columns of the corresponding Young tableau. We show first how to construct symmetry adapted states by accounting for high‐order cyclic symmetry conditions. For Young's projectors, it gives a new expression including nothing but antisymmetrizers. Next, transforming the Fock spin‐free state by a duality operator (the star operator in exterior algebra), we arrive at the representation closely related to spin‐flip models. In such spin‐flip models, a coupling operator is the basic object for which we show that the cyclic symmetry is transformed into a tracelessness of the coupling operator. The main results are related to the spin‐free theory of spin properties. In particular, the theorem previously stated (Luzanov and Whyman, Int J Quantum Chem, 1981, 20, 1179) is refined by an explicit general representation of spin density operators through spin‐free (charge) RDMs. Some applications implicating high‐order RDMs (collectivity numbers, the unpaired electron problem, cumulant spin RDMs, spin correlators, etc.) are also considered. For spin‐free RDM components, a new projection procedure without constructing any symmetry adapted state is proposed. An unsolved problem of constructing orthogonal representation matrices within the Fock theory is raised. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2010

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Dec 7, 2010•13 citations

What do kets represent?

Casey Blood

It is usually assumed that a ket represents the state of an actually existing particle. But one can show there is no evidence for particles. The particle-like properties of mass, spin and charge, as well as particle-like trajectories, the photoelectric effect, and localized effects from spread-out wave functions can be explained using quantum mechanics alone. It is therefore proposed instead that kets represent particle-like solutions to a pre-representational linear partial differential equation which has Poincaré and internal symmetries. This equation underlies the completely representational character, including mass, spin, charge, internal symmetries, and symmetric and antisymmetric statistics, of current quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1310.1295•Oct 4, 2013•0 citations

The first two moments of energy level distributions in N-electron spin-adapted model spaces

Jacek Karwowski, M. Bancewicz

Formulae are derived for the average value and for the dispersion of the spectrum of an electronic Hamiltonian in a finite-dimensional, antisymmetric and spin-adapted space. Both the moments are expressed in terms of the corresponding two-electron quantities. The derivation is based on the theory of spin-adapted reduced Hamiltonians.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Dec 21, 1987•31 citations
Abstract An information‐theoretic degree of symmetry adaptation of a ket with respect to a given group is introduced. Then the general equivalence between spin‐free electronic kets and antisymmetrized space‐spin kets is obtained so long as our attention is restricted to spin‐independent observables. It is noted that there are spin‐free kets for which there exists no single antisymmetrized space‐spin ket giving all the same expectation values; the converse is also noted.
Abstract First, the spin‐free formulation of electronic structure is reviewed within the standard first‐quantized framework, with special attention to its manner of correspondence to the standard antisymmetrized space‐spin (ASspin) formulation. Second, within this first‐quantized framework, note is made of some “discrepancies” in the correspondence, for example, regarding mismatches of symmetry‐related degeneracies. Third, a novel second‐quantized spin‐free formulation is introduced to overcome these “discrepancies,” and so achieve a one‐to‐one correspondence between ASspin wave functions and second‐quantized spin‐free wave functions. Yet further, this second‐quantized spin‐free description enables the identification of electrons as “para‐Fermions,” at least in the nonrelativistic limit of spin‐free interactions. From the point of view of elementary particle physics, a rather complete picture of the behavior of para‐Fermions emerges with electrons as a proxy, and so suggests that in fact para‐Fermions would be difficult to distinguish from ordinary Fermions, at least in this nonrelativistic limit or with but few such particles. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2011
Abstract The representation of an N‐electron Schrödinger Hamiltonian on an orthonormal, spin‐free (freon) orbital product space is exactly modeled by a second‐degree polynomial in the infinitesimal generators of the unitary group. Symmetry adaptation of the orbital product space with respect to the symmetric group yields Gel'fand states which provide base for irreducible represntations of the unitary group. These exist in closed form as, in consequence, does the representation of the model Hamiltonian in this same basis. We retain as physical only those states characterized by tableaux with no more than two columns for which the spin labelling is one‐half the difference in the lengths of the two columns. The unitary group formulation is equivalent to standard, number‐conserving, second‐quantized, many‐body theory.
Spin-free transition density matrices are derived from spin-free kets which are symmetry-adapted to the symmetric group and its algebra. The Dirac identity establishes that these spin-free density matrices are identical to those obtained by integrating the spin from the full-spin density martices. Derivations are first given for arbitrary primitive kets which may be geminals of higher polymals, after which we consider products of orbitals, either orthonormal or nonorthonormal. Correlation in the spin-free space is discussed and we show the influence of permutational symmetry on the probability of coincidence of pairs. A special case of this correlation is the well-known Fermi hole.
Abstract The spin‐free wave function due to Fock (Zh Eksp Teor Fiz, 1940, 10, 961) is re‐examined with a stress on the reduced density matrix (RDM) theory. The key notion of the Fock approach is the cyclic symmetry of wave functions. It is a specific algebraic identity involving transpositions of numbers taken from two different columns of the corresponding Young tableau. We show first how to construct symmetry adapted states by accounting for high‐order cyclic symmetry conditions. For Young's projectors, it gives a new expression including nothing but antisymmetrizers. Next, transforming the Fock spin‐free state by a duality operator (the star operator in exterior algebra), we arrive at the representation closely related to spin‐flip models. In such spin‐flip models, a coupling operator is the basic object for which we show that the cyclic symmetry is transformed into a tracelessness of the coupling operator. The main results are related to the spin‐free theory of spin properties. In particular, the theorem previously stated (Luzanov and Whyman, Int J Quantum Chem, 1981, 20, 1179) is refined by an explicit general representation of spin density operators through spin‐free (charge) RDMs. Some applications implicating high‐order RDMs (collectivity numbers, the unpaired electron problem, cumulant spin RDMs, spin correlators, etc.) are also considered. For spin‐free RDM components, a new projection procedure without constructing any symmetry adapted state is proposed. An unsolved problem of constructing orthogonal representation matrices within the Fock theory is raised. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2010
It is usually assumed that a ket represents the state of an actually existing particle. But one can show there is no evidence for particles. The particle-like properties of mass, spin and charge, as well as particle-like trajectories, the photoelectric effect, and localized effects from spread-out wave functions can be explained using quantum mechanics alone. It is therefore proposed instead that kets represent particle-like solutions to a pre-representational linear partial differential equation which has Poincaré and internal symmetries. This equation underlies the completely representational character, including mass, spin, charge, internal symmetries, and symmetric and antisymmetric statistics, of current quantum mechanics.