Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics

Physical-resource requirements and the power of quantum computation

Carlton M. Caves, Ivan Deutsch, Robin Blume-Kohout

Published Jul 28, 2004• 9 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The primary resource for quantum computation is the Hilbert-space dimension. Whereas Hilbert space itself is an abstract construction, the number of dimensions available to a system is a physical quantity that requires physical resources. Avoiding a demand for an exponential amount of these resources places a fundamental constraint on the systems that are suitable for scalable quantum computation. To be scalable, the number of degrees of freedom in the computer must grow nearly linearly with the number of qubits in an equivalent qubit-based quantum computer. These considerations rule out quantum computers based on a single particle, a single atom, or a single molecule consisting of a fixed number of atoms or on classical waves manipulated using the transformations of linear optics.

DOI
10.1088/1464-4266/6/8/027

Related papers

Physical-resource demands for scalable quantum computation

Carlton M. Caves, Ivan Deutsch, Robin Blume-Kohout

The primary resource for quantum computation is Hilbert-space dimension. Whereas Hilbert space itself is an abstract construction, the number of dimensions available to a system is a physical quantity that requires physical resources. Avoiding a demand for an exponential amount of these resources places a fundamental constraint on the systems that are suitable for scalable quantum computation. To be scalable, the number of degrees of freedom in the computer must grow nearly linearly with the number of qubits in an equivalent qubit-based quantum computer.

arXiv:quant-ph/0304083•Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•May 16, 2003•4 citations

Climbing mount scalable: Physical resource requirements for a scalable quantum computer

Robin Blume-Kohout, Carlton M. Caves, Ivan Deutsch

The primary resource for quantum computation is Hilbert-space dimension. Whereas Hilbert space itself is an abstract construction, the number of dimensions available to a system is a physical quantity that requires physical resources. Avoiding a demand for an exponential amount of these resources places a fundamental constraint on the systems that are suitable for scalable quantum computation. To be scalable, the effective number of degrees of freedom in the computer must grow nearly linearly with the number of qubits in an equivalent qubit-based quantum computer. KEY WORDS: quantum information; quantum computation; entanglement; quantum mechanics; scalability.

•Jan 1, 2002•70 citations

Quantum Computing Systems: A Brief Overview

Waranont Anukool, Jongseok Lim, Yunheung Song +1 more

A classical simulation of quantum systems demands enormous computational resources. The dimension of underlying Hilbert space scales exponentially with the number of participating elements ( N ), requiring a 2 2N size of calculation matrix for a unitary operation, for example, 2 100 ≈ 10 30 for only N = 50. With the increase of N , the first obstacle to encounter is in fact the deficiency of computer memories. A straightforward resolution is to use a quantum computer, a calculating device that operates with the principle of quantum mechanics. During the last twenty years, quantum computing once considered as theoretical exercise has become an important field of research in modern physics. At the forefront of quantum information technology, quantum computing has emerged as a new engineering field with broad interest not only in physics but also in computer science, electronics engineering, and mathematics.

Journal of the Korean Physical Society•Sep 1, 2018•7 citations

Basic principles of quantum computing

Santeri Huhtanen

Quantum mechanics has proven its position as the primary theory for accurately describing microscopic domains. Numerous fields in physics utilize quantum mechanics to great effects, with one prominent application being quantum computing. Quantum computing extends the field of quantum mechanics to information theory, striving to perform computational tasks utilizing quantum phenomena with notably greater efficiency compared to classical alternatives. In this thesis, I will go through the basics required in the field of quantum computing. To understand quantum computing demands adapting a new type of matrix mechanical view. This involves considering Hilbert spaces, which are linear vector space having a well defined inner product. Hilbert spaces contain state vectors describing quantum states, as well as operators for altering and measuring these states. The dynamics of quantum systems are governed by three quantum postulates. These specify Hilbert spaces and state vectors as the fundamental components of quantum systems, Hermitian operators as providing the physical manifestation of these systems, and finally, the Schrödinger's equation to describe the time evolution of such systems. These notions are required in producing quantum computing. Quantum computing uses qubits as the computational basis, analogous to classical bits but with the added capability of quantum superposition. Qubits are represented as two-state vectors, and can be physically realized with any quantum-behaving binary-valued system, like the electron spins. Qubits can be combined into higher dimensional states with the use of tensor products, causing the system's Hilbert space to expand as 2^n with n being the number of qubits, allowing for exponential computational speedup. Computational logic can be constructed by acting on the qubits using unitary operators, known as quantum gates. The combinations of qubits and quantum gates can be visualized as quantum circuits, depicted using specialized circuit diagram notations. An essential part of quantum computing, and the phenomena enabling exponential computational speedup, is quantum entanglement. Entanglement arises in interacting qubits, intertwining them so that the individual states become correlated. Entanglement can be characterized by being unable to reduce a combined state into its pure constituents. The amount of entanglement in a system can be measured using von Neumann entropy, analogous to Shannon entropy in classical information theory. Entanglement serves various purposes in quantum computing and is a defining feature distinguishing it from the classical domain. In this thesis, the entanglement properties of a periodic four-qubit circuit with alternating quantum gates were simulated. The simulation was performed computationally, and measured entanglement entropy as a function of the amount of circuit periods. The results demonstrated different characteristics of entanglement depending on the parameters used for the quantum gates, with the entanglement either being periodic, non-occurring or chaotic in nature.

•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Hilbert space as a computational resource in reservoir computing

William D. Kalfus, Guilhem J. Ribeill, Graham E. Rowlands +3 more

Accelerating computation with quantum resources is limited by the challenges of high-fidelity control of quantum systems. Reservoir computing presents an attractive alternative, as precise control and full calibration of system dynamics are not required. Instead, complex internal trajectories in a large state space are leveraged as a computational resource. Quantum systems offer a unique venue for reservoir computing, given the presence of interactions unavailable in classical systems and a potentially exponentially-larger computational space. With a reservoir comprised of a single $d$-dimensional quantum system, we demonstrate clear performance improvement with Hilbert space dimension at two benchmark tasks and advantage over the physically analogous classical reservoir. Quantum reservoirs as realized by current-era quantum hardware offer immediate practical implementation and a promising outlook for increased performance in larger systems.

Physical Review Research•Jul 5, 2022•31 citations

How big is a quantum computer?

Sascha Wallentowitz, Ian A. Walmsley, Joseph H. Eberly

Accounting for resources is the central issue in computational efficiency. We point out physical constraints implicit in information readout that have been overlooked in classical computing. The basic particle-counting mode of read-out sets a lower bound on the resources needed to implement a quantum computer. As a consequence, computers based on classical waves are as efficient as those based on single quantum particles.

arXiv:quant-ph/0009069•Sep 17, 2000•3 citations
The primary resource for quantum computation is the Hilbert-space dimension. Whereas Hilbert space itself is an abstract construction, the number of dimensions available to a system is a physical quantity that requires physical resources. Avoiding a demand for an exponential amount of these resources places a fundamental constraint on the systems that are suitable for scalable quantum computation. To be scalable, the number of degrees of freedom in the computer must grow nearly linearly with the number of qubits in an equivalent qubit-based quantum computer. These considerations rule out quantum computers based on a single particle, a single atom, or a single molecule consisting of a fixed number of atoms or on classical waves manipulated using the transformations of linear optics.
The primary resource for quantum computation is Hilbert-space dimension. Whereas Hilbert space itself is an abstract construction, the number of dimensions available to a system is a physical quantity that requires physical resources. Avoiding a demand for an exponential amount of these resources places a fundamental constraint on the systems that are suitable for scalable quantum computation. To be scalable, the number of degrees of freedom in the computer must grow nearly linearly with the number of qubits in an equivalent qubit-based quantum computer.
The primary resource for quantum computation is Hilbert-space dimension. Whereas Hilbert space itself is an abstract construction, the number of dimensions available to a system is a physical quantity that requires physical resources. Avoiding a demand for an exponential amount of these resources places a fundamental constraint on the systems that are suitable for scalable quantum computation. To be scalable, the effective number of degrees of freedom in the computer must grow nearly linearly with the number of qubits in an equivalent qubit-based quantum computer. KEY WORDS: quantum information; quantum computation; entanglement; quantum mechanics; scalability.
A classical simulation of quantum systems demands enormous computational resources. The dimension of underlying Hilbert space scales exponentially with the number of participating elements ( N ), requiring a 2 2N size of calculation matrix for a unitary operation, for example, 2 100 ≈ 10 30 for only N = 50. With the increase of N , the first obstacle to encounter is in fact the deficiency of computer memories. A straightforward resolution is to use a quantum computer, a calculating device that operates with the principle of quantum mechanics. During the last twenty years, quantum computing once considered as theoretical exercise has become an important field of research in modern physics. At the forefront of quantum information technology, quantum computing has emerged as a new engineering field with broad interest not only in physics but also in computer science, electronics engineering, and mathematics.
Quantum mechanics has proven its position as the primary theory for accurately describing microscopic domains. Numerous fields in physics utilize quantum mechanics to great effects, with one prominent application being quantum computing. Quantum computing extends the field of quantum mechanics to information theory, striving to perform computational tasks utilizing quantum phenomena with notably greater efficiency compared to classical alternatives. In this thesis, I will go through the basics required in the field of quantum computing. To understand quantum computing demands adapting a new type of matrix mechanical view. This involves considering Hilbert spaces, which are linear vector space having a well defined inner product. Hilbert spaces contain state vectors describing quantum states, as well as operators for altering and measuring these states. The dynamics of quantum systems are governed by three quantum postulates. These specify Hilbert spaces and state vectors as the fundamental components of quantum systems, Hermitian operators as providing the physical manifestation of these systems, and finally, the Schrödinger's equation to describe the time evolution of such systems. These notions are required in producing quantum computing. Quantum computing uses qubits as the computational basis, analogous to classical bits but with the added capability of quantum superposition. Qubits are represented as two-state vectors, and can be physically realized with any quantum-behaving binary-valued system, like the electron spins. Qubits can be combined into higher dimensional states with the use of tensor products, causing the system's Hilbert space to expand as 2^n with n being the number of qubits, allowing for exponential computational speedup. Computational logic can be constructed by acting on the qubits using unitary operators, known as quantum gates. The combinations of qubits and quantum gates can be visualized as quantum circuits, depicted using specialized circuit diagram notations. An essential part of quantum computing, and the phenomena enabling exponential computational speedup, is quantum entanglement. Entanglement arises in interacting qubits, intertwining them so that the individual states become correlated. Entanglement can be characterized by being unable to reduce a combined state into its pure constituents. The amount of entanglement in a system can be measured using von Neumann entropy, analogous to Shannon entropy in classical information theory. Entanglement serves various purposes in quantum computing and is a defining feature distinguishing it from the classical domain. In this thesis, the entanglement properties of a periodic four-qubit circuit with alternating quantum gates were simulated. The simulation was performed computationally, and measured entanglement entropy as a function of the amount of circuit periods. The results demonstrated different characteristics of entanglement depending on the parameters used for the quantum gates, with the entanglement either being periodic, non-occurring or chaotic in nature.
Accelerating computation with quantum resources is limited by the challenges of high-fidelity control of quantum systems. Reservoir computing presents an attractive alternative, as precise control and full calibration of system dynamics are not required. Instead, complex internal trajectories in a large state space are leveraged as a computational resource. Quantum systems offer a unique venue for reservoir computing, given the presence of interactions unavailable in classical systems and a potentially exponentially-larger computational space. With a reservoir comprised of a single ddd-dimensional quantum system, we demonstrate clear performance improvement with Hilbert space dimension at two benchmark tasks and advantage over the physically analogous classical reservoir. Quantum reservoirs as realized by current-era quantum hardware offer immediate practical implementation and a promising outlook for increased performance in larger systems.