Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

AIP conference proceedings

Causal Analysis of the Quantum States

Sergey M. Korotaev, Evgeniy O. Kiktenko, Richard L. Amoroso, Peter Rowlands, Stanley Jeffers

Published Jan 1, 2010• 8 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We suggest quantum generalization of the method of causal analysis used before only for the classical variables. The causality parameters for the series of examples of two‐qubit entangled states are computed. The results are compared with the concurrence and degree of mixedness of the states. The role of state asymmetry in quantum information transfer is shown. For the qubits under nonuniformity external magnetic field the nontrivial role of this nonuniformity for subsystem causal connection has been studied. At last quantum causal analysis helps to understand Cramer principle of week causality which admits extraction of information from the future without the classical paradoxes.

DOI
10.1063/1.3536443

Related papers

Причинность в квантовых запутанных состояниях

Коротаев Сергей Маратович, Evgeniy O. Kiktenko

The application of a new method of the quantum cause-and-effect analysis, where causality is determined without reference to a delay, for entangled states is considered. This helps to understand the Cramer's weak-causality principle llowing for time reverse in entangled states. It is found that the finite causality an exist only in mixed asymmetric entangled states. The causality parameters are computed for a series of three-qubit entangled states. Results are compared with measures of mixedness and entanglement. For the simplest cases, the formal measure of causality is not inconsistent with intuitive representations. However when a situation is somewhat complicated, the intuition may bring to an incorrect result, whereas the cause-and-effect analysis demonstrates a nontrivial role of the tate asymmetry in transfer of quantum information. Refs. 19. Figs. 9.

Вестник Московского государственного технического университета им. Н.Э. Баумана. Серия «Естественные науки»•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Quantum Causality

Sergey M. Korotaev, Evgeniy O. Kiktenko

The quantum extension of causal analysis has shown a rich picture of the subsystem causal connections, where the usual intuitive approach is hampered more commonly. The direction of causal connection is determined by the direction of irreversible information flow, and the measure of this connection, called the course of time c 2 , is determined as the velocity of such flow. The absence of causality corresponds to infinite c 2 , accordingly the degree of causal connection is inversely related to c 2 . This formal definition of causality is valid at any time direction. The possibilities of causal analysis have been demonstrated before by series of examples of the two- and three-qubit states. In this paper we consider the new applications. The first one is the application of quantum causal analysis to the asymmetric entangled state under decoherence. Three models of decoherence: dissipation, depolarization and dephasing are studied. For the all models the strength and the direction of induced causality has been computed. It turns out that the decoherence acting along original causality destroys entanglement to a lesser degree than it acting against this causality. The second application is the interaction between a two-level atom and infinite-dimensional quantized mode of a field by Jaynes-Cummings model. An analytical solution of von Neumann equation for different initial states is examined. The filed is considered initially to be in thermal mixed state, while atom – sequentially in excited, ground or thermal states. Negativity, mutual information and causal characteristics for different temperatures are computed. It is obtained that for high temperatures distinction between behaviors of different initial states smoothes over and the state turns out to be causal, entangled and “classical” in entropic sense. And the third application is the teleportation (three-particle protocol). Contrintuitively the teleported qubit is not an effect of the original one; it proves the common effect of both two other ones. But at the same time the result of Bell measurement constitutes a cause with respect to every qubits of entangled pair just since moment of their birth. The latter is manifestation of causality in reverse time.

International Symposium Honoring Mathematical Physicist Jean-Pierre Vigier•Oct 16, 2013•1 citation

Causality and decoherence in the asymmetric states

Sergey M. Korotaev, Evgeniy O. Kiktenko

Formal quantum causal analysis is applied to the three-qubit states. ‘Quantum causality’ means asymmetry in the transfer of information. It leads to different entanglement decay of the system at decoherence of different subsystems. The relationship between decoherence (by dissipation, depolarization and dephasing) and causal connections for the different model states has been studied. Generally, this relationship turns out to be rather sophisticated, although some simple relations have been established. So, the dissipated one-particle party tends to be the effect with respect to the rest of the system, while the depolarized one tends to be the cause. In the asymmetric states, the dissipation and depolarization acting along original causality destroy entanglement to a lesser degree than against it. The decohered internal (inside a subsystem) effect destroys entanglement to a lesser degree than the decohered internal cause.

Physica Scripta•May 1, 2012•9 citations

Tomographic causal analysis of two-qubit states

Aleksey K. Fedorov, Evgeniy O. Kiktenko

The behavior of two-qubit states under a tomographic measurement is under consideration. We suggest the method of tomographic quantum causal analysis, based on using of quantum causal analysis for defining entropic asymmetry and quantum tomography for investigation of measurement influence. Pure maximally entangled state and asymmetrical quantum-classica states are considered. We show that in the asymmetrical state measurement can change an original direction of asymmetry. The connection with original direction of asymmetry is revealed.

•Sep 19, 2013•0 citations

Causality and Reversibility in Irreversible Time

Sergey M. Korotaev

In the book the idea of irreversibility as an inherent property of time is developed theoretically and experimentally. The matter is related with causality, and the method of causal analysis is presented. The quantum causal analysis helps understand the principle of week causality which admits extraction of information from the future without the classical paradoxes. It implies a possibility of observation of the future as the existing reality. So, the acceptance of time irreversibility leads to a striking manifestation of reversibility – signaling in reverse time. Quantum insight allows considering correlations of the distant irreversible processes as nonlocal ones originated from a macroscopic entanglement. The experimental approach to study of macroscopic nonlocality is discussed, and design of the experimental setup is described. The results of experiments on macroscopic nonlocal correlations, the signals in reverse time and their application to the forecast of large-scale random processes are expounded.

•Jan 1, 2011•11 citations

Quantum causal inference in the presence of hidden common causes: An entropic approach

Mohammad Ali Javidian, Vaneet Aggarwal, Zubin Jacob

Quantum causality is an emerging field of study which has the potential to greatly advance our understanding of quantum systems. In this paper, we put forth a theoretical framework for merging quantum information science and causal inference by exploiting entropic principles. For this purpose, we leverage the tradeoff between the entropy of hidden cause and the conditional mutual information of observed variables to develop a scalable algorithmic approach for inferring causality in the presence of latent confounders (common causes) in quantum systems. As an application, we consider a system of three entangled qubits and transmit the second and third qubits over separate noisy quantum channels. In this model, we validate that the first qubit is a latent confounder and the common cause of the second and third qubits. In contrast, when two entangled qubits are prepared and one of them is sent over a noisy channel, there is no common confounder. We also demonstrate that the proposed approach outperforms the results of classical causal inference for the Tubingen database when the variables are classical by exploiting quantum dependence between variables through density matrices rather than joint probability distributions. Thus, the proposed approach unifies classical and quantum causal inference in a principled way.

arXiv:2104.13227•Physical Review A•Dec 19, 2022•2 citations
We suggest quantum generalization of the method of causal analysis used before only for the classical variables. The causality parameters for the series of examples of two‐qubit entangled states are computed. The results are compared with the concurrence and degree of mixedness of the states. The role of state asymmetry in quantum information transfer is shown. For the qubits under nonuniformity external magnetic field the nontrivial role of this nonuniformity for subsystem causal connection has been studied. At last quantum causal analysis helps to understand Cramer principle of week causality which admits extraction of information from the future without the classical paradoxes.
The application of a new method of the quantum cause-and-effect analysis, where causality is determined without reference to a delay, for entangled states is considered. This helps to understand the Cramer's weak-causality principle llowing for time reverse in entangled states. It is found that the finite causality an exist only in mixed asymmetric entangled states. The causality parameters are computed for a series of three-qubit entangled states. Results are compared with measures of mixedness and entanglement. For the simplest cases, the formal measure of causality is not inconsistent with intuitive representations. However when a situation is somewhat complicated, the intuition may bring to an incorrect result, whereas the cause-and-effect analysis demonstrates a nontrivial role of the tate asymmetry in transfer of quantum information. Refs. 19. Figs. 9.
The quantum extension of causal analysis has shown a rich picture of the subsystem causal connections, where the usual intuitive approach is hampered more commonly. The direction of causal connection is determined by the direction of irreversible information flow, and the measure of this connection, called the course of time c 2 , is determined as the velocity of such flow. The absence of causality corresponds to infinite c 2 , accordingly the degree of causal connection is inversely related to c 2 . This formal definition of causality is valid at any time direction. The possibilities of causal analysis have been demonstrated before by series of examples of the two- and three-qubit states. In this paper we consider the new applications. The first one is the application of quantum causal analysis to the asymmetric entangled state under decoherence. Three models of decoherence: dissipation, depolarization and dephasing are studied. For the all models the strength and the direction of induced causality has been computed. It turns out that the decoherence acting along original causality destroys entanglement to a lesser degree than it acting against this causality. The second application is the interaction between a two-level atom and infinite-dimensional quantized mode of a field by Jaynes-Cummings model. An analytical solution of von Neumann equation for different initial states is examined. The filed is considered initially to be in thermal mixed state, while atom – sequentially in excited, ground or thermal states. Negativity, mutual information and causal characteristics for different temperatures are computed. It is obtained that for high temperatures distinction between behaviors of different initial states smoothes over and the state turns out to be causal, entangled and “classical” in entropic sense. And the third application is the teleportation (three-particle protocol). Contrintuitively the teleported qubit is not an effect of the original one; it proves the common effect of both two other ones. But at the same time the result of Bell measurement constitutes a cause with respect to every qubits of entangled pair just since moment of their birth. The latter is manifestation of causality in reverse time.
Formal quantum causal analysis is applied to the three-qubit states. ‘Quantum causality’ means asymmetry in the transfer of information. It leads to different entanglement decay of the system at decoherence of different subsystems. The relationship between decoherence (by dissipation, depolarization and dephasing) and causal connections for the different model states has been studied. Generally, this relationship turns out to be rather sophisticated, although some simple relations have been established. So, the dissipated one-particle party tends to be the effect with respect to the rest of the system, while the depolarized one tends to be the cause. In the asymmetric states, the dissipation and depolarization acting along original causality destroy entanglement to a lesser degree than against it. The decohered internal (inside a subsystem) effect destroys entanglement to a lesser degree than the decohered internal cause.
The behavior of two-qubit states under a tomographic measurement is under consideration. We suggest the method of tomographic quantum causal analysis, based on using of quantum causal analysis for defining entropic asymmetry and quantum tomography for investigation of measurement influence. Pure maximally entangled state and asymmetrical quantum-classica states are considered. We show that in the asymmetrical state measurement can change an original direction of asymmetry. The connection with original direction of asymmetry is revealed.
In the book the idea of irreversibility as an inherent property of time is developed theoretically and experimentally. The matter is related with causality, and the method of causal analysis is presented. The quantum causal analysis helps understand the principle of week causality which admits extraction of information from the future without the classical paradoxes. It implies a possibility of observation of the future as the existing reality. So, the acceptance of time irreversibility leads to a striking manifestation of reversibility – signaling in reverse time. Quantum insight allows considering correlations of the distant irreversible processes as nonlocal ones originated from a macroscopic entanglement. The experimental approach to study of macroscopic nonlocality is discussed, and design of the experimental setup is described. The results of experiments on macroscopic nonlocal correlations, the signals in reverse time and their application to the forecast of large-scale random processes are expounded.
Quantum causality is an emerging field of study which has the potential to greatly advance our understanding of quantum systems. In this paper, we put forth a theoretical framework for merging quantum information science and causal inference by exploiting entropic principles. For this purpose, we leverage the tradeoff between the entropy of hidden cause and the conditional mutual information of observed variables to develop a scalable algorithmic approach for inferring causality in the presence of latent confounders (common causes) in quantum systems. As an application, we consider a system of three entangled qubits and transmit the second and third qubits over separate noisy quantum channels. In this model, we validate that the first qubit is a latent confounder and the common cause of the second and third qubits. In contrast, when two entangled qubits are prepared and one of them is sent over a noisy channel, there is no common confounder. We also demonstrate that the proposed approach outperforms the results of classical causal inference for the Tubingen database when the variables are classical by exploiting quantum dependence between variables through density matrices rather than joint probability distributions. Thus, the proposed approach unifies classical and quantum causal inference in a principled way.