Physical Review

Dissipation in Quantum Mechanics. The Two-Level System

I. R. Senitzky

Published Sep 15, 1963• 38 citations

Abstract

The study of a two-level system (TLS) coupled to a loss mechanism (LM), the fluctuations of which are taken into account, is motivated by relating the problem to spin-lattice relaxation, radiation damping, and Brownian motion. A TLS of the electric dipole type (coupled to the LM through one variable only) is discussed first. The problem is formulated in terms of the Pauli spin matrices, and the Langevin equations for Brownian motion of a TLS are derived. Their solution---made possible by taking expectation values in LM space---contains the Weisskopf-Wigner exponential decay formula of radiation theory, as well as a second-order shift in frequency of the TLS produced by the (nondispersive) LM. A driving force is added to the problem and expressions are obtained for a driven lossy TLS of the electric dipole type. The same analysis is applied to a TLS of the magnetic dipole type and differential equations for the spin matrices---for which the expectation values in LM space has been taken---are obtained. Taking expectation values in TLS space converts these equations into the Bloch equations. Unlike the electric dipole case, no frequency shift is present.

DOI: 10.1103/physrev.131.2827

Related papers

Dissipation in Quantum Mechanics. Two-Level System. II

I. R. Senitzky

The theory of a previous article, dealing with two types of two-level systems coupled to a loss mechanism (LM), is extended. The first extension consists of the consideration of the most general type of two-level system (TLS), in which the dipole moment is expanded in terms of the three Pauli spin matrices and unit matrix, the expansion coefficients being vectors (dipole vectors). The second extension consists of the addition to the thermal-reservoir type of LM of a large number of systems identical to the TLS under consideration. The TLS is described in terms of the time development of the Pauli matrices and differential equations are obtained for their expectation value in the presence of arbitrary driving fields. The Bloch equations for a magnetic dipole of spin \textonehalf{} are exhibited as a special case of these equations, corresponding to a particular combination of the dipole vectors. All other combinations describe electric dipole systems. Equations for two simple special cases of such systems are presented, one treated in the previous article and the other having permanent dipole moment. The frequency of oscillation of a freely decaying TLS is derived and shown to be shifted by an amount that depends on the relationship between the dipole vectors. It is pointed out that the commonly held belief that any TLS can be represented as a magnetic dipole of spin \textonehalf{} is only approximately correct in the presence of dissipation. The conditions under which the differential equations for the expectation values of the dynamical variables of the TLS can be converted into differential equations for macroscopic variables are discussed.

Physical ReviewMay 18, 196422 citations

Two-Level System with Dissipation. Off-Resonance Amplification at Nonequilibrium Positive Temperatures

I. R. Senitzky

Previously derived equations of motion---in terms of the expectation values of the Pauli spin matrices---for a two-level system (TLS) coupled to a loss mechanism (LM) are generalized to include higher order interactions which describe the reaction of the LM to the effect of the driving field on the TLS. This generalization results in the addition of a driving term to the equations of motion which is approximately independent of the state of the TLS and involves parameters of the LM that characterize its response at the difference between the TLS frequency $\ensuremath{\omega}$ and the driving-field frequency $\ensuremath{\nu}$. The new driving term is negligible unless the TLS possesses a permanent dipole moment, and, in the case of a magnetic TLS, unless the driving field has a transverse component. A solution of the equations of motion for a magnetic TLS being driven by a transverse rotating field shows that amplification of the driving field may be obtained without population inversion of the TLS provided $\ensuremath{\nu}<\ensuremath{\omega}$, provided the loss constant $\ensuremath{\eta}$ (which is a measure of the response of the LM) has a frequency dependence such that $\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\nu})$ is significant compared to $\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\nu})$, and provided the TLS temperature exceeds the LM temperature by an appropriate amount that is minimized when $\frac{\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\nu})}{\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\nu})}$ is a minimum. If $\frac{\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\nu})}{\ensuremath{\eta}(\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\nu})}$ is small compared with unity, amplification is obtained when the TLS temperature is larger than the LM temperature by a factor $\frac{\ensuremath{\omega}}{(\ensuremath{\omega}\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\nu})}$. The induced emission power is discussed.

Physical ReviewFeb 4, 19663 citations

Dissipation in Quantum Mechanics. Two-Level System. III

I. R. Senitzky

Previous theory describing the behavior of a general two-level system (TLS) coupled to a loss mechanism and driven by an oscillating field near resonance is generalized to include an arbitrary driving field. Integro-differential equations of motion for the expectation values of the Pauli spin matrices, which describe completely the behavior of a TLS, are derived. The relaxation constants involved in these equations prove to be frequency-dependent, and reactive effects produced by the loss mechanism appear. It is shown that for an approximately monochromatic driving field near resonance, the general equations of motion can be approximated by differential equations. In the case of a magnetic TLS, these differential equations reduce to the Bloch equations if reactive effects are neglected. An exact solution of the general equations of motion for the special, simple case of a magnetic TLS being driven by a transverse rotating field of arbitrary frequency is obtained, and deviation from a Lorentzian resonance shape, caused by the frequency dependence of the relaxation and reactive constants, is found to exist.

Physical ReviewMar 15, 19659 citations

Forced Two-Level Oscillator

I. R. Senitzky

Previously derived equations for the expectation values of the dynamical variables of a general two-level dipole system (TLS) coupled to a relaxation mechanism---of which the Bloch equations for a spin-\textonehalf{} magneticdipole system are a special case---are reformulated in the density-matrix formalism in order to point out the explicit difference in the relaxation terms between the present description, which includes electric-dipole systems, and that of conventional treatments that are based on the assumption that any TLS is equivalent to a spin-\textonehalf{} magnetic dipole. The original equations are then solved for a weak monochromatic driving field, and the frequency of maximum power absorption is shown to depend on the type of TLS under consideration. The case of a stronger monochromatic driving field and the resulting saturation effects are studied for a special TLS, a spatially linear electric dipole which may have permanent dipole moment. This case exhibits a strong-field resonance shift that depends on the magnitude of the permanent dipole moment. A driving field consisting of a strong component at resonance and a weak component near resonance is considered in connection with the same TLS. The polarization is shown to contain, in lowest order, a component at the difference frequency with an amplitude determined by the magnitude of the permanent dipole moment.

Physical ReviewSep 14, 19646 citations

Dissipation in Quantum Mechanics. The Harmonic Oscillator

I. R. Senitzky

The need for a quantum-mechanical formalism for systems with dissipation which is applicable to the radiation field of a cavity is discussed. Two methods that have been used in this connection are described. The first, which starts with the classical Newtonian equation of motion for a damped oscillator and applies the conventional formal quantization techniques, leads to an exact solution; but subsequent discussion shows that this method is invalid, the results being unacceptable from a quantum-mechanical viewpoint. The second method, which considers the interaction of two systems, the lossless oscillator and the loss mechanism, is adopted in the present article. No special model is used for the loss mechanism, but this mechanism is assumed to have a large number of densely-spaced energy states.The approximations with respect to the loss mechanism that underlie the concept of dissipation are discussed. These approximations are then applied to the analysis, and a differential equation for a coordinate operator of the harmonic oscillator is obtained which has the formal appearance of the Newtonian equation of motion for a driven damped harmonic oscillator, the driving term being an operator referring to the loss mechanism. The presence of the driving term is responsible for the difference between the present theory and that of the first method mentioned above. A solution of the differential equation for the coordinate operator is given explicitly. An examination of the physical significance of the solution shows that the driving term is responsible not only for the thermal fluctuations which are due to the loss mechanism, but also for the proper commutation relationship of the conjugate coordinates of the oscillator and for its zero-point fluctuations.A generalization of the solution to provide for a classical driving force and coupled atomic systems is given. The results are then restated in a form that refers to the loss mechanism only through the two parameters by which it is usually described---the dissipation constant and the temperature.

Physical ReviewJul 15, 1960466 citations

Two-level quantum mechanical system with decay: density matrix description and shifted frequency approximation

D. C. Morgan, J. E. Grindlay

The shifted frequency approximation is used to solve the equations of motion for the density matrix describing a quantum mechanical two-level system, with decay, in an applied monochromatic electric field. Expressions are obtained for the transient and the long-term linear electric dipole moment and occupation probability, and the long-term third-order dipole moment. The results are valid across the frequency spectrum, including resonance, provided the phenomenological decay times for the system are not too large or too close in value.

Canadian Journal of PhysicsDec 1, 19850 citations