Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Physical Chemistry A

Consistent Treatment of Spin-Selective Recombination of a Radical Pair Confirms the Haberkorn Approach

Konstantin L. Ivanov, Marina V. Petrova, Nikita N. Lukzen, Kiminori Maeda

Published Aug 12, 2010• 68 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In the present work, we have shown that consistent derivation of the kinetic equations describing the electron spin-selective recombination of radical pairs confirms the conventional Haberkorn approach. The derivation has been based on considering the interaction of the reactive system (radical pair and product state) with the thermal bath. The consistency of this approach has also been substantiated by numerical simulations performed for the purely quantum mechanical model of the recombining radical pair. Finally, we have shown that the quantum Zeno effect on radical pair recombination is not an exclusive feature of the approach recently proposed by Kominis, as it should be present at any rate of the singlet-triplet dephasing in the radical pair, which always accompanies the recombination process.

DOI
10.1021/jp1048265

Related papers

F-cluster: Reaction-induced spin correlation in multi-radical systems

DR Kattnig (21871391)

We provide a theoretical analysis of spin-selective recombination processes in clusters of n ≥ 3 radicals. Specifically, we discuss how spin correlation can ensue from random encounters of n radicals, i.e., "F-clusters" as a generalization of radical F-pairs, acting as precursors of spin-driven magnetic field effects. Survival probabilities and the spin correlation of the surviving radical population, as well as transients, are evaluated by expanding the spin density operator in an operator basis that is closed under application of the Haberkorn recombination operator and singlet-triplet dephasing. For the primary spin cluster, the steady-state density operator is found to be independent of the details of the recombination network, provided that it is irreducible; pairs of surviving radicals are triplet-polarized independent of whether they are actually reacting with each other. The steady state is independent of the singlet-triplet dephasing, but the kinetics and the population of sister clusters of smaller size can depend on the degree of dephasing. We also analyze reaction-induced singlet-triplet interconversion in radical pairs due to radical scavenging by initially uncorrelated radicals ("chemical Zeno effect"). We generalize previous treatments for radical triads by discussing the effect of spin-selective recombination in the original pair and extending the analysis to four radicals, i.e., radical pairs interacting with two radical scavengers.

•Aug 1, 2025•0 citations

Monte-Carlo wavefunction approach for the spin dynamics of recombining radicals

Robert H. Keens, Daniel R. Kattnig

Abstract We adapt the Monte-Carlo wavefunction (MCWF) approach to treat the open-system spin dynamics of radical pairs subject to spin-selective recombination reactions. For these systems, non-Lindbladian master equations are widely employed, which account for recombination via the non trace-preserving Haberkorn superoperator in combination with reaction-dependent exchange and singlet–triplet dephasing terms. We show that this type of master equation can be accommodated in the MCWF approach, by introducing a second type of quantum jump that accounts for the reaction simply by suitably terminating the propagation. In this way, we are able to evaluate approximate solutions to the time-dependent radical pair survival probability for systems that have been considered untreatable with the master equation approach until now. We explicate the suggested approach with calculations for radical pair reactions that have been suggested to be relevant for the quantum compass of birds and related phenomena.

arXiv:2005.04417•New Journal of Physics•Jul 20, 2020•9 citations

The chemical zeno effect in exchange-bounded radical pairs: 2. Singlet and random radical pairs

I. N. Yakunin, V. L. Berdinskiĭ

Manifestations of the chemical Zeno effect (slowing down of the quantum evolution of radical pairs as a result of spin-selective recombination of exchange-bounded radical pairs) are considered. In radical pairs created in singlet and random spin states, the chemical kinetics is described by the sum of kinetic evolution (exponential) and oscillatory functions. The kinetic function is a superposition of two exponential functions. Recombination monotonically decreases the amplitude of quantum beats in singlet radical pairs. The dependence of the amplitude of quantum beats in noncorrelated radical pairs on the recombination rate constant is not monotonic.

Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry B•Jun 1, 2010•1 citation

Multiple re-encounter approach to radical pair reactions and the role of nonlinear master equations

Jens Clausen, Gian Giacomo Guerreschi, Markus Tiersch +1 more

We formulate a multiple-encounter model of the radical pair mechanism that is based on a random coupling of the radical pair to a minimal model environment. These occasional pulse-like couplings correspond to the radical encounters and give rise to both dephasing and recombination. While this is in agreement with the original model of Haberkorn and its extensions that assume additional dephasing, we show how a nonlinear master equation may be constructed to describe the conditional evolution of the radical pairs prior to the detection of their recombination. We propose a nonlinear master equation for the evolution of an ensemble of independently evolving radical pairs whose nonlinearity depends on the record of the fluorescence signal. We also reformulate Haberkorn's original argument on the physicality of reaction operators using the terminology of quantum optics/open quantum systems. Our model allows one to describe multiple encounters within the exponential model and connects this with the master equation approach. We include hitherto neglected effects of the encounters, such as a separate dephasing in the triplet subspace, and predict potential new effects, such as Grover reflections of radical spins, that may be observed if the strength and time of the encounters can be experimentally controlled.

arXiv:1310.6194•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Aug 5, 2014•10 citations

Describing Spin-Selective Reactions of Radical Pairs Using Quantum Jump Approaches

Alpha A. Lee

Recently, spin-selective radical pair reactions have been studied using concepts from quantum measurement theory. In this Article, we show that the approach taken by Kominis (Physical Review E, 83, 2011, 056118) leads to erroneous results due to a problematic treatment of quantum jumps. Correct consideration of quantum jumps leads to either the traditional master equation or the Jones-Hore master equation.

arXiv:1110.2298•Oct 11, 2011•0 citations

Effect of state-selective reactive decay on the evolution of quantum systems

Anatoly I. Shushin

The effect of state-selective reactive decay on the relaxation kinetics of quantum multistate systems is studied in detail in the Bloch-Redfield approach (BRA). The results are applied to the analysis of this effect in radical pair recombination kinetics. The BRA is shown to be able to describe quantitatively most important specific features of the recombination kinetics including those predicted by phenomenological treatment and by recently proposed approaches based on quantum measurement theories.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 22, 2010•20 citations
In the present work, we have shown that consistent derivation of the kinetic equations describing the electron spin-selective recombination of radical pairs confirms the conventional Haberkorn approach. The derivation has been based on considering the interaction of the reactive system (radical pair and product state) with the thermal bath. The consistency of this approach has also been substantiated by numerical simulations performed for the purely quantum mechanical model of the recombining radical pair. Finally, we have shown that the quantum Zeno effect on radical pair recombination is not an exclusive feature of the approach recently proposed by Kominis, as it should be present at any rate of the singlet-triplet dephasing in the radical pair, which always accompanies the recombination process.
We provide a theoretical analysis of spin-selective recombination processes in clusters of n ≥ 3 radicals. Specifically, we discuss how spin correlation can ensue from random encounters of n radicals, i.e., "F-clusters" as a generalization of radical F-pairs, acting as precursors of spin-driven magnetic field effects. Survival probabilities and the spin correlation of the surviving radical population, as well as transients, are evaluated by expanding the spin density operator in an operator basis that is closed under application of the Haberkorn recombination operator and singlet-triplet dephasing. For the primary spin cluster, the steady-state density operator is found to be independent of the details of the recombination network, provided that it is irreducible; pairs of surviving radicals are triplet-polarized independent of whether they are actually reacting with each other. The steady state is independent of the singlet-triplet dephasing, but the kinetics and the population of sister clusters of smaller size can depend on the degree of dephasing. We also analyze reaction-induced singlet-triplet interconversion in radical pairs due to radical scavenging by initially uncorrelated radicals ("chemical Zeno effect"). We generalize previous treatments for radical triads by discussing the effect of spin-selective recombination in the original pair and extending the analysis to four radicals, i.e., radical pairs interacting with two radical scavengers.
Abstract We adapt the Monte-Carlo wavefunction (MCWF) approach to treat the open-system spin dynamics of radical pairs subject to spin-selective recombination reactions. For these systems, non-Lindbladian master equations are widely employed, which account for recombination via the non trace-preserving Haberkorn superoperator in combination with reaction-dependent exchange and singlet–triplet dephasing terms. We show that this type of master equation can be accommodated in the MCWF approach, by introducing a second type of quantum jump that accounts for the reaction simply by suitably terminating the propagation. In this way, we are able to evaluate approximate solutions to the time-dependent radical pair survival probability for systems that have been considered untreatable with the master equation approach until now. We explicate the suggested approach with calculations for radical pair reactions that have been suggested to be relevant for the quantum compass of birds and related phenomena.
Manifestations of the chemical Zeno effect (slowing down of the quantum evolution of radical pairs as a result of spin-selective recombination of exchange-bounded radical pairs) are considered. In radical pairs created in singlet and random spin states, the chemical kinetics is described by the sum of kinetic evolution (exponential) and oscillatory functions. The kinetic function is a superposition of two exponential functions. Recombination monotonically decreases the amplitude of quantum beats in singlet radical pairs. The dependence of the amplitude of quantum beats in noncorrelated radical pairs on the recombination rate constant is not monotonic.
We formulate a multiple-encounter model of the radical pair mechanism that is based on a random coupling of the radical pair to a minimal model environment. These occasional pulse-like couplings correspond to the radical encounters and give rise to both dephasing and recombination. While this is in agreement with the original model of Haberkorn and its extensions that assume additional dephasing, we show how a nonlinear master equation may be constructed to describe the conditional evolution of the radical pairs prior to the detection of their recombination. We propose a nonlinear master equation for the evolution of an ensemble of independently evolving radical pairs whose nonlinearity depends on the record of the fluorescence signal. We also reformulate Haberkorn's original argument on the physicality of reaction operators using the terminology of quantum optics/open quantum systems. Our model allows one to describe multiple encounters within the exponential model and connects this with the master equation approach. We include hitherto neglected effects of the encounters, such as a separate dephasing in the triplet subspace, and predict potential new effects, such as Grover reflections of radical spins, that may be observed if the strength and time of the encounters can be experimentally controlled.
The effect of state-selective reactive decay on the relaxation kinetics of quantum multistate systems is studied in detail in the Bloch-Redfield approach (BRA). The results are applied to the analysis of this effect in radical pair recombination kinetics. The BRA is shown to be able to describe quantitatively most important specific features of the recombination kinetics including those predicted by phenomenological treatment and by recently proposed approaches based on quantum measurement theories.