Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Theory of photon echoes and hole burning in low temperature glasses: How good are the standard approximations?

Eitan Geva, James L. Skinner

Published Nov 15, 1997• 37 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The theory of optical photon echo and hole burning spectroscopies in low temperature glasses is discussed within the framework of the tunneling two-level system and stochastic sudden jump models. Exact results for the relevant theoretical quantities involve certain averages over the distributions of the two-level system energies and relaxation rates. The standard approximations for these averages are critically examined, for experimentally realistic parameters, via comparison to numerically exact calculations. The general conclusion is that the standard approximations are often used under conditions where they are not expected to be quantitatively accurate.

DOI
10.1063/1.475112

Related papers

Modified Model of Photon Echoes in Low-Temperature Glasses: Effect of Minimal Distance between Two-Level Systems and Chromophore

А. В. Наумов, Yuri G. Vainer

A modified theoretical model of photon echoes (PE) in low-temperature doped glasses based on the tunneling two-level system (TLS) and stochastic sudden jump models has been developed. The distinguishing feature of the model is its adaptation for Monte Carlo technique. The developed approach is more general than usual PE theories and allows us to take into account the different microscopic parameters of spectral dynamics in doped amorphous solids: in particular, the minimal radius of interaction between TLS and chromophore molecules, the dispersion of this coupling constant, and the changes of matrix properties nearby chromophore (shell-effect). The developed theory was applied for calculations of two-pulse PE decays for an organic amorphous system with typical parameters. It was found that the slope of temperature dependence of the homogeneous line width is decreased with an increase in the above-mentioned minimal radius. This effect could be one of the main reasons for the discrepancy between some PE experimental results versus calculation using standard PE theory.

The Journal of Physical Chemistry B•Feb 6, 2003•1 citation

Optical linewidths and photon-echo decays of impurities in glasses

W. O. Putikka, David L. Huber

Using a stochastic model, we calculate the temperature dependence of the homogeneous linewidth and the two-pulse photon-echo decay rate of optically active impurities in glasses. The theory applies to the low-temperature regime T\ensuremath{\lesssim}10 K, where it is assumed that the dephasing arises from an elastic dipole interaction of the impurity with an array of thermally excited tunneling systems. Averaging over the tunneling parameters and using relaxation rates appropriate to vitreous silica, we find that the photon-echo decay rate varies as ${T}^{1.1}$ and the homogeneous linewidth as ${T}^{1.2}$ for 0.1\ensuremath{\le}T\ensuremath{\le}1 K, assuming a constant density of states for the tunneling systems. Both the photon-echo amplitude and the optical dipole-moment correlation function decay exponentially in time. The rates, however, are different, with a ratio of photon-echo dephasing time to optical-absorption dephasing time of 6.9 at T=1 K, assuming a constant density of states. The relation of our results to various experimental studies is discussed.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Aug 15, 1987•52 citations

Laser Hole Burning Spectroscopy: A High Resolution Probe of Molecular Environments.

R. M. Macfarlane, Robert M. Shelby

Laser induced hole burning in optical absorption bands of low temperature solids has been investigated with emphasis on mechanisms for population hole burning, the interactions with the environment which limit the hole widths and the use of hole burning for ultra high resolution spectroscopy. Hole burning was observed in a wide range of solids including organic and organometallic molecules in crystals and rare earth ions in crystals and glasses. The mechanisms for hole burning also varied widely and a new mechanism involving optically induced nuclear spin flips of near neighbor nuclei was discovered. Examples of hole burning in new classes of materials are presented here for the first time, namely inorganic glasses (silicate glasses containing Nd(3+), Pr(3+) or Eu(3+)) and undoped stoichiometric compounds (e.g., EuP5O14). Hole recovery was used to determine nuclear spin lattice relaxation rates in praseodymium doped crystals. For allowed optical transitions (e.g., singlet states of zinc porphyrin, dibromoindigo and color centers in alkali halides) the hole widths at 2K are limited by population decay to approximately 50 MHz. For longer lived optical levels in crystalline materials, e.g., those containing rare earth ions, the hole widths are narrower (less than 10 MHz) and are limited by dynamical interactions with surrounding nuclei. In amorphous materials such as europium doped silicate glass, hole widths are much broader, being limited by low frequency tunneling motions. Hole burning measurements were complemented by time domain coherent transient (photon echo, and optical free decay) measurements of homogeneous linewidths which enabled us to measure optical resonances as narrow as 760 Hz in Eu(3+):Y2O3.

Final Report•Jun 1, 1981•0 citations

Low temperature dynamics in amorphous solids: A photon echo study

Hans C. Meijers, Douwe A. Wiersma

The long-lived stimulated photon echo is put forward as a powerful technique to probe structural dynamics in glasses and other amorphous solids. We present results of optical dephasing measurements on several doped organic glasses (deuterated ethanol, toluene, and triethylamine) and polymers (polystyrene, polyvinylbutyral, and polymethylmethacrylate). Using a stochastic analysis within the so-called two-level-system model, we can extract from these measurements the distribution function of fluctuation rates over a huge range of time scales, varying from picoseconds to hundreds of milliseconds. We show that the dynamics, which lies at the origin of spectral diffusion, is very dependent on the glass structure and can be described by two separate hyperbolic distribution functions of fluctuation rates. From longitudinal photon echo measurements in the population dimension, we find evidence for structural dynamics which is not accounted for in the standard two-level-system model and which is related to a spatially inhomogeneous distribution of fluctuation centers.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Oct 15, 1994•56 citations

Picosecond photon echo and optical hole burning studies of chromophores in organic glasses

Mark A. Berg, Cecilia A. Walsh, L. R. Narasimhan +1 more

The range of relaxation rates present in amorphous systems is shown to affect the results of optical dephasing measurements. The interpretation of these experiments in terms of four-time correlation functions is introduced. Photon echo and hole burning results are shown for resorufin in three glass hosts: ethanol, d-ethanol, and glycerol. The hole burning data are shown to be affected by slow relaxation processes whereas the echo results are not. The implications of a slowest relaxation rate in amorphous systems are also considered.

Journal of Luminescence•Dec 1, 1987•15 citations

Long-lived stimulated photon echo: the ideal probe of glass dynamics

Hans C. Meijers, Douwe A. Wiersma

In the last two decades the dynamics of glasses has been a field of great interest. In order to explain the dynamical properties of glasses the two-level-system model has been proposed. In this model an atom, or group of atoms, can access two potential minima separated by a barrier. Phonon-assisted-tunneling between the two minima of this asymmetric double well potential represents a jump between two different local glass structures. These double well potentials are referred to as two-level-systems (TLS). In the standard TLS-model the potentials do not change in time. The intrinsic disorder of the glass provides a wide range of asymmetries and a broad distribution of transition rates. Consequently the dynamics of the glass takes place over a broad range of time scales.

Spectral Hole-Burning and Related Spectroscopies: Science and Applications•Jan 1, 1992•0 citations
The theory of optical photon echo and hole burning spectroscopies in low temperature glasses is discussed within the framework of the tunneling two-level system and stochastic sudden jump models. Exact results for the relevant theoretical quantities involve certain averages over the distributions of the two-level system energies and relaxation rates. The standard approximations for these averages are critically examined, for experimentally realistic parameters, via comparison to numerically exact calculations. The general conclusion is that the standard approximations are often used under conditions where they are not expected to be quantitatively accurate.
A modified theoretical model of photon echoes (PE) in low-temperature doped glasses based on the tunneling two-level system (TLS) and stochastic sudden jump models has been developed. The distinguishing feature of the model is its adaptation for Monte Carlo technique. The developed approach is more general than usual PE theories and allows us to take into account the different microscopic parameters of spectral dynamics in doped amorphous solids: in particular, the minimal radius of interaction between TLS and chromophore molecules, the dispersion of this coupling constant, and the changes of matrix properties nearby chromophore (shell-effect). The developed theory was applied for calculations of two-pulse PE decays for an organic amorphous system with typical parameters. It was found that the slope of temperature dependence of the homogeneous line width is decreased with an increase in the above-mentioned minimal radius. This effect could be one of the main reasons for the discrepancy between some PE experimental results versus calculation using standard PE theory.
Using a stochastic model, we calculate the temperature dependence of the homogeneous linewidth and the two-pulse photon-echo decay rate of optically active impurities in glasses. The theory applies to the low-temperature regime T\ensuremath{\lesssim}10 K, where it is assumed that the dephasing arises from an elastic dipole interaction of the impurity with an array of thermally excited tunneling systems. Averaging over the tunneling parameters and using relaxation rates appropriate to vitreous silica, we find that the photon-echo decay rate varies as T1.1{T}^{1.1}T1.1 and the homogeneous linewidth as T1.2{T}^{1.2}T1.2 for 0.1\ensuremath{\le}T\ensuremath{\le}1 K, assuming a constant density of states for the tunneling systems. Both the photon-echo amplitude and the optical dipole-moment correlation function decay exponentially in time. The rates, however, are different, with a ratio of photon-echo dephasing time to optical-absorption dephasing time of 6.9 at T=1 K, assuming a constant density of states. The relation of our results to various experimental studies is discussed.
Laser induced hole burning in optical absorption bands of low temperature solids has been investigated with emphasis on mechanisms for population hole burning, the interactions with the environment which limit the hole widths and the use of hole burning for ultra high resolution spectroscopy. Hole burning was observed in a wide range of solids including organic and organometallic molecules in crystals and rare earth ions in crystals and glasses. The mechanisms for hole burning also varied widely and a new mechanism involving optically induced nuclear spin flips of near neighbor nuclei was discovered. Examples of hole burning in new classes of materials are presented here for the first time, namely inorganic glasses (silicate glasses containing Nd(3+), Pr(3+) or Eu(3+)) and undoped stoichiometric compounds (e.g., EuP5O14). Hole recovery was used to determine nuclear spin lattice relaxation rates in praseodymium doped crystals. For allowed optical transitions (e.g., singlet states of zinc porphyrin, dibromoindigo and color centers in alkali halides) the hole widths at 2K are limited by population decay to approximately 50 MHz. For longer lived optical levels in crystalline materials, e.g., those containing rare earth ions, the hole widths are narrower (less than 10 MHz) and are limited by dynamical interactions with surrounding nuclei. In amorphous materials such as europium doped silicate glass, hole widths are much broader, being limited by low frequency tunneling motions. Hole burning measurements were complemented by time domain coherent transient (photon echo, and optical free decay) measurements of homogeneous linewidths which enabled us to measure optical resonances as narrow as 760 Hz in Eu(3+):Y2O3.
The long-lived stimulated photon echo is put forward as a powerful technique to probe structural dynamics in glasses and other amorphous solids. We present results of optical dephasing measurements on several doped organic glasses (deuterated ethanol, toluene, and triethylamine) and polymers (polystyrene, polyvinylbutyral, and polymethylmethacrylate). Using a stochastic analysis within the so-called two-level-system model, we can extract from these measurements the distribution function of fluctuation rates over a huge range of time scales, varying from picoseconds to hundreds of milliseconds. We show that the dynamics, which lies at the origin of spectral diffusion, is very dependent on the glass structure and can be described by two separate hyperbolic distribution functions of fluctuation rates. From longitudinal photon echo measurements in the population dimension, we find evidence for structural dynamics which is not accounted for in the standard two-level-system model and which is related to a spatially inhomogeneous distribution of fluctuation centers.
The range of relaxation rates present in amorphous systems is shown to affect the results of optical dephasing measurements. The interpretation of these experiments in terms of four-time correlation functions is introduced. Photon echo and hole burning results are shown for resorufin in three glass hosts: ethanol, d-ethanol, and glycerol. The hole burning data are shown to be affected by slow relaxation processes whereas the echo results are not. The implications of a slowest relaxation rate in amorphous systems are also considered.
In the last two decades the dynamics of glasses has been a field of great interest. In order to explain the dynamical properties of glasses the two-level-system model has been proposed. In this model an atom, or group of atoms, can access two potential minima separated by a barrier. Phonon-assisted-tunneling between the two minima of this asymmetric double well potential represents a jump between two different local glass structures. These double well potentials are referred to as two-level-systems (TLS). In the standard TLS-model the potentials do not change in time. The intrinsic disorder of the glass provides a wide range of asymmetries and a broad distribution of transition rates. Consequently the dynamics of the glass takes place over a broad range of time scales.