Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Theory of the effect of odd-photon destructive interference on optical shifts in resonantly enhanced multiphoton excitation and ionization

M. G. Payne, L. Deng, W. R. Garrett

Published Aug 1, 1998• 10 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We present a theory for two- and three-photon excitation, optical shifting, and four-wave mixing when a first laser is tuned onto, or near, a two-photon resonance and a second much more intense laser is tuned near or on resonance between the two-photon resonance and a second excited state. When the second excited state has a dipole-allowed transition back to the ground state and the concentration is sufficiently high, a destructive interference is produced between three-photon coupling of the ground state and the second excited state and one-photon coupling between the same states by the internally generated four-wave mixing field. This interference leads to several striking effects. For instance, as the onset of the interference occurs, the optical shifts in the two-photon resonance excitation line shape become smaller in copropagating geometry so that the line shapes for multiphoton ionization enhanced by the two-photon resonance eventually become unaffected by the second laser. In the same range of concentrations the four-wave mixing field evolves to a concentration-independent intensity. With counterpropagating laser beams the line shape exhibits normal optical shifts like those observed for both copropagating and counterpropagating laser beams at very low concentrations. The theoretical work presented here extends our earlier works by including the effect of laser bandwidth and by removing the restriction of having the second laser be tuned far from three-photon resonance. In this way we have now included, as a special case, the effect of both laser bandwidth and interference on laser-induced transparency. Unlike other effects related to odd-photon destructive interference, the effect of a broad bandwidth is to bring about the predicted effects at much lower concentrations. Studies in rubidium show good agreement between theory and experiment for both ionization line shapes and four-wave mixing intensity as a function of concentration.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.58.1361

Related papers

Effect of the odd-photon destructive interference on laser-induced transparency and multiphoton excitation and ionization in rubidium

L. Deng, W. R. Garrett, M. G. Payne +1 more

We report experimental results on two-color multiphoton ionization and four-wave-mixing production under conditions where one form of laser-induced transparency (LIT) occurs. Under the conditions of LIT, multiphoton-ionization line shapes obtained by tuning one laser through a two-photon resonance exhibit a pronounced Autler-Townes splitting at low concentrations, when a second laser couples the two-photon state to a third level. In this concentration region we observed a four-wave-mixing field that increased quadratically with concentration. As the concentration is increased the Autler-Townes splitting starts to decrease, and disappears completely as a critical concentration is reached. Simultaneously, the four-wave-mixing field intensity starts to level off and finally becomes concentration independent. These observations are explained in terms of odd-photon destructive interference between different excitation pathways. In rubidium, we demonstrate that above concentrations of n\ensuremath{\simeq}5\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}${10}^{14}$ ${\mathrm{cm}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}3}$ the four-wave-mixing field is concentration independent and the multiphoton-ionization line shape shows no Autler-Townes splitting, and the width of the line shape is determined by the laser bandwidth. The results presented here demonstrate that destructive interference significantly limits the high-efficiency and high-intensity nonlinear optical generation promised in early studies on LIT, at least for the multimode laser system used in the present experiment. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1996•8 citations

Effects of four-wave mixing on four-photon resonance excitation and ionization in the presence of a three-photon intermediate state resonance enhancement

M. G. Payne, J. C. Miller, Roger C. Hart +1 more

We consider effects which occur when four-wave sum frequency generation and multiphoton ionization are induced by lasers tuned near a three-photon resonance and simultaneously near or at a dipole allowed four-photon resonance. In studies with unfocused laser beams, if the phase mismatch of the generated four-wave-mixing field is large and the related two-photon resonance for the absorption of a four-wave-mixing photon and a laser photon results in strong absorption of the four-wave-mixing field, a coherent cancellation occurs between the pumping of the resonance by two- and four-photon processes. This interference effect occurs when the first laser is tuned on either side of the three-photon resonance and \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Delta}${\mathit{k}}_{\mathit{r}}$L\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\gg}1, where \ensuremath{\Delta}${\mathit{k}}_{\mathit{r}}$ is the mismatch and L is the length of the path of the laser beams in the gas. With focused laser beams large differences occur between ionization with unidirectional beams and with counterpropagating laser beams when \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Delta}${\mathit{k}}_{\mathit{r}}$b\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\gg}1, where b is the confocal parameter of the focused laser beams. Strong absorption of the four-wave-mixing field is shown not to be necessary for strong destructive interference with focused laser beams when the phase mismatch is large. This work also suggests an explanation for earlier experiments where the presence of a four-photon resonance enabled the generation of third-harmonic light in a positively dispersive wavelength region. We argue that this process can occur when the laser used to achieve the four-photon resonance is focused on the small z (z is the coordinate in the direction of propagation) side of the focal point of the laser responsible for the third-harmonic generation. In this way the absorption of the third-harmonic light on one side of the focal point is made much stronger than on the other side. Correspondingly, contributions to the third-harmonic field from the two sides of the focal point are unequal and cannot undergo complete destructive interference as would otherwise occur in a positively dispersive region.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1991•19 citations

Effect of quantum interference on the suppression of the ac Stark shifting of a multiphoton resonance

L. Deng, W. R. Garrett, J. Y. Zhang +1 more

We report detailed experimental results in xenon that confirm theoretical predictions [Payne et al., Phys. Rev. A 48, 2334 (1993)] on the interference-based suppression of ac Stark shifting of even-photon resonances under circumstances where the shift is produced through strong coupling to a state that is also coupled back to the ground state. In the copropagating-beam configuration and in the pressure range of 0.5--250 Torr, the multiphoton ionization spectral line shape is unchanged regardless of the presence of the second laser field, i.e., the ac Stark shift introduced by the second laser is totally suppressed due to a complete destructive interference between two excitation pathways. In the counterpropagating-beam configuration, however, the ac Stark shift persists in the range of the pressure studied. By choosing a different set of energy levels where no four-wave-mixing field is permitted, we show that the very same ac Stark shift introduced by the second laser field persists even with copropagating-beam configuration, as predicted by theory.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1995•11 citations

Effect of pressure-dependent quantum interference on the ac Stark shifting of two-photon resonances

M. G. Payne, J.Y. Zhang, W. R. Garrett

We describe ac Stark shift production and measurement in a two-laser mode where a first laser is tuned through a two-photon resonance between the ground state and an excited state in order to record a line shape for the corresponding resonantly enhanced multiphoton ionization. A second laser is tuned to a fixed wavelength which is close to a resonance between the upper state in the two-photon transition and a third state which has dipole-allowed transitions back to the ground state. At low concentrations the second laser leads to very large ac Stark shifts in the two-photon excitation and in the related resonantly enhanced multiphoton ionization. However, at high concentrations a destructive interference occurs involving the three-photon coupling between the third state and the ground state and the one-photon coupling due to the four-wave-mixing field at frequency 2${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{\mathit{L}1}$\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{\mathit{L}2}$. This interference leads to a pressure-dependent suppression of the amplitude for the third state. When this destructive interference occurs, the ac Stark shift due to the second laser undergoes a corresponding pressure-dependent suppression. The criteria for the pressure to be high enough to completely suppress the ac Stark shift is that the real part of phase mismatch \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Delta}k\ensuremath{\Vert} at the angular frequency 2${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{\mathit{L}1}$\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{\mathit{L}2}$ and (or) the absorption coefficient \ensuremath{\beta} at the same frequency should be very large, so that with unfocused focused beams \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Delta}k\ensuremath{\Vert}L>5[(${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\mathit{s}}^{(\mathrm{max})}$\ensuremath{\tau}${]}^{1/2}$, where L is the thickness of gas penetrated before the shift is measured, ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\mathit{s}}^{(\mathrm{max})}$ is the maximum ac Stark shift at very low pressure, and \ensuremath{\tau} is the pulse length of the lasers.At positions and concentrations such that 1\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Delta}k\ensuremath{\Vert}L\ensuremath{\le}2[(${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\mathit{s}}^{(\mathrm{max})}$\ensuremath{\tau})${]}^{1/2}$ the ac Stark shift is present but the two-photon excitation is suppressed due to a destructive interference between excitation by two photons from the first laser and by two-photon excitation between a four-wave-mixing photon and a photon from the second laser.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1993•17 citations

Two-color interference effect involving three-photon atomic excitation and four-wave mixing in crossed laser beams

Viktor E. Peet

Through multiphoton ionization measurements, the polarization effects in destructive quantum interference under three-photon resonant excitation have been studied. Recent observations [V. Peet, Phys. Rev. A 74, 033406 (2006)] have indicated that contrary to the well-known pattern of a total suppression of resonance excitation, the destructive interference becomes incomplete if three-photon transition is driven by crossed beams with orthogonal polarization planes. These observations have been tested for a more general case of two-color excitation and very similar polarization-dependent anomalies in the interference character have been registered. It has been shown that the destructive interference is modified and the resonance excitation does occur if two crossed laser beams have opposite circular polarizations. The pressure-induced evolution of the uncanceled ionization peaks has the ratio of blue shift to width close to 0.5 exactly as it is known for resonance ionization peaks registered under excitation by counterpropagating laser beams.

Physical Review A•Sep 25, 2007•3 citations

Consequences of induced transparency in a double-Λ scheme: Destructive interference in four-wave mixing

M. G. Payne, L. Deng

We investigate a four-state system interacting with long and short laser pulses in a weak probe beam approximation. We show that when all lasers are tuned to the exact unperturbed resonances, part of the four-wave mixing (FWM) field is strongly absorbed. The part that is not absorbed has the exact intensity required to destructively interfere with the excitation pathway involved in producing the FWM state. We show that with this three-photon destructive interference, the conversion efficiency can still be as high as 25%. Contrary to common belief, our calculation shows that this process, where an ideal one-photon electromagnetically induced transparency is established, is not most suitable for high-efficiency conversion. With appropriate phase matching and propagation distance, and when the three-photon destructive interference does not occur, we show that the photon flux conversion efficiency is independent of probe intensity and can be close to 100%. In addition, we show clearly that the conversion efficiency is not determined by the maximum atomic coherence between two lower excited states, as commonly believed. It is the combination of phase matching and constructive interference involving the two terms arising in producing the mixing wave that is the key element for the optimized FWM generation. Indeed, in this scheme no appreciable excited state is produced, so that the atomic coherence between states |0〉 and |2〉 is always very small.

arXiv:quant-ph/0203076•Physical Review A•Jun 3, 2002•53 citations
We present a theory for two- and three-photon excitation, optical shifting, and four-wave mixing when a first laser is tuned onto, or near, a two-photon resonance and a second much more intense laser is tuned near or on resonance between the two-photon resonance and a second excited state. When the second excited state has a dipole-allowed transition back to the ground state and the concentration is sufficiently high, a destructive interference is produced between three-photon coupling of the ground state and the second excited state and one-photon coupling between the same states by the internally generated four-wave mixing field. This interference leads to several striking effects. For instance, as the onset of the interference occurs, the optical shifts in the two-photon resonance excitation line shape become smaller in copropagating geometry so that the line shapes for multiphoton ionization enhanced by the two-photon resonance eventually become unaffected by the second laser. In the same range of concentrations the four-wave mixing field evolves to a concentration-independent intensity. With counterpropagating laser beams the line shape exhibits normal optical shifts like those observed for both copropagating and counterpropagating laser beams at very low concentrations. The theoretical work presented here extends our earlier works by including the effect of laser bandwidth and by removing the restriction of having the second laser be tuned far from three-photon resonance. In this way we have now included, as a special case, the effect of both laser bandwidth and interference on laser-induced transparency. Unlike other effects related to odd-photon destructive interference, the effect of a broad bandwidth is to bring about the predicted effects at much lower concentrations. Studies in rubidium show good agreement between theory and experiment for both ionization line shapes and four-wave mixing intensity as a function of concentration.
We report experimental results on two-color multiphoton ionization and four-wave-mixing production under conditions where one form of laser-induced transparency (LIT) occurs. Under the conditions of LIT, multiphoton-ionization line shapes obtained by tuning one laser through a two-photon resonance exhibit a pronounced Autler-Townes splitting at low concentrations, when a second laser couples the two-photon state to a third level. In this concentration region we observed a four-wave-mixing field that increased quadratically with concentration. As the concentration is increased the Autler-Townes splitting starts to decrease, and disappears completely as a critical concentration is reached. Simultaneously, the four-wave-mixing field intensity starts to level off and finally becomes concentration independent. These observations are explained in terms of odd-photon destructive interference between different excitation pathways. In rubidium, we demonstrate that above concentrations of n\ensuremath{\simeq}5\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}1014{10}^{14}1014 ${\mathrm{cm}}^{\mathrm{\ensuremath{-}}3}$ the four-wave-mixing field is concentration independent and the multiphoton-ionization line shape shows no Autler-Townes splitting, and the width of the line shape is determined by the laser bandwidth. The results presented here demonstrate that destructive interference significantly limits the high-efficiency and high-intensity nonlinear optical generation promised in early studies on LIT, at least for the multimode laser system used in the present experiment. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
We consider effects which occur when four-wave sum frequency generation and multiphoton ionization are induced by lasers tuned near a three-photon resonance and simultaneously near or at a dipole allowed four-photon resonance. In studies with unfocused laser beams, if the phase mismatch of the generated four-wave-mixing field is large and the related two-photon resonance for the absorption of a four-wave-mixing photon and a laser photon results in strong absorption of the four-wave-mixing field, a coherent cancellation occurs between the pumping of the resonance by two- and four-photon processes. This interference effect occurs when the first laser is tuned on either side of the three-photon resonance and \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Delta}kr{\mathit{k}}_{\mathit{r}}kr​L\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\gg}1, where \ensuremath{\Delta}kr{\mathit{k}}_{\mathit{r}}kr​ is the mismatch and L is the length of the path of the laser beams in the gas. With focused laser beams large differences occur between ionization with unidirectional beams and with counterpropagating laser beams when \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Delta}kr{\mathit{k}}_{\mathit{r}}kr​b\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\gg}1, where b is the confocal parameter of the focused laser beams. Strong absorption of the four-wave-mixing field is shown not to be necessary for strong destructive interference with focused laser beams when the phase mismatch is large. This work also suggests an explanation for earlier experiments where the presence of a four-photon resonance enabled the generation of third-harmonic light in a positively dispersive wavelength region. We argue that this process can occur when the laser used to achieve the four-photon resonance is focused on the small z (z is the coordinate in the direction of propagation) side of the focal point of the laser responsible for the third-harmonic generation. In this way the absorption of the third-harmonic light on one side of the focal point is made much stronger than on the other side. Correspondingly, contributions to the third-harmonic field from the two sides of the focal point are unequal and cannot undergo complete destructive interference as would otherwise occur in a positively dispersive region.
We report detailed experimental results in xenon that confirm theoretical predictions [Payne et al., Phys. Rev. A 48, 2334 (1993)] on the interference-based suppression of ac Stark shifting of even-photon resonances under circumstances where the shift is produced through strong coupling to a state that is also coupled back to the ground state. In the copropagating-beam configuration and in the pressure range of 0.5--250 Torr, the multiphoton ionization spectral line shape is unchanged regardless of the presence of the second laser field, i.e., the ac Stark shift introduced by the second laser is totally suppressed due to a complete destructive interference between two excitation pathways. In the counterpropagating-beam configuration, however, the ac Stark shift persists in the range of the pressure studied. By choosing a different set of energy levels where no four-wave-mixing field is permitted, we show that the very same ac Stark shift introduced by the second laser field persists even with copropagating-beam configuration, as predicted by theory.
We describe ac Stark shift production and measurement in a two-laser mode where a first laser is tuned through a two-photon resonance between the ground state and an excited state in order to record a line shape for the corresponding resonantly enhanced multiphoton ionization. A second laser is tuned to a fixed wavelength which is close to a resonance between the upper state in the two-photon transition and a third state which has dipole-allowed transitions back to the ground state. At low concentrations the second laser leads to very large ac Stark shifts in the two-photon excitation and in the related resonantly enhanced multiphoton ionization. However, at high concentrations a destructive interference occurs involving the three-photon coupling between the third state and the ground state and the one-photon coupling due to the four-wave-mixing field at frequency 2${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{\mathit{L}1}$\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{\mathit{L}2}$. This interference leads to a pressure-dependent suppression of the amplitude for the third state. When this destructive interference occurs, the ac Stark shift due to the second laser undergoes a corresponding pressure-dependent suppression. The criteria for the pressure to be high enough to completely suppress the ac Stark shift is that the real part of phase mismatch \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Delta}k\ensuremath{\Vert} at the angular frequency 2${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{\mathit{L}1}$\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\omega}}}_{\mathit{L}2}$ and (or) the absorption coefficient \ensuremath{\beta} at the same frequency should be very large, so that with unfocused focused beams \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Delta}k\ensuremath{\Vert}L>5[(${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\mathit{s}}^{(\mathrm{max})}$\ensuremath{\tau}]1/2{]}^{1/2}]1/2, where L is the thickness of gas penetrated before the shift is measured, ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\mathit{s}}^{(\mathrm{max})}$ is the maximum ac Stark shift at very low pressure, and \ensuremath{\tau} is the pulse length of the lasers.At positions and concentrations such that 1\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Delta}k\ensuremath{\Vert}L\ensuremath{\le}2[(${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{\mathit{s}}^{(\mathrm{max})}$\ensuremath{\tau})]1/2{]}^{1/2}]1/2 the ac Stark shift is present but the two-photon excitation is suppressed due to a destructive interference between excitation by two photons from the first laser and by two-photon excitation between a four-wave-mixing photon and a photon from the second laser.
Through multiphoton ionization measurements, the polarization effects in destructive quantum interference under three-photon resonant excitation have been studied. Recent observations [V. Peet, Phys. Rev. A 74, 033406 (2006)] have indicated that contrary to the well-known pattern of a total suppression of resonance excitation, the destructive interference becomes incomplete if three-photon transition is driven by crossed beams with orthogonal polarization planes. These observations have been tested for a more general case of two-color excitation and very similar polarization-dependent anomalies in the interference character have been registered. It has been shown that the destructive interference is modified and the resonance excitation does occur if two crossed laser beams have opposite circular polarizations. The pressure-induced evolution of the uncanceled ionization peaks has the ratio of blue shift to width close to 0.5 exactly as it is known for resonance ionization peaks registered under excitation by counterpropagating laser beams.
We investigate a four-state system interacting with long and short laser pulses in a weak probe beam approximation. We show that when all lasers are tuned to the exact unperturbed resonances, part of the four-wave mixing (FWM) field is strongly absorbed. The part that is not absorbed has the exact intensity required to destructively interfere with the excitation pathway involved in producing the FWM state. We show that with this three-photon destructive interference, the conversion efficiency can still be as high as 25%. Contrary to common belief, our calculation shows that this process, where an ideal one-photon electromagnetically induced transparency is established, is not most suitable for high-efficiency conversion. With appropriate phase matching and propagation distance, and when the three-photon destructive interference does not occur, we show that the photon flux conversion efficiency is independent of probe intensity and can be close to 100%. In addition, we show clearly that the conversion efficiency is not determined by the maximum atomic coherence between two lower excited states, as commonly believed. It is the combination of phase matching and constructive interference involving the two terms arising in producing the mixing wave that is the key element for the optimized FWM generation. Indeed, in this scheme no appreciable excited state is produced, so that the atomic coherence between states |0〉 and |2〉 is always very small.