In a recent letter [PRL 80 (1998) 3539] Fisher, Le Doussal and Monthus report new predictions for the persistence properties of Sinai's model, which they obtain by using an approximate real space renormalization group scheme. In this comment we show that these predictions can be derived in a rigorous and more transparent way by reducing the quantities of interest to particular statistical properties of a simple random walk in a homogeneous environment. We also point out that they are valid in a much more general context: our results are neither restricted to the random force model but are valid for any asymmetric hopping model, nor to the vicinity of the critical point.
Abstract Random walks in a finite Abelian group G are studied. They use Markov chains with doubly stochastic transition matrices, in a Birkhoff subpolytope B ( G ) associated with the group G . It is shown that all future probability vectors belong to a polytope which does not depend on the transition matrices, and which shrinks during time evolution. Various quantities are used to describe the probability vectors: the majorization preorder, Lorenz values and the Gini index, entropic quantities, and the total variation distance. The general results are applied to the additive group Z ( d ) , and to the Heisenberg–Weyl group H W ( d ) / Z ( d ) . A physical implementation of random walks in Z ( d ) that involves a sequence of non-selective projective measurements, is discussed. A physical implementation of random walks in the Heisenberg–Weyl group H W ( d ) / Z ( d ) using a sequence of non-selective positive operator-valued measure measurements with coherent states, is also presented.
Random walks in a finite Abelian group
G are studied. They use Markov chains with doubly stochastic transition matrices, in a Birkhoff subpolytope
B(G) associated with the group
G. It is shown that all future probability vectors belong to a polytope which does not depend on the transition matrices, and which shrinks during time evolution. Various quantities are used to describe the probability vectors: the majorization preorder, Lorenz values and the Gini index, entropic quantities, and the total variation distance. The general results are applied to the additive group
Z(d), and to the Heisenberg-Weyl group
HW(d)/Z(d). A physical implementation of random walks in
Z(d) that involves a sequence of non-selective projective measurements, is discussed. A physical implementation of random walks in the Heisenberg-Weyl group
HW(d)/Z(d) using a sequence of non-selective POVM measurements with coherent states, is also presented.