Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Theoretical Physics

Testing for Classicality of a Physical System

Dietmar W. Dorninger, Helmut Länger

Published Dec 5, 2012• 9 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/s10773-012-1429-7

Related papers

Elementary test for nonclassicality based on measurements of position and momentum

Luca Fresta, Johannes Borregaard, Anders Søndberg Sørensen

We generalize a nonclassicality test described by Kot et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 233601 (2012)], which can be used to rule out any classical description of a physical system. The test is based on measurements of quadrature operators and works by proving a contradiction with the classical description in terms of a probability distribution in phase space. As opposed to the previous work, we generalize the test to include states without rotational symmetry in phase space. Furthermore, we compare the performance of the nonclassicality test with classical tomography methods based on the inverse Radon transform, which can also be used to establish the quantum nature of a physical system. In particular, we consider a nonclassicality test based on the so-called filtered back-projection formula. We show that the general nonclassicality test is conceptually simpler, requires less assumptions on the system, and is statistically more reliable than the tests based on the filtered back-projection formula. As a specific example, we derive the optimal test for quadrature squeezed single-photon states and show that the efficiency of the test does not change with the degree of squeezing.

arXiv:1508.00828•Physical Review A•Dec 8, 2015•5 citations

Probability measurements characterizing the classicality of a physical system

Dietmar W. Dorninger, Helmut Länger

Reports on Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 2014•7 citations

Experimental non-classicality of an indivisible system

Radek Łapkiewicz, Peizhe Li, Christoph Schaeff +4 more

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 23, 2011•1 citation

Foundations for Quantum Mechanics

Robin Giles

A discussion is given of the structure of a physical theory and an ``ideal form'' for such a theory is proposed. The essential feature is that all concepts should be defined in operational terms. Quantum (and classical) mechanics is then formulated in this way (the formulation being, however, restricted to the kinematical theory). This requires the introduction of the concept of a mixed test, related to a pure test (or ``question'') just as a mixed state is related to a pure state. In the new formulation, the primitive concepts are not states and observables but certain operationally accessible mixed states and tests called physical. The notion of a C*-system is introduced; each such system is characterized by a certain C*-algebra. The structure of a general C*-system is then studied, all concepts being defined in terms of physical states and tests. It is shown first how pure states and tests can be so defined. The quantum analog of the phase space of classical mechanics is then constructed and on it is built a mathematical structure, called a q-topology, which is a quantum analog of the topology of classical phase space. Mathematically, a q-topology is related to a noncommutative C*-algebra as an ordinary topology is related to a commutative C*-algebra. Some properties of the q-topology of a C*-system are given. An appendix contains some physically motivated examples illustrating the theory.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jul 1, 1970•132 citations

Degree of information accessibility: a precursor of the quantum--classical transition

Junior, J. G. Oliveira, J. G. Peixoto de Faria, Maria Carolina Nemes

One of the fundamental problems with the interpretation of Quantum Mechanics, according to Bohr, is the fact that "our usual description of physical phenomena is based entirely on the idea that the phenomena concerned may be observed without disturbing them appreciably". Furthermore in his articles discussing the subject Bohr argues that the action of the probe will be affected by the system and inasmuch the system will be affected by the probe. Specifically in Gedanken experiments he tests the wave-particle duality of the system and implicitly assumes that the probe is also a quantum system. A universal character can only be attributed to Quantum Mechanics provided a complementarity relation is also valid for the probe. As a consequence the state system-probe becomes entangled. In the past fourty years complementarity tests have been proposed. However, much less attention has been paid to the study of an arbitrary probe system. In the present contribution, we fill in this gap and show that the key ingredient for the quantum-classical transition is not necessarily the information generated by the system-probe interaction but rather by its accessibility. Our results have been successfully tested in the interferometric experiment. Our results also allow for a simple physical interpretation of the physics of Ramsey Zones where one photon (average) interacts with a two level atom in a classical manner, i.e., no entanglement is generated.

arXiv:1101.4694•Jan 25, 2011•0 citations

Functional Interpretations of Classical Systems

Justus Diller

De Gruyter eBooks•Dec 31, 2010•0 citations
We generalize a nonclassicality test described by Kot et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 233601 (2012)], which can be used to rule out any classical description of a physical system. The test is based on measurements of quadrature operators and works by proving a contradiction with the classical description in terms of a probability distribution in phase space. As opposed to the previous work, we generalize the test to include states without rotational symmetry in phase space. Furthermore, we compare the performance of the nonclassicality test with classical tomography methods based on the inverse Radon transform, which can also be used to establish the quantum nature of a physical system. In particular, we consider a nonclassicality test based on the so-called filtered back-projection formula. We show that the general nonclassicality test is conceptually simpler, requires less assumptions on the system, and is statistically more reliable than the tests based on the filtered back-projection formula. As a specific example, we derive the optimal test for quadrature squeezed single-photon states and show that the efficiency of the test does not change with the degree of squeezing.
A discussion is given of the structure of a physical theory and an ``ideal form'' for such a theory is proposed. The essential feature is that all concepts should be defined in operational terms. Quantum (and classical) mechanics is then formulated in this way (the formulation being, however, restricted to the kinematical theory). This requires the introduction of the concept of a mixed test, related to a pure test (or ``question'') just as a mixed state is related to a pure state. In the new formulation, the primitive concepts are not states and observables but certain operationally accessible mixed states and tests called physical. The notion of a C*-system is introduced; each such system is characterized by a certain C*-algebra. The structure of a general C*-system is then studied, all concepts being defined in terms of physical states and tests. It is shown first how pure states and tests can be so defined. The quantum analog of the phase space of classical mechanics is then constructed and on it is built a mathematical structure, called a q-topology, which is a quantum analog of the topology of classical phase space. Mathematically, a q-topology is related to a noncommutative C*-algebra as an ordinary topology is related to a commutative C*-algebra. Some properties of the q-topology of a C*-system are given. An appendix contains some physically motivated examples illustrating the theory.
One of the fundamental problems with the interpretation of Quantum Mechanics, according to Bohr, is the fact that "our usual description of physical phenomena is based entirely on the idea that the phenomena concerned may be observed without disturbing them appreciably". Furthermore in his articles discussing the subject Bohr argues that the action of the probe will be affected by the system and inasmuch the system will be affected by the probe. Specifically in Gedanken experiments he tests the wave-particle duality of the system and implicitly assumes that the probe is also a quantum system. A universal character can only be attributed to Quantum Mechanics provided a complementarity relation is also valid for the probe. As a consequence the state system-probe becomes entangled. In the past fourty years complementarity tests have been proposed. However, much less attention has been paid to the study of an arbitrary probe system. In the present contribution, we fill in this gap and show that the key ingredient for the quantum-classical transition is not necessarily the information generated by the system-probe interaction but rather by its accessibility. Our results have been successfully tested in the interferometric experiment. Our results also allow for a simple physical interpretation of the physics of Ramsey Zones where one photon (average) interacts with a two level atom in a classical manner, i.e., no entanglement is generated.