Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Comment on ‘‘Self-field quantum electrodynamics: The two-level atom’’

Michael D. Crisp

Published Apr 1, 1991• 3 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Barut and Dowling [Phys. Rev. A 41, 2284 (1990)] have raised questions concerning the ``illegal use'' of superposition in the neoclassical radiation theory of Crisp and Jaynes [Phys. Rev. 179, 1253 (1969)]. They also continue to use an expansion for their wave function that has been questioned as to its validity and interpretations [Bialynicki-Birula, Phys. Rev. A 34, 3500 (1986)]. Both of these points will be discussed in this Comment.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.43.4058

Related papers

Comment on “Enhancing Acceleration Radiation from Ground-State Atoms via Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics”

B. L. Hu, Albert Roura

This is a comment on [Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 243004 (2003)] by Marlan O. Scully, Vitaly V. Kocharovsky, Alexey Belyanin, Edward Fry and Federico Capasso (quant-ph/0305178).

arXiv:quant-ph/0402088•Physical Review Letters•Sep 17, 2004•36 citations

Self-field quantum electrodynamics: The two-level atom

A. O. Barut, Jonathan P. Dowling

We use a self-field approach to quantum electrodynamics (QED) to show how one may obtain spontaneous emission and the Lamb shift in a two-level atom without second quantization of the radiation field. In addition, we compare the self-field formalism to that of the neoclassical theory of electrodynamics advanced by Crisp and Jaynes [Phys. Rev. 179, 1253 (1969)]. We show that the neoclassical model can be obtained from the self-field approach used here, but that the two are not equivalent. In particular, the self-field approach appears to give a more complete description of radiative processes. Finally, we show that the neoclassical theory's prediction of a nonexponential ``chirruped'' decay is most likely a mathematical artifact of the improper application of the superposition principle in a nonlinear model where such a principle does not hold. A correct treatment with self-field QED yields the usual exponential decay dynamics.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1990•34 citations

Comment on “Electromagnetic Wave Dynamics in Matter-Wave Superradiant Scattering”

Wolfgang Ketterle

A Comment on the Letter by L. Deng, M. G. Payne, and E. W. Hagley, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104 050402 (2010). The authors of the Letter offer a Reply.

Physical Review Letters•Mar 15, 2011•5 citations

Comment on “Lagrange Equilibrium Points in Celestial Mechanics and Nonspreading Wave Packets for Strongly Driven Rydberg Electrons”

David G. Farrelly, Ernestine Lee, T. Uzer

A Comment on the Letter by Iwo Bialynicki-Birula, Maciej Kaliński, and J. H. Eberly, Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 1777 (1994). The authors of the Letter offer a Reply.Received 10 March 1995DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.75.972©1995 American Physical Society

Physical Review Letters•Jul 31, 1995•32 citations

Comment on “Quantum-Mechanical Position Operator in Extended Systems”

J. Žák

A Comment on the Letter by Raffaele Resta, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 1800 (1998).Received 29 October 1999DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.85.1138©2000 American Physical Society

Physical Review Letters•Jul 31, 2000•26 citations

On the classical limit of quantum electrodynamics

Stig Stenholm

We write the density matrix of a two-level atom interacting with a single-mode radiation field in terms of the average photon number and the degree of offdiagonality. The latter represents quantum correlations, which are transformed to a phase variable analogous to the phase of the classical field. Using a consistent expansion in the inverse powers of the square root of the average photon number we obtain the ordinary classical limit. The surprising feature which emerges is that the zero point energy contributes to the classical field parameter as efficiently as the photon occupation number; this result agrees with one derived differently by Bialynicki-Birula and Bialynicka-Birula.

Annales de Physique•Jan 1, 1985•6 citations
Barut and Dowling [Phys. Rev. A 41, 2284 (1990)] have raised questions concerning the ``illegal use'' of superposition in the neoclassical radiation theory of Crisp and Jaynes [Phys. Rev. 179, 1253 (1969)]. They also continue to use an expansion for their wave function that has been questioned as to its validity and interpretations [Bialynicki-Birula, Phys. Rev. A 34, 3500 (1986)]. Both of these points will be discussed in this Comment.
We use a self-field approach to quantum electrodynamics (QED) to show how one may obtain spontaneous emission and the Lamb shift in a two-level atom without second quantization of the radiation field. In addition, we compare the self-field formalism to that of the neoclassical theory of electrodynamics advanced by Crisp and Jaynes [Phys. Rev. 179, 1253 (1969)]. We show that the neoclassical model can be obtained from the self-field approach used here, but that the two are not equivalent. In particular, the self-field approach appears to give a more complete description of radiative processes. Finally, we show that the neoclassical theory's prediction of a nonexponential ``chirruped'' decay is most likely a mathematical artifact of the improper application of the superposition principle in a nonlinear model where such a principle does not hold. A correct treatment with self-field QED yields the usual exponential decay dynamics.
We write the density matrix of a two-level atom interacting with a single-mode radiation field in terms of the average photon number and the degree of offdiagonality. The latter represents quantum correlations, which are transformed to a phase variable analogous to the phase of the classical field. Using a consistent expansion in the inverse powers of the square root of the average photon number we obtain the ordinary classical limit. The surprising feature which emerges is that the zero point energy contributes to the classical field parameter as efficiently as the photon occupation number; this result agrees with one derived differently by Bialynicki-Birula and Bialynicka-Birula.