Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics

Saturated FDFWM lineshapes and intensities: theory and application to quantitative measurements in flames

Brigitte Attal‐Trétout, H. Bervas, J. P. Taran, S. Le Boiteux, Paul L. Kelley, T. Kenneth Gustafson

Published Feb 14, 1997• 31 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The present paper deals with a three-level model of interaction with three cross-polarized and co-propagating fields having the same frequency. The two pump waves have arbitrary intensities and the third one (the probe wave) is assumed to be non-saturating. Using the radiative renormalization method, density matrix equations are solved analytically. The forward degenerate four-wave mixing (FDFWM) signal is calculated under thermodynamic conditions where collisional and Doppler broadenings are comparable. The calculation also takes into account crossed-polarization effects. The FDFWM intensity is computed as a function of power densities and pressure. FDFWM experimental spectra of the - (0 - 0) band of OH obtained in a welding torch flame are compared to theoretical profiles. For incident laser intensities in the range of a few , a good agreement is obtained between calculated and experimental profiles. Discrepancies arise under stronger conditions of saturation, showing the limits of application of our model. However, because there is little virtue in using higher laser powers, the model should be extremely useful in practical applications. In particular, we demonstrate that the signal intensity is optimal and the pressure dependence is minimized when the saturation parameter is unity.

DOI
10.1088/0953-4075/30/3/008

Related papers

Saturation effects in gas-phase degenerate four-wave mixing spectroscopy: nonperturbative calculations

Robert P. Lucht, Roger L. Farrow, David J. Rakestraw

Saturation effects in gas-phase degenerate four-wave mixing (DFWM) are investigated for conditions of interest for diagnostic applications in flames and plasmas. In particular, the case in which Doppler and collisional broadening are comparable, as is often the case for flame species such as NO and OH, is investigated. DFWM line shapes and signal intensities are calculated nonperturbatively and compared with high-resolution laser measurements. In the nonperturbative calculations the time-dependent density-matrix equations for a two-level system interacting with three laser fields are integrated directly on a grid of spatial locations along the phase-matching axis. The electric-field amplitude for the DFWM signal is determined by multiplying the time-varying, laser-induced polarization at each grid point by the appropriate phase factor and then by summing over all grid points. The calculations are in excellent agreement with measurements of DFWM line shapes and signal intensities for NO in a buffer gas of He over a wide range of He pressure. Under saturation conditions the pressure dependence of the DFWM signal is reduced greatly compared with the unsaturated case. The signal level is still dependent on the ratio of pure dephasing to quenching collisions, even for saturation conditions. From the standpoint of minimal dependence on collisional processes it appears that operation with pump-laser intensities approximately equal to the saturation intensity is optimal. The dependence of the DFWM line shape and signal intensity on the ratio of probe to pump-laser intensity is also investigated.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Sep 1, 1993•75 citations

Forward degenerate four wave mixing in two-level Doppler broadened absorbers: analytical calculation

Dai‐Hyuk Yu, Jai-Hyung Lee, Joon-Sung Chang +1 more

Nowadays degenerate four wave mixing (DFWM) with forward geometry (FDFWM) has found increasing usage, for example, in the gas phase detection. In the fields of theoretical development of DFWM, most of the studies have been concentrated on the understanding of phase-conjugated DFWM. However, few theories have dealt with FDFWM. These models calculated the signal directly from the off-diagonal element of the density matrix by assuming optically thin medium. In the paper we obtain a theoretical model for FDFWM in Doppler broadened two-level absorbers including propagation effect and discuss the Doppler effect on the signal intensity and lineshape. Assuming that probe and signal field amplitudes are small compared with those of the pump fields and pump field amplitudes are constant in the interaction volume, we obtain the following coupled equations from the Maxwell equation using the slowly varying envelope approximation and the paraxial approximation.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Pacific Rim (CLEO-PR)•Jan 20, 2003•0 citations

Effect of Doppler broadening on quantitative concentration measurements with degenerate four-wave mixing spectroscopy

Thomas A. Reichardt, Robert P. Lucht

The effect of Doppler broadening on degenerate four-wave mixing (DFWM) signal intensities in the regime of high pump and probe laser intensities is investigated theoretically. DFWM reflectivities are calculated by solving the time-dependent density-matrix equations for a two-level system interacting with three laser fields. The density-matrix equations are integrated directly in the time domain on a grid of spatial locations along the phase-matching axis; the DFWM signal level is then calculated by summation of the polarization contribution (with the appropriate phase factor) from each of the spatial grid points. For the case in which the Doppler and the collisional linewidths are comparable, the DFWM reflectivity is found to be inversely proportional to the factor 1 + (bΔωD/ΔωC)2, where ΔωD is the Doppler width, ΔωC is the collisional width, and b is weakly dependent on the pump and the probe laser powers. We developed an analytical expression for the reflectivity of a line that is both collision and Doppler broadened by dividing the widely used Abrams and Lind expression for homogeneous reflectivity Rhom by the factor 1 + (bΔωD/ΔωC)2. This modified reflectivity expression is found to give accurate results for the DFWM reflectivity over a wide range of values for the ratio of Doppler to collisional width. With this modified Abrams–Lind expression, strategies for quantitative DFWM concentration measurements in flames and plasmas are proposed and analyzed. We conclude that, by selection of the appropriate rotational transition, a DFWM reflectivity that is directly proportional to the square of the total species number density can be obtained over a wide range of temperature for constant-laser-intensity spatial profile mapping in flames.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Jun 1, 1996•27 citations

Forward degenerate four-wave-mixing spectra of NO in the strong-field regime including polarization, line coupling, and multipole effects. I. Theory

V. Krüger, M. Dumont, S. Le Boiteux +3 more

In the present paper, we investigate the saturation mechanism of FDFWM (forward degenerate four-wave-mixing) spectra, observed with different polarizations of the input beams, line coupling, and Doppler effect. Our theoretical approach uses a nonperturbative resolution of the density matrix equations, decomposed on the irreducible tensor basis. This formalism greatly simplifies analytical expressions and allows for a correct treatment of magnetic sublevels structure in a three-J level system. Systematic calculations of the FDFWM signal for specific NO lines are performed to characterize intensities and line shapes as a function of saturation. Relative intensities exhibit strong changes in the intermediate regime of saturation further supporting the necessity for using such a complete model. Under saturating conditions, line coupling is shown to distort the spectra, according to the type of transition and the polarization configuration. This effect is observed in the following paper [V. Kr\"uger et al., paper II, Phys. Rev. A 2001 (to be published)], where saturated experimental spectra of NO are presented and interpreted for two polarization configurations of interest for diagnostic purposes.

Physical Review A•Jun 13, 2001•10 citations

Resonant degenerate four-wave mixing spectroscopy of transitions with degenerate energy levels: Saturation and polarization effects

Thomas A. Reichardt, Robert P. Lucht

The physics of the degenerate four-wave mixing process for resonant transitions between two degenerate energy levels is investigated by direct numerical integration of the time-dependent density matrix equations. The Zeeman structure of the upper and lower energy levels is included in a multistate formulation of the density matrix equations. The inclusion of the Zeeman structure enables the investigation of the degenerate four-wave mixing process for different polarization configurations of the forward pump, backward pump, and probe beams. Saturation curves and lineshapes are calculated for different polarization configurations and for numerous low-J transitions. At low laser intensity, the results of our calculations are in excellent agreement with perturbation theory in terms of the relative intensities of the degenerate four-wave mixing signal for linear polarization configurations. As the laser intensity increases and the resonance starts to saturate, we find in general that the relative degenerate four-wave mixing reflectivity increases for the crossed polarization configurations compared to the parallel polarization configuration because the saturation intensity is higher. However, for some resonance transitions, some of the crossed polarization configurations saturate at lower laser intensities than the parallel polarization configuration, even though the reflectivity for these crossed polarization configurations is much lower than for the parallel polarization configuration in the perturbative intensity limit. This result is explained in terms of the coupling of the various Zeeman states during the degenerate four-wave mixing interaction for specific polarization configurations. The effect of saturation on the resonance line shapes for the different polarization configurations is also investigated. Finally, a limited number of calculations are performed for resonances that are Doppler broadened as well as collision broadened. The effect of saturation on the reflectivity of the crossed polarization configurations compared to the parallel polarization configuration is even more significant for resonances with comparable Doppler and collisional broadening.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 8, 1999•22 citations

Theoretical investigation of the forward phase-matched geometry for degenerate four-wave mixing spectroscopy

Thomas A. Reichardt, Robert P. Lucht, Paul M. Danehy +1 more

We examine theoretically the degenerate four-wave mixing (DFWM) signal intensities and line shapes obtained with the forward phase-matched geometry in which all beams propagate in the same direction and compare the results to those of the phase-conjugate geometry with counterpropagating pump beams. To examine the forward phase-matched geometry, we modify a theoretical approach used previously to calculate phase-conjugate DFWM signal intensities. This theoretical approach, which involves numerical integration of the time-dependent density-matrix equations, is validated for the forward phase-matched geometry by comparison of our calculated line shapes to both a perturbative solution and to experimental data. This methodology is then used to compare the signal intensities and line shapes obtained with the forward phase-matched geometry and the phase-conjugate geometry in the perturbative (low laser power) and saturated (high laser power) regimes. In the perturbative regime the forward phase-matched signal exhibits less sensitivity to the Doppler linewidth. At pump laser intensities approximately equal to the saturation intensity the signal for the forward phase-matched geometry is stronger than that for the phase-conjugate geometry for primarily Doppler-broadened resonances, assuming the same probe volume for both geometries. These advantages warrant further investigations employing the forward phase-matched configuration for DFWM measurements of gas-phase species.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Oct 1, 1998•15 citations
The present paper deals with a three-level model of interaction with three cross-polarized and co-propagating fields having the same frequency. The two pump waves have arbitrary intensities and the third one (the probe wave) is assumed to be non-saturating. Using the radiative renormalization method, density matrix equations are solved analytically. The forward degenerate four-wave mixing (FDFWM) signal is calculated under thermodynamic conditions where collisional and Doppler broadenings are comparable. The calculation also takes into account crossed-polarization effects. The FDFWM intensity is computed as a function of power densities and pressure. FDFWM experimental spectra of the - (0 - 0) band of OH obtained in a welding torch flame are compared to theoretical profiles. For incident laser intensities in the range of a few , a good agreement is obtained between calculated and experimental profiles. Discrepancies arise under stronger conditions of saturation, showing the limits of application of our model. However, because there is little virtue in using higher laser powers, the model should be extremely useful in practical applications. In particular, we demonstrate that the signal intensity is optimal and the pressure dependence is minimized when the saturation parameter is unity.
Saturation effects in gas-phase degenerate four-wave mixing (DFWM) are investigated for conditions of interest for diagnostic applications in flames and plasmas. In particular, the case in which Doppler and collisional broadening are comparable, as is often the case for flame species such as NO and OH, is investigated. DFWM line shapes and signal intensities are calculated nonperturbatively and compared with high-resolution laser measurements. In the nonperturbative calculations the time-dependent density-matrix equations for a two-level system interacting with three laser fields are integrated directly on a grid of spatial locations along the phase-matching axis. The electric-field amplitude for the DFWM signal is determined by multiplying the time-varying, laser-induced polarization at each grid point by the appropriate phase factor and then by summing over all grid points. The calculations are in excellent agreement with measurements of DFWM line shapes and signal intensities for NO in a buffer gas of He over a wide range of He pressure. Under saturation conditions the pressure dependence of the DFWM signal is reduced greatly compared with the unsaturated case. The signal level is still dependent on the ratio of pure dephasing to quenching collisions, even for saturation conditions. From the standpoint of minimal dependence on collisional processes it appears that operation with pump-laser intensities approximately equal to the saturation intensity is optimal. The dependence of the DFWM line shape and signal intensity on the ratio of probe to pump-laser intensity is also investigated.
Nowadays degenerate four wave mixing (DFWM) with forward geometry (FDFWM) has found increasing usage, for example, in the gas phase detection. In the fields of theoretical development of DFWM, most of the studies have been concentrated on the understanding of phase-conjugated DFWM. However, few theories have dealt with FDFWM. These models calculated the signal directly from the off-diagonal element of the density matrix by assuming optically thin medium. In the paper we obtain a theoretical model for FDFWM in Doppler broadened two-level absorbers including propagation effect and discuss the Doppler effect on the signal intensity and lineshape. Assuming that probe and signal field amplitudes are small compared with those of the pump fields and pump field amplitudes are constant in the interaction volume, we obtain the following coupled equations from the Maxwell equation using the slowly varying envelope approximation and the paraxial approximation.
The effect of Doppler broadening on degenerate four-wave mixing (DFWM) signal intensities in the regime of high pump and probe laser intensities is investigated theoretically. DFWM reflectivities are calculated by solving the time-dependent density-matrix equations for a two-level system interacting with three laser fields. The density-matrix equations are integrated directly in the time domain on a grid of spatial locations along the phase-matching axis; the DFWM signal level is then calculated by summation of the polarization contribution (with the appropriate phase factor) from each of the spatial grid points. For the case in which the Doppler and the collisional linewidths are comparable, the DFWM reflectivity is found to be inversely proportional to the factor 1 + (bΔωD/ΔωC)2, where ΔωD is the Doppler width, ΔωC is the collisional width, and b is weakly dependent on the pump and the probe laser powers. We developed an analytical expression for the reflectivity of a line that is both collision and Doppler broadened by dividing the widely used Abrams and Lind expression for homogeneous reflectivity Rhom by the factor 1 + (bΔωD/ΔωC)2. This modified reflectivity expression is found to give accurate results for the DFWM reflectivity over a wide range of values for the ratio of Doppler to collisional width. With this modified Abrams–Lind expression, strategies for quantitative DFWM concentration measurements in flames and plasmas are proposed and analyzed. We conclude that, by selection of the appropriate rotational transition, a DFWM reflectivity that is directly proportional to the square of the total species number density can be obtained over a wide range of temperature for constant-laser-intensity spatial profile mapping in flames.
In the present paper, we investigate the saturation mechanism of FDFWM (forward degenerate four-wave-mixing) spectra, observed with different polarizations of the input beams, line coupling, and Doppler effect. Our theoretical approach uses a nonperturbative resolution of the density matrix equations, decomposed on the irreducible tensor basis. This formalism greatly simplifies analytical expressions and allows for a correct treatment of magnetic sublevels structure in a three-J level system. Systematic calculations of the FDFWM signal for specific NO lines are performed to characterize intensities and line shapes as a function of saturation. Relative intensities exhibit strong changes in the intermediate regime of saturation further supporting the necessity for using such a complete model. Under saturating conditions, line coupling is shown to distort the spectra, according to the type of transition and the polarization configuration. This effect is observed in the following paper [V. Kr\"uger et al., paper II, Phys. Rev. A 2001 (to be published)], where saturated experimental spectra of NO are presented and interpreted for two polarization configurations of interest for diagnostic purposes.
The physics of the degenerate four-wave mixing process for resonant transitions between two degenerate energy levels is investigated by direct numerical integration of the time-dependent density matrix equations. The Zeeman structure of the upper and lower energy levels is included in a multistate formulation of the density matrix equations. The inclusion of the Zeeman structure enables the investigation of the degenerate four-wave mixing process for different polarization configurations of the forward pump, backward pump, and probe beams. Saturation curves and lineshapes are calculated for different polarization configurations and for numerous low-J transitions. At low laser intensity, the results of our calculations are in excellent agreement with perturbation theory in terms of the relative intensities of the degenerate four-wave mixing signal for linear polarization configurations. As the laser intensity increases and the resonance starts to saturate, we find in general that the relative degenerate four-wave mixing reflectivity increases for the crossed polarization configurations compared to the parallel polarization configuration because the saturation intensity is higher. However, for some resonance transitions, some of the crossed polarization configurations saturate at lower laser intensities than the parallel polarization configuration, even though the reflectivity for these crossed polarization configurations is much lower than for the parallel polarization configuration in the perturbative intensity limit. This result is explained in terms of the coupling of the various Zeeman states during the degenerate four-wave mixing interaction for specific polarization configurations. The effect of saturation on the resonance line shapes for the different polarization configurations is also investigated. Finally, a limited number of calculations are performed for resonances that are Doppler broadened as well as collision broadened. The effect of saturation on the reflectivity of the crossed polarization configurations compared to the parallel polarization configuration is even more significant for resonances with comparable Doppler and collisional broadening.
We examine theoretically the degenerate four-wave mixing (DFWM) signal intensities and line shapes obtained with the forward phase-matched geometry in which all beams propagate in the same direction and compare the results to those of the phase-conjugate geometry with counterpropagating pump beams. To examine the forward phase-matched geometry, we modify a theoretical approach used previously to calculate phase-conjugate DFWM signal intensities. This theoretical approach, which involves numerical integration of the time-dependent density-matrix equations, is validated for the forward phase-matched geometry by comparison of our calculated line shapes to both a perturbative solution and to experimental data. This methodology is then used to compare the signal intensities and line shapes obtained with the forward phase-matched geometry and the phase-conjugate geometry in the perturbative (low laser power) and saturated (high laser power) regimes. In the perturbative regime the forward phase-matched signal exhibits less sensitivity to the Doppler linewidth. At pump laser intensities approximately equal to the saturation intensity the signal for the forward phase-matched geometry is stronger than that for the phase-conjugate geometry for primarily Doppler-broadened resonances, assuming the same probe volume for both geometries. These advantages warrant further investigations employing the forward phase-matched configuration for DFWM measurements of gas-phase species.