Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations of Physics

?Special? states in quantum measurement apparatus: Structural requirements for the recovery of standard probabilities

Lawrence S. Schulman

Published Aug 1, 1991• 1 citation
Publisher
DOI
10.1007/bf00733216

Related papers

Conditional Probabilities and Collapse in Quantum Measurements

Roberto Laura, Leonardo Vanni

arXiv:0801.1805•International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Jan 29, 2008•26 citations

The Problem of Measurement

Eugene Paul Wigner

The standard theory of measurements in quantum mechanics is reviewed with special emphasis on the conceptual and epistemological implications. It is concluded that the standard theory remains the only one which is compatible with present quantum mechanics. Hence, if one wants to avoid the conclusion that quantum mechanics only gives probability connections between subsequent observations, the quantum-mechanical equations would have to be modified. Particular attention is paid to the case that the measuring apparatus is macroscopic and its state vector not accurately known before the measurement.

American Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1963•844 citations

State-Dependent Measurement Statistics and Martingale Breaking in Continuous Quantum Measurement

Zelic, Sol J

This work identifies a minimal mechanism by which the martingale structure enforcing Born-rule invariance in continuous quantum measurement can fail. In standard quantum filtering, conditional probabilities are martingales with respect to the measurement record, guaranteeing ensemble-level Born-rule conservation. We show that if short-time likelihood diffusion inferred from the record depends weakly on the conditional state, quadratic variation terms generate a deterministic drift that breaks the martingale property while preserving normalization and boundary invariance of probabilities. Starting from Bayesian updating in a pointer basis, we derive the effective stochastic dynamics for diagonal probabilities and prove that the resulting statistics cannot be reproduced by any fixed, state-independent POVM. A micro-to-effective toy model demonstrates how marginalization over an unobserved apparatus variable produces the required state-dependent diffusion. The results clarify how nonlinear or resource-limited measurement chains can yield effective deviations from standard quantum measurement statistics without modifying microscopic unitary dynamics.

•Dec 1, 2025•0 citations

Measurement problem in quantum mechanics: Characteristics of an apparatus

Deepak Kumar

Pramana•Nov 1, 1998•1 citation

Abundance of special states

Lawrence S. Schulman

Pure quantum evolution is deterministic, ψ → exp (—iHt/ħ)ψ , but as for classical mechanics probability enters because a given macroscopic initial condition contains microscopic states that lead to different outcomes; the relative probability of those outcomes equals the relative abundance of the microscopic states for each outcome. This is the postulated basis for the recovery of the usual quantum probabilities, as discussed in Chapter 6. In this chapter we take up the question of whether the allowable microstates (the ‘special’ states) do indeed come with the correct abundance. To recap: ‘special’ states are microstates not leading to superpositions of macroscopically different states (‘grotesque’ states). For a given experiment and for each macroscopically distinct outcome of that experiment these states form a subspace. We wish to show that the dimension of that subspace is the relative probability of that outcome. This is an ambitious goal, especially considering the effort needed to establish that there are any special states—the subject of Chapter 7. As remarked there, the special states exhibited are likely to be only a small and atypical fraction of all special states in the physical apparatus being modeled (e.g., the cloud chamber). In one example (the decay model) there is a remarkable matching of dimension and conventional probability, but I would not make too much of that. What is especially challenging about the present task is that we seek a universal distribution.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 31, 1997•0 citations

Quantum structures due to fluctuations of the measurement situation

Diederik Aerts

International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Dec 1, 1993•37 citations
The standard theory of measurements in quantum mechanics is reviewed with special emphasis on the conceptual and epistemological implications. It is concluded that the standard theory remains the only one which is compatible with present quantum mechanics. Hence, if one wants to avoid the conclusion that quantum mechanics only gives probability connections between subsequent observations, the quantum-mechanical equations would have to be modified. Particular attention is paid to the case that the measuring apparatus is macroscopic and its state vector not accurately known before the measurement.
This work identifies a minimal mechanism by which the martingale structure enforcing Born-rule invariance in continuous quantum measurement can fail. In standard quantum filtering, conditional probabilities are martingales with respect to the measurement record, guaranteeing ensemble-level Born-rule conservation. We show that if short-time likelihood diffusion inferred from the record depends weakly on the conditional state, quadratic variation terms generate a deterministic drift that breaks the martingale property while preserving normalization and boundary invariance of probabilities. Starting from Bayesian updating in a pointer basis, we derive the effective stochastic dynamics for diagonal probabilities and prove that the resulting statistics cannot be reproduced by any fixed, state-independent POVM. A micro-to-effective toy model demonstrates how marginalization over an unobserved apparatus variable produces the required state-dependent diffusion. The results clarify how nonlinear or resource-limited measurement chains can yield effective deviations from standard quantum measurement statistics without modifying microscopic unitary dynamics.
Pure quantum evolution is deterministic, ψ → exp (—iHt/ħ)ψ , but as for classical mechanics probability enters because a given macroscopic initial condition contains microscopic states that lead to different outcomes; the relative probability of those outcomes equals the relative abundance of the microscopic states for each outcome. This is the postulated basis for the recovery of the usual quantum probabilities, as discussed in Chapter 6. In this chapter we take up the question of whether the allowable microstates (the ‘special’ states) do indeed come with the correct abundance. To recap: ‘special’ states are microstates not leading to superpositions of macroscopically different states (‘grotesque’ states). For a given experiment and for each macroscopically distinct outcome of that experiment these states form a subspace. We wish to show that the dimension of that subspace is the relative probability of that outcome. This is an ambitious goal, especially considering the effort needed to establish that there are any special states—the subject of Chapter 7. As remarked there, the special states exhibited are likely to be only a small and atypical fraction of all special states in the physical apparatus being modeled (e.g., the cloud chamber). In one example (the decay model) there is a remarkable matching of dimension and conventional probability, but I would not make too much of that. What is especially challenging about the present task is that we seek a universal distribution.