The fixed-node quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) method is used to obtain the classical barrier height for the H + H2 exchange reaction. Using a spin-restricted, single-determinant trial function ΨT, the authors find that the reaction barrier Eb is less than 9.69 ± 0.25 kcal/mol. This mean value is below the calculated energy barrier obtained by Liu in the most extensive CI calculations on this system. Furthermore, the QMC saddle-point energy of – 1.65903 ± 0.00040 hartrees at the CI-determined geometry lies 0.00027 a.u. (0.17 kcal/mol) below Liu's best CI value. Finally, spinrestricted and spin-unrestricted single-determinant trial functions are contrasted. Although the variational energy 〈ΨT|H|ΨT〉 for an SCF ΨT must be lower for the unrestricted case, this is not true generally for QMC. In fact, we show that if the unrestricted SCF ΨT has the lower QMC energy, then there exists another spin-restricted, single-determinant ΨT whose QMC energy is lower than the QMC energy of the spin-restricted SCF ΨT.
The fixed-node quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) method is used to obtain the classical barrier height for the H + H2 exchange reaction. Using a spin-restricted, single-determinant trial function ΨT, the authors find that the reaction barrier Eb is less than 9.69 ± 0.25 kcal/mol. This mean value is below the calculated energy barrier obtained by Liu in the most extensive CI calculations on this system. Furthermore, the QMC saddle-point energy of – 1.65903 ± 0.00040 hartrees at the CI-determined geometry lies 0.00027 a.u. (0.17 kcal/mol) below Liu's best CI value. Finally, spinrestricted and spin-unrestricted single-determinant trial functions are contrasted. Although the variational energy 〈ΨT|H|ΨT〉 for an SCF ΨT must be lower for the unrestricted case, this is not true generally for QMC. In fact, we show that if the unrestricted SCF ΨT has the lower QMC energy, then there exists another spin-restricted, single-determinant ΨT whose QMC energy is lower than the QMC energy of the spin-restricted SCF ΨT.
The classical barrier height for the H+H2 exchange reaction, as well as the energies at two other points along the reaction path, are calculated using fixed-node quantum Monte Carlo (FNQMC). Several single-determinant importance functions are used at the saddle point in order to relate the quality of the importance function to the accuracy and precision of the final result. The computed barrier is an upper bound since the energy of H and of H2 is obtained exactly by FNQMC. Our best upper bound (9.70±0.13 kcal/mol) has a mean within 0.1 kcal/mol of the presumed exact value. This best bound is obtained with a single determinant, double-zeta basis importance function. Contrary to experience with expansion methods, it is found that an importance function with a basis set of near Hartree–Fock quality, as well as one derived from a spin-unrestricted SCF calculation, are among the least efficient and least accurate of the importance functions used. Specifically, a nodal surface appearing in the lowest energy molecular orbital in these functions apparently increases the FNQMC energy. The FNQMC energy at the two other points along the reaction path is found to agree with the most accurate CI results of Liu to within statistical error.
The classical barrier height for the H + H 2 exchange reaction, as well as the energies at two other points along the reaction path, are calculated using fixed-node quantum Monte Carlo (FNQMC).Several single-determinant importance functions are used at the saddle-point in order to relate the quality of the importance function to the accuracy and precision of the final result.The computed barrier is an upper bound since the energy of H and of H 2 is obtained exactly by FNQMC.Our best upper bound, 9.70 ~ 0.13 kcal/mole, has a mean within 0.1 kcal/mole of the presumed exact value.This best bound is obtained with a single determinant, double-zeta basis importance function.Contrary to experience with expansion methods, it is found that an importance function with a basis set of near Hartree-Fock quality, as well as one derived from a spin-unrestricted SCF calculation, are among the least efficient and least accurate of the importance functions used.Specifically, a nodal surface appearing in the lowest energy molecular orbital in these functions apparently increases the FNQMC energy.The FNQMC energy at the two other points along the reaction path is found to agree with the most accurate CI results of Liu to within statistical error.
Abstract In this paper Grossman reported pseudopotential fixed-node diffusion QMC calculations of atomization energies for the Gl set of 55 small molecules,0 a standard benchmark set for testing methods in quantum chemistry. To maintain the uniformity in the calculations, they were carried out with the same basis sets and orbital types for single-determinant trial functions and effective core potentials (with a few exceptions). Variational QMC was used to optimize the determinan Jastrow trial functions. The mean absolute deviation EMAD in atomization energy from the experimental values was found to be 2.9 kcal/mol, the maximum deviation was 14 kcal/mol (for SO2), and the next five largest deviations were 7-8 kcal/mol. A comparison with results from other methods tested with the Gl set shows the FN-DQMC method to be competitive. For EMAD the list is: FN-DQMC, 2.9 kcal/mol; DFT (LDA), 40 kcal/mol; DFT (B3LYP or B3PW91), 2.9 kcal/mol; CCSD(T)/aug-cc-pVQZ, 2.8 kcal/mol; CCSD(T)/extrapolated, 1.3 kcal/mol; semi-empirical G1 theory, 1.6 kcal/mol. Additional calculations with different trial functions indicated that node location errors could be significantly reduced with multi determinant trial functions. Computational effort was not compared, but linear scaling for FN-DQMC was mentioned as an important advantage for QMC. 0J. A. Pople, M. Head-Gordon, D. J. Fox, K. Raghavachari, and L. A. Curtiss, Gaussian-I theory - A general procedure for prediction of molecular energies, J. Chem. Phys. 90, 5622 (1989).
We investigate here the performance of our recently developed linear-scaling Jastrow-generalized-valence-bond (J-LGVB) wave functions based on localized orbitals, for the quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) calculation of the barrier heights and reaction energies of five prototypical chemical reactions. Using the geometrical parameters from the Minnesota database collection, we consider three hydrogen-exchanges, one heavy-atom exchange, and one association reaction and compare our results with the best available experimental and theoretical data. For the three hydrogen-exchange reactions, we find that the J-LGVB wave functions yield excellent QMC results, with average deviations from the reference values below 0.5 kcal/mol. For the heavy-atom exchange and association reactions, additional resonance structures are important, and we therefore extend our original formulation to include multiple coupling schemes characterized by different sets of localized orbitals. We denote these wave functions as J-MC-LGVB, where MC indicates the multiconfiguration generalization, and show that such a form leads to very accurate barrier heights and reaction energies also for the last two reactions. We can therefore conclude that the J-LGVB theory for constructing QMC wave functions, with its multiconfiguration generalization, is valid for the study of large portions of ground-state potential energy surfaces including, in particular, the region of transition states.
Abstract In this work Manten and Liichow assessed the accuracy of allelectron fixed-node diffusion QMC calculations with nodes taken from Hartee-Fock wavefunctions with high-quality basis sets. The electronic energies associated with 17 different reactions involving a total of 20 small molecules were determined and compared with experimental values and with those calculated by Klopper et al.a using the coupled cluster method CCSD(T) with correlation consistent basis sets cc-pVDZ and cc-pVTZ. The molecules involved were limited to those containing the atoms H, C, 0, N, and F. Typical reactions were H2CO + 2H2 --+ CH4 + H2O and H2O + F --+ HOF + H. The geometries for the QMC calculations were optimized with MP2/cc-pVTZ calculations. The QMC total energies for the 20 molecules were lower than CCSD(T) values, but only valence electrons were correlated in the CCSD(T) calculations. Node location error was approximately 0.0015 hartrees for the C, N, 0, and F atoms and their hydrides, but substantial cancellation of node error is to be expected in determining enthalpy changes for reactions.
Two distinct types of Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) calculations are applied to electronic structure problems such as calculating potential energy curves and producing benchmark values for reaction barriers. First, Variational and Diffusion Monte Carlo (VMC and DMC) methods using a trial wavefunction subject to the fixed node approximation were tested using the CASINO code.[1] Next, Full Configuration Interaction Quantum Monte Carlo (FCIQMC), along with its initiator extension (i-FCIQMC) were tested using the NECI code.[2] FCIQMC seeks the FCI energy for a specific basis set. At a reduced cost, the efficient i-FCIQMC method can be applied to systems in which the standard FCIQMC approach proves to be too costly. Since all of these methods are statistical approaches, uncertainties (error-bars) are introduced for each calculated energy. This study tests the performance of the methods relative to traditional quantum chemistry for some benchmark systems. References: [1] R. J. Needs et al., J. Phys.: Condensed Matter 22, 023201 (2010). [2] G. H. Booth et al., J. Chem. Phys. 131, 054106 (2009).