Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

AIP Advances

Numerical Feynman integrals with physically inspired interpolation: Faster convergence and significant reduction of computational cost

Nikesh S. Dattani

Published Jan 19, 2012• 16 citations
Publisher

Abstract

One of the most successful methods for calculating reduced density operator dynamics in open quantum systems, that can give numerically exact results, uses Feynman integrals. However, when simulating the dynamics for a given amount of time, the number of time steps that can realistically be used with this method is always limited, therefore one often obtains an approximation of the reduced density operator at a sparse grid of points in time. Instead of relying only on ad hoc interpolation methods (such as splines) to estimate the system density operator in between these points, I propose a method that uses physical information to assist with this interpolation. This method is tested on a physically significant system, on which its use allows important qualitative features of the density operator dynamics to be captured with as little as two time steps in the Feynman integral. This method allows for an enormous reduction in the amount of memory and CPU time required for approximating density operator dynamics within a desired accuracy. Since this method does not change the way the Feynman integral itself is calculated, the value of the density operator approximation at the points in time used to discretize the Feynamn integral will be the same whether or not this method is used, but its approximation in between these points in time is considerably improved by this method. A list of ways in which this proposed method can be further improved is presented in the last section of the article.

DOI
10.1063/1.3680607

Related papers

Numerical Feynman integrals for density operator dynamics using master equation interpolants: faster convergence and significant reduction of computational cost

Nikesh S. Dattani

The Feynman integral is one of the most accurate methods for calculating density operator dynamics in open quantum systems. However, the number of time steps that can realistically be used is always limited, therefore one often obtains an approximation of the density operator at a sparse grid of points in time. Instead of relying only on \textit{ad hoc} interpolation methods such as splines to estimate the system density operator in between these points, I propose a method that uses physical information to assist with this interpolation. This method is tested on a physically significant system, on which its use allows important qualitative features of the density operator dynamics to be captured with as little as 2 time steps in the Feynman integral. This method allows for an enormous reduction in the amount of memory and CPU time required for approximating density operator dynamics within a desired accuracy. Since this method does not change the way the Feynman integral itself is calculated, the value of the density operator approximation at the points in time used to discretize the Feynamn integral will be the same whether or not this method is used, but its approximation in between these points in time is considerably improved by this method.

arXiv:1009.1674•Sep 9, 2010•0 citations

Adaptive kernel methods to simulate quantum phase space flow

Arnaldo Donoso, Laboratorio de F ́ isica

A technique for simulating quantum dynamics in phase space i discussed. It makes use of ensembles of classical trajectories to approximate the distribution functions and their derivatives by implementing Adaptive Kernel Density Estimation. It is found to improve the accuracy and stability of the simulations compared to more conventional particle methods. Formulation of the method in higher dimensions is straightforward. Complete analytical description of physical systems exist only for the most simple ideal cases. The vast majority of physical problems require the solution of approximate equations most fre- quently by using numerical calculations. To this end, much effort has been devoted to the devel- opment of suitable techniques to be used in computer simulations. The increasing computational power makes possible the description of more complicated, that is, less ideal systems allowing for more precise predictions of their properties as well as for a better understanding of the underlying phenomena. Among the wealth of numerical approaches to solve dynamical equations by means of discretization, particle methods have gained attention in the last few decades as a conceptu- ally appealing alternative. Conventional numerical solvers rely on a regular discretization of the independent variables to facilitate the evaluation of derivatives to a given order of accuracy. As a consequence, a mesh needs to be defined as the base of the simulations, parts of which remain empty at any given simulation time even with the most sophisticated mesh schemes. The cen- tral idea of particle methods consists of representing functions by sets of particles conveniently located and weighted such that the function is appropriately sampled by the particles. Evolution of the functions is then accomplished by an equivalent evolution of the particles. This meshless or Lagrangian type of discretization has some intrinsic computational efficiency advantages because there is no wasted space. The advantage, however, comes at the expense of having to evaluate derivatives of functions on unstructured arrays of sampling points. The issues about convergence and stability of the resulting algorithms have been the subject of active and fruitfull research. Currently there are some well established techniques to solve dynamical equations with particle methods. Our interest is to provide an alternative ingredient to further improve the performance of numerical solutions of dynamical problems of physical relevance. In the present work we discuss, in the context of particle methods, the implementation of a technique for representing functions and derivatives with adaptive parameters. Adaptiveness require the parameters to be automatically ad- justed to optimal values according to the location of the particles. As shown below, the proposed scheme is conceptually simple and has been tested in a number of different situations. In some simple test models the present work focuses on quantum dynamics, previously treated with more

•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

Approximate Functional Integral Methods in Statistical Mechanics. I. Moment Expansions

Armand Siegel, Terence Burke

In this paper, four distinct ideas are combined, which under a wide range of circumstances can give very rapidly converging series expansions for functional integrals. (1) Expansion of the functional being integrated in functional Taylor series. In the familiar case arising in quantum statistical mechanics, that of the Wiener integral of exp[−∫V(x(t))dt],V(x) being the perturbing potential, this is equivalent to expanding the characteristic functional of the probability functional of V(x(t)) in central moments of V(x(t)). The lowest-order term of the series is the approximation obtained by Feynman and Hibbs through a variational method. (2) Transfer of the harmonic term of the potential, when the functional integral is the quantum-statistical density matrix (Green's function of the Bloch equation), to the weighting function. This transforms the functional integral from a Wiener to an Uhlenbeck-Ornstein integral. The formal expressions for the terms of the expansion are somewhat more complicated, but they can be worked out, and the result is a great improvement in the speed of convergence of the series with decreasing temperature and/or decreasing relative magnitude of the anharmonic part of the potential. (3) ``Reservation of variables'' in the integration. This amounts to breaking the averaging process down into an average over subsets of the distributed random function (conditional average), followed by an averaging of these averages. Any step of this kind (it may be repeated within the subsets, etc.) gives an improvement of accuracy. (4) When the quantity being evaluated through functional integration is the partition function, the device introduced by Feynman and Hibbs, of interchanging the functional integration with the integration of the Green's function over the equated initial and final configuration-space points, may be combined with the above techniques. This eliminates one integration in the terms of the expansion and seems to improve accuracy at the same time. The general series obtained is correlated with more conventional operator techniques of quantum-mechanical perturbation theory, in order to answer the perennial question, does the path-integral method bring with it anything that could not be derived by other methods? It is in some sense a Feynman-Dyson expansion of the Green's function, but one that is further modified mathematically in a way characteristic only of the path-integral point of view, and which, moreover, improves its accuracy. It thus appears unlikely that the result is merely one of standard type disguised as a functional integral result. Sample numerical calculations are given to assay the accuracy of the methods, which are shown to compare very favorably with the traditional approximation of finite subdivision of the time interval.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 1, 1972•13 citations

Efficient Temperature-Dependent Green’s Function Methods for Realistic Systems: Using Cubic Spline Interpolation to Approximate Matsubara Green’s Functions

Alexei A. Kananenka, Alicia Rae Welden, Lan Nguyen Tran +2 more

The popular, stable, robust, and computationally inexpensive cubic spline interpolation algorithm is adopted and used for finite temperature Green's function calculations of realistic systems. We demonstrate that with appropriate modifications the temperature dependence can be preserved while the Green's function grid size can be reduced by about 2 orders of magnitude by replacing the standard Matsubara frequency grid with a sparser grid and a set of interpolation coefficients. We benchmarked the accuracy of our algorithm as a function of a single parameter sensitive to the shape of the Green's function. Through numerous examples, we confirmed that our algorithm can be utilized in a systematically improvable, controlled, and black-box manner and highly accurate one- and two-body energies and one-particle density matrices can be obtained using only around 5% of the original grid points. Additionally, we established that to improve accuracy by an order of magnitude, the number of grid points needs to be doubled, whereas for the Matsubara frequency grid, an order of magnitude more grid points must be used. This suggests that realistic calculations with large basis sets that were previously out of reach because they required enormous grid sizes may now become feasible.

arXiv:1602.05898•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Apr 6, 2016•48 citations

Improved Feynman’s path integral method with a large time step: Formalism and applications

Alexander N. Drozdov

We describe an efficient path integral scheme for calculating the propagator of an arbitrary quantum system, as well as that of a stochastic system in special cases where the Fokker–Planck equation obeys strict detailed balance. The basic idea is to split the respective Hamiltonian into two exactly solvable parts and then to employ a symmetric decomposition of the time evolution operator, which is exact up to a high order in the time step. The resulting single step propagator allows rather large time steps in a path integral and leads to convergence with fewer time slices. Because it involves no system-specific reference system, the algorithm is amenable to all known numerical schemes available for evaluating quantum path integrals. In this way one obtains a highly accurate method, which is simultaneously fast, stable, and computationally simple. Numerical applications to the real time quantum dynamics in a double well and to the stochastic dynamics of a bistable system coupled to a harmonic mode show our method to be superior over the approach developed by the Makri group in their quasiadiabatic propagator representation, to say nothing about the propagation scheme based on the standard Trotter splitting.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Apr 22, 1998•14 citations

Quantum dynamics for a system coupled to slow baths: On-the-fly filtered propagator method

Eunji Sim

An on-the-fly filtered propagator functional path integral scheme is introduced as an efficient way of calculating the iterative dynamics of complex condensed systems. Time evolution of the reduced density matrix of a dissipative quantum system is evaluated iteratively by filtering the negligible propagator elements at each propagation step. This on-the-fly filtering along with the finiteness of the bath memory dramatically reduces the configuration space to be integrated without losing numerical accuracy of the results. The required computational storage space for the configuration and the weight of the survived path segments increases linearly with the bath memory length. Up to the bath memory time, it is found that a strikingly small fraction of the configurations survives the on-the-fly filtering process and the number of surviving configurations increases algebraically with the propagation time. At times longer than the bath memory time, the number of surviving configurations required for numerically accurate results is essentially saturated and is less than 0.1% of the total number of the configurations. This new scheme is extremely useful for the problems of low-frequency solvents for which the bath memory spans many time steps of the propagation.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Sep 8, 2001•92 citations
One of the most successful methods for calculating reduced density operator dynamics in open quantum systems, that can give numerically exact results, uses Feynman integrals. However, when simulating the dynamics for a given amount of time, the number of time steps that can realistically be used with this method is always limited, therefore one often obtains an approximation of the reduced density operator at a sparse grid of points in time. Instead of relying only on ad hoc interpolation methods (such as splines) to estimate the system density operator in between these points, I propose a method that uses physical information to assist with this interpolation. This method is tested on a physically significant system, on which its use allows important qualitative features of the density operator dynamics to be captured with as little as two time steps in the Feynman integral. This method allows for an enormous reduction in the amount of memory and CPU time required for approximating density operator dynamics within a desired accuracy. Since this method does not change the way the Feynman integral itself is calculated, the value of the density operator approximation at the points in time used to discretize the Feynamn integral will be the same whether or not this method is used, but its approximation in between these points in time is considerably improved by this method. A list of ways in which this proposed method can be further improved is presented in the last section of the article.
The Feynman integral is one of the most accurate methods for calculating density operator dynamics in open quantum systems. However, the number of time steps that can realistically be used is always limited, therefore one often obtains an approximation of the density operator at a sparse grid of points in time. Instead of relying only on \textit{ad hoc} interpolation methods such as splines to estimate the system density operator in between these points, I propose a method that uses physical information to assist with this interpolation. This method is tested on a physically significant system, on which its use allows important qualitative features of the density operator dynamics to be captured with as little as 2 time steps in the Feynman integral. This method allows for an enormous reduction in the amount of memory and CPU time required for approximating density operator dynamics within a desired accuracy. Since this method does not change the way the Feynman integral itself is calculated, the value of the density operator approximation at the points in time used to discretize the Feynamn integral will be the same whether or not this method is used, but its approximation in between these points in time is considerably improved by this method.
A technique for simulating quantum dynamics in phase space i discussed. It makes use of ensembles of classical trajectories to approximate the distribution functions and their derivatives by implementing Adaptive Kernel Density Estimation. It is found to improve the accuracy and stability of the simulations compared to more conventional particle methods. Formulation of the method in higher dimensions is straightforward. Complete analytical description of physical systems exist only for the most simple ideal cases. The vast majority of physical problems require the solution of approximate equations most fre- quently by using numerical calculations. To this end, much effort has been devoted to the devel- opment of suitable techniques to be used in computer simulations. The increasing computational power makes possible the description of more complicated, that is, less ideal systems allowing for more precise predictions of their properties as well as for a better understanding of the underlying phenomena. Among the wealth of numerical approaches to solve dynamical equations by means of discretization, particle methods have gained attention in the last few decades as a conceptu- ally appealing alternative. Conventional numerical solvers rely on a regular discretization of the independent variables to facilitate the evaluation of derivatives to a given order of accuracy. As a consequence, a mesh needs to be defined as the base of the simulations, parts of which remain empty at any given simulation time even with the most sophisticated mesh schemes. The cen- tral idea of particle methods consists of representing functions by sets of particles conveniently located and weighted such that the function is appropriately sampled by the particles. Evolution of the functions is then accomplished by an equivalent evolution of the particles. This meshless or Lagrangian type of discretization has some intrinsic computational efficiency advantages because there is no wasted space. The advantage, however, comes at the expense of having to evaluate derivatives of functions on unstructured arrays of sampling points. The issues about convergence and stability of the resulting algorithms have been the subject of active and fruitfull research. Currently there are some well established techniques to solve dynamical equations with particle methods. Our interest is to provide an alternative ingredient to further improve the performance of numerical solutions of dynamical problems of physical relevance. In the present work we discuss, in the context of particle methods, the implementation of a technique for representing functions and derivatives with adaptive parameters. Adaptiveness require the parameters to be automatically ad- justed to optimal values according to the location of the particles. As shown below, the proposed scheme is conceptually simple and has been tested in a number of different situations. In some simple test models the present work focuses on quantum dynamics, previously treated with more
In this paper, four distinct ideas are combined, which under a wide range of circumstances can give very rapidly converging series expansions for functional integrals. (1) Expansion of the functional being integrated in functional Taylor series. In the familiar case arising in quantum statistical mechanics, that of the Wiener integral of exp[−∫V(x(t))dt],V(x) being the perturbing potential, this is equivalent to expanding the characteristic functional of the probability functional of V(x(t)) in central moments of V(x(t)). The lowest-order term of the series is the approximation obtained by Feynman and Hibbs through a variational method. (2) Transfer of the harmonic term of the potential, when the functional integral is the quantum-statistical density matrix (Green's function of the Bloch equation), to the weighting function. This transforms the functional integral from a Wiener to an Uhlenbeck-Ornstein integral. The formal expressions for the terms of the expansion are somewhat more complicated, but they can be worked out, and the result is a great improvement in the speed of convergence of the series with decreasing temperature and/or decreasing relative magnitude of the anharmonic part of the potential. (3) ``Reservation of variables'' in the integration. This amounts to breaking the averaging process down into an average over subsets of the distributed random function (conditional average), followed by an averaging of these averages. Any step of this kind (it may be repeated within the subsets, etc.) gives an improvement of accuracy. (4) When the quantity being evaluated through functional integration is the partition function, the device introduced by Feynman and Hibbs, of interchanging the functional integration with the integration of the Green's function over the equated initial and final configuration-space points, may be combined with the above techniques. This eliminates one integration in the terms of the expansion and seems to improve accuracy at the same time. The general series obtained is correlated with more conventional operator techniques of quantum-mechanical perturbation theory, in order to answer the perennial question, does the path-integral method bring with it anything that could not be derived by other methods? It is in some sense a Feynman-Dyson expansion of the Green's function, but one that is further modified mathematically in a way characteristic only of the path-integral point of view, and which, moreover, improves its accuracy. It thus appears unlikely that the result is merely one of standard type disguised as a functional integral result. Sample numerical calculations are given to assay the accuracy of the methods, which are shown to compare very favorably with the traditional approximation of finite subdivision of the time interval.
The popular, stable, robust, and computationally inexpensive cubic spline interpolation algorithm is adopted and used for finite temperature Green's function calculations of realistic systems. We demonstrate that with appropriate modifications the temperature dependence can be preserved while the Green's function grid size can be reduced by about 2 orders of magnitude by replacing the standard Matsubara frequency grid with a sparser grid and a set of interpolation coefficients. We benchmarked the accuracy of our algorithm as a function of a single parameter sensitive to the shape of the Green's function. Through numerous examples, we confirmed that our algorithm can be utilized in a systematically improvable, controlled, and black-box manner and highly accurate one- and two-body energies and one-particle density matrices can be obtained using only around 5% of the original grid points. Additionally, we established that to improve accuracy by an order of magnitude, the number of grid points needs to be doubled, whereas for the Matsubara frequency grid, an order of magnitude more grid points must be used. This suggests that realistic calculations with large basis sets that were previously out of reach because they required enormous grid sizes may now become feasible.
We describe an efficient path integral scheme for calculating the propagator of an arbitrary quantum system, as well as that of a stochastic system in special cases where the Fokker–Planck equation obeys strict detailed balance. The basic idea is to split the respective Hamiltonian into two exactly solvable parts and then to employ a symmetric decomposition of the time evolution operator, which is exact up to a high order in the time step. The resulting single step propagator allows rather large time steps in a path integral and leads to convergence with fewer time slices. Because it involves no system-specific reference system, the algorithm is amenable to all known numerical schemes available for evaluating quantum path integrals. In this way one obtains a highly accurate method, which is simultaneously fast, stable, and computationally simple. Numerical applications to the real time quantum dynamics in a double well and to the stochastic dynamics of a bistable system coupled to a harmonic mode show our method to be superior over the approach developed by the Makri group in their quasiadiabatic propagator representation, to say nothing about the propagation scheme based on the standard Trotter splitting.
An on-the-fly filtered propagator functional path integral scheme is introduced as an efficient way of calculating the iterative dynamics of complex condensed systems. Time evolution of the reduced density matrix of a dissipative quantum system is evaluated iteratively by filtering the negligible propagator elements at each propagation step. This on-the-fly filtering along with the finiteness of the bath memory dramatically reduces the configuration space to be integrated without losing numerical accuracy of the results. The required computational storage space for the configuration and the weight of the survived path segments increases linearly with the bath memory length. Up to the bath memory time, it is found that a strikingly small fraction of the configurations survives the on-the-fly filtering process and the number of surviving configurations increases algebraically with the propagation time. At times longer than the bath memory time, the number of surviving configurations required for numerically accurate results is essentially saturated and is less than 0.1% of the total number of the configurations. This new scheme is extremely useful for the problems of low-frequency solvents for which the bath memory spans many time steps of the propagation.