Journal of Mathematical Physics

Compatibility of the uncorrelated joint distribution with the classical limit

Roderick I. Sutherland

Published Jun 1, 1983• 1 citation

Abstract

It is shown that the uncorrelated joint distribution, when adopted for quantum mechanics, is not (despite initial appearances to the contrary) in conflict with the known correlations between position and momentum in the classical limit. It is therefore not excluded on these grounds as a possible joint distribution expression for quantum mechanics.

DOI: 10.1063/1.525881

Related papers

The position–momentum correlation for quantum and classical probability distributions

Natascha Riahi

We compare the definition and the interpretation of the position–momentum correlation in classical statistical physics and quantum mechanics. The introduction of a regional momentum distribution makes a rigorous discussion in both theories possible. We investigate the mutual dependence of position and momentum for one- and two-centred probability distributions.

European Journal of PhysicsFeb 12, 20136 citations

Deterministic Quantum Mechanics

Shasanka Mohan Roy, Virendra Singh

Present quantum theory, which is statistical in nature, does not predict joint probability distribution of position and momentum because they are noncommuting. We propose a deterministic quantum theory which predicts a joint probability distribution such that the separate probability distributions for position and momentum agree with usual quantum theory. Unlike the Wigner distribution the suggested distribution is positive definite. The theory predicts a correlation between position and momentum in individual events.

arXiv:hep-th/9402025Feb 4, 19940 citations

Joint distribution indicated by the wave equations of quantum mechanics

Roderick I. Sutherland

By using the notion of conditional mean values and assuming that the classical relationship between momentum and energy remains valid, it is shown that both the Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon equations suggest a particular joint distribution expression for quantum mechanics, namely the Margenau and Hill distribution.

Journal of Mathematical PhysicsDec 1, 198210 citations

On joint lower bounds of position and momentum observables in quantum mechanics

Paul Busch

A new theorem on joint lower bounds of unsharp position and momentum observables is formulated and proven. It is developed as a straightforward formal generalization of a similar theorem for the spectral projections of the usual observables which has been employed to express the strict incompatibility of position and momentum. The relevance of our theorem to the problem of joint measurements in quantum mechanics has been discussed elsewhere.

Journal of Mathematical PhysicsJun 1, 198419 citations

Probability Concepts in Quantum Mechanics

Patrick Suppes

The fundamental problem considered is that of the existence of a joint probability distribution for momentum and position at a given instant. The philosophical interest of this problem is that for the potential energy functions (or Hamiltonians) corresponding to many simple experimental situations, the joint “distribution” derived by the methods of Wigner and Moyal is not a genuine probability distribution at all. The implications of these results for the interpretation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle are analyzed. The final section consists of some observations concerning the axiomatic foundations of quantum mechanics.

Philosophy of ScienceOct 1, 196181 citations

A study of deterministic models for quantum mechanics

Roderick I. Sutherland

A theoretical investigation is made into the difficulties encountered in constructing a deterministic model for quantum mechanics and into the restrictions that can be placed on the form of such a model.The various implications of the known 11 impossi bil ity proofs II are examined.A possible explanation for the non-locality required by Bell's proof is suggested in terms of backwards-in-time causality.The efficacy of the Kochen and Specker proof is brought into doubt by showing that there is a possible way of avoiding its implications in the only known physically realizable situation to which it applies.Also, a new thought experiment is put forward to show that a particle's predetermined momentum and energy values cannot satisfy the laws of momentum and energy conservation without conflicting with the predictions of quantum mechanics.Special attention is paid to a particular class of deterministic models which appear not to have been explicitly studied before.The models considered are those for which the individual outcomes of measurements are not dependent on hidden variables associated with the measuring apparatus and for which the hidden variables of a particle do not need to be randomized after each measurement.Specific models of this type are constructed and examined for the cases of both discrete and continuous spectra of eigenvalues.In developing these models a need is found for a joint distribution for position and momentum.In relation to this point, it is demonstrated that the quantum mechanical wave equations actually point to a particular joint distribution expression, namely the Margenau and Hill distribution.The schemes considered are found to have certain shortcomings and possible steps towards more satisfactory models are suggested.

Mar 18, 20220 citations