Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. B, Solid state

Surface effects on magnetic phase transitions

Kurt Binder, Pierre C. Hohenberg

Published Mar 1, 1974• 566 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The surface scaling theory previously presented by the authors is developed further, and derived heuristically from a cluster model. Monte Carlo calculations are carried out to obtain the spatial and temperature dependence of the magnetization in Ising and Heisenberg systems with free surfaces. The exponent ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{1}$ of the (surface) layer magnetization is shown to agree with the scaling value (${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{1}\ensuremath{\approx}\frac{2}{3}$) previously derived. In the Heisenberg system, the results at low temperature agree with a spin-wave calculation by Mills and Maradudin. Ising models with modified exchange ${J}_{s}=J(1+\ensuremath{\Delta})\ensuremath{\ne}J$ on the surface are considered, both in mean-field theory and by means of high-temperature-series expansions. The critical value ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{c}$ for surface ordering is found from the series to be 0.6, compared to the mean-field value of 0.25. For $\ensuremath{\Delta}>{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{c}$ there is a temperature region in which the surface behaves like a bulk two-dimensional Ising model near its phase transition. The critical exponents experience a crossover at $\ensuremath{\Delta}={\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{c}$, which is reflected in poorly behaved series, and effective exponents differing from the true ones for $\ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\lesssim}{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{c}$. In the case of weakened surface exchange ($0<{J}_{s}<J$), the layer magnetization is shown to fit a linear temperature dependence over a large temperature range below ${T}_{c}$, thus providing a possible explanation for previous experiments. For sufficiently strong negative ${J}_{s}$, mean-field theory predicts that the surface will order antiferromagnetically while the bulk is ferromagnetic.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.9.2194

Related papers

Phase Transitions and Static Spin Correlations in Ising Models with Free Surfaces

Kurt Binder, Pierre C. Hohenberg

Phase transitions in Ising models with tree surfaces are studied from various points of view, including a phenomenological Landau theory, high-temperature series expansions, and a scaling theory for thermodynamic quantities and correlation functions. In the presence of a surface a number of new critical exponents must be defined. These arise because of the existence of "surface" terms in the thermodynamic functions, and because of the anisotropy of space and lack of translational symmetry introduced by the surface. The need for these new critical exponents already appears in the phenomenological theory, which is discussed in detail and related to the microscopic mean-field approximation. The essential new parameter appearing in this theory is an extrapolation length $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ which enters the boundary condition on the magnetization at the surface. For magnetic systems this length is of the order of the interaction range, in contrast to superconductors, where it is usually much larger. In order to go beyond the mean-field theory, high-temperature series expansions are carried out for the Ising half-space, to tenth order in two dimensions and to eighth order in three dimensions. A scaling theory is developed both for thermodynamic functions and for spin correlations near the surface, and relations are found among the exponents of the half-space. Both the scaling theory and the numerical calculations are compared with the exact solution of the Ising half-plane (two dimensions) by McCoy and Wu, and agreement is found wherever the theory is applicable. In analogy to the bulk situation, the scaling theory is found to agree with mean-field theory in four dimensions. The prediction of the present work which is most easily accessible to experiment is the temperature dependence of the magnetization at the surface, with critical exponent estimated to be ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{1}=\frac{2}{3}$. The mean-field result, ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{1}=1$, seems to agree more closely with presently available experiment, and more work is needed to clarify the situation.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Nov 1, 1972•452 citations

Magnetic-Phase Transitions of Ising Surfaces with Modified Surface-Bulk Coupling: a Monte Carlo Study

Michele Vendruscolo, Mauro Rovere, Annalisa Fasolino

We present the Monte Carlo phase diagram of Ising surfaces with intrasurface ( J s ) and surface-bulk ( J 1 ) interactions modified with respect to the bulk exchange interaction J . The new parameter J 1 strongly affects the position of the Binder-Landau multi critical point and the crossover from three-dimensional to two-dimensional behaviour. The surface critical exponents β 1 and ϕ are determined by crossover scaling analysis. A detailed comparison with the results of the mean-field equations is also presented. The Monte Carlo phase diagram shows that stronger modifications of the surface couplings, with respect to those obtained by mean field, are needed to produce an ordered surface phase on a paramagnetic bulk. This is particularly relevant at low values of J s ; in the Monte Carlo simulation the surface is disordered for all values of J 1 when J s < (0.4 ÷ 0.5) J , while the mean field predicts that the ordered phase is present even in the limit J s → 0.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Nov 15, 1992•14 citations

Magnetic ordering and critical behavior near surfaces

Pierre C. Hohenberg, Kurt Binder

Films and semi‐infinite systems are studied for Ising and Heisenberg models, using mean‐field theory, scaling, series expansions, and Monte Carlo simulations. Predictions are made for the magnetization as a function of temperature and distance from the surface, and for the critical exponents. Possible experimental consequences of the theory are briefly reviewed.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 1975•11 citations

Edge wetting of an Ising three-dimensional system

L. Bahmad, A. Benyoussef, Hamid Ez-zahraouy A

The effect of edge on wetting and layering transitions of a three-dimensional spin-1/2 Ising model is investigated, in the presence of longitudinal and surface magnetic fields, using mean field theory and Monte Carlo simulations. For T=0, the ground state phase diagram shows that there exist only three allowed transitions, namely, surface and bulk transition, surface transition, and bulk transition. However, there exist a surface intralayering temperature T(s)(L), above which the surface and the intralayering surface transitions occur. While the bulk layering and intralayering transitions appear above another finite temperature T(b)(L)(>or=T(s)(L)). These surface and bulk intralayering transitions are not seen in the perfect surfaces case. Numerical values of T(s)(L) and T(b)(L), computed by Monte Carlo method are found to be smaller than those obtained using mean field theory. However, the results predicted by the two methods become similar, and are exactly those given by the ground state phase diagram, for very low temperatures. On the other hand, the behavior of the local magnetizations as a function of the external magnetic field, shows that the transitions are of the first order type. T(s)(L) and T(b)(L) decrease when increasing the system size and/or the surface magnetic field. In particular, T(b)(L) reaches the wetting temperature T(w) for sufficiently large system sizes.

arXiv:cond-mat/0209140•Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Nov 19, 2002•33 citations

Crossover Scaling and Critical Behavior at the "Surface-Bulk" Multicritical Point

Kurt Binder, D. P. Landau

With use of a novel Monte Carlo method suited for the study of surface phenomena, the authors have investigated a three-dimensional Ising model with modified surface exchange. The results verify the scaling behavior of the magnetization profile and confirm and extend renormalization-group predictions. The surface-layer magnetization exponent is ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{1}=0.78\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.02$ except at the "special" (multicritical) transition where ${{\ensuremath{\beta}}_{1}}^{m}=0.175\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.025$ and the crossover exponent is $\ensuremath{\phi}=0.56\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.04$.

Physical Review Letters•Jan 30, 1984•288 citations

Near-Surface Long-Range Order at the Ordinary Transition: Scaling Analysis and Monte Carlo Results

Peter Czerner, Uwe Ritschel

Motivated by recent experimental activities on surface critical phenomena, we present a detailed theoretical study of the near-surface behavior of the local order parameter m(z) in Ising-like spin systems. Special attention is paid to the crossover regime between “ordinary” and “normal” transition in the three-dimensional semi-infinite Ising model, where a finite magnetic field H1 is imposed on the surface which itself exhibits a reduced tendency to order spontaneously. As the theoretical foundation, the spatial behavior of m(z) is discussed by means of phenomenological scaling arguments, and a finite-size scaling analysis is performed. Then we present Monte Carlo results for m(z) obtained with the Swendsen-Wang algorithm. In particular the sharp power-law increase of the magnetization, m(z) ≈ H1z1−η∼ord, predicted for a smallH1 by previous work of the authors, is corroborated by the numerical results. The relevance of these findings for experiments on critical adsorption in systems where a small effective surface field occurs is pointed out.

•Jan 1, 1996•9 citations
The surface scaling theory previously presented by the authors is developed further, and derived heuristically from a cluster model. Monte Carlo calculations are carried out to obtain the spatial and temperature dependence of the magnetization in Ising and Heisenberg systems with free surfaces. The exponent \ensuremathβ1{\ensuremath{\beta}}_{1}\ensuremathβ1​ of the (surface) layer magnetization is shown to agree with the scaling value (\ensuremathβ1\ensuremath≈23{\ensuremath{\beta}}_{1}\ensuremath{\approx}\frac{2}{3}\ensuremathβ1​\ensuremath≈32​) previously derived. In the Heisenberg system, the results at low temperature agree with a spin-wave calculation by Mills and Maradudin. Ising models with modified exchange Js=J(1+\ensuremathΔ)\ensuremath≠J{J}_{s}=J(1+\ensuremath{\Delta})\ensuremath{\ne}JJs​=J(1+\ensuremathΔ)\ensuremath=J on the surface are considered, both in mean-field theory and by means of high-temperature-series expansions. The critical value \ensuremathΔc{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{c}\ensuremathΔc​ for surface ordering is found from the series to be 0.6, compared to the mean-field value of 0.25. For \ensuremathΔ>\ensuremathΔc\ensuremath{\Delta}>{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{c}\ensuremathΔ>\ensuremathΔc​ there is a temperature region in which the surface behaves like a bulk two-dimensional Ising model near its phase transition. The critical exponents experience a crossover at \ensuremathΔ=\ensuremathΔc\ensuremath{\Delta}={\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{c}\ensuremathΔ=\ensuremathΔc​, which is reflected in poorly behaved series, and effective exponents differing from the true ones for \ensuremathΔ\ensuremath≲\ensuremathΔc\ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\lesssim}{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{c}\ensuremathΔ\ensuremath≲\ensuremathΔc​. In the case of weakened surface exchange (0<Js<J0<{J}_{s}<J0<Js​<J), the layer magnetization is shown to fit a linear temperature dependence over a large temperature range below Tc{T}_{c}Tc​, thus providing a possible explanation for previous experiments. For sufficiently strong negative Js{J}_{s}Js​, mean-field theory predicts that the surface will order antiferromagnetically while the bulk is ferromagnetic.
Phase transitions in Ising models with tree surfaces are studied from various points of view, including a phenomenological Landau theory, high-temperature series expansions, and a scaling theory for thermodynamic quantities and correlation functions. In the presence of a surface a number of new critical exponents must be defined. These arise because of the existence of "surface" terms in the thermodynamic functions, and because of the anisotropy of space and lack of translational symmetry introduced by the surface. The need for these new critical exponents already appears in the phenomenological theory, which is discussed in detail and related to the microscopic mean-field approximation. The essential new parameter appearing in this theory is an extrapolation length $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ which enters the boundary condition on the magnetization at the surface. For magnetic systems this length is of the order of the interaction range, in contrast to superconductors, where it is usually much larger. In order to go beyond the mean-field theory, high-temperature series expansions are carried out for the Ising half-space, to tenth order in two dimensions and to eighth order in three dimensions. A scaling theory is developed both for thermodynamic functions and for spin correlations near the surface, and relations are found among the exponents of the half-space. Both the scaling theory and the numerical calculations are compared with the exact solution of the Ising half-plane (two dimensions) by McCoy and Wu, and agreement is found wherever the theory is applicable. In analogy to the bulk situation, the scaling theory is found to agree with mean-field theory in four dimensions. The prediction of the present work which is most easily accessible to experiment is the temperature dependence of the magnetization at the surface, with critical exponent estimated to be ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{1}=\frac{2}{3}$. The mean-field result, ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{1}=1$, seems to agree more closely with presently available experiment, and more work is needed to clarify the situation.
We present the Monte Carlo phase diagram of Ising surfaces with intrasurface ( J s ) and surface-bulk ( J 1 ) interactions modified with respect to the bulk exchange interaction J . The new parameter J 1 strongly affects the position of the Binder-Landau multi critical point and the crossover from three-dimensional to two-dimensional behaviour. The surface critical exponents β 1 and ϕ are determined by crossover scaling analysis. A detailed comparison with the results of the mean-field equations is also presented. The Monte Carlo phase diagram shows that stronger modifications of the surface couplings, with respect to those obtained by mean field, are needed to produce an ordered surface phase on a paramagnetic bulk. This is particularly relevant at low values of J s ; in the Monte Carlo simulation the surface is disordered for all values of J 1 when J s < (0.4 ÷ 0.5) J , while the mean field predicts that the ordered phase is present even in the limit J s → 0.
The effect of edge on wetting and layering transitions of a three-dimensional spin-1/2 Ising model is investigated, in the presence of longitudinal and surface magnetic fields, using mean field theory and Monte Carlo simulations. For T=0, the ground state phase diagram shows that there exist only three allowed transitions, namely, surface and bulk transition, surface transition, and bulk transition. However, there exist a surface intralayering temperature T(s)(L), above which the surface and the intralayering surface transitions occur. While the bulk layering and intralayering transitions appear above another finite temperature T(b)(L)(>or=T(s)(L)). These surface and bulk intralayering transitions are not seen in the perfect surfaces case. Numerical values of T(s)(L) and T(b)(L), computed by Monte Carlo method are found to be smaller than those obtained using mean field theory. However, the results predicted by the two methods become similar, and are exactly those given by the ground state phase diagram, for very low temperatures. On the other hand, the behavior of the local magnetizations as a function of the external magnetic field, shows that the transitions are of the first order type. T(s)(L) and T(b)(L) decrease when increasing the system size and/or the surface magnetic field. In particular, T(b)(L) reaches the wetting temperature T(w) for sufficiently large system sizes.
With use of a novel Monte Carlo method suited for the study of surface phenomena, the authors have investigated a three-dimensional Ising model with modified surface exchange. The results verify the scaling behavior of the magnetization profile and confirm and extend renormalization-group predictions. The surface-layer magnetization exponent is ${\ensuremath{\beta}}_{1}=0.78\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.02$ except at the "special" (multicritical) transition where ${{\ensuremath{\beta}}_{1}}^{m}=0.175\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.025$ and the crossover exponent is $\ensuremath{\phi}=0.56\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.04$.
Motivated by recent experimental activities on surface critical phenomena, we present a detailed theoretical study of the near-surface behavior of the local order parameter m(z) in Ising-like spin systems. Special attention is paid to the crossover regime between “ordinary” and “normal” transition in the three-dimensional semi-infinite Ising model, where a finite magnetic field H1 is imposed on the surface which itself exhibits a reduced tendency to order spontaneously. As the theoretical foundation, the spatial behavior of m(z) is discussed by means of phenomenological scaling arguments, and a finite-size scaling analysis is performed. Then we present Monte Carlo results for m(z) obtained with the Swendsen-Wang algorithm. In particular the sharp power-law increase of the magnetization, m(z) ≈ H1z1−η∼ord, predicted for a smallH1 by previous work of the authors, is corroborated by the numerical results. The relevance of these findings for experiments on critical adsorption in systems where a small effective surface field occurs is pointed out.