Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Foundations of probability and physics

PROBABILITY CONSERVATION AND THE STATE DETERMINATION PROBLEM

S. AERTS

Published Dec 1, 2001• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

The problem of finding an operational definition for the wave vector is briefly examined from a historical point of view. Led by an old idea of Feenberg, we integrate the one dimensional probability conservation equation to obtain a closed formula that determines the state vector in the spinless case. The formula that determines the state does not depend on the (real) potential, external fields having their influence on the state only through the time derivative of the probability density function in position space. We apply the method to the simple case of a free Gaussian wave packet. Some problems regarding the operational status of the quantities involved are discussed.

DOI
10.1142/9789812810809_0003

Related papers

Probability Tangles and Eigenstates of One-dimensional Potentials

Pranawa C. Deshmukh

The belief that there is only one truth, and that oneself is in possession of it, is the root of all evil in the world. —Max Born In this chapter, we build on the principles of quantum mechanics introduced in the previous two chapters to apply the same to physical situations. First, we shall address simple one-dimensional physical problems. These would involve single particles interacting with a potential. 3.1 Probability Current Density We have learned in Chapter 1 that if represents an energy eigenstate, then it is stationary and its time dependence is described by (Eqs. 1.114a,b and Eq. 1.115). The contribution of this term to the integrand in Eq. 1.109 and in Eq. 1.111a,b is essentially unity, no matter what the value of time t is. In this case, the probability density becomes independent of time. However, in other cases, the probability density, and hence the probability of finding a particle represented by the state vector within a volume element about the position, is time dependent. It then becomes necessary to determine The partial derivative with respect to time of the product of the wavefunction and its complex conjugate requires, which is available from the time-dependent Schrödinger equation. Also required is, which is readily obtainable from its complex conjugation. The result of the Solved Problem P3.1 at the end of this chapter, viz., has exactly the same form as the equation of continuity in fluid dynamics and also in electrodynamics (Eq. 10.26 and Eq. 13.71c in Reference [1]). In the above equation, or writing the same compactly, with the arguments implicit, In terms of the momentum operator, and it is called as the probability current density vector. Its integral over the whole space gives us where is the expectation value of the momentum operator at the instant t . The dimensions of the probability current density vector are L -2 T -1 . Notwithstanding the above relations, the probability current density vector at a point is not directly measurable. It would not be appropriate to equate it to the average particle flux at a point at a specific instant of time, though such an interpretation can sometimes be useful.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

The negative flow of probability

Anthony Allan D. Villanueva

We derive an inequality that the parameters of a 1D free-particle Gaussian wave packet with a positive group velocity, approaching a given region x > q, must satisfy such that a negative probability current J exists on q. Local probability conservation implies the counter-intuitive result that the particle detection probability in the region x > q is actually decreasing. The condition J < 0 requires the negative correlation of the position and momentum observables of the state, but the time scales for the negative current and anti-correlation regimes are not identical. Using a probability current operator, we obtain an integral representation of J in momentum space for any free particle wave packet. We use this integral representation to distinguish the separate contributions to J by the positive and negative momentum components, and we identify a third contribution to J composed of cross-terms of both momenta. For the specific case of a Gaussian wave packet with a negative correlation between its position and momentum, the positive momentum component can contribute a negative value to the probability current.

American Journal of Physics•Mar 19, 2020•7 citations

On the theory of wave packets

Dmitry V. Naumov

In this paper we discuss some aspects of the theory of wave packets. We consider a popular noncovariant Gaussian model used in various applications and show that it predicts too slow a longitudinal dispersion rate for relativistic particles. We revise this approach by considering a covariant model of Gaussian wave packets, and examine our results by inspecting a wave packet of arbitrary form. A general formula for the time dependence of the dispersion of a wave packet of arbitrary form is found. Finally, we give a transparent interpretation of the disappearance of the wave function over time due to the dispersion—a feature often considered undesirable, but which is unavoidable for wave packets. We find, starting from simple examples, proceeding with their generalizations and finally by considering the continuity equation, that the integral over time of both the flux and probability densities are asymptotically proportional to the factor 1/| x | 2 in the rest frame of the wave packet, just as in the case of an ensemble of classical particles.

arXiv:1309.1717•Physics of Particles and Nuclei Letters•Dec 1, 2013•46 citations

The Time-Dependent Schrödinger Equation

Reinhold A. Bertlmann, Nicolai Friis

Abstract The second chapter introduces the notion of wave functions and their equation of motion proposed by Erwin Schrödinger. The interpretation and normalization of the wave function are discussed, leading to the continuity equation. The chapter also introduces basic mathematical operations that can be carried out for wave functions and operators, describing e.g., how to calculate scalar products and commutators, as well as expectation values and variances of observables. With these tools at hand, Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle is re-examined, focusing on the example of a Gaussian wave packet, which is studied both in position space and momentum space. We also discuss the time evolution of general states and of the exemplary wave packet. Finally, we will see how classical physics is recovered as a limiting case of the quantum-mechanical description

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 7, 2023•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics and Liouville's Equation

Michael Nauenberg

In non-relativistic quantum mechanics, the absolute square of Schrödinger's wave function for a particle in a potential determines the probability of finding it either at a position or momentum at a given time. In classical mechanics the corresponding problem is determined by the solution of Liouville's equation for the probability density of finding the joint position and momentum of the particle at a given time. Integrating this classical solution over either one of these two variables can then be compared with the probability in quantum mechanics. For the special case that the force is a constant, it is shown analytically that for an initial Gaussian probability distribution, the solution of Liouville's integrated over momentum is equal to Schrödinger's probability function in coordinate space, provided the coordinate and momentum initial widths of this classical solution satisfy the minimal Heisenberg uncertainty relation. Likewise, integrating Lioville's solution over position is equal to Schrödinger's probability function in momentum space. Quanta 2017; 6: 53–56.

Quanta•Sep 9, 2017•0 citations

Evolution of a Gaussian Wavepacket

S. M. Blinder

An alternative derivation is given for the evolution in time of a Gaussian wavepacket representing a free particle. This is based on explicit evaluation of the action of the evolution operator on the initial wavefunction, rather than on expansions in free-particle eigenstates. Both the cases of a free particle initially at rest and in uniform linear motion are considered.

American Journal of Physics•Jun 1, 1968•23 citations
The problem of finding an operational definition for the wave vector is briefly examined from a historical point of view. Led by an old idea of Feenberg, we integrate the one dimensional probability conservation equation to obtain a closed formula that determines the state vector in the spinless case. The formula that determines the state does not depend on the (real) potential, external fields having their influence on the state only through the time derivative of the probability density function in position space. We apply the method to the simple case of a free Gaussian wave packet. Some problems regarding the operational status of the quantities involved are discussed.
The belief that there is only one truth, and that oneself is in possession of it, is the root of all evil in the world. —Max Born In this chapter, we build on the principles of quantum mechanics introduced in the previous two chapters to apply the same to physical situations. First, we shall address simple one-dimensional physical problems. These would involve single particles interacting with a potential. 3.1 Probability Current Density We have learned in Chapter 1 that if represents an energy eigenstate, then it is stationary and its time dependence is described by (Eqs. 1.114a,b and Eq. 1.115). The contribution of this term to the integrand in Eq. 1.109 and in Eq. 1.111a,b is essentially unity, no matter what the value of time t is. In this case, the probability density becomes independent of time. However, in other cases, the probability density, and hence the probability of finding a particle represented by the state vector within a volume element about the position, is time dependent. It then becomes necessary to determine The partial derivative with respect to time of the product of the wavefunction and its complex conjugate requires, which is available from the time-dependent Schrödinger equation. Also required is, which is readily obtainable from its complex conjugation. The result of the Solved Problem P3.1 at the end of this chapter, viz., has exactly the same form as the equation of continuity in fluid dynamics and also in electrodynamics (Eq. 10.26 and Eq. 13.71c in Reference [1]). In the above equation, or writing the same compactly, with the arguments implicit, In terms of the momentum operator, and it is called as the probability current density vector. Its integral over the whole space gives us where is the expectation value of the momentum operator at the instant t . The dimensions of the probability current density vector are L -2 T -1 . Notwithstanding the above relations, the probability current density vector at a point is not directly measurable. It would not be appropriate to equate it to the average particle flux at a point at a specific instant of time, though such an interpretation can sometimes be useful.
We derive an inequality that the parameters of a 1D free-particle Gaussian wave packet with a positive group velocity, approaching a given region x > q, must satisfy such that a negative probability current J exists on q. Local probability conservation implies the counter-intuitive result that the particle detection probability in the region x > q is actually decreasing. The condition J < 0 requires the negative correlation of the position and momentum observables of the state, but the time scales for the negative current and anti-correlation regimes are not identical. Using a probability current operator, we obtain an integral representation of J in momentum space for any free particle wave packet. We use this integral representation to distinguish the separate contributions to J by the positive and negative momentum components, and we identify a third contribution to J composed of cross-terms of both momenta. For the specific case of a Gaussian wave packet with a negative correlation between its position and momentum, the positive momentum component can contribute a negative value to the probability current.
In this paper we discuss some aspects of the theory of wave packets. We consider a popular noncovariant Gaussian model used in various applications and show that it predicts too slow a longitudinal dispersion rate for relativistic particles. We revise this approach by considering a covariant model of Gaussian wave packets, and examine our results by inspecting a wave packet of arbitrary form. A general formula for the time dependence of the dispersion of a wave packet of arbitrary form is found. Finally, we give a transparent interpretation of the disappearance of the wave function over time due to the dispersion—a feature often considered undesirable, but which is unavoidable for wave packets. We find, starting from simple examples, proceeding with their generalizations and finally by considering the continuity equation, that the integral over time of both the flux and probability densities are asymptotically proportional to the factor 1/| x | 2 in the rest frame of the wave packet, just as in the case of an ensemble of classical particles.
Abstract The second chapter introduces the notion of wave functions and their equation of motion proposed by Erwin Schrödinger. The interpretation and normalization of the wave function are discussed, leading to the continuity equation. The chapter also introduces basic mathematical operations that can be carried out for wave functions and operators, describing e.g., how to calculate scalar products and commutators, as well as expectation values and variances of observables. With these tools at hand, Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle is re-examined, focusing on the example of a Gaussian wave packet, which is studied both in position space and momentum space. We also discuss the time evolution of general states and of the exemplary wave packet. Finally, we will see how classical physics is recovered as a limiting case of the quantum-mechanical description
In non-relativistic quantum mechanics, the absolute square of Schrödinger's wave function for a particle in a potential determines the probability of finding it either at a position or momentum at a given time. In classical mechanics the corresponding problem is determined by the solution of Liouville's equation for the probability density of finding the joint position and momentum of the particle at a given time. Integrating this classical solution over either one of these two variables can then be compared with the probability in quantum mechanics. For the special case that the force is a constant, it is shown analytically that for an initial Gaussian probability distribution, the solution of Liouville's integrated over momentum is equal to Schrödinger's probability function in coordinate space, provided the coordinate and momentum initial widths of this classical solution satisfy the minimal Heisenberg uncertainty relation. Likewise, integrating Lioville's solution over position is equal to Schrödinger's probability function in momentum space. Quanta 2017; 6: 53–56.