Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Fortschritte der Physik

Thermodynamics under Dynamic Forcing

Robert H. Kohler

Published Jan 1, 1969• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Beginning with a system that is governed by an arbitrary time‐dependent Hamiltonian, we exhibit an existence proof for a unitary generator that has an arbitrary initial value and yet contact transforms the representation to one governed by any given kinematically equivalent Hamiltonian. By choosing the initial value of the unitary operator to be unity, we are able to compare the behaviour of the same system under two different Hamiltonians and the same initial state vector. We thus are able to establish that the eventual physical states evolving from two distinct initial quantum state vectors will become practically indistinguishable under one of the two Hamiltonians if and only if they do so under the other. For the restricted class of systems for which one of the two Hamiltonians is a time‐independent energy operator, and also generates equilibrium thermodynamics, then the condition for merging under the time‐dependent Hamiltonian is the same as under the time‐independent one. The two states must have the same initial energy. As a special case of the above, we choose the time‐independent Hamiltonian to be the relativistic energy measuring operator for the time‐dependent Hamiltonian, as associated with the chosen initial time. If the system under the time‐dependent Hamiltonian is such that its relativistic energy measuring operator for any fixed time generates equilibrium thermodynamics, then we are led rigorously to the conclusion that the instantaneous relativistic energy for the system under the time‐dependent Hamiltonian is simply a well‐defined function of time and depends only on the initial energy and not on any other initial conditions. For a composite system that is of the above type, and in addition consists of one very small system in contact with a very large one, which is called a generalized reservoir, we consider a specific initial physical state for the large system, and various states for the small one. The eventual dynamic state of the composite system is essentially independent of the initial state of the small system which has almost no influence on the total composite energy. Hence the eventual dynamic state of the small system is shown rigorously to be independent of its initial state. For a forced system with a time‐dependent Hamiltonian, we discuss the assignment of equilibrium thermodynamic potentials to a representation with a time‐independent Hamiltonian. We discuss the concept of a process under a time‐dependent Hamiltonian. Such a process is a natural generalization of the static and quasi‐static processes. Also, we verify all of the theory with both general and specific examples of electromagnetic interactions.

DOI
10.1002/prop.19690170902

Related papers

Nonlinear Generalization of Schrödinger's Equation Uniting Quantum Mechanics and Thermodynamics

Gian Paolo Beretta

The nonlinear equation of motion that accomplishes a self-consistent unification of quantum mechanics (QM) and thermodynamics conceptually different from the (von Neumann) foundations of quantum statistical mechanics (QSM) and (Jaynes) quantum information theory (QIT), but which reduces to the same mathematics for the thermodynamic equilibrium (TE) states, and contains standard QM in that it reduces to the time-dependent Schrödinger equation for zero entropy states is discussed in full mathematical detail. By restricting the discussion to a strictly isolated system (noninteracting, disentangled and uncorrelated), we show how the theory departs from the conventional QSM/QIT rationalization of the second law of thermodynamics, which instead emerges in QT (quantum thermodynamics) as a theorem of existence and uniqueness of a stable equilibrium state for each set of mean values of the energy and the number of constituent particles. To achieve this, the theory assumes Trρ lnρ B −k for the physical entropy and is designed to implement two fundamental ansatzs: (1) that in addition to the standard QM states described by idempotent density operators (zero entropy), a strictly isolated and uncorrelated system admits also states that must be described by non-idempotent density operators (nonzero entropy); (2) that for such additional states the law of causal evolution is determined by the simultaneous action of a Schrödinger-von Neumann-type Hamiltonian generator and a nonlinear dissipative generator which conserves the mean values of the energy and the number of constituent particles, and in forward time drives the density operator in the 'direction' of steepest entropy ascent (maximal entropy generation). The resulting dynamics is well defined for all non-equilibrium states, no matter how far from TE. Existence and uniqueness of solutions of the Cauchy initial value problem for all density operators implies that the equation of motion can be solved not only in forward time, to describe relaxation towards TE, but also in backward time, to reconstruct the 'ancestral' or primordial lowest entropy state or limit cycle from which the system originates. Zero entropy states as well as a well defined family of non-dissipative states evolve unitarily according to pure Hamiltonian dynamics and can be viewed as unstable limit cycles of the general nonlinear dynamics.

International Journal of Thermodynamics•Jun 1, 2008•3 citations

The second law of Thermodynamics as a theorem in quantum mechanics

Hal Tasaki

We treat a quantum mechanical system with certain general properties which are expected to be common in macroscopic quantum systems. Starting from a PURE initial state (which may not describe an equilibrium) in which energy is mildly concentrated at a single value, we consider a time evolution determined by a time-dependent Hamiltonian as a model of an adiabatic operation in thermodynamics. We take a family of operations with the same procedure and various ``waiting times.'' Then the Minimum Work Principle is rigorously proved for almost all choices of the waiting time.

arXiv:cond-mat/0011321•Nov 20, 2000•13 citations

What is quantum mechanics?

Gerard ’t Hooft

We discuss the arguments for suspecting that there exists a classical, i.e. deterministic theory underlying quantum mechanics. A difficulty is that an explanation must be found of the fact that the Hamiltonian, which is defined to be the operator that generates evolution in time, is bounded from below. The mechanism that can produce exactly such a constraint is identified in this paper. It is the fact that not all classical data are registered in the quantum description. Large sets of values of these data are assumed to be indistinguishable, forming equivalence classes. It is argued that this should be attributed to information loss, such as what one might suspect to happen during the formation and annihilation of virtual black holes.The nature of the equivalence classes is further elucidated, as it follows from the positivity of the Hamiltonian. Our world is assumed to consist of a very large number of subsystems that may be regarded as approximately independent, or weakly interacting with one another. As long as two (or more) sectors of our world are treated as being independent, they all must be demanded to be restricted to positive energy states only. What follows from these considerations is a unique definition of energy in the quantum system in terms of the periodicity of the limit cycles of the deterministic model.An example of a deterministic dissipative model producing exact quantum mechanics is provided for the case of a finite‐dimensional vector space. These lecture notes have been produced partly from material published earlier, and as such contain more material than what could be presented in the talk.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2007•10 citations

A mathematical theory for deterministic quantum mechanics

Gerard ’t Hooft

Classical, i.e. deterministic theories underlying quantum mechanics are considered, and it is shown how an apparent quantum mechanical Hamiltonian can be defined in such theories, being the operator that generates evolution in time. It includes various types of interactions. An explanation must be found for the fact that, in the real world, this Hamiltonian is bounded from below. The mechanism that can produce exactly such a constraint is identified in this paper. It is the fact that not all classical data are registered in the quantum description. Large sets of values of these data are assumed to be indistinguishable, forming equivalence classes. It is argued that this should be attributed to information loss, such as what one might suspect to happen during the formation and annihilation of virtual black holes. The nature of the equivalence classes follows from the positivity of the Hamiltonian. Our world is assumed to consist of a very large number of subsystems that may be regarded as approximately independent, or weakly interacting with one another. As long as two (or more) sectors of our world are treated as being independent, they all must be demanded to be restricted to positive energy states only. What follows from these considerations is a unique definition of energy in the quantum system in terms of the periodicity of the limit cycles of the deterministic model.

arXiv:quant-ph/0604008•Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 1, 2007•119 citations

Schr$ouml$dinger equation for joint bidirectional motion in time

G E Hahne

The conventional time-dependent Schrödinger equation describes only unidirectional time evolution of the state of a physical system, i.e. forward or, less commonly, backward. This paper proposes a generalized quantum dynamics for the description of joint, and interactive, forward and backward time evolution within a physical system. The principal mathematical assumption for bidirectional evolution in general is that the space of states should be taken to be not merely a Hilbert space, but a more restricted entity known as a Kreĭn space, which is a complex Hilbert space with a Hermitian operator that has eigenvalues +1 and −1 only, and that therefore gives rise to an indefinite metric. The vector subspaces of states with positive or negative norm with respect to the indefinite metric will—for open channels—be construed to be states in forward or, respectively, backward evolution along the time axis. The quantum dynamics is generated by a pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonian operator and conserves inner products with respect to the indefinite metric. Input and output states are defined in physically plausible ways such that the output comprises both reflected and transmitted states from a zone of interaction in time; a unitary transformation between input and output states is obtained from the pseudounitary transformation between the initial and final states. Three applications are studied: (1) a formal theory of collisions in terms of perturbation theory; (2) a relativistically invariant quantum field theory for a system that kinematically comprises the direct sum of two quantized real scalar fields, such that one subfield evolves forward and the other backward in time, and such that there is dynamical coupling between the subfields; (3) an argument that in the latter field theory, the dynamics predicts that in a range of values of the coupling constants, the expectation value of the vacuum energy of the universe is forced to be zero to high accuracy.

arXiv:quant-ph/0404103•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 7, 2002•4 citations

Second law of thermodynamics in closed quantum many-body systems

Yuuya Chiba, Yasushi Yoneta, Ryusuke Hamazaki +1 more

The second law of thermodynamics for adiabatic operations -- constraints on state transitions in closed systems under external control -- is one of the fundamental principles of thermodynamics. On the other hand, it is recently established that even pure quantum states can represent thermal equilibrium. However, pure quantum states do not satisfy the second law in that they are not passive, i.e., work can be extracted from them if arbitrary unitary operations are allowed. It therefore remains unresolved how quantum mechanics can be reconciled with thermodynamics. Here, based on our key quantum-mechanical notions of thermal equilibrium and adiabatic operations, we address the emergence of the second law for adiabatic operations in the thermodynamics limit. We first introduce infinite-observable macroscopic thermal equilibrium (iMATE); a quantum state, including pure states, is in iMATE if the expectation values of all additive observables agree with their equilibrium values. We also introduce a macroscopic operation as unitary evolution generated by a time-dependent additive Hamiltonian, which is regarded as corresponding to adiabatic operations. Employing these concepts, we show that no extensive work can be extracted from any quantum state in iMATE through any macroscopic operations. Furthermore, we introduce a quantum-mechanical form of entropy density such that it agrees with thermodynamic entropy density for any quantum state in iMATE. We then prove that for any initial state in iMATE, this entropy density cannot be decreased by any macroscopic operations, followed by a time-independent relaxation process. Our theory thus proves two different forms of the second law, by adopting macroscopically reasonable classes of observables, equilibrium states, and operations. We also discuss the time scales of macroscopic operations in these results.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2602.06657•PRX Quantum•Feb 9, 2026•5 citations
Abstract Beginning with a system that is governed by an arbitrary time‐dependent Hamiltonian, we exhibit an existence proof for a unitary generator that has an arbitrary initial value and yet contact transforms the representation to one governed by any given kinematically equivalent Hamiltonian. By choosing the initial value of the unitary operator to be unity, we are able to compare the behaviour of the same system under two different Hamiltonians and the same initial state vector. We thus are able to establish that the eventual physical states evolving from two distinct initial quantum state vectors will become practically indistinguishable under one of the two Hamiltonians if and only if they do so under the other. For the restricted class of systems for which one of the two Hamiltonians is a time‐independent energy operator, and also generates equilibrium thermodynamics, then the condition for merging under the time‐dependent Hamiltonian is the same as under the time‐independent one. The two states must have the same initial energy. As a special case of the above, we choose the time‐independent Hamiltonian to be the relativistic energy measuring operator for the time‐dependent Hamiltonian, as associated with the chosen initial time. If the system under the time‐dependent Hamiltonian is such that its relativistic energy measuring operator for any fixed time generates equilibrium thermodynamics, then we are led rigorously to the conclusion that the instantaneous relativistic energy for the system under the time‐dependent Hamiltonian is simply a well‐defined function of time and depends only on the initial energy and not on any other initial conditions. For a composite system that is of the above type, and in addition consists of one very small system in contact with a very large one, which is called a generalized reservoir, we consider a specific initial physical state for the large system, and various states for the small one. The eventual dynamic state of the composite system is essentially independent of the initial state of the small system which has almost no influence on the total composite energy. Hence the eventual dynamic state of the small system is shown rigorously to be independent of its initial state. For a forced system with a time‐dependent Hamiltonian, we discuss the assignment of equilibrium thermodynamic potentials to a representation with a time‐independent Hamiltonian. We discuss the concept of a process under a time‐dependent Hamiltonian. Such a process is a natural generalization of the static and quasi‐static processes. Also, we verify all of the theory with both general and specific examples of electromagnetic interactions.
The nonlinear equation of motion that accomplishes a self-consistent unification of quantum mechanics (QM) and thermodynamics conceptually different from the (von Neumann) foundations of quantum statistical mechanics (QSM) and (Jaynes) quantum information theory (QIT), but which reduces to the same mathematics for the thermodynamic equilibrium (TE) states, and contains standard QM in that it reduces to the time-dependent Schrödinger equation for zero entropy states is discussed in full mathematical detail. By restricting the discussion to a strictly isolated system (noninteracting, disentangled and uncorrelated), we show how the theory departs from the conventional QSM/QIT rationalization of the second law of thermodynamics, which instead emerges in QT (quantum thermodynamics) as a theorem of existence and uniqueness of a stable equilibrium state for each set of mean values of the energy and the number of constituent particles. To achieve this, the theory assumes Trρ lnρ B −k for the physical entropy and is designed to implement two fundamental ansatzs: (1) that in addition to the standard QM states described by idempotent density operators (zero entropy), a strictly isolated and uncorrelated system admits also states that must be described by non-idempotent density operators (nonzero entropy); (2) that for such additional states the law of causal evolution is determined by the simultaneous action of a Schrödinger-von Neumann-type Hamiltonian generator and a nonlinear dissipative generator which conserves the mean values of the energy and the number of constituent particles, and in forward time drives the density operator in the 'direction' of steepest entropy ascent (maximal entropy generation). The resulting dynamics is well defined for all non-equilibrium states, no matter how far from TE. Existence and uniqueness of solutions of the Cauchy initial value problem for all density operators implies that the equation of motion can be solved not only in forward time, to describe relaxation towards TE, but also in backward time, to reconstruct the 'ancestral' or primordial lowest entropy state or limit cycle from which the system originates. Zero entropy states as well as a well defined family of non-dissipative states evolve unitarily according to pure Hamiltonian dynamics and can be viewed as unstable limit cycles of the general nonlinear dynamics.
We treat a quantum mechanical system with certain general properties which are expected to be common in macroscopic quantum systems. Starting from a PURE initial state (which may not describe an equilibrium) in which energy is mildly concentrated at a single value, we consider a time evolution determined by a time-dependent Hamiltonian as a model of an adiabatic operation in thermodynamics. We take a family of operations with the same procedure and various ``waiting times.'' Then the Minimum Work Principle is rigorously proved for almost all choices of the waiting time.
We discuss the arguments for suspecting that there exists a classical, i.e. deterministic theory underlying quantum mechanics. A difficulty is that an explanation must be found of the fact that the Hamiltonian, which is defined to be the operator that generates evolution in time, is bounded from below. The mechanism that can produce exactly such a constraint is identified in this paper. It is the fact that not all classical data are registered in the quantum description. Large sets of values of these data are assumed to be indistinguishable, forming equivalence classes. It is argued that this should be attributed to information loss, such as what one might suspect to happen during the formation and annihilation of virtual black holes.The nature of the equivalence classes is further elucidated, as it follows from the positivity of the Hamiltonian. Our world is assumed to consist of a very large number of subsystems that may be regarded as approximately independent, or weakly interacting with one another. As long as two (or more) sectors of our world are treated as being independent, they all must be demanded to be restricted to positive energy states only. What follows from these considerations is a unique definition of energy in the quantum system in terms of the periodicity of the limit cycles of the deterministic model.An example of a deterministic dissipative model producing exact quantum mechanics is provided for the case of a finite‐dimensional vector space. These lecture notes have been produced partly from material published earlier, and as such contain more material than what could be presented in the talk.
Classical, i.e. deterministic theories underlying quantum mechanics are considered, and it is shown how an apparent quantum mechanical Hamiltonian can be defined in such theories, being the operator that generates evolution in time. It includes various types of interactions. An explanation must be found for the fact that, in the real world, this Hamiltonian is bounded from below. The mechanism that can produce exactly such a constraint is identified in this paper. It is the fact that not all classical data are registered in the quantum description. Large sets of values of these data are assumed to be indistinguishable, forming equivalence classes. It is argued that this should be attributed to information loss, such as what one might suspect to happen during the formation and annihilation of virtual black holes. The nature of the equivalence classes follows from the positivity of the Hamiltonian. Our world is assumed to consist of a very large number of subsystems that may be regarded as approximately independent, or weakly interacting with one another. As long as two (or more) sectors of our world are treated as being independent, they all must be demanded to be restricted to positive energy states only. What follows from these considerations is a unique definition of energy in the quantum system in terms of the periodicity of the limit cycles of the deterministic model.
Schroumloumloumldinger equation for joint bidirectional motion in time
The conventional time-dependent Schrödinger equation describes only unidirectional time evolution of the state of a physical system, i.e. forward or, less commonly, backward. This paper proposes a generalized quantum dynamics for the description of joint, and interactive, forward and backward time evolution within a physical system. The principal mathematical assumption for bidirectional evolution in general is that the space of states should be taken to be not merely a Hilbert space, but a more restricted entity known as a Kreĭn space, which is a complex Hilbert space with a Hermitian operator that has eigenvalues +1 and −1 only, and that therefore gives rise to an indefinite metric. The vector subspaces of states with positive or negative norm with respect to the indefinite metric will—for open channels—be construed to be states in forward or, respectively, backward evolution along the time axis. The quantum dynamics is generated by a pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonian operator and conserves inner products with respect to the indefinite metric. Input and output states are defined in physically plausible ways such that the output comprises both reflected and transmitted states from a zone of interaction in time; a unitary transformation between input and output states is obtained from the pseudounitary transformation between the initial and final states. Three applications are studied: (1) a formal theory of collisions in terms of perturbation theory; (2) a relativistically invariant quantum field theory for a system that kinematically comprises the direct sum of two quantized real scalar fields, such that one subfield evolves forward and the other backward in time, and such that there is dynamical coupling between the subfields; (3) an argument that in the latter field theory, the dynamics predicts that in a range of values of the coupling constants, the expectation value of the vacuum energy of the universe is forced to be zero to high accuracy.
The second law of thermodynamics for adiabatic operations -- constraints on state transitions in closed systems under external control -- is one of the fundamental principles of thermodynamics. On the other hand, it is recently established that even pure quantum states can represent thermal equilibrium. However, pure quantum states do not satisfy the second law in that they are not passive, i.e., work can be extracted from them if arbitrary unitary operations are allowed. It therefore remains unresolved how quantum mechanics can be reconciled with thermodynamics. Here, based on our key quantum-mechanical notions of thermal equilibrium and adiabatic operations, we address the emergence of the second law for adiabatic operations in the thermodynamics limit. We first introduce infinite-observable macroscopic thermal equilibrium (iMATE); a quantum state, including pure states, is in iMATE if the expectation values of all additive observables agree with their equilibrium values. We also introduce a macroscopic operation as unitary evolution generated by a time-dependent additive Hamiltonian, which is regarded as corresponding to adiabatic operations. Employing these concepts, we show that no extensive work can be extracted from any quantum state in iMATE through any macroscopic operations. Furthermore, we introduce a quantum-mechanical form of entropy density such that it agrees with thermodynamic entropy density for any quantum state in iMATE. We then prove that for any initial state in iMATE, this entropy density cannot be decreased by any macroscopic operations, followed by a time-independent relaxation process. Our theory thus proves two different forms of the second law, by adopting macroscopically reasonable classes of observables, equilibrium states, and operations. We also discuss the time scales of macroscopic operations in these results.