Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

IEEE Transactions on Communications

Performance Comparison of LDPC Block and Spatially Coupled Codes Over GF $(q)$

Kechao Huang, David G. M. Mitchell, Lai Wei, Xiao Ma, Daniel J. Costello

Published Jan 28, 2015• 45 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this paper, we compare the finite-length performance of protograph-based spatially coupled low-density paritycheck (SC-LDPC) codes and LDPC block codes (LDPC-BCs) over GF(q). To reduce computational complexity and latency, a sliding window decoder with a stopping rule based on a soft belief propagation (BP) estimate is used for the q-ary SC-LDPC codes. Two regimes are considered: one when the constraint length of q-ary SC-LDPC codes is equal to the block length of q-ary LDPC-BCs and the other when the two decoding latencies are equal. Simulation results confirm that, in both regimes, (3,6)-, (3,9)-, and (3,12)-regular non-binary SC-LDPC codes can significantly outperform both binary and non-binary LDPC-BCs and binary SC-LDPC codes. Finally, we present a computational complexity comparison of q-ary SC-LDPC codes and q-ary LDPC-BCs under equal decoding latency and equal decoding performance assumptions.

DOI
10.1109/tcomm.2015.2397433

Related papers

Performance Comparison of LDPC Block and Spatially Coupled Codes over GF(q)

Kechao Huang, David G. M. Mitchell, Lai Wei +2 more

In this paper, we compare the finite-length performance of protograph-based spatially coupled low-density parity-check (SC-LDPC) codes and LDPC block codes (LDPC-BCs) over GF(q). In order to reduce computational complexity and latency, a sliding window decoder with a stopping rule based on a soft bit-error-rate (BER) estimate is used for the q-ary SC-LDPC codes. Two regimes are considered: one when the constraint length of q-ary SC-LDPC codes is equal to the block length of q-ary LDPC-BCs and the other when the two decoding latencies are equal. Simulation results confirm that, in both regimes, (3,6)-, (3,9)-, and (3,12)-regular non-binary SC-LDPC codes can significantly outperform both binary and non-binary LDPC-BCs and binary SC-LDPC codes. Finally, we present a computational complexity comparison of q-ary SC-LDPC codes and q-ary LDPC-BCs under equal decoding latency and equal decoding performance assumptions.

arXiv:1408.2621•Aug 12, 2014•2 citations

Performance comparison of non-binary LDPC block and spatially coupled codes

Kechao Huang, David G. M. Mitchell, Lai Wei +2 more

In this paper, we compare the finite-length performance of non-binary spatially coupled low-density parity-check (NB SC-LDPC) codes constructed from protographs to non-binary LDPC block codes (NB LDPC-BCs). A sliding window decoding architecture with a stopping rule based on a soft bit-error-rate (BER) estimate for the NB SC-LDPC codes is considered. It is demonstrated that NB SC-LDPC codes with sliding window decoding outperform NB LDPC-BCs with no increase in decoding complexity when the decoding latency of the SC-LDPC codes equals the block length of the LDPC-BCs. We also investigate the relationship between the protograph lifting factor, the decoding window size, and the decoding performance of NB SC-LDPC codes when the decoding latency is fixed. Simulation results for several (3,6)-regular NB code examples confirm that NB SC-LDPC codes can significantly outperform both binary LDPC-BCs and binary SC-LDPC codes with the same decoding latency.

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 1, 2014•9 citations

Some results on spatially coupled protograph LDPC codes

Sudarsan V. S. Ranganathan, Kasra Vakilinia, Lara Dolecek +2 more

Spatially coupled low-density parity-check block codes (SC-LDPC-BCs) are a class of LDPC codes in which certain ensembles achieve capacity under iterative belief propagation decoding. Prior work has considered these codes mostly from a protograph perspective. Following this viewpoint, our work presents new protographs for the design of protograph-based SC-LDPC-BCs. A reciprocal channel approximation (RCA) analysis of the terminated protographs yields the asymptotic performance limits of the ensembles in terms of their iterative decoding thresholds. Our protographs possess the properties of linear minimum distance growth rate and excellent thresholds. We consider the following channels in our work: binary-input additive white Gaussian noise channel (BI-AWGNC), binary erasure channel (BEC), and binary symmetric channel (BSC). Our work focuses on obtaining good designs, with two classes of ensembles being asymptotically regular, for all the three channels while minimizing rate loss.

Information Theory and Applications Workshop (ITA)•Jan 1, 2016•2 citations

Threshold analysis of non-binary spatially-coupled LDPC codes with windowed decoding

Lai Wei, Toshiaki Koike–Akino, David G. M. Mitchell +2 more

We study the iterative decoding threshold performance of non-binary spatially-coupled low-density parity-check (NB-SC-LDPC) code ensembles for both the binary erasure channel (BEC) and the binary-input additive white Gaussian noise channel (BIAWGNC), with particular emphasis on windowed decoding (WD). We consider both (2, 4)-regular and (3, 6)-regular NB-SC-LDPC code ensembles constructed using protographs and compute their thresholds using protograph versions of NB density evolution and NB extrinsic information transfer analysis. For these code ensembles, we show that WD of NB-SC-LDPC codes, which provides a significant decrease in latency and complexity compared to decoding across the entire parity-check matrix, results in a negligible decrease in the near-capacity performance for a sufficiently large window size W on both the BEC and the BIAWGNC. Also, we show that NBSC-LDPC code ensembles exhibit gains in the WD threshold compared to the corresponding block code ensembles decoded across the entire parity-check matrix, and that the gains increase as the finite field size q increases. Moreover, from the viewpoint of decoding complexity, we see that (3, 6)-regular NB-SC-LDPC codes are particularly attractive due to the fact that they achieve near-capacity thresholds even for small q and W.

arXiv:1403.3583•IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 1, 2014•19 citations

Asymptotic distance properties of protograph-based spatially coupled LDPC codes over GF(q)

Kechao Huang, David G. M. Mitchell, Xiao Ma +1 more

In this paper, asymptotic methods are used to form lower and upper bounds on the typical free distance growth rate of ensembles of periodically time-varying protograph-based spatially coupled low-density parity-check (SC-LDPC) codes over GF(q). By evaluating and comparing these bounds, we find that the typical free distance of q-ary SC-LDPC codes increases linearly with constraint length and that the bounds coincide for a sufficiently large period. In particular, we show that the free distance to constraint length ratio of (3, 6)-regular q-ary SC-LDPC code ensembles exceeds the minimum distance to block length ratio of an underlying q-ary LDPC block code (LDPC-BC) ensemble. We also show that, similar to the minimum distance growth rate of the (3, 6)-regular q-ary LDPC-BC ensemble, the free distance growth rate of (3, 6)-regular q-ary SC-LDPC code ensembles increases with the field size q up to a certain point, and then it decreases as q increases further.

IEEE Information Theory Workshop (ITW)•Apr 1, 2015•1 citation

Finite-length performance of spatially-coupled LDPC codes under TEP decoding

Pablo M. Olmos, Fernando Pérez‐Cruz, Luis Salamanca +1 more

Spatially-coupled (SC) LDPC codes are constructed from a set of L regular sparse codes of length M. In the asymptotic limit of these parameters, SC codes present an excellent decoding threshold under belief propagation (BP) decoding, close to the maximum a posteriori (MAP) threshold of the underlying regular code. In the finite-length regime, we need both dimensions, L and M, to be sufficiently large, yielding a very large code length and decoding latency. In this paper, and for the erasure channel, we show that the finite-length performance of SC codes is improved if we consider the tree-structured expectation propagation (TEP) algorithm in the decoding stage. When applied to the decoding of SC LDPC codes, it allows using shorter codes to achieve similar error rates. We also propose a window-sliding scheme for the TEP decoder to reduce the decoding latency.

IEEE Information Theory Workshop (ITW)•Sep 1, 2012•1 citation
Performance Comparison of LDPC Block and Spatially Coupled Codes Over GF (q)(q)(q)
In this paper, we compare the finite-length performance of protograph-based spatially coupled low-density paritycheck (SC-LDPC) codes and LDPC block codes (LDPC-BCs) over GF(q). To reduce computational complexity and latency, a sliding window decoder with a stopping rule based on a soft belief propagation (BP) estimate is used for the q-ary SC-LDPC codes. Two regimes are considered: one when the constraint length of q-ary SC-LDPC codes is equal to the block length of q-ary LDPC-BCs and the other when the two decoding latencies are equal. Simulation results confirm that, in both regimes, (3,6)-, (3,9)-, and (3,12)-regular non-binary SC-LDPC codes can significantly outperform both binary and non-binary LDPC-BCs and binary SC-LDPC codes. Finally, we present a computational complexity comparison of q-ary SC-LDPC codes and q-ary LDPC-BCs under equal decoding latency and equal decoding performance assumptions.
In this paper, we compare the finite-length performance of protograph-based spatially coupled low-density parity-check (SC-LDPC) codes and LDPC block codes (LDPC-BCs) over GF(q). In order to reduce computational complexity and latency, a sliding window decoder with a stopping rule based on a soft bit-error-rate (BER) estimate is used for the q-ary SC-LDPC codes. Two regimes are considered: one when the constraint length of q-ary SC-LDPC codes is equal to the block length of q-ary LDPC-BCs and the other when the two decoding latencies are equal. Simulation results confirm that, in both regimes, (3,6)-, (3,9)-, and (3,12)-regular non-binary SC-LDPC codes can significantly outperform both binary and non-binary LDPC-BCs and binary SC-LDPC codes. Finally, we present a computational complexity comparison of q-ary SC-LDPC codes and q-ary LDPC-BCs under equal decoding latency and equal decoding performance assumptions.
In this paper, we compare the finite-length performance of non-binary spatially coupled low-density parity-check (NB SC-LDPC) codes constructed from protographs to non-binary LDPC block codes (NB LDPC-BCs). A sliding window decoding architecture with a stopping rule based on a soft bit-error-rate (BER) estimate for the NB SC-LDPC codes is considered. It is demonstrated that NB SC-LDPC codes with sliding window decoding outperform NB LDPC-BCs with no increase in decoding complexity when the decoding latency of the SC-LDPC codes equals the block length of the LDPC-BCs. We also investigate the relationship between the protograph lifting factor, the decoding window size, and the decoding performance of NB SC-LDPC codes when the decoding latency is fixed. Simulation results for several (3,6)-regular NB code examples confirm that NB SC-LDPC codes can significantly outperform both binary LDPC-BCs and binary SC-LDPC codes with the same decoding latency.
Spatially coupled low-density parity-check block codes (SC-LDPC-BCs) are a class of LDPC codes in which certain ensembles achieve capacity under iterative belief propagation decoding. Prior work has considered these codes mostly from a protograph perspective. Following this viewpoint, our work presents new protographs for the design of protograph-based SC-LDPC-BCs. A reciprocal channel approximation (RCA) analysis of the terminated protographs yields the asymptotic performance limits of the ensembles in terms of their iterative decoding thresholds. Our protographs possess the properties of linear minimum distance growth rate and excellent thresholds. We consider the following channels in our work: binary-input additive white Gaussian noise channel (BI-AWGNC), binary erasure channel (BEC), and binary symmetric channel (BSC). Our work focuses on obtaining good designs, with two classes of ensembles being asymptotically regular, for all the three channels while minimizing rate loss.
We study the iterative decoding threshold performance of non-binary spatially-coupled low-density parity-check (NB-SC-LDPC) code ensembles for both the binary erasure channel (BEC) and the binary-input additive white Gaussian noise channel (BIAWGNC), with particular emphasis on windowed decoding (WD). We consider both (2, 4)-regular and (3, 6)-regular NB-SC-LDPC code ensembles constructed using protographs and compute their thresholds using protograph versions of NB density evolution and NB extrinsic information transfer analysis. For these code ensembles, we show that WD of NB-SC-LDPC codes, which provides a significant decrease in latency and complexity compared to decoding across the entire parity-check matrix, results in a negligible decrease in the near-capacity performance for a sufficiently large window size W on both the BEC and the BIAWGNC. Also, we show that NBSC-LDPC code ensembles exhibit gains in the WD threshold compared to the corresponding block code ensembles decoded across the entire parity-check matrix, and that the gains increase as the finite field size q increases. Moreover, from the viewpoint of decoding complexity, we see that (3, 6)-regular NB-SC-LDPC codes are particularly attractive due to the fact that they achieve near-capacity thresholds even for small q and W.
In this paper, asymptotic methods are used to form lower and upper bounds on the typical free distance growth rate of ensembles of periodically time-varying protograph-based spatially coupled low-density parity-check (SC-LDPC) codes over GF(q). By evaluating and comparing these bounds, we find that the typical free distance of q-ary SC-LDPC codes increases linearly with constraint length and that the bounds coincide for a sufficiently large period. In particular, we show that the free distance to constraint length ratio of (3, 6)-regular q-ary SC-LDPC code ensembles exceeds the minimum distance to block length ratio of an underlying q-ary LDPC block code (LDPC-BC) ensemble. We also show that, similar to the minimum distance growth rate of the (3, 6)-regular q-ary LDPC-BC ensemble, the free distance growth rate of (3, 6)-regular q-ary SC-LDPC code ensembles increases with the field size q up to a certain point, and then it decreases as q increases further.
Spatially-coupled (SC) LDPC codes are constructed from a set of L regular sparse codes of length M. In the asymptotic limit of these parameters, SC codes present an excellent decoding threshold under belief propagation (BP) decoding, close to the maximum a posteriori (MAP) threshold of the underlying regular code. In the finite-length regime, we need both dimensions, L and M, to be sufficiently large, yielding a very large code length and decoding latency. In this paper, and for the erasure channel, we show that the finite-length performance of SC codes is improved if we consider the tree-structured expectation propagation (TEP) algorithm in the decoding stage. When applied to the decoding of SC LDPC codes, it allows using shorter codes to achieve similar error rates. We also propose a window-sliding scheme for the TEP decoder to reduce the decoding latency.