Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of physics. A, Proceedings of the Physical Society. General

Position observables for relativistic systems

Maxine Pitter Lunn

Published Jan 1, 1968• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

An elementary proof of the results of Wightman concerning the existence and non-existence of position observables for relativistic systems is presented. The method uses an explicitly described unitary transformation to relate the representations of the Euclidean group obtained by restricting the m not=0 representations of the Poincare group to representions having position observables. The position observables are displayed explicitly as differential operators in the cases in which they exist.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/2/1/004

Related papers

Relativistic Particle Theories Without Canonical Quantization

Nisticò, Giuseppe

The diffculties of relativistic particle theories formulated my means of canonical quantization, such as Klein-Gordon and Dirac theories, ultimately led theoretical physicists to turn on quantum field theory to model elementary particle physics. The aim of the present work is to pursue a method alternative to canonical quantization that avoids these dfficulties. In order to guarantee this result, the present approach is constrained to be developed deductively from physical principles. The physical principles assumed for a free particle consist of the symmetry properties of the particle with respect to the Poincaré group and of the transformation properties of the position observable, expressed by means of a suitably conceived notion of quantum transformation. In so doing, the effectiveness of group theoretical methods is exploited. Our work has pointed out the necessity of new classes of irreducible representations of the Poincaré group the theory can be based on. For spin 0 particle, four inequivalent theories are completely determined, that differ from Klein-Gordon theory for the physical interpretation but also for the mathematical structures. In particular, two of these theories requires irreducible representations in the new classes. The present lack of the explicit transformation properties of position with respect to boosts forbids the complete determination of non zero spin particle theories. A particular form of these transformation properties was in past adopted by Jordan and Mukunda. We check its consistency within the present approach; it is found that for spin 1/2 particles there is only one consistent theory; it is unitarily related to Dirac theory, but, once again, it requires the new classes of irreducible representations.

arXiv:1811.01546•Nov 5, 2018•1 citation

Lorentz-Invariant Localization for Elementary Systems. II

Andrés J. Kálnay

The purpose of this paper is to find to what extent the notion of position in the relativistic quantum mechanics of free elementary systems of nonzero mass is defined (or precluded) by the requirement that the descriptions of a localized state as seen from two observers in different frames of reference should be physically consistent. Neither the existence of a time component of the position operator nor the compatibility of the space components of position is assumed. Hermiticity with respect to the quantum-relativistic scalar product in state-vector space is neither assumed nor rejected. There are three possibilities: (i) The position is represented as usual by a Hermitian operator; this is the point-type position. (ii) Non-Hermitian operators are accepted, and the $k$ component of position can represent segments of the $k$ axis with length of the order of $\frac{1}{m}$; when the operator is not only non-Hermitian, but also non-normal, this is the extended-type position. (iii) Non-Hermitian operators are accepted, but the segments are reduced to points; this is the limiting case of the extended-type position. Case (ii) is not studied in this paper. General conditions are found for any spin as regards cases (i) and (iii), and their consequences are obtained for spin 0 and spin \textonehalf{}. The results are the following: There is no position operator in case (i), but in case (iii) the position operator is unique for spin 0 and unique up to a parameter for spin \textonehalf{}. For both spins, in spite of the lack of relativistic Hermiticity, the eigenvalues of position are real, and the velocity is the expected one. The eigenstates of one component of the position are found. The components of the position are compatible with each other for spin 0, and incompatible for spin \textonehalf{}. In the former case, the simultaneous eigenstates of all components are Philip's class-I localized states. Related work is discussed.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Feb 15, 1970•27 citations

General expressions for the position and spin operators of relativistic systems

Miguel Lorente, P. Román

Some general assumptions based on the physical properties of elementary and of composite quantized systems lead in a natural way to general expressions for the position and spin operators of massive particles. All previously proposed position and spin operators, defined in the enveloping algebra of the Poincaré group, appear as special cases. By algebraic arguments a general local position operator is obtained which is proved to coincide under special conditions with the Pryce-Newton-Wigner position operator.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 1974•31 citations

On some representations of the Poincaré group on phase space. II

S. Twareque Ali

Representations of the proper Poincaré group on spaces of functions of the phase space variables q and p have been studied, by starting with the rotation subgroup SO(3), and carrying out an inducing procedure. A complete decomposition theory, for the physically interesting representations, have been developed. Explicit computations of the forms of the generators and certain systems of imprimitivity have been carried out. The role of the Newton–Wigner position and momentum operators, in the setting of phase space representations, has been discussed. The work is a continuation of an earlier paper on phase space representations, inspired ultimately by the possibility of developing a consistent relativistic quantum mechanics for single particles on phase space.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Apr 1, 1980•18 citations

Poincaré Group and Operators of Position and Spin

Alexander J. Silenko, Pengfei Zhang, Liping Zou

Abstract Fundamental properties of the position and spin operators in relativistic quantum mechanics are defined with the Poincaré group. Quantum-mechanical counterparts of the classical position and spin variables are the corresponding operators in the Foldy–Wouthuysen representation but not in the Dirac one. The probabilistic interpretation is valid only for Foldy–Wouthuysen wave functions. The relativistic operators of the position and spin are discussed.

Physics of Particles and Nuclei•Nov 29, 2023•0 citations

(Heisenberg-)Weyl Algebras, Segal-Bargmann Transform and Representations of Poincaré Groups

Miloslav Havlíček, Jan Kotrbatý, Patrick Moylan +1 more

In a recent paper [1] we described a novel treatment of the unitary irreducible representations of the Poincaré groups in 2, 3 and 4 space-time dimensions as unitary operators on the representation spaces of the Schrödinger representation of the Heisenberg-Weyl algebra of index r = 1, 2, and 3, respectively. Here we relate this approach to the usual method of describing the representations of these Poincaré groups, i.e. the Wigner-Mackey construction.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Apr 1, 2019•0 citations
An elementary proof of the results of Wightman concerning the existence and non-existence of position observables for relativistic systems is presented. The method uses an explicitly described unitary transformation to relate the representations of the Euclidean group obtained by restricting the m not=0 representations of the Poincare group to representions having position observables. The position observables are displayed explicitly as differential operators in the cases in which they exist.
The diffculties of relativistic particle theories formulated my means of canonical quantization, such as Klein-Gordon and Dirac theories, ultimately led theoretical physicists to turn on quantum field theory to model elementary particle physics. The aim of the present work is to pursue a method alternative to canonical quantization that avoids these dfficulties. In order to guarantee this result, the present approach is constrained to be developed deductively from physical principles. The physical principles assumed for a free particle consist of the symmetry properties of the particle with respect to the Poincaré group and of the transformation properties of the position observable, expressed by means of a suitably conceived notion of quantum transformation. In so doing, the effectiveness of group theoretical methods is exploited. Our work has pointed out the necessity of new classes of irreducible representations of the Poincaré group the theory can be based on. For spin 0 particle, four inequivalent theories are completely determined, that differ from Klein-Gordon theory for the physical interpretation but also for the mathematical structures. In particular, two of these theories requires irreducible representations in the new classes. The present lack of the explicit transformation properties of position with respect to boosts forbids the complete determination of non zero spin particle theories. A particular form of these transformation properties was in past adopted by Jordan and Mukunda. We check its consistency within the present approach; it is found that for spin 1/2 particles there is only one consistent theory; it is unitarily related to Dirac theory, but, once again, it requires the new classes of irreducible representations.
The purpose of this paper is to find to what extent the notion of position in the relativistic quantum mechanics of free elementary systems of nonzero mass is defined (or precluded) by the requirement that the descriptions of a localized state as seen from two observers in different frames of reference should be physically consistent. Neither the existence of a time component of the position operator nor the compatibility of the space components of position is assumed. Hermiticity with respect to the quantum-relativistic scalar product in state-vector space is neither assumed nor rejected. There are three possibilities: (i) The position is represented as usual by a Hermitian operator; this is the point-type position. (ii) Non-Hermitian operators are accepted, and the kkk component of position can represent segments of the kkk axis with length of the order of 1m\frac{1}{m}m1​; when the operator is not only non-Hermitian, but also non-normal, this is the extended-type position. (iii) Non-Hermitian operators are accepted, but the segments are reduced to points; this is the limiting case of the extended-type position. Case (ii) is not studied in this paper. General conditions are found for any spin as regards cases (i) and (iii), and their consequences are obtained for spin 0 and spin \textonehalf{}. The results are the following: There is no position operator in case (i), but in case (iii) the position operator is unique for spin 0 and unique up to a parameter for spin \textonehalf{}. For both spins, in spite of the lack of relativistic Hermiticity, the eigenvalues of position are real, and the velocity is the expected one. The eigenstates of one component of the position are found. The components of the position are compatible with each other for spin 0, and incompatible for spin \textonehalf{}. In the former case, the simultaneous eigenstates of all components are Philip's class-I localized states. Related work is discussed.
Some general assumptions based on the physical properties of elementary and of composite quantized systems lead in a natural way to general expressions for the position and spin operators of massive particles. All previously proposed position and spin operators, defined in the enveloping algebra of the Poincaré group, appear as special cases. By algebraic arguments a general local position operator is obtained which is proved to coincide under special conditions with the Pryce-Newton-Wigner position operator.
Representations of the proper Poincaré group on spaces of functions of the phase space variables q and p have been studied, by starting with the rotation subgroup SO(3), and carrying out an inducing procedure. A complete decomposition theory, for the physically interesting representations, have been developed. Explicit computations of the forms of the generators and certain systems of imprimitivity have been carried out. The role of the Newton–Wigner position and momentum operators, in the setting of phase space representations, has been discussed. The work is a continuation of an earlier paper on phase space representations, inspired ultimately by the possibility of developing a consistent relativistic quantum mechanics for single particles on phase space.