Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

AIP conference proceedings

Understanding Retrocausality—Can a Message Be Sent to the Past?

Richard Shoup, Daniel P. Sheehan

Published Jan 1, 2011• 3 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1063/1.3663728

Related papers

Two roads to retrocausality

Emily Adlam

arXiv:2201.12934•Synthese•Oct 11, 2022•47 citations

Retrocausal Communication Email Process That Violates Causality

Ricardo Valverde Gil

In the theory of special relativity, a particle that has rest mass with subluminal velocity needs infinite energy to accelerate to the speed of light. Special relativity does not prohibit the existence of particles that travel faster than light. In arXiv:1303.0614 quantum entanglement was measured at 10,000 times the speed of light or 4 orders of magnitude the speed of light or 2.99 E 12 m/s 2. At the quantum level some believe that retrocausality is forbidden. The purpose of this paper is to show how an email message can go proportionally faster than light to report on an event from the present into the past. The event reported from the present is sent into the past in the Inbox history instantaneously and a copy of the email that is (-) 2.7 hours in the past will also be sent to the Inbox history. Whether or not the event reported from the present that is sent into the past can be changed is not the purpose of this paper. The purpose of this paper is to show how a message from now can report on an event from now and sent into the past.(retrocausal communication)

•Oct 1, 2016•0 citations

Temporal Radio: toward controlled retrocausal communication (two preprints, supplementary material and code)

Valentina Sanna

This record contains two preprints and their supplementary material, in English and Italian, together with the code and LaTeX sources that reproduce every number and figure. Toward controlled retrocausal communication: the successive-rewriting model and its bottleneck (main paper). Can information be sent to the past? With known physics it cannot; the possibility is not, however, excluded a priori, and the Temporal Radio project asks what would be needed. We show that the bottleneck has a single root: making even a single controllable bit appear in the past without a cause in that past. We show it through the author's successive-rewriting model, formulated with declared premises: a message that reaches the past alters the causal chain, reality is perturbed and resettles, overwriting the future, and a protected log numbers the versions and guides the senders. We formalize it as a dynamics over the versions, in which consistency is not an imposed principle but the equilibrium between settling and the senders' choices; a toy model shows that the author's rule of intervening only for a serious reason allows the succession to stop despite a strong butterfly effect. The bottleneck appears in two forms. The first is the channel: the message must reach the past on a physical signal, which we discuss as a hypothesis in terms of the advanced component of the electromagnetic field; two entangled particles supply a key that only the receiver can use, but reduce neither the amount of information to be sent back nor the difficulty. The second is the persistence of information across versions: with a protected log the model makes a conditional prediction that distinguishes it from Novikov consistency, the alternating entries left by the paradoxical protocol. Future boundary conditions and feedback loops: two solvable models that send no signal to the past (companion note). In models with boundary conditions in the future it is easy to mistake a global dependence for a signal to the past. Two elementary, solvable models make the distinction explicit: two coupled linear oscillators with data at both ends, and a scalar field crossing the throat of an Ellis wormhole placed in a feedback loop. An operational criterion in five conditions organizes what each model does and does not show. The supplementary material contains the catalogue of models, the verification register with the evidence level of every number, and a guide to the computation package. The work was carried out with the assistance of an AI model, as declared in the papers.

•Oct 16, 2026•0 citations

Open Paradoxes: Retrocausality

Jordi Vallverdú

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Retrocausality and conditional probability

C. I. J. M. Stuart

Foundations of Physics Letters•Feb 1, 1991•6 citations

Retrocausal Capacity of a Quantum Channel: Communicating through Noisy Closed Timelike Curves

Kaiyuan Ji, Seth Lloyd, Mark M. Wilde

We study the capacity of a quantum channel for retrocausal communication, where messages are transmitted backward in time, from a sender in the future to a receiver in the past, through a noisy postselected closed timelike curve mathematically represented by the channel. We completely characterize the one-shot retrocausal quantum and classical capacities, and we show that the corresponding asymptotic capacities are equal to the average and sum, respectively, of the channel's max-information and its regularized Doeblin information. This endows these information measures with a novel operational interpretation. Furthermore, our characterization can be generalized beyond quantum channels to all completely positive maps. This imposes information-theoretic limits on transmitting messages via postselected-teleportation-like mechanisms with arbitrary initial- and final-state boundary conditions, including those considered in various black-hole final-state models.

arXiv:2509.08965•Physical Review Letters•Apr 14, 2026•3 citations
In the theory of special relativity, a particle that has rest mass with subluminal velocity needs infinite energy to accelerate to the speed of light. Special relativity does not prohibit the existence of particles that travel faster than light. In arXiv:1303.0614 quantum entanglement was measured at 10,000 times the speed of light or 4 orders of magnitude the speed of light or 2.99 E 12 m/s 2. At the quantum level some believe that retrocausality is forbidden. The purpose of this paper is to show how an email message can go proportionally faster than light to report on an event from the present into the past. The event reported from the present is sent into the past in the Inbox history instantaneously and a copy of the email that is (-) 2.7 hours in the past will also be sent to the Inbox history. Whether or not the event reported from the present that is sent into the past can be changed is not the purpose of this paper. The purpose of this paper is to show how a message from now can report on an event from now and sent into the past.(retrocausal communication)
This record contains two preprints and their supplementary material, in English and Italian, together with the code and LaTeX sources that reproduce every number and figure. Toward controlled retrocausal communication: the successive-rewriting model and its bottleneck (main paper). Can information be sent to the past? With known physics it cannot; the possibility is not, however, excluded a priori, and the Temporal Radio project asks what would be needed. We show that the bottleneck has a single root: making even a single controllable bit appear in the past without a cause in that past. We show it through the author's successive-rewriting model, formulated with declared premises: a message that reaches the past alters the causal chain, reality is perturbed and resettles, overwriting the future, and a protected log numbers the versions and guides the senders. We formalize it as a dynamics over the versions, in which consistency is not an imposed principle but the equilibrium between settling and the senders' choices; a toy model shows that the author's rule of intervening only for a serious reason allows the succession to stop despite a strong butterfly effect. The bottleneck appears in two forms. The first is the channel: the message must reach the past on a physical signal, which we discuss as a hypothesis in terms of the advanced component of the electromagnetic field; two entangled particles supply a key that only the receiver can use, but reduce neither the amount of information to be sent back nor the difficulty. The second is the persistence of information across versions: with a protected log the model makes a conditional prediction that distinguishes it from Novikov consistency, the alternating entries left by the paradoxical protocol. Future boundary conditions and feedback loops: two solvable models that send no signal to the past (companion note). In models with boundary conditions in the future it is easy to mistake a global dependence for a signal to the past. Two elementary, solvable models make the distinction explicit: two coupled linear oscillators with data at both ends, and a scalar field crossing the throat of an Ellis wormhole placed in a feedback loop. An operational criterion in five conditions organizes what each model does and does not show. The supplementary material contains the catalogue of models, the verification register with the evidence level of every number, and a guide to the computation package. The work was carried out with the assistance of an AI model, as declared in the papers.
We study the capacity of a quantum channel for retrocausal communication, where messages are transmitted backward in time, from a sender in the future to a receiver in the past, through a noisy postselected closed timelike curve mathematically represented by the channel. We completely characterize the one-shot retrocausal quantum and classical capacities, and we show that the corresponding asymptotic capacities are equal to the average and sum, respectively, of the channel's max-information and its regularized Doeblin information. This endows these information measures with a novel operational interpretation. Furthermore, our characterization can be generalized beyond quantum channels to all completely positive maps. This imposes information-theoretic limits on transmitting messages via postselected-teleportation-like mechanisms with arbitrary initial- and final-state boundary conditions, including those considered in various black-hole final-state models.